What is 'mathematical maturity' to you?
Hello r/math,
I have recently been poking around some math books, and I have come across the concept of mathematical maturity a lot. Sometimes being 'mathematically mature' seems to mean "you are smart enough and have enough tools at your disposal to prove the theorems contained in this book all by yourself (after some effort)." Other times it only seems to mean "you are independent enough and curious enough to do mathematical work independently, and look for your own answers whenever you have questions." This seems a bit fuzzy to me. What do you think? Is mathematical maturity dependent on how much math you already know? Or does it depend on how independent you are as a person? both? If you think you have mathematical maturity, when did you start thinking you had it? How does one go from not having it to having it?
Comments Section
I think "mathematical maturity" refers to how much math you've seen and how comfortable you are with common arguments and ideas.
One example is a "compactness argument". When you first learn topology, you prove lots of facts about compact sets by painstakingly going through the details and definitions---continuous functions on compact sets achieve a maximum, compact subsets of hausdorff spaces are closed... Mathematical maturity is realizing that all these proofs are variations of the same theme. This comes after figuring out lots of proofs. Once you have this maturity, someone can tell you that something is true "by a compactness argument" and you'll be able to visualize the proof in your head without getting the details fed to you.
Another example is the concept of a vector bundle. It took me years to feel comfortable with vector bundles. Now that I get it, I have an easier time understanding lots of other constructions that build on the same ideas... For instance, understanding how a vector bundle can be locally trivial but not globally trivial gives insight into how summands of free modules can be not free. Or in general, how something can have a local property but not a global property.
Speaking of which, I think mathematical maturity includes understanding math jargon, like "local", "canonical", "trivial". These words don't have precise definitions, but once you've seen them enough, you can figure out what they mean in most contexts.
Interested at all in explaining vector bundles? I understand the basics of topology (compactness, density, open/closed sets etc.) but this topic has always eluded me
Not OP, but here's one way to start thinking of them.
Take your favorite topological space X, and pick your favorite vector space V (which need not have anything to do with X). The corresponding vector bundle is the data (E,p), where E is a new space (the "total space") and p is a map from E to X. What do these look like? The fiber of p over a point x is just a copy of V, and for every x there exists some open neighborhood U such that the preimage of U is isomorphic to V × U. So we can think of p as being, at least locally, as projection.
The second condition is why we say "locally, a vector bundle is trivial." However, you can "glue" these trivial parts of the bundle together in such a way as to get globally interesting data. The first example is usually to let X be the circle S and let V be the reals R. Then the (infinite) Möbius band is a one-dimensional vector bundle over S: if you look at any proper open subset U of the circle, the part of the Möbius band above it is just R × U. However, it's not globally trivial, as it has the familiar "twist." In contrast, the trivial bundle is just R × S and can be imagined as a(n infinite) cylinder.
Haha I can try! Here's sort of an overview. You start with some topologial space B. A vector bundle a topological space you get by gluing a given vector space V to each point in B. For example, let's say B is R1. Now I'm going to attach a vector space to each point in B---in particular, I'm going to attach a copy of R1 to each point of B. This gets me the set R1 x R1, or another words R2. So R2 is a vector bundle over R1. (Exercise: write a precise proof of this fact using this precise definition of a vector bundle)
Ok, so that was our first example of a vector bundle. In fact, this same operation works no matter what B is---the space B x Rn will be a vector bundle over B. And this makes sense, right? The space B x Rn is, as a set, literally just a copy of Rn for each point in B. That's all we need in a vector bundle. You can think of an element (b,v) of B x Rn as representing "the vector v in the copy of Rn that's glued to b".
Now here's the tricky part, which is also what confused me for a long, long time: this is not the only way to get a vector bundle over B. The crux of the matter is that you can just glue an abstract vector space without a given basis to each point in B and still get a vector bundle. The first example of this is the cylinder (by which I mean S1 x R1) and the mobius strip (by which I mean that same cylinder with a "twist"). Each of these vector spaces is a vector bundle over the circle! After all, you can get each of these spaces by gluing a line to each point of the circle. And indeed, the mobius strip is not homeomorphic to the cylinder! After all, the cylinder is orientable and the mobius strip is not (nevermind what "orientable" actually means---you use vector bundles to define that :) ). Now here's where undergrad me would protest: "but wait," I would say, "just choose a basis for each of those lines you glued to the circle to get your mobius strip. Then that gives an isomorphism from the the line to R1. Shouldn't those all combine to give a homeomorphism from the mobius strip to the cylinder??" To which present-day me would respond "you can, but this just gives you a bijection. In fact, there's no way to choose a basis for each of those lines so that the isomorphisms from your lines to corresponding copies of R1 in the cylinder give a continuous map from the whole mobius strip to the whole cylinder."
