The election

Procedurally it seems to have gone just fine, and the people predicting “the end of democracy in America” now look foolish.  They have been suffering under fundamental misunderstandings of how this country works.  During this election cycle, democracy never was under threat and the United States has not been under risk of fascism.

Rising in status:

Matt Yglesias (socially moderate Democrats did very well)

Normie social science results on campaign finance

Nate Silver predictions

Falling in status:

Tariffs

Corruption

War with Iran

Wealth taxes (losing in CA)

Gerrymandering (came back to hurt Republicans, given the Blue wave)

And there you go.

Comments

Democracy is holding and we should celebrate that. But how can you differentiate between:
a) It was never in danger and all those who worried were ignorant hysterics.
b) It was in danger and all those who worried and acted saved it.

I can't.

Respond

Indeed. I don’t accept the logic of “patient was cured of cancer therefore did not have cancer.”

Respond

It's fortunate that Trump can't resist the impulses of his id, make long term plans, take advice from people smarter than him, or coordinate the Silicon valley, Claremont, and Heritage people who would eagerly end democracy. But he has shown the path and someone more competent will try this again.

Respond

Indeed people who claim that others don't understand how this country works might stop to consider that they themselves don't understand that presidential elections are different from midterms. Hard to rig hundreds of different separate contests. Much easier to subvert the Electoral College by producing phony slates of electors and prompting your crackpot cronies in Congress to accept these results, using if necessary the tactics of leverage and delay that could be enabled by pressure from an outside riot, which you yourself have fomented. A series of felonies for which Trump should have gone to jail for 20 years. Were it not for the honorable Mike Pence this scheme might have worked.

Respond

I keep asking, and keep never getting an answer. Suppose Jan 6th worked. The invaders capture congress, force the acceptance of Trump friendly electors under threat of execution. What do you think happens then?

Will the executive agencies roll over? Will people still pay taxes and obey laws? Once we get into general strike territory, the repressive option is going to need a lot of men with guns ... and who here thinks that the 1st division would have turned their guns on Americans.

Actually succeeding with an anti-democratic coup needs very large amounts of support from key groups. The Bolsheviks and the Nazis both were operating with north of 20% popular support and both managed to secure the loyalty of large military formations with guns. Mussolini, Franco, Salazar, and Pilsiduski all did likewise.

Whatever the criminal case, Trump's path to rule in 2020 required far more than hanging Mike Pence. It required a populace unwilling to resist such extralegal measures and ultimately a military willing to enforce it.

The "easy" way to coup America is the easy way to coup anywhere - you bribe the military and murder the opposition. That will be stupendously difficult because the US has so many servicemen and veterans and they are simply not that different than the broad sweep of society.

Ginning up a pretext is easy, but as we recently saw in South Korea, getting the actual powers that be to play along is a lot, lot harder.

Respond

You're correct. The Jan 6th "coup" attempt or whatever we want to call that half-baked attempt at election manipulation, would never have worked. There's no way that they would have prevented the count from being certified. Even IF Mike Pence had gone along with it, it would have gone to SCOTUS and SCOTUS would never have upheld it.

Respond

Bingo.

Trump is too venal and incompetent to pull off a viable coup. But unless something tamps down the forces he rode to power twice, somebody will eventually marry his pandering to ruthless efficiency and that likely does not end well.

Respond

And it's 50-50 whether that somebody will be left-wing or right-wing.

Respond

Tyler is wording this one carefully: people *predicting* “the end of democracy in America”. The analogy is predicting that the cure won't work. Tyler was never arguing against curing cancer. He was saying that the cure was already being applied.

Respond

You are conveniently excluding the other two sentences of the statement.

Respond

Your basic point is sound with some qualifications:

b. is not at all the same as “people predicting “the end of democracy in America””. TC should name a few of the fools making such predictions. Completely different would be someone like Norm Eisen who saw a threat and went to work. I also know many, many other people who saw a threat, and know very few if any making TC’s prediction (obviously there are many people making foolish predictions all the time, so there will still be quite a few).

On a., democracy is always in danger.

Respond

The comment filtering algorithm really seems to be a fan of Norm Eisen.

Respond

We've avoided nuclear war for 80 years, but I'd nonetheless stop short of calling Einstein, Oppenheimer, Schweitzer, and others who warned us about the danger of those weapons as fools. In fact I'd thank them.

Respond

Hopefully you'll thank me for warning you to always watch above for falling pianos! :)

Respond

Well, at least from a Bayesian view we can ask did we say any of the behaviors commonly correlated with successful anti-democratic transitions in other countries. Maybe I am missing some of those but what I have seen simply did not happen here.

1) Is there any evidence that where the folks who were threats to democracy held more power (say due to demographics, base partisanship, or whatever) that bucked the overall trend in results? Typically, ballot boxes get stuffed, voters get turned away, or the like much more where the anti-democrats have stronger grasp on power. If Trump and company were actually subverting democracy we should anomolous overperformance by his candidates in places where the mechanics of the election were more securing managed by his partisans. Aside from Florida, the only real overperformance I am seeing prima facie is in Michigan. Which is odd from an anti-democratic perspective, but quite expected given the more leftwing bonafides of AES and the bruising intrademocratic split there with his primary opponent endorsing the Republican. Likewise, I am not seeing any obvious areas where Trump acolytes fraudulently ran up the score in say rural jurisdictions.

2) Were there any candidates barred from running by legal or questionable procedural grounds? In other countries that have lost democracy an idiotically common tactic is to rule that some popular candidate is barred from running - say via trumped up corruption charges - and the election must be fought by a proxy. Did any of this happen anywhere in this election? Another classic option was assassination, yet I have not seen any stories of any even credible threats on that front. No democratic candidate, to the best of my knowledge was charged with, let alone convicted or barred, during the process. Nobody had close encounters with vehicular homicide.

3) Civil service subornation to anti-democratic politicking is pretty tame compared to historical standards. Trump cannot manage to prevent massive amounts of internal leaking. Senior civil servants are going to journalists with reports of having saved damning evidence to give to the new Democratic congress. Such propganda as the civil servants produced and distributed with public funds was miniscule compared to private expenditures. And frankly I have seen far better product produced by African despots.

4) Banking restrictions and resource impoundment appear to be totally absent. I am aware of no reports that Democrats, their allied PACs, or their grassroot organizational collaborators ever experienced property seizures for any pretext - no campaign offices closed, no bank accounts frozen, no computers seized, no printings destroyed.

5) And of course the biggest thing anti-democrats have historically done is to buy off the military. Trump did get a 3.8% increase in basic pay, but this is peanuts compared to typical offerings. He tried, and failed, to get a 7% raise which is anathema to anti-democratic regimes - the garrison always eats first. Nor have we seen any evidence that Trump made any sort of anti-democratic pitch to either senior generals or to the junior officers. Generally, anti-democrats either cancel elections or they hold sham ones, but either course typically results in the public not affording cooperation to the government out of a sense of moral obligation and fair play. Anecdotally, I am extremely doubtful that Republicans even won the police vote yesterday and their margins among military members are down.

Maybe I am missing something, but even if Trump is anti-democratic, I am just not seeing any evidence that he took any of the typical steps anti-democrats take. Maybe that is because he is a coward. Or a moron. Maybe it is because there is such a strong firewall against typical anti-democratic tactics that he gave up early.

But even if we grant Trump anti-democratic motives, what are his actual means to achieve it? What opportunities did he have?

In many ways I contend that Trump is so utterly incompetent this term that democracy could not be under threat from him. He cannot effectively use anti-democratic gifts from the gods (e.g. Ilhan Omar's immigration investigations started long ago and he still never found a way to actually evict her from office, he had a pandemic pretext and somehow failed to using the increase in vote-by-mail to stuff the ballot boxes when everything is delivered by the postal service). He failed to move legislation with supermajority support. He was unable to convince his partisan allies to remove procedural limits that favored his opponents in the moment (and that with widespread talk that said opponents intend to remove the filibuster when they next attain power). Trump cannot even get the people who owe political fealty to him (lest they go down in the primary) to vote his way ... I just don't see much signs that the man has the means to orchestrate and manage some extralegal putsch. I'd honestly expect he to be kicked out of real power by whomever actually did the grunt work should some sort of coup actually go down. Trump is simply not disciplined enough nor popular enough nor savvy enough to manage non-democratic politics.

Maybe somebody is seeing Trump as competent to pull off a coup, but I just don't see him willing and able to do the work of even Samuel Doe.

