As an educator, I’m devastated by what calculators are doing to my students
I’ve been teaching math for 69 years, and I’ve never felt this hopeless about the future of my profession.
Something happened yesterday that I can’t stop thinking about. I gave my class a warm-up problem, 847 × 36, and one of my students had the answer in about three seconds. For a second, I thought I was finally getting through to him. Then I asked him to show his work. He didn’t say anything. He just slowly turned his phone around, and there it was: the calculator app, with “30492” still glowing on the screen. I felt my stomach drop.
I don’t know how to explain to him that what he did isn’t math. He pressed some buttons and a machine gave him a number. He didn’t carry anything or line up any columns. When I told him he won’t always have a calculator in his pocket, he looked at me like I was the crazy one.
What really gets me is that nobody wants to talk about is where these things got their math. They stole it. Every calculator runs on centuries of work by real mathematicians, people who poured their whole lives into it. Then some company scraped all of it, crammed it into a $12 piece of plastic, and started selling it. Nobody asked them, and nobody paid them. That’s theft.
And they aren’t even reliable. Type 0.1 + 0.2 into a computer sometime and you get 0.30000000000000004. And people want this thing doing their taxes?
I also think about the people this replaced. NASA used to have whole rooms of human “computers,” mostly women, doing real calculations by hand. Those jobs are gone, and now people act like that’s progress.
The worst part is that I can always tell. Calculator work has no soul. My students’ homework used to have personality: eraser smudges, crossed-out digits, a 7 that looked suspiciously like a 1. You could see a person thinking on the page. Now everything comes back clean and correct, and it makes me want to cry.
I’m not anti-technology. I’m just scared. I’m scared that in ten years nobody will know their times tables, every bridge will be designed by “button-pushers,” and I’ll be the last person on earth who can carry a one. Maybe that’s dramatic. Or maybe I’m the only one paying attention.
TLDR: If it didn’t take suffering, it’s not math
Comments Section
The fact that some people's thinking here works so well with this analogy bothers me.
the parallel to AI art is so obvious it hurts. people want the output without any understanding of what happens in between, and then they get mad when you point out the machine did the work for them.
i teach programming at a small college and see same thing with chatgpt. students turn in perfect code but can't explain single line of it. the homework looks flawless until you ask them to modify it on spot and they freeze.
the 0.1 + 0.2 thing is exactly what i mean about trusting tools blindly. most people don't even know floating point exists, they just assume computer math works same as real math. that's dangerous when you're building things that matter.
Bro... those students existed before AI too dude. Instead of plugging it into chatGPT you search stack overflow.
Bullshit. I used to get yelled at there when I was first starting out… they always had an appreciation for those who worked out at least some of the problem themselves.
Alright so are you then going to walk your students through being semi competent mathematicians and teach actual engineering?
It's weird that as an educator you completely missed the real issue with what your student did.
You likely aren't assigning multiplication problems so that they just plug them in to a calculator. Your student using the calculator has missed the point of the exercise, and apparently so have you. You should be upset because, unless it was a lesson about calculators, they havent demonstrated any understanding of the topic by plugging it into a calculator.
I think that's what actually makes it a really perfect analogy. AI is the same way, if you let people use AI for everything they'll lose the ability to understand what they're using AI for and even how to use it effectively. We teach times tables and THEN we hand the student a calculator, the same should be done with AI. The satire is how many people are faced with their problem and their solution is "ban all calculators from every classroom"
95% of people will be absolute dipshits. No matter what tools you do or don't give them. The calculator just reduces their stress.
And boost their ego. The amount of people that can easily multiply three numbers nowadays but have no concept of what meters cubed as a unit are supposed to be is astonishing. Sure you can type it in but understanding how to map the world onto numbers that can be multiplied to get something useful is extremely low. AI just makes this worse.
Some people choose to cheat. Not all of them, but some of them. They'd rather finish the job, then do something worth their time.
And THAT is the issue here. The student using the calculator doesn't want to learn.