So the crux of my confusion is that those lines you glued to the circle to get a mobius strip don't have a god-given basis like R1 does. Another way of thinking about this is that the points on your cylinder know which way is up. Points on the mobius strip do not, because of stuff like this.
To nitpick, in any given context, "local" can often be given a precise definition even if it's not stated explicitly.
Yes, thanks for the clarification. Mathematical maturity is being able to infer the definition based on context.
Is it possible for someone young to be mathematically mature then?
Definitely!
As long as they've seen enough math?
Yup!
If you can hear a lecture about Tits buildings, or the Tits Alternative, without giggling, then you, sir, are mathematically mature.
Here in America it's a scandal to talk about Tits buildings, but no one bats an eye when you talk about Killing Fields.
Mathematical maturity is actually doing the exercise when the author says "The proof is left to the reader as an exercise."
I know you might be partly joking, but I've found the opposite to be true. The senior mathematicians I know hardly ever do explicit computations or, say, epsilon/3 arguments unless they absolutely have to. The reason being, they know what the result of the computation "should be" before they even do it. Terry Tao referred to it as the "post-rigorous" stage in a blog post, which is quite relevant to this thread.
This makes sense. In physics or chemistry (or indeed, problem solving in general) a big part of solving a problem is knowing how the answer 'should' look like before you even attempt the problem. In science this means knowing how big it should be, what units it should have, etc. It all has to do with the notion of intuition (something I'm finding more and more often). I suppose there's analogous stuff a mathematician looks for in a calculation to know how it 'should' look like.
Mathematical maturity definitely isn't an absolute concept; it's a matter of degrees. Any topic requires enough mathematical maturity, and how much is enough depends on the topic.
The main point of the term is to distinguish classic prerequisites ("you shouldn't bother reading this book until you learned topology, because we use ideas from topology on every page") from the fuzzier "you don't need to know very much specific math to understand this, but you won't be able to make sense of it unless you know enough math". It turns out that for a lot of things, the latter is actually the big barrier (the example that comes up my life: first-semester logic---first-order logic, models, proofs, perhaps the incompleteness theorem; in terms of formal material, the subject basically starts from scratch, but it's really hard if you don't have enough experience with mathematical techniques and notation).
Does it depend on the topic then? Because I'd imagine that while one mathematician may be perfectly well versed in, say, analysis, he or she might not know a thing about number theory.
An expert in analysis may not know anything about number theory, but he could pick up the basics and get to a point where he could at least talk about some research problems in number theory, about 10,000 times faster than a first-year graduate student whose primary interest is number theory.
How much mathematical maturity a person has is (basically) a linear amount---you can have more or less of it, but how much you have is topic independent. Similarly, how much mathematical maturity a given topic (not something as broad as "number theory"---usually a particular book or course) needs depends on the topic. Basically, it's like a "you must be this tall to enter": in order to study a given book/course, you usually need at least the corresponding level of mathematical maturity.
The whole point of the term is to separate familiarity with thinking like a mathematician from familiarity with the prerequisites to a particular topic. So a mathematician with a PhD who specializes in analysis might not know any number theory, but almost certainly has the mathematical maturity needed for any course or book in the subject. (But may lack the mathematical knowledge to jump into an advanced area of number theory immediately.) On the other hand anyone coming out basic calculus has all the mathematical knowledge to take an introductory logic class, but almost everyone needs to study a bunch more math before they have the mathematical maturity for it.
If you find out, id like to know. Ive long passed by brothers and father in mathematical ability, even a good percentage of my former teachers, but I kinda feel like no matter how much i learn, im still very small in the grand scheme of things.