Respond

One of the common accusations leveled against Trump is general incompetence. I have certainly leveled it myself. Perhaps that explains some of the "underperformance" of theoretical coup planning. But I also wonder to what extent his heart has never been in the pure dictator business. My earlier profiles of Trump focused on greed, vengeance, vanity, and narcissism among other traits. Those were on full display during the entire first two years. But he has never demonstrated the literal killer instinct that many autocrats exhibit. I dont know if it is a lack murderous desire, or he doesn't "have what it takes" to kill as needed, or perhaps that he is much more entertained by watching people suffer, and letting people live with the suffering he imposed. I previously thought, and still do, that many of the worst impulses of this administration have been driven by other members of the admin e.g. Steven Miller and Kristie Noem executing egregious immigration enforcement. He has never wanted to do the "hard work" that being a dictator involves, but he definitely appears to love larping as one.

To the extent that "he bankrupted a casino Carl, A CASINO!", this is probably about par for the course for him, just on the biggest stage possible.

The market reaction is a little funny this morning. Much like the election results, I dont think you can pin this market reaction on even a small set of factors. Saw someone bring out the old adage that a bull market continues when it stops falling on bad news. For the moment, except for oil, none of the major trends of the past month have really broken, but we'll see where this goes in the next few days. I do think that perhaps the market is underestimating the still open set of circumstances and future outcomes regarding Iran and oil.

Respond

I agree. The worst evils of the Trump administration come not from the man himself, but the people he enabled in order to get into power. It's more that he doesn't really care what kinds of harms these people do, as long as they support him. He's not nearly as racist or as anti-immigration as his MAGA base is. But he let's them do whatever they want as long as they support him.

Respond

How did those who worried act to save democracy? What were the close calls? It looked to me that this midterm was politics as usual. There were no 'we almost lost democracy' near misses that I can point to -- can you?

Respond

See Ricardo's comment below.

Respond

The constitution doesn't provide for 'firewalls' between the president and the executive agency that are part of the executive branch. The constitution DOES provide for presidents who abuse their powers to lose cases before the Supreme Court to be defeated electorally or removed by impeachment. Trump has lost many cases before the court (birthright citizenship, tariffs) his party just suffered an electoral defeat, and impeachments may be forthcoming. That's how the system was designed. 'Firewalls' between the executive and the agencies supposedly under executive control are not part of the constitution.

Respond

Apart from running a more or less normal series of campaigns across the country, what were the actions people undertook to save democracy? As far as I can tell, Trump overreached and made a series of really bad decisions (tariffs, Iran, ICE raids, focused on trivial matters) that resulted in higher gas prices and bad optics. Had he not imposed the tariffs, stopped bombing in Iran with the nuclear sites, and focused on border security and immigration enforcement at the employer level rather than the public raids, and promoted terrible candidates, we probably wouldn't have seen the stunning rebuked we witnessed. In other words, democracy worked. He performed poorly and the voters let him know it. In 2014, after Obama overreached, he saw a nine seat swing. Bush saw -6 in 2006. Clinton and Reagan each saw -8 in their lameduck midterm. It will be 7-9 for Trump. This looks like normal democracy at work to me.

Maybe I'm missing something. What were the things done outside of normal partisan politics to save democracy? Extraordinary alliances like those attempted in Germany to thwart the AFD? Major policy shifts to chip away at his coalition? I'm not seeing it?

Respond

I would say that since the cost of living crisis in this country is largely a function of voting in local, state and federal elections-I’d rather ask who is going to save us from democracy?

The supply constraints brought about by voting and democracy are getting pretty bad out there. Nobody is voting to increase FAR ratios and increase the size of the building department last I checked.

The mayor of New York banning Walmart but insisting on government grocers hardly seems like a glowing endorsement of “democracy.”

Respond

Jamelle Bouie has a column listing Trump's string of efforts to subvert this election. (gift link) https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/04/books/agatha-christie-british-library.html?unlocked_article_code=1.N1E.bYr0.TsNh2_LY0mCx&smid=url-share

That Trump is incompetent makes him less of a threat to democracy. It does not make him not a wannabe dictator or not a threat. Had the Senate come out 51-50 Trump and other Republicans would already be in court.

Respond

> listing Trump's string of efforts to subvert this election. (gift link)

I thought "wow here is an actual attempt to substantiate this over-the-top rhetoric". But the link is nothing of the sort.

Respond

The ignorant hysterics made a bunch of predictions about how the past few days would play out and none of them came true. Hence the ignorant hysterics part.

Respond

He distinguishes it by insulting your intelligence then praising the YIMBY guy who said he wouldn't cover Trump's corruption because it was a distraction.

Respond

As far as I can tell, for you and others here "Democracy is holding" simply equals "Democrats Winning".

Respond

“The people predicting the end of democracy in America now look foolish.”

Not really. Apocalyptic messaging is a standard feature of campaigns. “If you elect my opponent, the country you know and love may cease to exist.” Or “If you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country anymore.”

Do we think anyone is foolish for saying those things, or do we think they are foolish if they don’t say those things?

Respond

Case in point†:

I am not here to tell you that Republicans have done a wonderful job. I am here to tell you that the Democrat Party has been fully captured by communists who want you dead and seek to destroy western civilization itself. Go vote against them. It’s the only choice.

— Matt Walsh—X.com

† via Noahpinion

Respond

I can accept politicians saying stuff like that; it's kinda pathetic for average people to repeat it, though, and there were a lot of average people doing exactly that. I put it on the same level as people buying Gucci bags because they think it makes them look high class or something.

Respond

The reason they say those things, is because people accept it.

I wouldn't mind a bit more scorn thrown at politicians who use such language. How are they to be taken seriously?

Respond

I disagree with TC on this. I almost didn't vote for the first time in 50 years. My sentiment was/is "A plague on both their houses". I see little reason to prefer the Republican subsidies and govmint ownership interest in various "private enterprise" to the Democratic Socialists. They're both not part of the America I'm comfortable with and yet they're mainstream. So much for the silent majority. I wish I could be as optimistic as TC about the country's trajectory, but I see no reason to be. Oh, and TC insinuates that Democrats when in power don't gerrymander is a blatant falsehood. (Take designing districts along racial lines, for example...)

Respond

Do you not know that in the service... one must always choose the lesser of two weevils.

— (YouTube) Captain Jack Aubrey, Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World (2003)

Respond

"...one must always choose the lesser of two weevils."

That's only true if there are only two weevils.

Respond

Ah, the infamous weevil Catch-22 ;-)

Respond

You can be optimistic about the robustness of the continuance of the American system of government (which I mostly am) without being optimistic about the current political directions of either major party (and, no, I'm not optimistic about that right now).

I qualify my optimism about the system holding up because I think it's possible that Democrats will actually go ahead and try to pack the Supreme Court after 2028 if the win the presidency and keep the senate. It's true that the size of the court is fixed only in long tradition, not the constitution. But packing the court would almost certainly set off a chain of tit-for-tat expansions that would effectively turn the body into something very different -- yet another political branch of government with control flipping every time one party controlled both the presidency and majorities in Congress.

Respond

"I almost didn't vote for the first time in 50 years."

Yeah, the clearest read on this election is that actual Republicans, conservatives not populists, didn't show up to vote. I know there's an aspect of "No True Scotsman" to that, but it's true. Republican turnout in, for example, the Texas gubernatorial race was very low. There's real disappointment in Trump's performance.

As to your "trajectory" point, the history of recent elections is that the victors radically overread their mandate and shoot themselves in the foot.

Respond

I'm more with TC on this than against. But I also wonder if it would have been better for R to keep the senate. D senate + house seems like the maximally chaotic way for the next two years of Trump's presidency to play out.

Respond

I'm glad Democrats took the Senate. If another Supreme Court opening occurs before 2028, I think Donald Trump would have nominated, and the Senate would have approved, a Supreme Court Judge who was utterly unqualified, but firmly committed to voting in whatever way Trump would approve of. And that judge would be on the Court for life.

Respond

1) Trump's three appointees so far have not looked remotely like that.
2) Ehh so the court gets another James Clark McReynolds who absconded from the court to go duck hunting, refused to talk Jewish justices, and was an assured vote for pretty much anything ever reactionary. Is the court somehow going to stop functioning?

Like a bad Supreme Court Justice is a loss, but I am not certain that would even be in the top 5 for most impactful things Trump could still do.

Respond

I assume that if a court opening happens during the next two years, it will go unfilled until after the 2028 election. I don't see any way that Trump would nominate a candidate acceptable to a Democratic senate (or, indeed, that a D senate would confirm anybody Trump might nominate).

Respond

Trump nominees have actually been good. Certainly better than the recent left-wing nominees. I don't know why that is but I also don't know why that would not continue.

Respond

You are being far too generous to Tyler. That Trump failed to subvert a (second!) election is not evidence that he didn't try.

Respond

Falling:

Thiel
Musk
The Free Press
Economists who dismiss any criticism of the above as "mood affiliation"

Respond

Falling
Crypto , AI, datacenters. A datacenter slowdown might not be so bad actually. It was increasingly financed by a wall of debt and circular deals and seems to be a Red Queen race.