One of my best friends in college was my English Composition professor, who I kept in touch with long afterwards. He finally retired (long before "AI" came out), and he said the reason that he retired was that the kids were demanding "A" grades for "D" level work. They didn't want to learn. They hired people to write their assignments for them in some cases. And their parents are PAYING for their education. It's a waste of time and money, and they were giving my friend grief over it every semester. So, he retired, and it became someone else's problem.
Then came "AI", and that whole problem exploded.
It's a deliberate dumbing-down of the human race. The "AI" developers prey on the human tendency to be lazy, and they're destroying all our greatest minds before they even get out of the gate.
Back in my day, they just came out with the Texas Instruments graphing calculators, and they were banned outright - because not only could they do computations, they could store the answers to any quiz question, and as such, made cheating easy.
#BanAI, and stop the cheating.
It's not lazy students, it's either student being in a degree they don't want, or curriculum full of useless subjects. I vividly remember how my friend, a journalist major, had some stupid grade-level chemistry class, and I, chemistry major, was getting multiple essays on (insert phylosofer)'s views on (insert subject) in my phylosofy class. As you can guess, we wrote this assignments for each other for the next semester
With this level of absurd I can't blame those who cheat on these irrelevant subjects. It's not students, it's curriculum authors who should be punished for that
#MakeCurriculumMakeSense and noone would cheat
I'm starting to think OP isn't an actual teacher...
You will find people saying that you are right and calculators are making people dumber... But if you ask them if they learned complicated math to not be dumb, crickets. People would rather spend their time complaining about technology instead of improving themselves.
There's a reason we only use calculators in school after spending years of your education pre ~12 years old learning mental math and doing basic calculations by hand. It's generally a lot easier to use a calculator when you know the fundamentals, same can be applied to AI. Also you get the most out of a calculator if you study mathematics to a further level. For what it's worth it is also a problem that math levels have been decreasing in recent years.
"Why do pushups when machines exist?"
I vote to bring back telephone books, nobody remembers phone numbers anymore. Its easily avaliable on your cellular device there isnt any need to remember them.Imagine a helpless girl she dropped her precious IPhone and broke it, lost, frantic not knowing where she was her instincts were to find the nearest person. Plenty were walking about phone in hand she asks for help but she cant remember anyone's number. Usually its a slide of a thumb away not this time, nothing but a gap in her memory, afraid and lost with nobody to call. She is now homeless in a city somewhere her family cannot reach. They were never called to them she's just another face on a milk carton.
We already have worse literacy and critical thinking skills than any other country, don't need to make people more brainless, idiotic take. There's a difference between using calculators to help vs never learning math at all.
You're being facetious, but I do think it's good to be able to do simple mental arithmethics and I try to do any small calculations in my head before/IF I use a calculator. I do this to avoid losing that ability and to help stay sharp. So. Yeah.
I assume this is meant satirical. The problem is that your scenario doesn't quite match the argument you're comparing it to. And I say that as someone who dislikes that argument
And worst of all, OP can't even do math right
I too had a teach who taught 69 years.
Or maybe it was positions. Idk
So here's the thing. I actually had a teacher who joked about "punch punch punch, you punch so hard you punch your brain!"
Because like. You do still need to have at least some awareness for calculations, how to input them, how to check, how to show work.
And that's the problem with AI. The one thing that typical math does which is "solve the problem, check the answer, then review your process"
Doesn't work with AI. You can't control the weights. You can't give the same prompt to another person and get the exact same result. The drift will always occur.
I know you tried really hard, but. You...really screwed up here.
I have ONE real issue with calculators ; "500+5%" calculator can do that, but how many people understand they just did 500+5/100*500 ? Who care? Your choice, it physically hurt me when someone need to get their phone to know if they can afford the 79$ shoes that are 50% off on this store.
You wonder why your school calculator doesn't have a % button? well I may have an idea...
PS : I'm totally fine with AI if you understand what you're doing.
I presume this is satire. Quite funny!
No it’s not satire they’re being serious. I am also against big calculator.
you joke but people really were this against basically every technology ever
Did you know that the “solar panels” in most calculators don’t do anything and it’s sucking up microwatts of battery power each time you turn one on??
And also, think of the water!!
