Skip to main content Why is a maths degree sooooo hard even though i was really good In maths at school? How do i get super good? : r/mathematics

Why is a maths degree sooooo hard even though i was really good In maths at school? How do i get super good?

I’m studying maths at uni and I’ve been finding it incredibly hard. I have 2 unit finals in about 6 weeks and right now I don’t consider myself great. Like I will definitely pass but I NEED a first class (+70%) preferably even higher than that which is hard right now. My units are Linear Algebra and an introduction to Pure for this half of the year.

How do i study for it? It has gotten to a point that i don’t even wanna look at the problem sheets. Like i learn the content from the notes and then when i try to do the problem sheets, past the first part which is easy i usually can’t complete the questions or even if i do it’s either wrong or somethings missing.

How do i get better with the 6 weeks that i have ahead of me?

If i catch up now I think I will have a very comfortable next half of the year since I will kinda learn how to revise for Uni.


Join the conversation
Top (Default)
Open comment sort options

Comments Section

if its hard u r in correct class

u have to just do it, maybe ask around for problem solving tips idk

Wow that’s an interesting way to put it. That itself made me motivated.

Edited

The bad news is that "maths" in school often has very little to do with the actual work of mathematicians. It is often more taught purely as "calculation" than "mathematics". (Of course massive over-generalisation here. Maths is taught very differently all over the world)

That's bad news for students who excelled at "maths" in school and are suddenly confronted with real maths. On the other hand, it's good news for students who sucked at "maths" in school; they have a real chance of doing better when doing actual maths.

As to "how to study". Again: Good news and bad news. The bad news is that the methods of studying that are often encouraged when learning school-"maths" don't really apply to maths. There is very little to be gained from repetition of recipes for calculations. You can gain speed at doing calculations that way, but that's not what matters in maths. In maths, the "why does this work at all?" is many orders of magnitude more important that the "how fast can I do it?". And even "can I calculate anything at all?" may sometimes be a second-class question over the "is there even an answer in the first place?" kind of question.

You have to be in the right frame of mind for these kinds of deeper questions to be successful in maths. You have to always look for the "why" behind it all, for the logical connections between things that force everything to be the way it inevitable has to be.

So bad news: If you're not in that frame of mind, it's going to be very hard. But good news: If you are in that frame of mind, if you like the puzzle-aspect of it all, then "being good at maths" can flow very natural from your own curiosity. Sadly, many modern systems of education, including university-level systems, are not really set up to reward curiosity and put too much pressure on students to achieve more easily-measured goals instead.

This leads to the curious situation in which the students which care very little about their studies can do better than students who are totally laser-focused, because the former style gives one more freedom to be curious.

Of course, I don't know about your specific situation, so this is all very general advice.

Thanks a lot for your advice. I understand what you are saying and I will have a think about how I can increase that level of curiosity

Pasting what I wrote on a similar post yesterday...

This is entirely normal for a student starting a mathematics degree in the UK. 

New material is thrown at you ten times faster than it was at school,  because everyone in your lectures was, like you, top of the class at school and not really stretched. 

Analysis is particularly tough because you've never seen anything like it before. I can still remember the shock, though it was 40 years ago.

Yes it does get better, because you get used to the pace, you get used to the fact that there's stuff you don't understand and questions you can't do, you get used to not being top of the class anymore. Also, in years 2 and 3 you get some choice so you can pick the topics you like best.

Your university tutor should have given you a pep talk along these lines. 

Thanks for your comment.
Is there a way to not feel that way and to actually be the best?
I know it requires hard work but what kind of work is considered as hard work in a maths degree?

In high school, you never read the book, you just went straight to the exercises and learned via trial and error.

In university, *you have to read the book-*in particular the theorems and their proofs-to understand how to do other proofs.

In short, do intensive reading of section material before trying out the more involved proof-based exercises.

Hope this helps.

Incubation, as I understand it, is where, if you get stuck, you back away from it and maybe come back the next day. Your mind will have worked on it, even though you weren't concentrating on it.

True, very true

Profile Badge for the Achievement Top 1% Commenter Top 1% Commenter

Here's what I would do based on my own experiences in high school, college, and graduate school.

I would get a copy of my textbook and supplemental textbooks with their solutions manuals. I would use my course syllabus or ask my instructor to tell me what chapters and topics are being covered.

Now, I would read everything a few times and do end-of-chapter problems and then work on practice tests.

I would read a chapter in 3 passes. 