I don’t think Gina Hinosoja is so much against datacenters as she just want them built by union workers , and given no tax incentives. Elizabeth Warren on the other hand …

I still dont understand how this issue got so polarized. A poll showed people would rather live near a nuclear plant than a datacenter. Crazy !

Respond

Falling in status: Israel

Respond

This is an underrated one: The new Republican party we will see in two years will be 100% Groyper. Just look at what JD Vance said today.

Respond

If this means withdrawal of "military support" (really, subsidies for American defense companies), this will actually help Israel improve its security. It will not longer need to kowtow to the whims of American politicians when choosing military tactics, and, to some extent, strategy.

And, it is entirely capable of building all of the military hardware it needs for its defense. While that is a somewhat longer-term play, the loosened strings on the IDF/IAF will - in a much shorter time-frame - allow it to take advantage of its people, training, intelligence superiority and philosophical devotion to the Zionist project in being more effective at defending itself.

This will have further side benefits to Israel, in that it will spur its innovation economy even more, and probably push toward less regulation: the Israeli venture capital sector, which will be responsible for lots of early-stage investment in Israel's military industries, tends to favor deregulation, especially when it comes to spinning off these technologies into civilian use.

Ultimately, I expect America will become a customer for the products of the Israeli military industrial complex; they will certainly be the best in the world in many specialized weapons systems.

Respond

AI disrupts every institution and status game on the planet and people do not like change and uncertainty. I am surprised you're surprised!

Respond

Parsing the difference between these democrats is pretty pointless, you don’t even need to remember their names.

Respond

Funny, that's what a lot of people think about Republicans.

Respond

Andreesen. Falling so fast the egg will break.

Respond

The entire right wing tech bros, really. Even good old gdb, who might be dreaming of billions, but is ultimately the same stable genius that decided to use MongoDB as a queue.

Respond

"Musk"

Well, maybe. The likely coming anti-datacenter push plays right into his hands.

Respond

Interesting point... and l agree. Just like how redistricting played into dem hands (note that nate silver was early and correct about that as well). Its important to rise above the hysterics and think several steps down the road along all possible known forks.

Respond

"Criticism" generally consists of citations of what these people say and then engaging with their substance. "Sneering" however is a form of mood affiliation.

Respond

People who constantly bring up mood affiliation are mood affiliators.

Respond

Tyler sounds scared. How many of his colleagues would emerge unscathed from a serious crackdown on white collar crime?

Respond

None.

He should be scared.

Respond

Tyler's comment comes across as overly-complacent.

Let's just take the fact that all firewalls that have sat in between the President and the DOJ and FBI are gone. The opposition party winning narrow control over the Senate does nothing to fix that. Unless or until the Senate can credibly commit to having enough votes to remove Trump and his appointees from office, there are no real checks left on executive power.

Trump said he will accept the results of the midterm election. Progress, I guess? But this raises the question about why we even need to care what the president thinks about the midterm election results. The fact that we need to read what Trump thinks of the results and then breathe a sigh of relief is part of the problem.

Respond

The "war" or whatever it is on Iran was absolutely buffoonish. Republican or Democrat, the days of Israel as lodestar for American policy are numbered.

Georgia and Texas: change the people, change the place.

Respond

The US has a lot more allies in the region than Israel who wanted and benefit from this war (Saudi in particular is a more important consideration for this war in several ways), and has completely obvious interests of its own in Iran not recovering a nuclear weapons program. The fact that Israel is strong af and has aligned interests vis a vis Iran is convenient for the US, not the cause of the war. But if you need someone to blame for anything you don't like, then sure, they're great.

Respond

Texas is about more than "change the people". Trump beat Harris by 13.7 points in Texas just 2 years ago.

Respond

Iran acquiring nuclear weapons would be, to put it mildly, a significant historical event. Everyone generally understood this to be the case until Obama/Kerry caved to Iran with the JCPOA.

Now a world with a nuclear Iran just one of those things that people refuse to talk about.

Respond

Constitutionally speaking, there are not supposed to be 'firewalls' between the executive and executive branch agencies. For presidents who misuse their power, we have both elections and an impeachment process. But 'independent' executive agencies that aren't controllable by the executive really aren't democratically accountable to *anybody*.

Why should we care what a president whose party loses the midterms and control of Congress thinks about an election? Because they are going to be working with an opposition Congress for the next 2 years, and how that works (or doesn't) will obviously matter. Didn't we care what Obama thought about the Republican wave in 2010?

Respond

"Constitutionally speaking, there are not supposed to be 'firewalls' between the executive and executive branch agencies."

The Constitution doesn't have a monopoly on really and obviously good ideas. Tell me again how it's good that the president views the attorney general as his personal lawyer? Tell me how good it is that he directs prosecutions based on personal vendettas. I'll take independent agencies with rules as established by Congress over that any day. And no, some degree of independence does not mean unaccountable--- seriously this is a lame talking point. Whatever agency you think is "unaccountable," just look up the rules of how political appointments are made. If you think that anything less than complete control by the current president means unaccountable, you merely equivocate.

Respond

"Tell me again how it's good that the president views the attorney general as his personal lawyer?"

It isn't good. We have existing constitutional ways of restraining and removing presidents. And 'prosecutions based on personal vendettas' certainly didn't begin with Trump.

An unaccountable independent agency is one whose leaders can neither be removed or controlled by a new, popularly elected president. No executive agency should be beyond the control of the executive -- such independence is pretty obviously anti-democratic. Independent agencies represent efforts by a previous congress or administration to tie the hands of an incoming president. That's not the way it's supposed to work.

Respond

"The Constitution doesn't have a monopoly on really and obviously good ideas."

That's why we have an amendment process

"Tell me how good it is that he directs prosecutions based on personal vendettas. "

Excuse me? The whole Biden admin and associated Congress was an anti-Trump vendetta. That's what you get for running the rent seekers out of the government.

Rising in status: Federal Rent Seekers.

Respond

I noticed you didn't answer my question. How is it *good* for the president to direct prosecutions based on personal vendettas? You simply claimed that Biden did bad things. Ok, let's agree for now: Biden=bad. How is that a justification of althe current president directing prosecutions by the DOJ for personal vendettas?

But really, I mean if you thought it was bad to not even end up bringing charges for literally attempting to overthrow an election, boy howdy, just wait til you hear what the new guy has done with the place!

Respond

""The Constitution doesn't have a monopoly on really and obviously good ideas."

That's why we have an amendment process"

You know it's not actually UNconstitutional for the president to act ethically, right? I know that's not a Constituinal requirement, but that doesn't mean it's prohibited...

Respond

Its ethical to use the government to relentlessly attack political opponents? Who knew?

As always, the left's self justification makes it immune.

Respond
Continue this thread →

It's unconstitutional for the president to accept foreign emoluments but that has meant bupkis for 10 years.
As Gary Kasparov has said, a tyrant never asks why; he only asks why not.

Respond

There was a firewall? That sure would be news to people like FDR and JFK.

Respond

"Let's just take the fact that all firewalls that have sat in between the President and the DOJ and FBI are gone."
So how does your theory treat the United Kingdom? After all, the King-in-Parliament approach allows anyone with a bare majority of votes to direct MI-5 as they choose. The PM can sack Home Secretaries until they find somebody to do their dirty work. Likewise, my understanding is that a committed PM with majority support in parliament can likewise refashion the CPS.

The check on Trump's power with the FBI and the DOJ is the same in the UK - he only has such authorities as congress gives them. A supermajority of congress could abolish the FBI. Trump, like many president before him, routinely loses cases regarding FBI and DOJ conduct before his own judicial appointees.

Is the status quo less democratic that is was? I don't know. He won the election and if a majority of the voters really want the DOJ to do something, they should have the right to attempt it in a purely democratic society. I would argue that the British model is innately more democratic than the American one, but if the measure of democracy is making it easier for a plurality to enact their preferred law enforcement priorities Trump's move towards the sorts of powers Burnham could wield is more democratic and less constitutional.

I also think you have a far, far too high view of Trump's ability to pull off anything complicated. Anti-democratic politics and management are very, very hard. You need to placate the guys with guns. You need to organize folks to stuff ballot boxes and you need to make decisions that allow regime survival without the feedback mechanism of elections. Absolutely nothing I have seen from Trump this term suggests to me that he has such competency. If you can pass some sort of performative voter ID legislation when it has supermajority support (and a consitutional amendment even won in North Carolina even as the other side shellacked your candidate 3:2), I don't see how you are going to manage keeping the military, any secret police, or the rest from just dispensing with you as well. Very, very few anti-democratic regimes can maintain power without somebody coordinating 10% of society into uniform action.

I just don't see how Trump could possibly get the military or whomever to do his dirty work to nullify the midterms. I mean the man, repeatedly, was unable to throw special elections. Like that's minor leagues for anti-democratic regimes.

