Skip to main content Were they just jerking it like crazy on pirate ships or what? : r/AskHistorians

Were they just jerking it like crazy on pirate ships or what?

All ships really. But they didn’t have room or anything to do it privately. Or did they?


Join the conversation
Best
Open comment sort options

Comments Section

Moderator | Medieval Warfare (Logistics and Equipment)

Hello everyone,

If you are a first time visitor, welcome! This thread is trending high right now and getting a lot of attention, but it is important to remember those upvotes represent interest in the question itself, and it can often take time for a good answer to be written. The mission of r/AskHistorians is to provide users with in-depth and comprehensive responses, and our rules are intended to facilitate that purpose. We remove comments which don't follow them for reasons including unfounded speculation, shallowness, and of course, inaccuracy. Making comments asking about the removed comments simply compounds this issue. So please, before you try your hand at posting, check out the rules, as we don't want to have to warn you further.

Of course, we know that it can be frustrating to come in here from your frontpage or r/all and see only [removed], but we thank you for your patience. If you want to be reminded to come check back later, or simply find other great content to read while you wait, this thread provides a guide to a number of ways to do so, including the RemindMeBot- Click Here to Subscribe - or our Bluesky.

Finally, while we always appreciate feedback, it is unfair to the OP to further derail this thread with META conversation, so if anyone has further questions or concerns, I would ask that they be directed to modmail. Thank you!

There was a great thread I remembered reading about a nearly identical topic. It was about a year ago from u/jschooltiger

Here is the link to it: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/s/y4ckv57Xo8

This was a very good read, thank you.

Hopefully not TOO good of a read.

Don't kink-shame me.

I love this subreddit because where else on the internet am I going to click on a thread asking about pirate sex lives, only to find that it’s been asked and answered in incredible detail already in a previous thread?

Thank you u/jschooltiger! and to you u/AbjectChef2085 for pointing me there
This was really eye opening

Great thread where the answer is just a long-winded "maybe? Who knows." If there were an interesting answer the mods of this subreddit would delete it instantly.

Edited
Moderator | Shipbuilding and Logistics | British Navy 1770-1830

Sorry to be a buzz kill, but the answer for a lot of historical things is that we truly don’t know. Sodomy, being a crime that’s punishable by death, wasn’t something that sailors talked about openly, and we’re talking about a period about 200 years before what we call the social turn in history, when histories of the common person became much more interesting to people and much more emphasized over great man stuff.

What we can do, and what’s done in the books that I referenced, is look at prevailing attitudes towards homosexuality. But even then, we know the lens that we’re looking at the issue through is a lens that has been specifically recorded by people who are relatively elite, and often more concerned about punishment for a suspected crime, than of recording actual attitudes towards homosexuality.

The last word I use there actually gets to a second, larger issue: the idea of homosexuality as an identity, or that a group of people would be homosexual, is a very, very modern construct that didn’t exist in the time we’re talking about. The crimes that we know that are recorded are those of sodomy, which is generally understood as some sort of intercourse that is not penis in vagina. That covers a whole lot of ground for people to get up to all sorts of stuff that is not that, and some of which was probably considered fairly innocuous - stuff like frotting or mutual masturbation doesn’t seem to have been as much of a concern to people as anal intercourse was. There was also a perception, which unfortunately has held on, that men who are interested in other men tend to be interested in young boys first. That’s not to say that there wasn’t likely abuse of the equivalent of midshipman or other boys; there seems to be depressingly universal in close societies where some people have positions of authority over others.

So now that I’ve rambled for a minute, let me get to the point: we know that there was sexual activity on board ships that we would probably describe as homosexual activity today. We have a very incomplete picture of how people at the time thought about it, because the voices of ordinary people are not recorded in the documents that came down to us; those are generally the ones that are concerned with crime and punishment. But what I can’t do is tell you with any certainty that, say, 72% of pirates use their right hand, while another 11% engaged in mutual masturbation with others and 4% had anal sex or whatever. The other issue, of course, is that we don’t know how many men engaged in same sex activity aboard ships, then went on to engage in same-sex activity on shore or over the rest of their lives, or whether some stolen time with another sailor in a quiet corner of the ship was simply something that people did to relieve loneliness and boredom at sea. We’ve recently seen some ships from the US Navy come back from 300+ day deployments at sea; I can guarantee you that there was same-sex and also opposite-sex activity going on during that time, but I doubt we’ll ever know more than anecdotes from that, and this is during a time when gay people can openly serve in the military

To perhaps further illustrate that point, let me tell you about how difficult it is even to find information about women during the age of sail: we know that there were a couple of women who were pirates. We presume that there were probably other women who were aboard pirate ships, either there as some sort of sexual slaves or potentially in a very few cases as members of the crew. We know that men in the Royal Navy often smuggled women award, or that officers and captains could have their wives award for short periods of time, or even that it wasn’t unusual in ships that did not offer liberty in port to simply allow boatloads of sex workers on board: we have an (anecdotal) account from a chaplain of the rather arresting sight of several hundred men and women simultaneously engaging in sex in hammocks on the lower deck. But even though we have those, they are rather fragmentary chunks of evidence that are difficult to make into a social history of women on board ships during this time.

