Love at first photo?

Romantic interest on swipe-based dating apps (SBDAs) is highly concentrated. This can frustrate both popular users who feel overwhelmed by a glut of attention, and less popular users who feel dejected by a lack of it. Is the concentration of interest exacerbated by the platform design of dating apps? I provide causal evidence on the effects of two common design features – the emphasis on visual elements in profiles,and limits on the number of profiles users can express interest in – on the concentration of interest (“likes”), and show that both, as implemented under the status quo,concentrate interest. To do so, I design, build, and run my own experimental dating app, which closely resembles conventional SBDAs and allows participants to form real matches. Across three field experiments, over 1,000 participants use the app to makeover 70,000 matching decisions. Under conventional SBDA profile design, I show that visual profile components (i.e., photos and height) dominate matching decisions, and that the concentration of interest is driven mainly by users’ reactions to profile visuals. Simply reducing the salience of visuals on profiles does not significantly affect which profiles receive likes, but requiring users to screen profiles on other components spreads likes more evenly (Gini coefficient decrease of 0.05 points) without reducing their number or the resultant number of matches. Finally, I show that limiting the number of profiles that users can express interest in, which many SBDAs do as part of a freemium subscription model, amplifies concentration (Gini coefficient increase of 0.1 points).

That is from the job market paper of Sofia Shchukina, who is on the job market from the University of Chicago.

Comments

The move away from real-life meeting situations towards online apps seems almost inherently to entail a move from broad personality matches to the most quickly, visually judged (especially but not only appearance). It's the nature of the medium.

Nowadays, meeting at work is heavily frowned on, churches carry less weight generally, especially with the young, and broad social activities (bowling is the archetype) have faded. Hobbies themselves are often online (gaming, etc.)

And, smaller families make it a little harder too - among the relatively smaller pool that a young person knows, the ease of identifying a suitable sibling or cousin as a potential match is lower. Nieces/nephews/kids also, for the middle-aged person aspiring to matchmake a younger co-worker or friend.

I met my wife through a friend, on an evening group social activity (that ended with Trivial Pursuit - she could casually check me out for smarts). Then I got a nudge from her friend a bit later to reach out to her. Would either of us have swiped right or connected in the modern setting? Would have been less likely, I think...

Respond

Also, there's a much stronger social norm towards marrying older, and, especially for women now vs. a generation or two ago, getting a lot of education and a career going before thinking much about marriage.

But, college and even high school can be GREAT places to meet lots of folks of the opposite sex and identify those you click with on grounds other than pure physical attraction. However, if you frown on young women getting an Mrs. degree or even (perish the thought!) marrying their high school sweetheart, you substantially reduce the pool of in-person connections that are readily available, when someone does decide they want to find "the one".

Respond

The other big thing to consider is that people now move away from their educational milieu before they marry. Going from highschool sweethearts to marriage partners with a normative courting setup means incurring signficant costs in both your college options and hampering your job mobility for those all important "entry level" options.

And even if you are committed to staying in your hometown, there is basically no hope that your potential romantic network will do the same.

It is very hard to signal that your interest in somebody is sufficient to either manage long distance during schooling or some foot-in-the-door experience without looking weird.

Once upon a time, most people could go to State U, get a job in one of the cities within a reasonable drive, and maintain the social networks for both of a couple. If they moved to California, it was much more commonly done after marriage. Now? Expect to cycle through three complete social networks by the time you are beginning to be normatively marriagable.

And even for the folks who don't get training or want to work in niche industries that require relocation ... it is very hard to know who will light out because they hate winters, want lower taxes, or cannot take another hurricane season. And all of this compounds when folks spend less time together for the years they are together. Every class that meets on zoom or videotapes the lectures, every night spent in solo streaming Netflix ... we get to know folks in our real world networks much less quickly. So we learn less per year in some locale, spend fewer years there, and to top it off - demand that we know more about someone to be certain.

Modern life courses are just pretty bad for romance and commitment.

Respond

Also, real-world dating/connections can be hard. Getting rejected in person (or even on a phone call) is tough. An app where you just swipe a lot but rarely get personally rejected (other than maybe a non-response to a trivial outreach message) has less pain, perhaps, but sometimes a little pain is necessary, or at least tolerable, in pursuit of a big long-term payoff.

