Ladies and gentlemen, I present you the state of “peer review” in ML academia (thanks to for finding this gem)
Conversation
Ladies and gentlemen, I present you the state of “peer review” in ML academia (thanks to for finding this gem)
At least this person honestly admits that they aren’t qualified to evaluate the paper, so propa to them
I have seen lots of reviews where people don’t understand basic things about the topic and yet assess their confidence as 3/4



I would choose this review over unadulterated, AI-generated shit. Props to the reviewer for their honestly, but the language is not professional.
What is wrong with this reviewer, they probably are randomly assigned to this paper. They honestly admit they are not expert enough instead of just copying ai review. Write it everywhere + gives low confidence. I would say it is a responsible reviewer.
Just register and open a chequing account (with at least $1). T&Cs apply.
This is genuinely not that bad. English is clearly not their first language, and they don't know much, but they still tried to provide two concrete suggestions and also gave a good score to the paper. What else could they have done?
Discover more
Sourced from across X
The End of AI Frontiers hunch.net/?p=13764006 .
There's a bit of a train wreck here that's painful to express. Nevertheless, it's a significant event for me and quite a few other folks involved so I wanted to memorialize a bit.
My biggest struggle with reviews in 2026 is that (AI) reviewers don’t seem to know the difference between limitations and critical issues. An LLM can easily find 100+ limitations in any paper (even the best ones in history), but that doesn’t mean the paper shouldn’t be accepted.
ICLR reviews are out.
Reviewer 1: “The paper is well-written and addresses an important problem. However, the authors should consider additional baselines.”
Reviewer 2: “The paper is well-written and addresses an important problem. However, the authors should consider additional
Trending now
What’s happening
Trending in Canada
Nebraska
Politics · Trending
Trudeau
Trending
6.2 Astra
Trending
Postgres