It has to be given the line "maybe I'm the only one paying attention"
They lost me at the 0.1 + 0.2 =0.3000000000004 😂
Are people seriously comparing calculators to LLMs
They are. Unironically even. Some even use the term "Luddite" without minimal research into the history. But my personal favorite is the comparison with horses, phone operators and the like. Without the realization of how many generations usually goes between those changes.
I mean, what do you expect from knuckleheads renting intelligence
They finally feel powerful, but in reality they are just like little kids using an aimbot to win in a shooter game.
These idiots are. There's great money in making people even dumber.
Bahaha this is brilliant. I would argue that two things are true from this story. 1) kids should know how to do math without a calculator, and 2) calculators are an incredible tool that can save us all a lot of time.
I am a full stack developer and absolutely love using AI to build apps and software. I can absolutely do the work that it's doing, or most of it anyway, and understand how to properly organize a projec, review code, etct. With that being said, I see no harm in using AI to do my job at a speed that I could have never achieved before.
Yes. Using a calculator to do simple maths is exactly the same as asking chat BPD to write all your essays for you without opening a single book yourself. How remarkably intelligent you must be
I went to college so I could take pictures of math problems, copy the answers that Claude gives me onto a piece of paper, and then turn it in to get sweet future career points. Just like when they invented the calculator! Wow society will be awesome when everyone is educated this way!
Yeah it’s like no one pro on this thread understands that before you need a calculator for bigger numbers, we learn how multiplication works and then with that understanding, apply it to future problems with that knowledge. Which is a good use for the calculator because all it’s doing is acting as a time saving tool and a QC point that basic algebra isn’t wrong.
Meanwhile the way generative AI is used, there is no learning about the things that it does in almost any context unless you learned before AI existed. Like you pointed out before, generating an entire paper for someone deprived them of the exercise of learning to write, and the concept of research and communication.
A 1 to 1 comparison of this strawman calculator example would be if AI was used for grammar and spellcheck on a paper. Which would be completely reasonable if you already learned proper grammar and are just using it for a revisionary tool.
There will be real consequences far in the future if people lose the ability to think for themselves and learn things. Not to mention the actual main reason AI will damage society currently which is economically due to living in a capitalist world.
Yep I completely agree and reiterated this somewhat more simply in my own comment a little while ago. Calculators didn't intend to replace things like mental math and still require actual SKILL to operate in their best capacity (e.g. statistics calculations, probability distribution etc)
Calculators require you to know the equations. And as a not-stupid human, I AM bothered by how many people can’t do basics in their heads anymore. Knowing 6x4 off the top of my head impressed the shit out of a Zoomer.
Was the goal to teach them multiplication? Then yes, the calculator has robbed them of the opportunity to learn something.
Yeah I agree I actually miss being a hunter gatherer more tbh. Well, though ever since we created fire arms I haven't seen many rhinos around.
Everyone shut up, I have a 100% original idea that's going to absolutely blow all your minds and save academia:
In-person, in-class, handwritten essays using pen/pencil and paper
>What really gets me is that nobody wants to talk about is where these things got their math. They stole it. Every calculator runs on centuries of work by real mathematicians, people who poured their whole lives into it. Then some company scraped all of it, crammed it into a $12 piece of plastic, and started selling it. Nobody asked them, and nobody paid them. That’s theft.
I know youre trying a big smart gotcha against LLMs but this part is so stupid it's laughable
You can tell who the antis are because they all completely missed the joke 😂
Posts like this are proof that the brain rot has already taken hold.
what baffles me is the amount of upvotes it has
It spreads fast. This is the purpose of AI.
The irony of saying this when you can't notice obvious satire and reductio ad absurdum...
They did notice it. The fact that in their tiny little brains this is comparable is the evidence of the brainrot
Reducto Absurdum? Is that what you named your AI sex bot?
Yeeeeeeeeah….no.
Ignorance must be a bliss
The irony of saying this when you can’t notice obvious satire and reductio ad absurdum…
I see you are baiting by pretending to be absurd. Aight.
Once we gave up on the slide ruler, we never went back to the moon, think about it — black slate and a stick of white chalk — that’s going to save our youth.