I understand that can be disappointing to people who are used to stats and stories and all sorts of explicit stuff in the modern era, but it’s not fair to the sources, or the very real people who were involved in this trade, to simply make shit up.

Edited
19th c. American Military | War of 1812 | Moderator

This is an interesting and historically vexing question, for a number of reasons. Pirates are haloed with nonsense and it can be difficult to separate historical doomerism and fantasy from modern grimdarkism and fantasy. The history of masturbation seems to have been mostly overlooked despite the popularity and attention of historical sexual topics in recent years. What you're asking requires significant data on two separate questions:

  • how did men commonly engage in masturbation at the time?

  • how similar or different was the same behavior on board a presumably all-male sailing ship?

There is a third, hidden question: should we assume that modern behaviors regarding masturbation are similar in historical spaces? That is, how much of a culture's ideation of sexual activity is a response to inalienably human wiring, and how much of it reflects cultural beliefs and attitudes? Do masturbatory behaviors differ between modern cultures?

This is to say nothing about the cultures of shame and ridicule, the normalization of circumcision as a means to specifically curb masturbation... it's a lot to get your hands on. You must understand that there are historians who may come across data about masturbation as part of larger questions, and there are sexologists studying sexual behaviors who may use historical data for their studies. They do not approach the topic the same way, and they may use data differently and may come to different conclusions.

Let's take the two questions in hand one at a time. The first: it's the Golden Age of Piracy. Let us imagine a recently emancipated indentured servant suffering from an excess of salacious humors, who is not interested in sex with men or animals, and there are no willing women nearby. Presuming there is time and opportunity, does he even want to masturbate?

To preface, we don't know how much masturbation was "normal" in this period. We know that masturbation emerged into the western European cultural conversation in a very big way around 1715 with the publication of Onania: or, the Heinous Sin of Self-Polution by an anonymous author. The word Onan, Onania, Onanism etc comes from the Biblical story of Onan who, ordered by God to copulate with his late brother's widow instead "spilled his semen on the ground" and was put to death thereafter. The lesson being: semen has a place where it belongs, which is inside you or inside your wife and if it's anywhere else it is an appalling sin.

Onania was articulating beliefs that many would have held before the publication of the pamphlet, many of which sound familiar today. A couple of excerpts:

IN some it has been the Cause of fainting Fits and Epilepsies; in others of Consumptions; and many young Men who were strong and lusty before they gave themselves over to this Vice, have been worn out by it, and by its robbing the Body of its balmy and vital Moisture, without Cough or Spitting, dry and emaciated, sent to their Graves. In others again, whom it has not kill'd, it has produc'd Nightly and excessive Seminal Emissions; a Weakness in the Penis, and loss of Erection, as if they had been Castrated.

if we turn our Eyes upon licentious Masturbaters, we shall find them with meagre Jaws, and pale Looks, with feeble Hams, and Legs without Calves, their Generative Faculties weakon'd, if not destroy'd in the Prime of their Years. A Jest to others, and a Torment to themselves.

This would certainly have not been written if no one was masturbating, but more questions follow. Why, if we presume that every generation of humans who have ever existed have had the same sexual urges we do, was masturbation a quiet non-issue until ~1715? What motivated someone to take up a pen and write 83 pages about how fucked up you'll be if you touch your dick?

I think the answer is, partially, the combined effect of the enclosures along with Calvinist moral activism. Enclosures were the process by which landowners ended centuries of common law land usage to build factories and mines and so on. This in turn led to a sharp rise in poverty, and the growth of the urban poor. Overcrowded, filthy cities lend themselves to disease and crime, and many of those unfortunate enough to be born into urban poverty who survived into young adulthood did so with visible health defects, unhealed injuries and so on. This is, for instance, why recruiting men into the army or navy often required recruiters to check recruits' teeth, the straightness of their limbs and so on.

The way you deal with all these unwashed paupers is to criminalize poverty and sentence those guilty of not having any money to transportation, which meant that you were sold into indentured servitude and shipped - transported - to the colonies. There, your contract could be bought and sold and even if you, unlike an enslaved African, were not doomed to a hereditary enslavement that didn't mean your life was any less miserable. Alexander Esquemeling, a former indentured servant who accompanied Henry Morgan on a number of his barbarous campaigns, argues that indentures were often forced to do the more dangerous work simply because to lose an indenture lost a few years of labor, whereas losing a slave meant losing decades.

By Calvinism, I don't mean the faith itself but the belief that the government should exert a controlling influence on people's private lives, not simply stopping at their public behavior. Consider laws against adultery: it is a crime because it is disruptive. It threatens to disentangle business relationships at minimum, and lead to murder at maximum. It makes sense, in theory, for the government to encourage folks not to covet each others' wives and punish those who do for the same reason it makes sense to punish people who cause traffic jams or fire guns off at random.

But what's the reason that I, hypothetically a citizen reading Onania, might want to see masturbation punished? If we assume the reader has perhaps a time or two shamefully committed an appalling sin when no one else was around, what does it matter? Adultery is socially and economically disruptive, there are external stakes. Even if masturbation was self-pollution to a preposterous degree, the masturbator, by definition, can't really hurt anyone but themselves.