The first pass is the one where I read the text like a novel. So, for 100 pages, it would take me anywhere from 1.5 to 3.5 hours, depending on whether I am familiar with the content or not as well as the font size. I am just getting passive familiarity with notation, terminology, symbols, presentation, writing style, etc. I'm not reading for memory nor understanding at that point. I am getting a sense of what is being discussed (and in what order) and what comes next.

On the second pass, I am reading and then handwriting definitions, theorems, lemmas, corollaries, propositions, core proofs, key examples and counterexamples, helpful diagrams, procedures, formulas, etc. into notecards to memorize them all. This can take anywhere from 5 to 25 hours, depending on the information density of the pages. This step is key.

On the third pass, I would work on end-of-chapter problems if available, or I would rework proofs in the main text to see if I can emulate the methods and techniques presented. Here, I am spending more time studying patterns and approaches.

Each problem gets 5 serious attempts from me of at most 20 minutes. After 20 minutes, I skip it and come back to work on other problems and walk in nature or take a nap. After the 5th attempt, I look up the solution, study it, write it down, try to explain it to myself, and then I rewrite it from memory on a blank sheet of paper without looking.

I would then check all of my other answers. If there were mistakes, I would make a mental note of them and rework the problems I missed a couple of times.

Finally, I would go over any available practice tests or create my own with questions from the lectures and textbook or look up ones at other schools, and I would do a few tests under timed conditions to see how I do. If there are solutions available, I would score myself, and rework problems I missed and look for similar ones for practice.

THANK YOU SO MUCH!
It looks like it will be hard and very long but if that’s what it takes to get better and maybe even on of the best i will have to do it.

Profile Badge for the Achievement Top 1% Commenter Top 1% Commenter

My pleasure! 😄 I got A's in those classes in undergrad , so if you do that and go to office hours, you should be set.

Math is hard, no matter how good you were at school as university level maths is something different and way more abstract and proof oriented.

The best way is not to do it on your own. You need other people to collaborate on your problem sheets with. Not only does it get easier to solve a problem with 3 or 4 people, but it also teaches you different approaches and ways to think about a problem.

I managed to graduate with a MMath 1st and here's how I did it. Now as you've only got 6 weeks this might be more advice for next year but... Go to everything and do everything you can.

I mean everything, do any little practice questions they set, go to any problem solving seminars, even if they are optional, it will help your understanding and be good practice.

Another important thing is office hours, go to them, every week. Get to know your lecturers and make sure they know you and see your passion. Turn up with questions you have or even if you've done all the work see if they can give you deeper insights on what you've learnt or further ideas. It will massively help in the long run.

I will use this for my next term but thank you so much!!

What unit courses are you preparing for right now?

Introduction to pure and linear algebra

What is "pure"? Pure Mathematics?

Yes, sorry for the unclear answer

And what are the topics you are learning right now?

الكيمياء العضوية الرياضية ⚗️

Maths at school is mostly problem solving, some mathematical modelling, a little bit of logic but nothing excessive.

Maths at uni - in my parts of the world - begins right where school maths end.

Analysis, algebra, vectors, sets, functions, logic. While many of the topics are familiar (and it's not like you never get 'applied' problems to solve), the treatment is anything but. Everything is proof-based and abstract. The mindset shift is what gets most people.

Get better: Learn the ropes of proofs and logic. I suppose 'introduction to pure maths' is essentially a logic and proofs course, maybe using some set theory examples. A book like Velleman or Bloch might be a good read, though even Gowers (VSI Mathematics) does a great job of explaining how mathematical argument works.

Linear algebra: The abstraction of vector spaces is essential and one of the main points of the entire mod but consider - as a stepping stone, if nothing else - visual intuition for what's going on. 3Blue1Brown's videos do this very well. The book by Strang also ties things to solving linear equations, which is a major motivation for the development of linear algebra.

Profile Badge for the Achievement Top 1% Commenter Top 1% Commenter

because high school maths and university maths are basically completely separate subjects. there is no "real maths" in a high school maths class.

high school math is VASTLY different from uni math. i’m in my last semester for mathematics undergrad and when i was a sophomore i was beating myself up for not being smart enough and being bad at math. now things i learned that year come easily to me and im struggling all over again with the even more advanced stuff but this time i know. it’s really all about practice. you can study and read definitions all day but you have to solve problems and proofs and get into the weeds to really grasp it.

Do you go to Oxford by chance?

intro to pure + linalg sounds suspiciously like UOB maths course 🤨

Repost

Repost suggestions