Surely beauty matters. The impact of beauty on our lives is undoubtedly pervasive. Along with other human characteristics, beauty is an important quality through which individuals assess themselves and others. Equally ubiquitous is the concept of beautification. As of 2023, beauty is the third most popular category among global Instagram influencers, only after music and lifestyle (
Statista, 2024a). The thriving beauty industry prompts people to care about their appearance and attend to various seemingly viable means of beautification. Beyond holding a more subjective view that beauty is “in the eyes of a suitable beholder,” people spend considerable effort to enhance their beauty. One means is via the use of cosmetics, with the global cosmetics market estimated to value at 758.4 billion U.S. dollars by 2025 (
Statista, 2024b), even higher than the GDP of Belgium (689.36 billion U.S. dollars) which is ranked 23 of the major economies (
Investopedia, 2024). Even during the COVID-19 pandemic, beauty products have been considered an essential commodity (
CNBC, 2020). Being able to beautify the self has had “currency” probably since before at least 2,500 years ago when people started to debate about what beauty is (
Feagin, 1995;
Reber et al., 2004;
Tatarkiewicz, 1970). Beauty signals success in life. It is positively correlated with social and professional skills (
Langlois et al., 2000). In labor economics, physically attractive workers are considered to be more able by employers (
Mobius & Rosenblat, 2006). In the present research, we ask several fundamental questions. Given the pervasive roles that beauty has in multiple domains of our life, do beliefs in the improvability and malleability of this human attribute influence decision making? If so, what are the nature of these effects? We attempt to answer these questions by examining the effect of implicit theories of beauty on risk-taking behavior.
These research questions are unique and important because of theoretical and practical reasons. First, understanding whether and how beliefs pertaining to beauty may play a role in behavior and decision-making is important given that individuals are bombarded by numerous media messages on the notion of beautifying the self on a daily basis. Second, human traits and attributes do not only make a direct impact on behavior and decision-making but also
indirectly via implicit theories, which shape how people make judgment about the self and others. Surprisingly, how beliefs or mindsets about beauty, which is one of the most important human attributes, influence human behavior, is largely unknown. Third, most research in this area has mainly focused on the effect of implicit theories on how people process information (encoding, attention;
Hong et al., 2009) and form judgment about the self and others
within the same domain of interest (
Dweck et al., 1993,
1995;
Dweck & Leggett, 1988). Implicit theories may influence within-domain self-regulatory processes and affective, cognitive, and behavioral outcomes. Renowned researchers have urged for an increased attention to a follow-up research avenue, namely, how implicit theories influence cross-domain judgment and decisions (e.g.
Molden & Dweck, 2006). This research attention is particularly germane to the beauty domain because of the broad nature of beauty (i.e. beauty is considered to be correlated with reproduction ability, financial success, and positive trait perceptions such as credibility). In the current research, we asked whether and how implicit theories of beauty may transcend the beauty domain and influence non-beauty related risk-taking behavior. Fourth, the current research provides robust evidence that uniquely distinguishes itself from previous studies.
In the remainder of this article, we first describe our theorizing of how implicit theories of beauty may be related to risk-taking. Next, we present a set of seven studies, and three supplementary studies in Supplemental Materials, which examined the causal influence of beauty implicit theories on risk-taking indirectly through felt optimism that positive outcomes would occur in many domains in life. Finally, we discuss the theoretical and practical implications of the current research.