Respond

In the UK the power belongs to the party, not to a single person. In the US that single person can and does control the FBI/DOJ, the military and decides whether or not to spend the money approved by Congress. They can control major parts of the economy, impose taxes (tariffs) and have the government take ownership in private companies. All of that and it's just one person making those decisions.

On the buffer side all we really have is impeachment (not realistic) and the courts. While the courts have stopped some excesses this is also the same court that supports the idea of the unitary executive and declared POTUS essentially immune for any act committed while in office. The question I think Trump supporters and/or Tyler should ask themselves is how they will feel if a Dem becomes POTUS and acts the same way as Trump has. Pack the court and away you go.

Steve

Respond

None of this analysis addresses if this is somehow a threat to democracy. Presidential systems afford the electorate a direct vote on who controls all the powers you name. And with our staggered senatorial elections and differential turnout, the presidential elections likely represent more democratic mandate on average than the majority in congress (what with the gerrymandering and other self-dealing ploys).

The president having the power to undertake economic interventions and set law enforcement policy is likely more directly democratic than reserving those powers to a senate that is only turned over every six years.

Now, you can object that the imperial president is a threat to good government, rule of law, and the rest. And Republicans were doing exactly that when Obama elected to use "pen and phone" powers to reshape immigration policy, prevent states from enforcing the laws on the books, and the rest.

But that is a federalist or constitutionalist argument (i.e. something Republicans used to routinely hold sancrosanct), not a democratic one.

And yes, my biggest worry with Obama, Trump, and Biden has been what the next turn of the screw will bring forth. Have a de facto expynocracy where the cleverest lawyers attain the most freedom of action does not end well whoever takes the intermediate steps.

The real solution would be for congress to reassert its power and independence. But that won't happen if the voters punish folks who buck the party. Manchin, Chaffee, Fetterman, Sinema, Collins ... opposing the leadership of your party does not appear to have healthy consequences for electoral careers these days.

Until the voters care about constitutional protections regardless of cui bono, congress will rollover for their own, and pretzel themselves to oppose their enemy.

But a system where a plurality of the electorate can enable somebody to remake the justice system or the intelligence agencies as they like? That is the UK system in a nutshell. Maybe it is unwise, but it certainly seems more democratic.

Respond

Having one person run everything is not a threat to democracy? Seriously? While your point about voters having a say every 4 years that leaves a lot of room for non-democratic actions in the interim. Also, it's not people bucking the party in the GOP its people acting or speaking out against Trump. We have a system that has little ability to check the power of a POTUS who decides to act outside of norms other than the courts and they have not shown much willingness to use that power.

I agree that in theory Congress could place some limits but in practice it's pretty clear now that the party in power wont do much to put constraints on POTUS when it also holds Congress. That holds somewhat for Dems but it is worse now than we have ever seen. We have another big step towards placing the authority of governance in the hands of a single person and maybe this election is at least a symbolic step towards reversing or slowing that trend. We should note that the Dems controlling Congress wont really stop Trump from doing what he has been doing and I am skeptical that future POTUS will want to give up the authority Trump has demonstrated.

Steve

Respond

"Having one person run everything is not a threat to democracy?"
Correct democracy is orthogonal to questions of rule of law, consitutionality, etc.

Leichenstein, for instance, gave the Prince wide ranging powers - he can dismiss the government at will following the plebiscate in 2003. The electorate again gave an even larger democratic mandate for some of the broadest executive authorities in the world in 2012.

I may think that this is dumb, but the people of Leichenstein voted for the setup so it is strictly democratic.

This why I am a republican (please note the explicit lower case) and not a direct democrat. I believe that it is wise to have checks on democratic mandates and obstacles to prevent such democratically endorsed actions from trampling upon electoral minorities. But if you are making the arguement that government needs to act as a checking force rather than the administrator of popular will, then we are talking about something other than pure democracy.

Like Trump's action the DOJ are bad on a lot of fronts (and again I would say the same about Biden and Obama), but they are very much more in keeping with direct democratic accountability.

"We have a system that has little ability to check the power of a POTUS who decides to act outside of norms other than the courts and they have not shown much willingness to use that power."
We have a system that affords the president no power at all if he is opposed by two-thirds of the legislature. The problem we have is that starting with GHWB, nobody has been willing to buck the party. Largely this is the result of the voters forgoing sectional voting (i.e. voting for old bulls who really where R/DINO) and instead opting for ideological sorting. But throughout the history of the Republic this was not the norm. FDR won epochal majorities and was wildly popular, but even he had a few vetos get overriden because the legislature cared more about results than strict partisanship.

And ultimately that is democracy in action. Primary voters, both R and D, will not abide folks who oppose their copartisans or hold opposing views.

Until primary voters are willing to accept folks paying the prices needed to get veto overrides (e.g. offering genuine concessions on taxes, immigration, abortion, or whatever), we get the imperial presidency. And I don't see how democratic accountability improves if we try to create independent powers within the executive. Either the presidential appointees can dig deep as well - in which case we are rewarding ever more psychophancy among such appointees. Or we will inevitably bring back the spoils system.

But when the voters care only about their partisan goals, punish legislators who make concessions across the aisle, and are inherently being lied to (i.e. there is no way to meet current budget obligations without current tax revenue, there is no magical pot of gold that will allow DOGE, single payer, or whatever to change that fact, nor is there some painless constituency to tax) ... it is going to be very hard to get any real accountability regardless of the system. Somebody wins, they do what they want.

Respond

"Presidential systems afford the electorate a direct vote on who controls all the powers you name."

Elections occur only at 4-year intervals (2 for congressmen) and are a blunt instrument that can only say yes/no.

This country is supposed to have checks and balances. The courts, like elections, move slowly. But Congress is supposed to wield considerable power, including the power of the purse which Trump routinely ignores by unilaterally deciding to close or gut or un-fund programs, offices, and even departments that were created by Congress.

Respond

Correct, the US has a lot of anti-democratic checks and balances.

But those would be actions where Trump is anti-consitutionally (which he has, as have most presidents since at least GWB), not anti-democratically.

I mean imagine a the Swiss passed a referendum that attained somebody as guilty of treason. Would that be democratic? Yes. Would it be wise, moral, or correct? No.

Democracy is not the answer to every problem with political underpinnings. Sometimes it is representation. Sometimes it is stare decesis (i.e. letting the dead really vote). Sometimes it is divided sovreignties. And so on.

Trump doing stupid crap doesn't make it anti-democratic. And something being anti-democratic doesn't mean it is innately bad.

The US has a representative republican government precisely because having one election and then letting the people or their champion do whatever was thought to be a bad idea. And I maintain that the Trump era is pretty good proof of that concept.

Respond

Expanding on Steve's comment, unlike American presidents, prime ministers in parliamentary systems can be removed by their own party without a general election. Two mechanisms are common: a formal party leadership vote (often called a leadership spill in Australia), or a caucus revolt that forces the PM to resign under threat of losing party support. Some examples:

Margaret Thatcher — UK, 1990
Kevin Rudd — Australia, 2010
Julia Gillard — Australia, 2013
Tony Abbott — Australia, 2015
Malcolm Turnbull — Australia, 2018
Theresa May — UK, 2019
Boris Johnson — UK, 2022
Liz Truss — UK, 2022
Justin Trudeau — Canada, 2025

Respond

"Expanding on Steve's comment, unlike American presidents, prime ministers in parliamentary systems can be removed by their own party without a general election. "

Isnt that bsc prime ministers arent elected but appointed by the head of state (previously) or the (largest) party in parliament?

Respond

Absolutely. I suspect the point is that the mechanics a parliamentary system creates seem better than the ones the US will have in the next 2 years. Still, more of preferences than something we can evaluate empirically, as presidents like the one the US has are not exactly normal. A lame duck Clinton, Bush or Obama is very different than this.

Respond

"all firewalls that have sat in between the President and the DOJ and FBI are gone."

We can thank Obama for that when he launched the "Russian interference" hoax. (expects denial from left)

Respond

The DOJ and FBI under Obama also famously investigated Hillary Clinton, which proves my point. These institutions under Biden prosecuted his son, Hunter.

Respond

Given the humiliating defeats each led their respective parties to in the space of 24 months, I would say the main takeaway is to be wary of leaders in their 80s.

Respond

I agree, the last presidential election and this midterm one are more of a referendum on the person in charge.

Trump is just too fickle , venal, narcissistic , and his administration too sycophantic while his family is unchecked to use his presidency as a springboard to enrich themselves.

His bromance with Putin , his economic war with Canada , his on again , off again tariffs, the seemingly pointless , meandering war with Iran , the ballroom extension , the feuds with Powell and many other twists and turns didn’t make sense to the average American.

Biden was a shadow of himself , a figurehead.
We need more normal , presidents.

