It's ok to say that the doomsday sex cultists have a doomsday sex cult.
TW: mentions of non-vegan meals
Show me one Bay Area AI safety or AI welfare organisation no member whereof ever participated in one of Aella's orgies, and they all shall be spared.
... until then, no: I don't think it "cheapens the discourse" to mention that, in particular as the same people are courting sections of the Christian right and Catholic caucus that would, at least publicly, feel embarrassed to be associated with something so—?
If the two things were kept safely apart by the cultists themselves, I would have empathised more with the case for mercy. That most definitely isn't the case, unfortunately. Covfefe knows what's up:
>but I think focusing on that is both cheap and counterproductive. What matters is that they’re ruthlessly power-seeking doomsday cultists
Ruthlessly power-seeking doomsday cults frequently include repulsive sexual practices both to bond people to the cult as well as an attractor
The two are related
It also happens to be a simple handle for understanding what they are - if someone is unable to dive into the details of the most logorrheic cult of all time then "doomsday [ugly] sex cult" is a fair summary
Quote
Hunter Ash
@ArtemisConsort
EAs being sex weirdos makes for good tabloid gossip, and maybe helps negatively polarize people against them, but I think focusing on that is both cheap and counterproductive. What matters is that they’re ruthlessly power-seeking doomsday cultists, and if they get their way it
There's a reason sex cults seeking to influence policy are frowned upon
There's just so much loyalty to be gained by it, in particular if the effects of a publicity backlash would be felt more strongly the farther you were from the core cult:
- kinship through ritualised transgression Think of it a sort of Peter-Singer-friendly σπαραγμός¹, and to wonder whether the ideal answer to the plzdontkillus cow question might not have been "alive—at first";
- antinomian "stotting" "Wow, basically anyone who's anyone in AI risk is a participant to the same rituals, then they turn around and host a catholic AI conference? and they can get away with it, with no one saying a word? better stay on their good side"
- tacit blackmail threat Liminal practices such as CNC orgies or drug-fuelled SM sessions are never unambiguously safe or consensual. you might think it's a risk worth taking, but don't bullshit yourself. still, the limits are blurred—that's the point. Therefore, reputational hazard might easily befall those who get on the bad side of the people controlling the frame: try to explain that yes, you used DATE RAPE drug 𝛾-butyrolactone to incapacitate your partner but you did discuss it beforehand and why of course you slipped it in her drink "without her knowing" but like, at the meta-level she kn— Be serious.
Now you could simply say: ok but how about you simply don't go to the parties? I mean, im sure not everyone approves of the stuff.
Well, perhaps not. But if you're interested in AI alignment or AI welfare you'll soon find that ALL the fellowships, grantmakers, and research institutes working on the topic are very much under the Bene Jizzerit's influence, to the point that the Redolent Mother herself can allow herself to state, quite plainly, that if you aren't okay with CNC orgies you aren't welcome in the community.