Implicit Theories of Beauty
Scholars (
Chiu, Hong, et al., 1997;
Dweck et al., 1995;
Hong et al., 1997) have identified two types of implicit theories: an entity theory, which refers to the belief that human attributes and characteristics are fixed and cannot be changed, and an incremental theory which sees them as changeable and improvable with effort and able to be cultivated. Implicit theories have been shown to influence attitudes and behavior across various domains, such as intelligence (
Hong et al., 1999;
Nussbaum & Dweck, 2008), race (
Tadmor et al., 2013), morality (
Chiu, Dweck, et al., 1997), and sexuality (
Maxwell et al., 2016). Numerous studies have demonstrated how implicit theories influence information processing and decision-making (
Dweck et al., 1993,
Kwon & Nayakankuppam, 2015;
Mathur et al., 2012). For example, entity (incremental) theorists of intelligence tend to make trait (effort) attributions when evaluating failures of themselves and others (
Dweck et al., 1993); entity (incremental) theorists of moral characters, meanwhile, tend to make stronger (weaker) trait-attributions for others’ recent behavior as well as more long-term behavioral predictions (
Dweck et al., 1995).
Previous findings on implicit theories have primarily focused on trait-like attributes (e.g. intelligence, morality, personality, race, gender roles) and transient states (e.g. emotion, feelings of interest, shyness). Surprisingly, not much attention has been paid to beauty. There are two exceptions which have robustly confirmed in both the field and lab that beauty implicit theories exist (
Burkley et al., 2014;
Faust et al., 2024). Unlike most human attributes that have been studied (e.g. intelligence, morality, emotions, and passion), beauty is a human attribute that is immediately visible to the external environment. Its visibility may contribute to its immediate impact on perceptions in social and professional domains. Beautiful people are perceived to be capable and paid good salary in labor market (e.g.
Mobius & Rosenblat, 2006). Intelligence and morality do not necessarily bring similar, immediate impact on professional success and social perceptions. A meta-analysis showed that a relatively larger proportion of physically attractive adults (68%) are high income earners, compared to that among physically unattractive adults (32%) (
Langlois et al., 2000). Given that beauty has such a strong and direct effect on individuals’ decisions across a broad number of domains (reproductive, social, and professional), it is reasonable to assume that how people believe about beauty (i.e. implicit theories) may bring strong and unique impact on decisions related to risk-taking. Understanding how implicit theories of beauty influence decision-making and behavior is important because human attributes and traits may influence judgment and behavior both
directly (e.g. via beauty) and
indirectly (via implicit theories about beauty).
Implicit Theories of Beauty, Optimism, and Risk-taking
The present research is focused on the indirect effect of beauty theories on individuals’ behavior. We conjecture that they provide distinctive effects on (a) general risk-taking behavior, and (b) this is because the broad and visible nature of beauty elevates a sense of optimism that positive outcomes would occur in various domains in life (
Scheier & Carver, 1985;
Scheier et al., 1994). Given the breadth of impact of beauty on multiple domains, it is reasonable to argue that implicit theories of beauty may produce cross-domain influences. We define cross-domain influences as the impact of beauty implicit theories that occur in seemingly unrelated domains in life. Previous research has provided some evidence for the relationship between beauty and risk-taking. For example, a study showed that young men tend to take more physical risk in the presence of an attractive female (
Ronay & Hippel, 2010). Further, men who see other attractive men take greater financial risks to increase their desirability as a mating partner to women (
Chan, 2015). Attractiveness-enhancement goals were found to increase young women’s willingness to take health-related risks such as tanning and taking dangerous diet pills (
Hill & Durante, 2011). In addition, even though the few research that examined implicit theories of beauty (e.g.
Burkley et al., 2014;
Faust et al., 2024) did not directly test beauty-related risk-taking, the findings point to a possibility that an incremental (vs. entity) theory of beauty may be more related to risky beautification methods. Specifically,
Faust et al. (2024) found that beauty entity (vs. incremental) theorists consume more cosmetic products, whereas
Burkley et al. (2014) showed that beauty incremental (vs. entity) theorists were more likely to undertake cosmetic surgery, which is riskier compared to using cosmetic products. If a growth mindset of beauty leads to more beauty-related risk-taking, would it also influence risk-taking behavior beyond the beauty domain? Given the broad nature of beauty, we argue that should be the case.