Don't fret. if we ever have "the great EMP", you'll be like a god.
And it turns out, having people who can't do basic arithmetic was pretty bad. The calculator is good as long as we don't use it to make ourselves dumber. The schoolteachers were right on not letting 5 year olds use it.
oh fun, a strawman argument instead of the usual pro-AI whataboutism! still waiting for a real argument from yall tho 🥱
'No True Scotsman' over here searching for a real argument.
lmao fair enough, “real” argument was a silly way to word it for sure
What bile was brought on humanity by the slide rule! How dare such a device used in the dark arts and kept in secrecy have such a control of the devil's arithmetic.
My mom had one of these for her accounting job in the 1970s, not this one exactly.
Congrats on 69.420 years in the business!
Those are the sex numbers AND the drug numbers!
8008135
No you, the e is backwards! You have to type 5318008 and hold the calculator upside down
Well I've been teaching for 67 years and I attack my students with a baseball bat
from 6th grade on I used scientific calculators for maths. Not sure what grade it started for normal people, I was in the gifted math class.
Id bet anything you dont have a real job.
I appreciate the poor analogy but AI is like having a little servant who's mostly good at everything bookwise at your beck and call. Your only issue is hiding your use of him from the faculty so it looks like you're learning the subject matter.
ive learned math stuff so many times i lost count, every time, forget how, relearn, forget how, relearn, waste of time for anyone who isnt gonna practice it often. i believe its more important to know what exists and what you can do with math, if u know this you can always go find it if you need it
Welcome to the age of superficial knowledge, where everybody knows everything but also nothing at the same time.
Wow. This post is so cringe, it's almost too painful to read.
This is seriously some "I'm 14 and this is Deep" type of content.
No. It’s quite obviously a joke 🤦♂️
LOOOOOL. No shit Sherlock.
But the metaphor that OP is trying to illustrate is so childishly immature and stupid that it seriously must have been written by a 14 year old.
What grade are they in? I was learning to multiply like that in 4th-6th grade.
That's not math, that's romanticism.
Yes, of course. 8 billion people and it's all about you. LOL
This time is different
Username def does not checkout
This analogy would be better if you mentioned how some students won't make it all the way through school because their calculator convinced them to kill themselves.
It’s good rhetoric
In statistics it is hard to find how to do stuff too. When you do search you are being offered paid Excel plugins to do statistical work. You do not find "how to do it yourself" tutorials.
you must be joking. trapped by your personal algorithm lol
What part of what I said is wrong?
You do not know how to explain that what he did is not math, yet your job is education.
Based on this post, I have to worry about you and the situation you’re in with teaching these kids. What I’m seeing is that you’re going to Reddit instead of your colleagues because you’re lacking resources and support.
The fact that you’re expressing fear says that you’re not in a position that allows you to think about the process of learning, and that you take no joy in engaging that process. Ideally, that should be your job, but there’s a lack going on here.
Edit: I didn’t look at the subreddit in my feed before clicking on this. Yeah, maybe education isn’t your forte. If I were trying to approach something that I saw as a problem, this is the last place I would search for the answer.
TL;DR: If the emphasis is on suffering as the means for the learning, that’s trauma, not schoolwork.
You've been teaching math for 69 years? How old are you?
This is such a lame post, makes me want to unsubscribe. It's neither funny nor properly edgy or proper satire, nor confronting, nor debating, no holdup, it lacks nuances and doesn't even match the anti-AI side. This is just plane bad. Like writing of a 14 years old, who's trying too hard.
You offered neuroslop to defend neuroslop. Is there any reason to read it and post it? Just ask LLM to write several kind comments to you and be done with it
Ya'll sure love your poor analogies. lol
And that 0.30000000000000004 example... you're using a technical limitation as a gotcha without understanding what causes it.
Strawman. Reasonable people are arguing that the human input is necessary for art. Art does not have an objectively correct answer. Math does. The fact you apparently only view art as an end product is part of the problem. You view it as something to be mass produced.
Comment deleted by user
Math is not science. Science uses math but math is independent.
That said, arithmetic isn’t math, either, just to confuse everyone.