Respond

The problem for the Republicans is the primary. Getting past the dedicated votes who appear to vote about who will most strongly own the despised libs is selecting for things other than competency. Rubio and DeSantis both are wildly more able to achieve conservative goals but both simply could not generate the primary support to put a dent in Trump. And the folks who ran closest to Trump (e.g. Cruz) are themselves more prone to bombast than accomplishments. Once in power, it seems to be fiendishly hard for Trump or his state level mimics to actually get the machinery of government to accomplish durable goals.

On the Democratic side, there seems to be a lot more willingness to strategically fall on the sword or even to force vitiation of primaries when a critical threshold is reached. But the actual governance ends up being directed by some widly out of step demographics with priorities often alien to the electorate.

Both sides run well as the opposition - bombasts can rally voters and promise everything, an orderly annointing of national names awaiting their turn bespeaks competency after poor governance. But once in power, both parties get sucked into superminority positions and devote their energies to causes not matching the electorate. Democratic governance appeals to fail from the machinations below, Republican governance appears to fail from the machinations above.

Whichever side figures out to perform normal governance near the median voter will likely reap a voting premium for a generation.

Respond

For the love of God, will some please nominate a sane moderate? And make it a middle-aged white man, while you are at it. I don't want to take any chances.

Respond

Ehh, what matters is the governance. Both Biden and Trump could have been generational figures if they had eschewed going for idiosyncratic policies disliked by the populace while doing things (e.g. mass boondoggle spending, capricious tariffs) that juiced inflation.

In Trump's case, I think you are right. His deficiencies drive the bad policies and his personal unpopularity makes it ever harder for him to manage the machinery of government.

But on the Democratic side, the problem seems to come from the bottom up. Biden was the moderate white guy in the primary. But once in power, he staffed the place with very atypical liberals who persued a bunch of their priorities.

Republicans need to discipline their primary voters - and last night may have done that.

Democrats need to discipline their activists. Maybe 2024 did that, but I think it looks more like they are still holding out hope that their dreams are popular and that this isn't just anti-Trump backlash.

Respond

Democrats bask in the glory right now but I don't believe it's a signal the electorate loves them but rather that it got tired of Trump personally and wanted to send that message.

Respond

I am having a hard time with the comparisons here. Who did Biden put on his cabinet that was even remotely as inappropriate as RFK or Hegseth? How about miracles pills Dr Oz? I would agree that the radicals were louder under Biden than I hoped but AFAICT it didnt result in much legislation. They went overboard on stimulus which probably contributed to inflation but I think that is a bog standard Dem action and not due to the youngsters.

Steve

Steve

Respond

Again, you are looking at the top down. Democrats still have a bunch of folks at the top who are political hands doing their thing. But the bottom rungs of the Democratic administration were wildly more liberal.

Sam Brinton, for instance, was charged with multiple felonies and should have been shunned by a competent White House, but the grassroots demanded representation and their priorities are working their way up the food chain.

I honestly expect both of these problems to swap in the not too terribly distant future. Democrats will have their senior rungs filled with folks who do not remember '92 or even '04. The evergreening of socialism will lose some of the last liberal checks from learned experience of the Cold War. The Republicans, on the other hand, are likely to be awfully short of junior staffing folks and their rising stars are likely to be the folks with the political acument to neither go Full Trump nor to be so wedded to some other doctrine to lack the "flexibility" to retain office. Could be wrong; file it under speculative prophesy. But I think the giant Democratic divide between seniorleadership and junior staffers is working is way up through the age cohorts, while the Republican one is maybe just starting.

Respond

Rob Sand, Iowa governor elect

Respond

Rob Sand, Iowa governor elect.

Respond

"Biden was a shadow of himself" As far as I can see Biden was always a lazy, dim, obstinate man with a bad temper and a head full of inaccuracies and fictions. He also turned out to be corrupt.

Being a shadow of that is an improvement.

Respond

Very Much Rising in status: American immigrants, the hardest-working and most entrepreneurial people on Planet Earth

Respond

Legal? Always were fine in status.

Respond

There is extensive evidence at this point of ICE and the Trump administration ignoring court orders protecting immigrants from detention and deportation and of suddenly arresting and detaining immigrants who were granted immigration parole or some sort of humanitarian permission to stay in the country. Here is just one example: https://www.kpbs.org/news/border-immigration/2025/12/08/ice-detains-ukrainian-wife-of-us-citizen-following-green-card-interview

By definition, someone who has been granted temporary permission to stay via a court order or a pending visa application is not an illegal immigrant.

Respond

I would also add that Trump's utter non-enforcement of immigration law with respect to employers makes this pretty dubious. If the dividing line is legality, it would be trivial to both reduce the demand for illegal labor and build extensive cases against various forms of visa fraud if you take down folks who employ lots of illegal labor.

Maybe I missed it, but I do not recall Trump every filing suit against employers.

If it is about enforcing immigration law, you need to prosecute the natives who are violating said laws as well.

As somebody who supports a lot of legal immigration and wants stricter enforcement of the rules on the books, I am increasingly convinced that if you are not going to try wealthy Americans for their violations of immigration law, you are just playing politics.

Respond

There was some at first, including prominently the Hyundai plant raid in Georgia, but it got rapid pushback from the kind of people who have the ears of Republicans. Trump chickened out.

Respond

Maybe I missed something, but I thought all the action there was against the illegal workers. Did Trump ever arrest, charge, fine, or detain any of the employers or their local representatives?

If you are going to enforce immigration laws, it has to include the folks who reap the benefits of illegal labor, not just the laborers.

Respond

Well, he shut down their factory build out, which strikes me as a serious blow. But I don't think it ever got as far as the moves you're asking about. Nor do I think it would - I don't remember those kinds of consequences either.

If your point is "this was half-hearted," I agree. However, it was politically fraught, and there was always going to have to be some compromise. There might have been widespread agreement on the need for greater immigration enforcement, but there wasn't widespread agreement on all aspects of it and some of the more heavy-handed methods (e.g., ICE) were particularly unpopular.

Respond

My point is, if you are going to actually be the law and order enforcement guy on immigration, you cannot just give a pass to your side's beneficiaries of illegal immigration.

And on the politics of it? Sending folks out for high visibility confrontations with just the immigrants and *nothing*, not even a designated whipping boy, from the employer side is political malpractice.

You want to be a by the book sheriff? Then arrest the people with hundreds of counts of illegal employment, wage misreporting, and the rest.

You want to be a politician who "opposes illegal immigration", then again, sprinkle the charges around to make Ricardo's criticisms less reflexively valid.

Respond

You haven't been paying attention. What do you think "nativism" means?

Respond

*During this election cycle*, democracy never was under threat.

The United States has not been under risk of fascism.

If you ignore the masked ICE agents in unmarked vehicles grabbing people off the streets because brown or with an accent.

U.S. citizens are regularly and inadvertently caught up, detained, and sometimes even deported by ICE.

Respond

TC is a libertarian. Why would he care about masked federals grabbing people off the streets and shooting them?

Respond

Okay... that got a spit take!

Respond

This kind of thing predates Trump.

You just weren't paying attention.

Respond

Examples please. I would love to know more. Big, if true.

Respond

“The authoritarian will in general select those who obey, who believe, who respond to his influence. But in doing so, he is bound to select mediocrities. For he excludes those who revolt, who doubt, who dare to resist his influence.”

These words appeared in “The Open Society and Its Enemies,” Karl Popper’s 1945 attack on authoritarianism and defense of liberal democracy.

Reading the book today is a vital reminder of how proponents of free and open societies can arm themselves, intellectually and spiritually, for the battle against repressive states seeking to strengthen authoritarianism and weaken democracy.

Popper warned that the enemies of open societies were powerful and numerous, and cautioned that liberal democracies were rare, fragile and required extreme vigilance to maintain.

Popper advised that free men should pay homage to institutions, not individuals. He advised his readers that their main task should not be to think about how to elect good men and women, but rather “how can we so organize political institutions that bad or incompetent rulers can be prevented from doing too much damage?”

https://www.ussc.edu.au/the-writer-who-warned-against-rising-authoritarianism-and-his-advice-on-resisting-it

Respond

Institutions are downstream from people. They also degrade per Pournelle's Iron Law. The suburban goobers who formerly ran Texas and Georgia went all in on Chamber of Commerce ideology and no longer hold power.

Respond

TC: the anti-social scientist, chief mood affiliator

Respond

Popper also stated the paradox of toleration, that a tolerant society can tolerate anything except intolerance, which would destroy the tolerant society. We rejected a lot of intolerance yesterday.

Respond

Saying voting went well and democracy is OK so everyone was overreacting is like saying Y2K was a nothing burger and everyone made too big a deal.

It was because everyone made a big that Y2K was so smooth.

Respond

Worst take here in a while. Snarky, self-satisfied and, as others have pointed out, this outcome is hardly proof that there was never risk od another outcome.

What motivated TC to make such a a statement?