But then i think, it took mankinds greatest minds more than 10000 years to get where we are, taking more than a few weeks to really understand a concept is ok.
Here's a saying I've heard a few times. An undergraduate in math thinks they know everything. A masters student thinks they know nothing. A PhD knows nobody knows anything.
I conveniently skipped the undergraduate phase.
Or you just actually know nothing :) As I do... :(
I'd say you're beginning to mature when you can determine for yourself if your solution is correct or incorrect. I.e., when you first get your sense of mathematical self. I don't think the maturing process ever stops, but I'd say it starts when you stop looking up/asking for answers from the book/teacher.
I'd slightly disagree. If an answer genuinely eludes you I don't think there's anything wrong or 'immature' about looking it up. However, there's a difference between looking up an answer after you have given it an honest try (say, a day) and looking up an answer right away because you got bored or you can't be bothered to put effort into the problem. I think the big difference between a mathematically mature person (or indeed just a plainly mature one) and someone else, is that they are not content with writing down the answer after looking it up. They want to know what it was that they were missing and why did it not occur to them.
Right, but knowing that you know or don't know vs having no idea if you're right or wrong is where I think the process begins.
This is subjective, but personally, a big part of what I would call "mathematical maturity" is just the ability or willingness to think like a pure mathematician as far as reasoning goes.
Suppose I give you a definition of a mathematical entity that's new to you. Let's pretend that entity is called a "glorb". So I present you with "A glorb is..." where all the words after the "is" are words you've seen before.
I've given you the definition of a glorb. There's no ambiguity about what is or what isn't a glorb. To determine whether something is a glorb or not, you check whether the conditions in the definition are satisfied.
Of course, it might not yet be obvious to you why we care about glorbs. But "Why do we care?" is a different question from "What is the definition?" Sometimes, it's hard to answer the question "Why do we care?" right away. Sometimes the best way to understand why we care is to first play around with specific small examples of glorbs, and slowly develop an intuition for what they are.
"Mathematical maturity" could include the ability to parse and work with a definition even without a fully developed intuitive picture of what's behind the definition. "Mathematical maturity" could also include the willingness to come up with specific examples of glorbs and non-glorbs on your own, as an accompaniment to just reading the definition. (It could also include the willingness to experiment with changing the definition of a glorb -- maybe strengthening or weakening a condition -- and seeing where that takes you, if anywhere.)
Confidence, but also humility, topped with lashings of intuition.
when you can comfortably use QED :)
Nothing bugs me more than seeing QED at the end of an incorrect proof.
For me it's when students put "QED" at the end of something that isn't a proof.
I was once guilty of doing this. I just wanted to be cool
It's a matter of perspective.
Maturing in mathematics is like hiking up a mountain. The first hour you may be in the woods, hemmed in by the forest canopy, concentrating on local issues like streams and rocks, not seeing anything in the distance at all. You might be wondering what the point of it all is.
By the time several hours have passed, you’ve still got rocks to worry about underfoot, but you have climbed high enough to catch a glimpse through gaps in the trees at a distant skyline. Maybe the summit is now in sight.
Finally after hours of struggle you break out above tree line on the summit, and the whole panorama is clear. You look back, way down at where you have been. You can say things like "Oh, we thought we crossed two different streams back there, but it’s really the same stream -- see how it takes that dogleg over there around that hill". There is a sense
that was cute
If this makes you giggle then you're not mature, mathematically or otherwise.
Oh... :(
Being able to create or seek out examples of new abstract concepts introduced to you is a feature of mathematical maturity.
You are mathematically mature after Rudin pops your cherry.
I enjoy the degree to which Rudin seems to be a collective experience.
And here we have an example of mathematical immaturity.
Rudin is first base.
zzz rudin zzz
Bring lots and lots of lube. Maybe invest in aspirin by the caseload.
Rudin the lucky bastard get virgins erryday
Unless Spivak gets to them first.
An oxymoron -- mature students study applicable subjects so that they can provide for their families and not become depenent on state support.
Immature students study math because they selfishly choose the subject most interesting to them.
Actually, a math major is one of the best majors you could possibly get (behind maybe engineering), both in salary and in job prospects. Don't believe me? Ask the Bureau of Labor Statistics