Property Rights are Human Rights
There’s looting happening currently with videos and such posted. There are also various different reactions to shoplifting, often qualified by what is being shoplifted.
There are calls to action to stop these thefts, as well as calls for restraint in acting against the thieves.
It feels to me that there is a question to our property rights as they have existed. That having goods for sale is somehow lesser than having them in a home, which seems to remain unassailable, and those with goods for sale, particularly food and diapers, i.e., staples enjoy fewer rights to protect their goods.
I am curious as to the thoughts here, as I find the opinions here relatively grounded. Where are the lines in defending against theft and protecting one’s property?
My opinion is that our (western capitalist, free[ish] trade) society was built on strong property rights, and that the right to protect what is yours is a human right that we see everywhere. I don’t think shooting thieves is appropriate, and I don’t want someone to starve when there is an excess of bread, but it seems in some ways that thieves are enjoying undue protections.
Comments Section
Property rights are human rights but because all human rights are fundamentally derivative of the right of private property.
Property is a value holder for the time you put in to create that value. A person stealing something from you is akin to them stealing all the time in your life that it took you to obtain it.
So if you were to say, “killing a person to prevent them from stealing your car is ok”, someone might respond that someone’s life is worth more than a car.
The flip side of this would be, would you kill a person that was about to take away 6 months of your life?
I think disproportionate force should be allowed to prevent a crime being actively committed. Lefties have way too much sympathy for criminals victimizing innocent people to the extent they hate people trying to stop them more
Completely agree. Thieves should be shot.
I hear a lot that these criminals are released days or a week after committing the theft. Since they are in jail for a low amount of time, there are now opportunist that will rob stores more often. The state need to increase the penalty for theft to discourage these activities.
EDIT: spelling
Comment deleted by user
Allowing opportunist to roam free after a few days of committing the crime will only encourage more people to do the same. More crime prevention measures need to take place to prevent this wave of theft.
EDIT: grammar
I disagree with a lot of the comments in here. I believe that property rights are on par with rights to life and liberty.
I can get this position, but what I can't get is when people try to co-opt property rights with intellectual property rights.
Property rights are important because whenever someone steals from you, they are making you less whole. No amount of copyright infringement will make you less whole. It just becomes a debate of "how much potential earnings did you miss out on."
Such a hard stance simply can't exist in a modern society. Just taxes and infrastructure needs alone violates any principle on all property being untouchable by society. Hell just look at how insane American infrastructure is already because of how much influence and pushback people get to have over it, imagine if they had to pay way over market for every single piece of land too cause the sellers know the government has little choice but to pay it.
Right on, most people are forced to spend a large portion of their life and liberty acquiring property to support themselves and their familes. When you take someone's property, you take that from them.
Inb4 taxation is theft
Taxation without representation is theft
Nah, they are the price we pay for a civilized society, or so I heard.
Amen
Idk dude, property rights are an important human right but I also wouldn't call it as fundamental as basic human rights like free speech or other things to do with your own body.
And plenty of human rights declarations make it clear that general interest tends to come first when necessary
You actually see this all the time in real life. From taxes to housing codes to anti-discrimination laws.
Even some traditional folklore glorifies the thief who steals from the powerful in the interests of the everyman like Robin Hood, Goemon, and even real life people like John Dillinger. Typically of course this argument is almost always in the sense of helping other people. Robin Hood stole to give to the peasants, Goemon gave gold to the poor and John Dillinger was liked in part because he destroyed mortgage documents and other records which helped a lot of people out during the depression.
Obviously looting a store for your own personal gain is a lot different but we're certainly a lot more willing to make exceptions to property than we are with more fundamental rights.
Theft bad, but try telling this to people who watch torrented movies do mental gymnastics.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivalry_(economics)
And there it is! Property rights are human rights, unless it's intellectual property.
Intellectual property theft literally isn't theft by the classical definition of theft; it's making a copy and keeping the copy. Nobody was deprived of any property. The original owner still has their copy. By the classical definition it's only theft if you make a copy and also delete or deprive them of their copy. Since information is more or less infinitely multiplying for zero cost, theft is not a good moral framework to use. If someone went into a store and copied something in there and took the copy home, I don't think we'd define that the same way as if they took it and shoplifted it, nor would we justify shooting them or calling it a human rights violation.
See what I mean? ☝️ Those are the same kind of mental gymnastics the left does to justify theft.
Even if the data is infinitely reproducible, that intellectual property required capital somewhere to produce. Hell, even maintaining it isn't free, even if it might be super cheap. The owner is entitled to some compensation. You're obfuscating the economic value of the IP by not complying with the owner's intended usage under copyright. Is that not theft?
It's literally not theft by any definition of theft, not even the legal definition. It's copyright infringement. It is it's own thing. It's literally not even a type of theft. This is an already settled legal topic and you seem to have been totally uninformed about it. I recommend asking Google about it, or Bard, or chatGPT, or something. It's really basic stuff and you don't seem to understand what theft is except in a very informal, borderline slang contextual usage.
Property rights extend to intellectual property. Even if you might not consider it "theft"
Comment removed by moderator
Property rights for me, but not for thee.
Companies would flee the US if they didn't actually have strong IP laws, which they do.
This but unironically
Anyone who argues that theft is good should not be taken seriously, no matter who the theft is occurring from. People the usual reddit subs or other left-wing circlejerks seem to think that theft will just affect the companies and solely eat into their bottom line, when in actuality, we all will eat the costs with higher prices, and if they were insured against theft, normal people’s insurance premiums will go up since the insurance company isn’t just going to eat losses nonstop, and also employees will pay a price when companies close problem stores.
I think most people here would probably agree with the statement that you have a reasonable ability to protect your property, just with quibbling about what exactly constitutes “reasonable.” I think that if a thief is not armed, it is reasonable to detain said individual until police arrive using as minimal of force as possible. If they are armed, everything is on the table IMO.
Property rights are important, but I wouldn’t put them on the same level as say civil rights or the right to free speech or whatever. Also it just doesn’t look good to try and defend a faceless billionaire dollar corporation with that kind of zeal behind the language you use.
That being said theft is wrong and shouldn’t be tolerated at any level, but I wouldn’t try to say Walmart has the inalienable right to defend its margins from shoplifters, that’s just not how politicking works.
Did you mean person of means?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Theft bad.
But I don't think I'd put it on the same level as genocide or torture. I have to think that wasn't really what you meant. But that's kind of what it sounds like when I read, "property rights are human rights."
It wasn’t my intent to compare severity of crimes, more to argue that in the same way you have a right to not be murdered you have a right to own (and reasonably protect) property. That is to put property rights at an individual level instead of in the context of “that’s just a business so it doesn’t count”, as I feel can easily occur.
As is the case in many other contexts, I think its really just a matter of how sympathetic the victim is. Stealing from a home is always bad because the family is a clear, tangible, sympathetic victim. Stealing from a small mom and pop retail store is also bad for the same reason. Stealing from big retailers as is usually the case in these stories (not always, dont jump on me with some anecdote of a mom and pop shop) is considered far less bad because there is no clear tangible victim, and surely not one that most people consider to be worthy of sympathy.
Of course, all three situations are presumably covered by insurance, and there is certainly argument that stealing from big retailers just means costs passed on to consumers. But nonetheless, most people just don't care much when these thief gangs rob apple or target or Louis Vuitton.