Respond

Mama says Tyler's ornery because he's got all them teeth but no toothbrush.
Seriously, it's such a weird tone from him, just bitter grousing. Acute mood affiliation?

Respond

Fear.

Respond

Around 2 AM on election night TC posted about a random Islamic antiquity research paper, so I teased him in the comment section on why he wasn't posting anything about the election, whether he was butthurt about the blue tsunami. So he deleted my comment (!!!) and posted the above around 3 AM ("And there you go.") - ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Respond

You forgot to put “vibe shift” on the failing bucket.

Respond

I don't think there's any evidence that Yglesias's advice to not talk about certain things or to move directionally in response to the last election was helpful at all? But I haven't looked at these results in detail yet. Even if so, he wouldn't necessarily be "rising in status" overall unless the trade off for policy that they could enact was worth it. (The point of getting candidates in office is to do what you want, so giving up more political space to act than you're getting from additional candidates is a poor trade).

It may seem strange in future to historians looking back that the Republicans thought that Trump's victory in late 2025 signalled that it was time to celebrate being a rich "chud", as it was a vote that people at large actually liked that and wanted to be ruled by people like that? (Which would have been the first time ever in history where these sorts of Lord Farquaad flavoured rulers were ever popular among the people).

Rather than other things like high inflation (particularly plausible with a story that the gov's fiscal policy is to blame), and the late introduction of a female candidate to a country where the presidency has a distinctive international role in tough geopolitics.

Respond

in late 2025?? What victory was that?

Respond

Fair, typo spotted. These 2020s do feel like long hell years that blur into one though!

Respond

"I don't think there's any evidence that Yglesias's advice to not talk about certain things or to move directionally in response to the last election was helpful at all"
Prima facie the folks who bucked Yglesias's advice underperformed relative to baseline. Michigan, Maine, and Minnesota are all much more reliably Democratic than Texas, North Carolina, or Georgia yet the progressive campaigns there ran up much lower numbers. Likewise, so far it looks like AES is underrunning Democratic house members in Michigan.

"giving up more political space to act than you're getting from additional candidates is a poor trade"
The only political space Democrats have to act in the next two years is whatever leverage they have in negotiations with Trump. You have a lot more options to achieve such wins if you can cut loose would-be-kingmakers in quantity. Trump cutting a side deal on some nomination is going to require at least 4 senators and it is wildly harder to find a deal palatable to Senate Republics and 4 different senators than just buying off Fetterman. Even if folks in KS, SC, and maybe MS vote with Republicans 50% of the time ... that is massively more freedom of action.

In terms of inducing Republicans in congress to vote against Trump, and possibly overturn his vetos, this is, by far, the better option. Getting to veto override territory means getting folks in places like Tennessee to buck Trump and that was never going to happen if Trump could primary red state partisans and then have his favorites walk to victory in the general. Wins in KS, SC, and maybe MS mean that there is going to be a lot more effective electoral pressure for senators up in 2028 from KS, IN, IA, MO, and the like to get behind popular democratic initiatives.

And the numbers for 2028 open up massively more possible courses of action. Democrats are defending Ohio and Arizona while the Republicans are hoping to hold Wisconsin. Nevada, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, and Georgia likely represent the entirety of the remaining traditional battlegrounds. Results yesterday give any Democratic president in 2028 much, much higher likelihood of holding the senate. And frankly having more senate seats to burn likely allows for a more leftwing president to squeek through with negative coattails and that opens up far more things than having a more liberal 2028 candidate who loses a senate seat or two and results in divided government.

For the next two years, Democratic wins need to get Trump on board or get to veto-override. They are much more likely to do that with this level of Trump thrashing in the toplines.

After that, the window of political action will be defined by how liberal a democratic president can be, and these numbers make that much, much more viable. And a strong Democratic performance? We might well be talking about 60 seats in the Senate and enough votes to let catch-and-release play for unpopular stuff like court packing.

Respond

James Talarico said God is nonbinary and transgender people aren't threatening and he won Texas in a landslide.

STFU about Yglesias, who is completely irrelevant. His obsession with woke, like Tyler's has been completely misplaced. He had no insight into this race and no connection to it. He's written himself out of any influence within the Democratic Party, maybe forever, as has everyone -- including the authors of this blog -- who did nothing to oppose the Trump admin when it mattered.

Respond

James Talarico dropped a lot of his more off-putting stances and was heavily focused on issues other than the progressive wishlist. He suddenly loved oil and gas. His campaign went carnivore.

The man is a smart politician who rode the wave. AES should have had much better numbers than Talarico, particularly if you believe Talarico's religious handicap was so bad.

AES spent a lot more time and effort on liberal causes and rode a purple state during a blue wave.

Undoubtedly there will be folks who believe that *this* time it is because the voters have finally come round to their worldview and I suspect the Democrats will run amok in 2029. But I just don't see it on the ground that this was an endorsement of progressive priorities more than a rejection of the Trump clownshow.

Respond

Yglesias doesn't even listen to Yglesias - he told people it was to pay too much attention to foreign elections, in Brazil... then was back to posting about elections in Israel in less than 24 hours!

Respond

If you can still win, there's value in being able to move the window of acceptable political dialogue, which for Democrats, is to move it away from traditionalism / Republicanism. Where did they not pick up a seat where they could have, because of not following some advice from Yglesias? I'm open to the idea there could be such a place, but one of their candidates winning by a smaller margin isn't that?

The Democrats have to get away from "How can the Democrats move to the Republican position in order to win, and then how can they "moderate" in power to move even further towards the Republicans?".

I don't think you can too technocratic about trying to *exactly* judge the perfect degree of policy position among candidates to get elected, without it being self-undermining in some sense of following up on that, because you've created a mandate that doesn't give you the authority for it, and you have undermined your image as a conviction politician.

Respond

There's also the thing that, even if moderation in the abstract could have helped to close some races, Yglesias's specific advice for *how to moderate* might have been quite bad.

Like, was Yglesias telling people to moderate in ways that actually mattered to the vote and would've helped, or was he just pushing Democrats to do conservative things that he likes which were generally unpopular and/or not salient issues?

Respond

On one level sure, on another level, if the administration had only pursued the corruption + DOJ angle, without pursuing the other policies that made them massively unpopular (endorsing Ken Paxton etc)... it's not really clear what would have happened.

You have posted about how Thomas Schelling votes in every election based on which candidate would do a better job of handling nuclear weapons... a 3% chance of fascism or whatever, and the massive amounts of time and effort people put in to opposing e.g. the ICE mobilization efforts in Minnesota, doesn't really seem like something to celebrate

Respond

Another group falling in status is those that claim marijuana legalization was a mistake:
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/03/us/elections/results-massachusetts-question-8-repeal-recreational-marijuana-legalization.html

Respond

Now I understand how you can watch so many weird movies and write reviews of them

Respond

Cue new healthcare dementia benefits for the Hempfest crowd.

Respond

Wow! This has to be the most lopsided result from yesterday.

Respond

The Dems won in many states where GOPers counted the votes too.

Respond

CA's one-time billionaire wealth tax might be failing but WA's annual flat 9.9% on incomes over a million seems to be upheld by voters. What does that mean?

Respond

WA will become less attractive to investment. TX, TN, etc. will become more attractive.

Respond

‘Democracy never was under threat and the United States has not been under risk of fascism.’

Or did the decisive Democrat victories merely suppress these risks? Had the victories been narrower, would Trump have tried to steal the elections? Even now, he looks as if he will continue to override Congress through vetoes and decrees.

Respond

this is so obvious that one has to suspect TC is being intentionally ignorant

Respond

"the people predicting “the end of democracy in America” now look foolish"

The marauders at the gate were fended off before the attack, therefore there were no marauders.

Respond

Falling in status as well: ICE. The only organization that, after many have tried and failed, could turn Texas blue.

Respond

Do not piss off the Hispanic vote in Texas.

Respond

Corruption being #1 on that list indicates that it is rising. Maybe not in "status" per se but in profile and importance. Perhaps I'm misremembering but I can't recall "corruption" being a headliner issue since the 70s.

Respond

>and importance

YMMV. The incumbunt party swept in MN. It will take CA awhile to finish counting the votes, but the incumbent party seems to be comfortably ahead, possibly even picking up seats.

Respond

You gotta remember only one party can be guilty of "corruption". The same behavior by the other part is "justice".

Respond

This is an overstatement verging on fallacy.
“predicting “the end of democracy in America” now look foolish.” Just because something didn’t happen doesn’t mean we weren’t justified in fearing it MIGHT happen. The administration and its crew gave reason for concern. Were the concerns overblown? Maybe. But people worrying too much may be a cause of why bad things didn’t happen.

Respond

TIL: the new Congress will be seated on January 3, 2027—the existing Congress retains its powers for 8 more weeks.