The answer there is that Calvinism uses law as a form of social activism because they believed that policing personal ethics would prevent the inevitable death of their civilization. These are the same stresses that, in the 1880s, lead to the perception that queerness was a social harm, that even allowing the existence of queerness would destroy the institution of marriage and western society would collapse into orgiastic anarchy. The anonymous writer of Onania has identified the same disastrous future not with homosexuality but with autosexuality (or perhaps egosexuality). If a man willingly pollutes himself for a bit of pleasure then what will he do when if he has power? The taboo against masturbation in Onania is entirely about reinforcing the border between prosocial sexuality - you have sex with your wife to propagate the race and for no other reason - and every other type of sexual behavior, which was then "buggery" or "sodomy:" any unauthorized sexual act.

All of which is to say that we know that there was enough masturbation out there in the world prior to 1715 for some folks to have developed some theory about how it was going to destroy the world. But apart from knowing that it existed and was the #1 public enemy, there is basically no way to make any kind of argument about frequency. I would be willing to bet that people today are far more likely to masturbate, and to do it much more frequently, than most folks in the past simply because no one in 1715 had internet pornography. I could very well be wrong. Later writers following Onania seem to suggest that excessive masturbation is the cause of every manner of death possible, which might be taken to mean that everyone was doing it. We just don't know, the evidence is very low-resolution.

So what about on board ship? Well it depends on the ship and the journey, and a number of other factors. Many pirates cruised around in small craft like periaguas and were lucky if they got hold of a sloop of some kind. Their cruises were short, and in the Golden Age Nassau was full to bursting with pirates and their go-betweens, and the average pirate might not be more than a few days on either side of carnal opportunity.

Things would be different in a navy, or long exploration voyage, where months might go by before similar opportunities arise. Though the navy has a deserved reputation for brutality and cruelty, many of the men in the navy may have come from situations on land which were similarly antaphrodisiacal, where opportunities for private self-pleasure would be risky and discouraged.

All in all in answer to the question on the marquee: were they jerking it like crazy? Probably not. Probably a few on every ship in history jerked like crazy and threw off the average. But we can't really know the whole extent of it. As humans our desire for sexual satisfaction has likely not changed in more than a hundred thousand years, but our relationship to our own bodies, the understanding of our sexual biology and psychology and so on, to say nothing of the culture itself, has changed and will continue to change.

You may be interested in Mels van Driel's With the Hand: A Cultural History of Masturbation (2012) and Thomas Laquer's Solitary Sex: A Cultural History of Masturbation (2003).

Quality Contributor

An important thing to note about self-pleasuring is that it was common enough of a thing that the 4th Century monk John Cassian listed masturbation as one of the four types of fornication and described it as a naturally occurring weakness of the flesh. Cassian was born to wealthy parents so he was part of the cultured Roman elite, not the "uncultured and unrefined" classes who one would think would be more familiar with the act.

The theologian Peter of Poiters associated it with homosexuality which increased it's perception as a horrific sin.

The Cannons of Theodore specifically list the penances and punishments for masturbation to include the frequent practice of it.

19th c. American Military | War of 1812 | Moderator

I don't disagree with any of this necessarily, I never said it wasn't present in human culture. I assume that the vast majority of humans who have existed have been aware that they could give themselves an orgasm and most probably have at one point or another.

That can be true in a society in which a man might feel horribly shameful after the fact and forswear himself never to do it again and then not do it again for weeks, and equally true in a society in which a man might masturbate multiple times a day, every day. There is no way to know if the data we do have about masturbation describes one type or the other.

That's all I mean. I think there is a tendency in the discussion of historical sexuality to assume that patterns of sexual behavior largely follow the observable patterns of sexual behavior in modern culture, and I think that the sexual cultures are too different between the 21st century and, for instance, the early 18th that we cannot afford to ride on any assumptions.

This is all just my own interpretation of the data I am aware of, and in general I caution folks from making assumptions like "people today masturbate all the time, so it must be true of humans in all historical periods too." Masturbation as a topic has not had the kind of attention that other types of sexual activity has, for reasons I think are understandably interrelated to the way people think about and engage in masturbation today - that it is private, shameful, and ubiquitous - and to the paucity of historical evidence.

Quality Contributor

Oh yeah, no. I wasn't disagreeing with you at all! Just adding some additional cultural context and background, and I meant the "Western Pirates" for the OP's question.

Sorry if I was giving the wrong impression I was critiquing!

Yeah I'm actually curious whether Internet has overnormalized their sexual behavior across cultures and times. It's obviously a private affair, so it's very very hard to actually confirm, so it's the prime breeding ground for hoaxes.

I realized this when I notice that almost all sexual words in my language is imported from western culture. For something that we should've done since the dawn of time! Maybe it's because western cultures are the first one to actually talk about it, but maybe as you said, it's not talked about because it's actually not that prevalent. Still, because of its private nature, this is an unfalsifiable topic. Neither of us would be able to conjure a convincing evidence either way.

Repost

Repost suggestions