We hypothesize that individuals who believe that beauty is malleable and improvable tend to take more risks in their decision-making because this belief may promote a sense of optimism about future outcomes in various domains in life. Why are beauty incremental theorists more optimistic than beauty entity theorists? Established research in implicit theories have shown that beliefs in malleability of human attributes shape individuals’ self-enhancement focus (
Mathur et al., 2016). Fixed mindset disposes individuals to attend to signaling their performance and abilities to others whereas growth mindset disposes individuals to attend to learning of the relevant human attributes and traits (e.g. beauty, intelligence, morality). Entity theorists tend to give up more easily in order to avoid signaling poor performance to the self and others. In the domain of beauty,
Faust et al. (2024) showed that entity theorists of beauty are similarly pressured about how they are evaluated by others. Beauty entity theorists experience social pressure arising from having to improve their physical appearance (i.e. to perform well). It suggests that this social pressure may hinder entity theorists from experiencing any optimistic feelings about future outcomes. In contrast, beauty incremental theorists tend to inherently focus on the improvement of beauty itself. Given the pervasive impact of beauty on social and professional success, we conjecture that believing in the improvability of beauty (i.e. incremental theory) may cultivate a sense of optimism about future outcomes in domains beyond beauty.
Indeed, as we mentioned earlier, beauty signals success in life. Beauty is positively correlated with perceptions of goodness (
Tsukiura & Cabeza, 2011), trustworthiness (
Wilson & Eckel, 2006), intelligence (
Zebrowitz et al., 2002), and social skills (
Langlois et al., 2000). Compared to unattractive adults, attractive adults receive more attention, positive social interaction, and help from others than do unattractive adults; they also achieve greater occupational success, have more dating experience, are more popular, and enjoy better physical and mental health (
Langlois et al., 2000).
Previous research has shown that attractive faces elicit activation in brain regions that respond to other types of reward, such as monetary reward or pleasant chemosensory stimuli (
Aharon et al., 2001). To the extent that people prefer beauty (e.g. choosing beautiful products; choosing to help beautiful beneficiaries) (
Bloch et al., 2003;
Cryder et al., 2017), merely believing that one’s own beauty can be improved may elevate a sense of positive outcome expectations. Beauty entity theorists, however, tend to focus on signaling their beauty (i.e. performance; or how good they look) to others; they may experience social pressure as recent studies suggest (
Faust et al., 2024). Hence, believing that beauty is largely unimprovable does not dispose them to experience a similar sense of optimism.
A meta-analysis showed that a belief in incremental theory is positively associated with positive outcome expectations during self-monitoring of goal progress (
Burnette et al., 2013). No research, however, has experimentally studied whether a more general sense of optimism can be generated and the causal influence of implicit theories on it. We propose that merely believing in the improvability of beauty may promote a sense of optimism that positive outcomes will occur in various domains of life. This might happen because of a belief held by many that beauty has broad impact in various areas. Our conjecture is supported by previous research, which suggested that physical attractiveness matters for important life outcomes (
Anderson et al., 2008). Importantly, people believe that physically attractive individuals experience more positive life outcomes than do their unattractive counterparts (
Dion et al., 1972). This effect has been documented in prior research as a physical attractiveness stereotyping effect, such that people not only judge attractive (vs. unattractive) individuals more positively on a variety of desirable attributes but also expect attractive individuals to experience greater overall happiness, obtain more prestigious jobs, have better marriages, and lead more satisfying social and professional lives (
Dion et al., 1972). There seems to be an expectation that attractive people should achieve more desirable life outcomes, such as marital happiness and occupational success (
Dickey-Bryant et al., 1986). Thus, believing one can improve one’s beauty should produce a sense of optimism that positive outcomes can be achieved in many domains of life.