Have a nice day :-)

Respond

Current Republican congressmen are already changing their rhetoric as a result of the midterms. They don't fear Trump as much.

Respond

Brown gets seated sooner and it seems highly doubtful that Collins or any of the primaried senators will be doing Trump many favors for taking their electoral careers.

If Trump has any sense, he would likely dump the legislative agenda and just spend whatever time he has running appointing every judge or executive appointee that 51 Republicans might vote for.

But legislation? I see no obvious majority in the wings for anybody shepherding anything past the fillibuster or via reconcilliation.

Trump should do his best to enforce the Iranian blockade and cut a (bad) deal there, appoint whomever he can appoint, and then figure out what popular stuff he wants to bully pulpit the Democrats over for two years. He just doesn't have the votes today to do much else.

Respond

Is the “Trumpian Tone” falling in status? I wouldn’t bet Vivek’s ad (Acton’s estranged mother) swayed voters that much, but the backlash and quiet retreat might not have happened in 2024.

Respond

Tariffs

I'm really hoping that the last two years will serve as an object lesson that will get the public to finally understand the gist of why free trade is net beneficial. Trump applied so many tariffs at once that you could actually observe the aggregate effect on the economy in the form of inflation. Normally, tariffs tend to be a niche thing where a concentrated group of people benefit and the costs are dispersed, and they're slowly accumulated over time. But if you do enough of them all at once all of a sudden the dispersed costs add up, and you can observe the difference. Even while manufacturing jobs have increased, the gains are outweighed by broad increases in the cost of living. When people see their standard of living fall relative to wages, even in an environment where labor supply is tight and wages are rising, the point becomes fairly clear.

Of course it helps that Trump managed to triply ruin the economy by driving away cheap labor and driving up oil prices, which drove food prices extra high.

Respond

"finally understand the gist of why free trade is net beneficial"

So far that's not what I've heard as the summary take on tariffs from economists. Generally they are eating crow: free trade wasn't the universal unmitigated benefit they thought it was. Trump's tariffs had relatively little impact on the economy. Probably that's because he quickly reduced or "temporarily" suspended tariffs that appeared to have a negative impact.

Its more about "what", than "whether".

Respond

Where do you think all this inflation is coming from?

Respond

Likely the same place where we see it with the Euro, Sterling, and Yen. All the major Western Economies are seeing inflation jump and my guess is that a lot of it comes from the Ukraine war disrupting a bunch of core inputs, Chinese economic policy distorting a bunch of things in the global economy, and uncertainty (the primary contribution from Trump's tariffs) having folks bid up core assets and creating new reverberations of previous shocks.

Remember a big problem with Trump is not just that he enacted tariffs, but that he enacted stupid tariffs in capricious and unpredictable manner. If somebody tarriffs some we buy in bulk (like PPE), we can plan to offset. Maybe we go in with other heath systems to fund domestic production. Maybe we lobby for an exemption on one component that is much expensive to offset. Maybe we even get creative like the guys who would import "sweet tea" and then distill out the sugar or the guys who would disassemble Volkswagens so they could sell "kits". But most any mitigation option for us requires time and stable conditions. Do I want to dump a couple of million in with other folks to fund the buildout of a plant to process gowns and masks? Not if the tariff might vanish the next time a foreign leader sucks up to Trump.

Supply is elastic if given time to reach equilibrium. And global inflation rates suggest to me that inflation is a much larger phenomenum than Trump. Honestly I wonder if some component of it is just the world growing older and all the eldercare provisions leading to more money chases the same goods just on that basis.

Respond

Exactly. Trumps tariffs are one of the root causes of global inflation. Not just in the US, but because the retaliatory tariffs are affecting other countries too. And because of the capricious and stupid nature in which they were implemented.

Of course everyone fantasizes about having "optimal" tariffs that somehow avoid retaliation if you implement them in a stable and consistent way. It's possible in theory, but politically never actually happens because the incentives for rent seeking makes it too hard to constrain it to just the optimal cases.

Respond

Hmm... I think one way this might be true is the exemptions from tariffs that he has carved out to protect the AI boom from their effects, in a somewhat capricious way.

That might plausibly be driving some of the expansions in consumer price inflation for electronics all around the world, as US demand gets funnelled towards electronics imports from East Asia, of which there is a finite supply? Electronics are contributor to the "normal" disinflation that we saw in the last 30-40 years, so if they're inflating, the other parts of the global economy have to inflate less to balance or you get higher inflation.

Also possible the tariffs might be exaggerating the push away from imported goods towards domestic services, which could again be inflationary. (For US's unique path on inflation, the US's services and corporate profits are historically probably kind of a big driver of inflation, while the imported goods are often disinflationary? That's exactly the thing that folks worry about - they are cheaper! FX guy Karthik Sankaran frequently makes this point.)

Ultimately, I think inflation is more likely to come from his expansive fiscal policy and the supply shocks that he has generated though, as well as AI boom.

The tariffs might be more distortionary towards the US economic structure - exaggerating its shift to tech and services, entirely not what he intends (which is more kind of "the world is now gonna buy US-made gas guzzlers for some reason and this will balance the current account to the -3% deficit that is sustainable for the US") - but less important for inflation?

Respond

It's not the covid money dumps still catching up with us? How could it not be?

Respond

Matthew Yglesias is a pompous fool and a friend of Cowen. Silly to throw him a bone when he was recently dismantled in a
conversation with Medhi Hasan, and his policies are losing out to the ascendent populist Left.

Respond

I don't follow Matt Yglesias. What does he say that makes Tyler think he rose in status? I tuned him out completely after his one billion Americans book, a weak one IMO.

Respond

You think Hasan "dismantled" Yglesias there? lol

Respond

Vibe shift.

But seriously, people took action to make sure this outcome was possible. The imply that this administration isn’t actively hostile to democracy because they lost is dumb

Respond

Very poetic to see Trump destroy a party he never had any allegiance to, but did everything to bolster his incompetence and contempt for norms. The universe doesn't care about justice or engage in karma, but sometimes it makes sense. This makes perfect sense.

Respond

Tyler, good grief, didn't Matt Yglesias who wrote "American Democracy is Doomed" in 2015?!?

Does it mean he completely change his mind?

https://www.vox.com/2015/3/2/8120063/american-democracy-doomed

Respond

Apologies, I can't correct the typos now!!!

Respond

This is Tyler's extremely tedious "scold the annoying liberals" mode but I prefer ito think of it as a retrospective warning to the Vances, Millers, Musks of the world: "elections aren't going to stop, so you're supposed to do smart and popular things with your power."

Respond

But they don't want to do smart and popular things with their power ;)

(Musk, among the various ingredients in his brain-stew, might want to some smart things I guess. But those are kind of things that he can already with his economic power and he doesn't really need political power to do?)

Respond

*During this election cycle*, democracy never was under threat…

Respond

This elections probably should not be considered as the confirmation of the healthy democracy. What follows is. What will Trump and Co do between now and January 2029.
You can legislate what you want but if person with a gun decides to follow his commander-in-chief your efforts are wasted.

Respond

'Never under threat, and the US has not been under risk of fascism'?? ICE? January 6? But this is what I expect here.

Respond

The current US Presidential Administration is like someone in India found a monkey paw and wished for their country to become a superpower.

Respond

"democracy never was under threat" - Tyler

And it is even spreading to ... (Mars Is 'That' Way).

Respond

This is comparable to the midterm losses Clinton and Obama both suffered in their respective first terms. But both actually went on to get re-elected handily anyway. That exact scenario's not in play here, but it still illustrates the risk of trying to extrapolate any implications for 2028 and beyond.

The big danger for Democrat is strange-bedfellow infighting over the soul of the party, if the democratic socialists overstep their mandate like Gingrich did in the 1990s.

In this new environment, we may yet see wheel-and-dealmaker Trump emerge. We had a glimpse of that when he cut a deal on USMCA in the midst of impeachment proceedings, which was passed with overwhelming bipartisan majorities in both houses and also with little or no opposition in the legislatures of Mexico and Canada. There could very well be a lot more of that now.

Trump has no actual principles, so he's perfectly willing to do whatever he thinks will make him look good, including repudiating his own past stances and achievements (USMCA, Operation Warp Speed).

Republicans will probably seek to distance themselves from him now with an eye on 2028, so he might very well do the same to them and cozy up to any Dems willing to hold their noses and engage with him. Not as farfetched as you might imagine.

Respond

Far more likely, imo, is two years of impeachment and indictment circus. Nothing substantiative will happen.

Respond

That’s certainly possible. Or Trump cuts some self-serving deal with Democrats is certainly likely. Also unlike his first term, he has lost the Senate and he is termed out. After this electoral wipe-out, with Democrats blocking all future judicial nominations blocked, how long will Republicans continue to back Trump?

Respond

"This is comparable to the midterm losses Clinton and Obama both suffered in their respective first terms."