Respond

IDK. Apps probably work well for certain personality types. The introvert crew is probably better sticking to repeated, small group interactions (clubs, friends-of-friends, etc) ...

...which are also tough if that introvert just moved accross country for a job. But at least it's a plausible path.

Respond

>meeting at work is heavily frowned on,

Sad given how much of your life is devoted to work during the key years.

Ironically, nepotism is fine in corporate america. At one point, my 1st line manager was the wife and my 3rd line was the husband.

Respond

I've also 'managed' a different 3rd line manager's kid as co-op one summer.

Respond

Maybe [the popular] people should be allowed to say how much they are interested in someone. Then use that to reduce the flood of attention so they only see their top 10 choices that also liked them. (The unpopular people don't even have 10 responses so...) Probably you could use that to redistribute down the other people as well.

I also posted another idea on here I had not that long ago for a non-profit and more marriage oriented site,
https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/10/alvin-roth-to-the-rescue-the-polity-that-is-singapore.html?commentID=161079939

Maybe it would help the situation too.

Respond

It seems that from a pure MATCHMAKING sense (though perhaps not the best business case for the app-makers), it would be useful to have the apps do a better job of detecting the desireability of the users, and steering them towards similarly desireable matches. i.e. Don't have all the 4s, 5s, and 6s, chasing mainly 9s and 10s, but nudge them (strongly) towards realistic matches.

But, I'm guessing that would damage a lot of fragile egos and somehow make less money for the app-makers.

(If the apps already do this to a significant extent, please fill me in/correct me.)

Respond

I wonder if app(s) strongly optimized towards enduring matches rather than profitability/recurring revenue might be a useful government project, especially in some of the countries (East Asia, etc.) with serious fertility issues. Governments can subsidize...

Maybe some of them are already doing this.

Respond

Indeed, the incentives of profit dating sites are all wrong. As I said in my other post. But I'm suspicious that a government website is going to be a great solution. Anyhow, don't let anyone know their score. That should be an internal only number. HotOrNot was a dating site for a while, but clearly won't be for everyone.

Respond

The apps do already do this, you get an Elo rating based on your matches and they try to keep you in your league.

Respond

Tinder has an elo, but got rid of it years ago. The problem is the incentives of the business are opposed to the interests of the users. Or at least those who want happy long term relationships. It's good for hookups. But it was based on a site for gay men to find hookups, so that's not that surprising. It's model is especially bad, but any business based on engagement won't really want to provide the things that makes two users permanently disengage.

Respond

I was told that there are internet dating sites for non-romantic friendship formation; mechanism the same, but teleologically distinct. I'd be interested to see whether this holds outside the sexual market.

Respond

Everyone seems to agree that dating apps were better before they were swipe apps. Yet nobody is stepping up to seize this potentially lucrative market for an old school dating app that is based on text profiles or questions. Is this a failure of entrepreneurship or people saying one thing in the MR comments section and doing something totally different on their phones?

Respond

Nobody agrees on that. Tinder was absolutely revolutionary in comparison to the likes of OkCupid. It generally mirrors the transition of the internet from niche nerd interest to the mainstream. Was Flickr better than Instagram? Only if you're being contrarian. In addition to being an "app" and smartphone oriented in comparison to the old web, dating benefits from mainstreaming in a way that forums and photography etc don't.

Apps were great when they were supplemental and people mostly had real lives, friends etc. Now the kids these days seem mostly app-mediated which is a disaster, but replacing that with a text profile is almost nonsensical

Respond

Physical attractiveness and height are also the first things that would be noticed encountering someone at a social function and would draw an interested person into starting a conversation, and physical attractiveness in the physical world is more enticing then any pretty pictures online. In smaller settings though there is more opportunity to talk with people first and then become interested.

Respond

The difference is that in the real world when you encounter someone several times casually and they are friendly sometimes they start to seem more attractive.

Respond

What’s the design of Singapore’s government sponsored matchmaking app?

Respond

A major problem with dating apps is that the market doesn't clear in the same place as in real life.

Men end up not matching with anyone, or greatly lowering their standards.

Women end up going on lots of dates with men who don't actually see them as good matches.

The old OKCupid days were much better for this -- your dating pool is the set of men who message you (if you're a woman) or the set of women who reply (if you're a man). That's still true, but now nobody has any idea what that pool looks like or how to find it!

Respond
Respond

Add Comment