This sense of optimism may motivate people to take more risks. Outside the beauty domain, a
correlational relationship between optimism and risk-taking has already been established (
Anderson & Galinsky, 2006;
Puri & Robinson, 2007;
Shah & Li, 2024). In a study by
Anderson and Galinsky (2006), people who were primed with power had more optimistic risk perceptions which led them to take more risks. Previous research has shown that optimists (vs. pessimists) tend to focus on the positive (vs. negative) outcomes of risky decisions which leads them to take more risks (
Dohmen et al., 2023). Even after experiencing negative gaming outcomes, optimists were more likely than pessimists to maintain positive expectations and continue gambling (
Gibson & Sanbonmatsu, 2004). In an organizational context, there is evidence that CEOs who were optimists were more likely to take on and pay more for a corporate merger and were also more likely to undertake value-destroying mergers (
Malmendier & Tate, 2008). Thus, the association between optimism and risk-taking is not new. No research, however, has examined the causal relationship between optimism and risk-taking in a seemingly unrelated domain. The present research intends to experimentally vary implicit theories of beauty and optimism to examine (a) whether implicit theories of beauty causally influence optimism that positive outcomes occur in
various domains in life and, if so, (b) whether enhanced cross-domain risk-taking behavior results as a downstream consequence.
Overview of Studies
Ten studies, including three supplementary studies, test our hypotheses. Across studies, we employed different measures of risk-taking behavior, both intentional and behavioral measures, in order to ensure that the effect observed is not merely a single effect on a specific risk-taking measure (
Crandall & Sherman, 2016). More importantly, we intended to examine whether the effect of beauty implicit theories on risk-taking occurs in various seemingly unrelated domains of life, verifying our assumption that people hold a belief that beauty has broad impact on various areas of life.
In most studies, we aimed for at least 100 participants per condition. Results of sensitivity analyses by G*Power (
Faul et al., 2009) show that these sample sizes provide 80% power (α = .05) to detect small effects in most studies (Study 1:
f2 = .01; Study 2:
η2 = .02; Study 3:
η2 = .017; Study 4:
η2 = .024; Study 5:
d = 0.19; Study 6:
d = 0.39; Study 7:
η2 = .027). We report all manipulations, measures, and exclusions in these studies. Studies 5, 6, 7, and Supplementary Studies B and C were preregistered.
1 Data, analysis codes, and materials are available at
https://osf.io/4s3nw/?view_only=07b74c9e89104d3e9458982b7725b18d.
General Discussion
Ten studies, including three supplementary studies, support the core hypothesis that implicit theories of beauty influence people’s tendency to engage in risk-taking behavior. Study 1 provided cross-country evidence on the correlational relationship between implicit theories of beauty and risk-taking. Study 2 provided causal evidence for the effect of beauty theories on a real, consequential risk-taking behavior. Supplementary Study A replicated this effect with a different measure of risk-taking. In Study 3, including a control condition indicated that it is the enhancing effect of an incremental theory, rather than the attenuating effect of an entity theory, that drove the risk-taking tendency observed. In Study 4, we showed that the effect of implicit theories is contingent on the domain; implicit theories of beauty influenced people’s risk-taking tendency, whereas implicit theories of intelligence did not show any effects. In Study 5, we showed that people hold a strong implicit association between beauty and optimism, more so than between moderate-looking and optimism. In Studies 6 and 7, we demonstrated that the effect is specific to beauty because of the belief that beauty has broad impact in various areas of life. Specifically, Study 6 showed the mediation of felt optimism that positive outcomes will occur in many domains of life, and Study 7 showed that the effect disappeared when the belief that beauty has broad impact was weakened. Supplementary Studies B and C further confirmed that optimism underlined the effect of implicit theories of beauty on risk-taking. Supplementary Study B established the causal link between implicit theories of beauty and optimism, and Supplementary Study C directly manipulated optimism to demonstrate its causal effect on risk-taking behavior.