No, this is only comparable to two elections: 1976 and 1932. I.e., Nixon/Vietnam and Great Depression.

Minimize that at your peril.

Respond

"This is comparable to the midterm losses Clinton and Obama both suffered"

Comparable, yes, in the sense that the losses that just occurred were much, much more severe than others experienced in recent memory.

Respond

Is "free speech" rising or falling? Musk chipped in $445 million for 2026 campaign contributions. That's a lot of "free speech".

Respond

It is gratifying to see the repudiation of Magaism. I hope the democrats have learned their lesson, but I doubt it. Their moderates did the best, but the leftists will not notice and consider the victory a mandate.

I'm afraid two years from now we'll be faced with the same two insane parties we keep oscillating between.

Respond

Yeah that's the thing. There's no shortage of loony policy ideas on the left, some of which Mamdani is already putting into practice. So though the Republicans under Trump have been unconscionable and often literally unconstitutional, the Democrats are a fragmented mess that includes some really bad policy ideas.

However, the billionaire tax in CA looks like it is going to be defeated. Portland OR had just one electoral measure in this election, a bizarre one to have residents vote on how to spend 2% of the city's discretionary budget. That measure was being defeated with the early results being 2:1 against it. So it remains to be seen how much influence the Democratic far left will have.

Respond

Falling in status: Putin (and other strongmen) and Russia

Respond

One reason I am optimistic about the election results is due to the success of leftwing islamic politicians in the US like Mamdani and El Sayed.

America has been in a civilizational conflict with the middle east for 30+ years. Intermittent wars have yielded ephemeral benefits at best. The long term solution to this conflict is to acculturate islamic culture to be compatible with Western values. Our liberal politicians who simultaneously extol their muslim faith while also favoring leftist social policies provide a model for a liberal muslim civilization that can be exported to foreign countries. The long term, the cultural impact of people like El Sayed may be more important than their domestic political impact.

Respond

Was this intended as satire?

Because it's disastrously, comically, and ahistorically wrong.

The Middle East has had plenty of governments, at various places on the secular to Islamist spectrum, who pursue heavily statist economic policies. When those policies unsurprisingly fail (except in places with astonishing amounts of oil and gas wealth per capita), those leaders then blame those failures on a mix of the United States, former colonial powers, and Israel/Jews in general.

Mamdani and El-Sayed are part of that same intellectual tradition.

Respond

Gerrymandering worked as intended.

It was a priori known they hardcore maximizing will backfire with a Democrats wave.

For Trump, Dem +1 majority is almost as bad as +200.

The expected value from gerrymandering was positive for Trump to keep control of the house.

The coin falls on the wrong side, doesn't change the original EV, nor the skewed utility of the bet

Respond

More evidence that the cure for populism is to elect a populist.

Respond

"Socially moderate Democrats did very well"

I would disagree. Peggy Flanagan (Minnesota), Abdul Sayed (Michigan), and James Talarico (Texas), to name a few, are not socially moderate.

Respond

"how can you differentiate"

By assessing what was done and estimating the effectiveness of those actions.

Respond

Wow...so just because the fire department functions, there's nothing to worry about unkempt brush? Not your best observation.
YMMV

Respond

Gerrymandering (came back to hurt Republicans, given the Blue wave)

Yep. Notable "+5 GOP" house races went blue.

TX 23 with San Antonio going southwest along the border was one. Populist "guntuber" Brandon Herrera lost and it wasn't close.

Respond

The pro-gerrymandering amendment passed in Maryland, overturning the anti-gerrymandering amendment we passed recently. Of course, the root cause (or at least it's how it was sold this time) was a response to the GOP.

Respond

I find it very weird that, for the first time, Trump *isn't* saying that the election was rigged, like he's been saying for years when anything goes against him. Weirder still is that no one seems to have noticed.

Respond

Have any of the newly elected been sworn in? "It ain't over till it's over."

Respond

This has been very satisfying. In BC my party , The Conservative Party, won a significant majority, and the GOP, a party I find ghastly, led by an amoral imbecile, lost decisively . Good Times.

Respond

Wealth taxes are falling in status? Tell that to Washington state, which roundly rejected a proposition to repeal the "millionaire's tax" on income over $1 million. Interestingly, opposition to the measure wasn't just concentrated in the greater Seattle area but spread to some redder counties, include Spokane, though there were some pockets of support in deeply red rural counties. The rich/poor divide overshadowed left/right.

Respond

Senator Schumer just said he intends to get rid of the filibuster. There may be enough States to enact the ‘Democratic Compact’ eliminating the use of the electoral collage, moving all decision making to big cities. There will be an increased possibility of court packing and gerrymandering by targeted State creation.
All of these are technically ‘Democracy,’ but the American political system’s robustness relies on a lot more than bare Democracy.
Are you sure people were worried about the right side?

Respond

Hmmm

Thousands if not tens of thousands of people worked very hard for two years to make sure an uneventful election occurred. From Secretaries of State and their election offices (both parties), to political parties' staff, to local officials and staff, to lawyers (Trump was 0-27 in his attacks on election procedures over the last three months--does Tyler think opposition to this just materialized out of thin air?), to lots of local orhanizing that sent people to polling places with even hints of problems, etc.

The risk was definitely there. It was a huge effort by many dedicated people to make it 'nothing'.

Tyler is wrong, and it typifies his lack of awareness or concern for how society actually works.

Respond

What's your take on Jason Stanley in light of this? He gave up the Jacob Urowsky chair at Yale to move to Toronto, all to avoid fascism.

Respond

I'm sure he's very happy to live and work in a functioning country, but damn your jealousy is showing today.

Respond

Ridiculous take, coward.

Respond

The "democracy is under threat" claims I've seen most weren't about the conduct of this election so much as what the Left would do *after* the election. Finding pretexts to prosecute opponents, finding pretexts to ban disfavored speech, packing the supreme court, etc. And the fun thing about those claims is they can't be retrospectively evaluated until well after the election winners get seated.

(As for worries about fascism, well, the left has been consistently apoplectic about how the first thing Musk did when he bought Twitter was to pull their stick out of the bundle.)

Respond

Falling in status:

Data centers in AI.

There's a bit of mass hysteria going on and that's why there was a blue wave.

There's always been wars in the middle easy and that didnt cause texas to flip blue. The tariffs were held in place by Biden and aren't going away.

Rural Texans hate data centers, that's the core of Trump support. Combined with energized Dem base, here we are

Respond

What does it say about the "billionaires are buying out elections" crowd if Elon Musk can spend $500 million (heck you could even argue his entire acquisition of Twitter was to get Republicans elected) and it did absolutely zilch?

Respond

You’ve got to be joking. WTI rose to $112, up from $58 when Trump started the war with Iran. Big oil chipped in over $200 million in campaign contributions for 2024 election cycle. Economists perhaps should name this the Genius of Putin dividend.

Respond

Rising in status: fraud. The democrats again (!) swept Minnesota.

Respond

I don't see how the vote was anti-corruption. Minnesota probably has the largest fraud problem in the US and all the incumbents there won.

Respond

Trump was never a fascist. The Left thinks in large utopian political ideologies so that's how they labeled him. Trump was more like a mafia boss who rewarded his friend and family and punched back at people he thought wronged him. Trump is a lame duck now. What worries me are the people who think in large political ideologies and that the government is the answer to achieve it. That's who won yesterday.

Respond

Fascism was an ideology of a particular time and place: the vacuum left by retreating monarchical powering Inter-War Europe. The only people remaining with the requisite all-encompassing view of the State as preeminent human institution are women, Canadians, Europeans, and State-capacity libertarians ("classical liberals").

Respond

Many a fascist movement, just like most supposed communists, are just robes against mafia style authoritarianism. It's just which justification you use to make the people be mostly OK with your kleptostate. The only reason we can tell the difference between the US in the last 2 years and a banana republic is that said banana republics sold themselves off to bigger countries for the sake of the junta's profits, while here those bribing the junta are either smaller countries or tech oligarchs.

The fortunate bit, which is Tyler's one key good point, is that there's not enough appetite in the US armed forces and police to actually go along with the authoritarian and clamp down really hard on an angry populace. No deploying ICE against everyone.

Respond

The only reason Trump isn't x or y is because the Constitution doesn't allow it. If only Mao's incompetence could've been prevented by the same institutions.

Respond

Unfortunately also rising: tolerance for exterminatory anti-Semitism.
And fear of tech, which may have an impact on economy, in particular in the race with China. And raising taxes or blocking tax cuts. Raising redistribution is claimed to increase consumption, but that's doubtful and may give bad incentives.

I'm curious what you think about this.

Respond

The exit polls suggest that they voted about 2/3 D, 1/3 R ... just about the same as they have the last few elections.

Respond

Rising in status:

Matt Yglesias (Commies did very well)

Respond

Um, should I have said parasites?

Respond
Respond

Add Comment