This seems like a reasonable idea with precedent from Obama’s education department.
The government shouldn’t be in the business of encouraging people to take loans they won’t be able to repay.
Didn’t Obama’s Ed Dept start this whole federal loan mess to begin with? I recall a key selling point was that these loans would return a great profit. Just like if you like your doctor you can keep your doctor.
The GOP shouldn't play favorites. It should just shut down the federal student loan program (grandfather existing loans but otherwise stop it for new underwriting). That will have the most immediate, radical effect on the real price of education.
Except for English Literature. Lots of people who major in English aren't looking for jobs with their undergrad degrees; they're going straight on to law school.
Is this actually a good rule for determining "won't be able to repay"? I can imagine majors getting excluded from loans because of a recession or a field-specific temporary downturn, and then when things pick up again there's a shortage of people with relevant degrees.
Classhog Matthew ‘Egghead’ Yglesias with another burning, stentorian call to do very little and nothing at all, but make sure I’m lavishly paid to minister to the worst people alive. I’d have a lot more respect for you if you seemed, at all, in any way, to actually believe in it.
Who’s to say a doctor or lawyer will be able to repay? We have friends in their 50’s who are doctors struggling to repay. Meanwhile, my wife and I paid ours off by 25 both with careers in musical theater.
Why not ban all student loans for institutions other than vocational schools/colleges?
If the purpose of living is to work, not to learn, then there is no purpose in subsidizing learning
Only loan money if it's going to be used to create workers, not citizens
This will probably take away most student loans from kids with Republican parents. You really need a loan when daddy owns a car dealership, you want to go to a fancy private school, and your grades aren't good enough for merit scholarships.
The concept of arguing the degree shouldn’t be accessible to anyone who wants to study rather than arguing the inflated cost of accessing a degree is becoming an issue.
Loans should be banned for people who don’t get a certain sat score. Probably a better prediction of repayment than major. But the banks don’t want to actually reduce the number of loans do they?
If you make it illegal for the government to federally back student loans the market will fix this on its own. It will also reduce the cost of college tuition. But why would the government want to fix a problem they created when they can just grab more power! They will also no