Previous research has documented how implicit theories may influence information processing and decision-making (
Dweck et al., 1993,
1995;
Dweck & Leggett, 1988;
Kwon & Nayakankuppam, 2015;
Mathur et al., 2012). Most of the existing findings have largely focused on understanding the impact of implicit theories on domain-specific decision contexts. To our knowledge, the present research is among the first to demonstrate that domain-specific implicit theories may influence decision-making and behavior outside that domain. As noted earlier, we consider cross-domains of life that are seemingly unrelated to or not directly related to beauty. We seek to extend past research on implicit theories by demonstrating the effect of implicit theories of beauty on an important aspect of human behavior, namely risky decision-making. Adding to previous research which demonstrated that risk-taking in decision-making can be affected by cognitive, emotional, and social factors that are not directly related to the decision per se (e.g.
Duclos et al., 2013;
Hsee & Weber, 1999;
Zhu et al., 2012), we showed that implicit theories of beauty is a novel and important antecedent of risk-taking behavior. Further, this work is the first to demonstrate that (a) implicit theories of beauty increases optimism that positive outcomes would occur in various domains in life, and (b) this sense of optimism increases risk-taking behavior. We thus contribute to the literature examining the antecedents (
Anderson & Galinsky, 2006;
Monga & Houston, 2006) and consequences of optimism (
Chan et al., 2013;
Zhang et al., 2007).
Our findings ruled out several alternative explanations including salience of loss in financial decision scenarios (
Montford et al., 2019), perceptions of one’s own beauty, cultural orientations, and affect. In particular, Study 1 showed that the correlational relationship between implicit theories of beauty and risk-taking remains across cultures that is more collectivistic or individualistic. Across studies, we considered both decision-making scenarios in which loss is salient or not so salient. A previous research showed that loss salience moderates the impact of implicit self-theories on financial risk-taking (
Montford et al., 2019). The latter work focuses on a different domain and a different dependent variable (self-theories, rather than beauty theories; and financial risk-taking, rather than general risk-taking as in the present research). Our results suggest that beauty implicit theories influence risk-taking behavior regardless of salience of loss presented in the decision scenarios considered.
Our findings also provide important societal implications. By identifying the consequence of implicit beauty beliefs and shedding light on the mechanism and motivation behind it, we hope to help individuals make more informed decisions in their lives. For instance, individuals who tend to believe in the malleability of beauty should be aware of how their heightened optimism may affect their decisions and thus, such individuals should especially consider their choices carefully and rationally to avoid any unrealistic optimism.
The present research informs several meaningful avenues of future research. First, while we found that an incremental theory of beauty increased the optimism that one will achieve favorable outcomes in many domains of life, we did not directly test why this occurs. Although the impact of implicit theories on information processing and decision-making is well-established (
Dweck et al., 1993,
1995;
Dweck & Leggett, 1988), its impact on optimism is not foreordained. It is plausible that individuals who endorse a beauty incremental belief would perceive a heightened likelihood of attaining mastery of beauty, which in turn may enhance a sense of optimism of future positive outcomes given the broad nature of beauty. Future research may examine this assumption. Second, we did not investigate any potential boundary conditions. Our conjecture is that beauty implicit theories have an impact on risk-taking in domains outside of beauty (cross-domains of life). We showed empirical evidence for our predictions across various domains. However, we did not examine the boundaries of our conjecture. Future research can further examine potential moderators that could influence the effect of beauty theories on risk-taking behavior of different domains. Third, numerous research has shown that gender plays a significant role in the impact of physical attractiveness (
Feingold, 1990;
Li et al., 2013;
Shackelford et al., 2005). To examine the role of gender in the effect of beauty implicit theories on risk-taking in our studies, we conducted additional analyses (reported in
Supplemental Material S19) which showed that the effects of gender were not consistent across studies. For example, in Study 1 in which we measured chronic beauty implicit theories and risk-taking propensity across two countries, we observed a significant interaction of beauty implicit theories and gender on risk-taking. The effect of beauty incremental theory was stronger among men than women. In Study 3, we observed similar interactive effect of beauty implicit theories and gender. In other studies, beauty implicit theories did not interact with gender. We do not know why this is the case. Given the gender differences demonstrated in the attractiveness literature, research investigating the role of gender in the effects of beauty implicit theories could offer intriguing insights.