Interviewing Yiyang Zhuge (Zhong Shu)

Many people are writing to me, upset that I am interviewing Ziyang Zhuge, a well-known Chinese internet intellectual, who recently was accused of plagiarism.  I am keen to proceed with the interview, and am happy to explain why.  A few points:

1. The relevant facts here still are being disputed, and furthermore it all happened in Chinese.  If I cannot personally adjudicate the matter, I remain inclined to proceed.  I am also well aware that standards in China, including for plagiarism, are very different than in the United States.  If someone tells me “A person in China did [fill in the blank]” my initial reaction is still “Are they interesting to talk to?”

2. I have had on numerous CEOs and business leaders.  Your opinions of each will vary, but surely some of them are guilty of something.  I do not regret any of them as guests, except insofar as they were boring.  You also can debate whether a former CIA head, in this case John Brennan, ever did anything wrong.  He was fascinating.

3. I once had on Sam Bankman-Fried, now a convicted felon.  It was an excellent episode, and I will point out my lines of questioning were more perspicacious than many people since have realized.

4. I once had on a convicted murderer, Shaka Senghor.  It was an excellent episode, and if I recall only a single person wrote me to complain.  I would gladly have more criminals on, and they do not all have to be repentant in the manner that Shaka is.  Would not a pickpocket guest be intriguing?  For Althusser however it is too late.

5. Without knowing the full story, I suspect the case of Yiyang Zhuge (neither a felon nor a murderer) is most analogous to having on the CEO of DeepSeek, Liang Wenfang.  At this point it is pretty well known that DeepSeek (and other Chinese AI models) distilled a lot from Anthropic’s Claude.  That is a violation of terms of service, and in economic terms it is an event and a depredation of pretty serious magnitude.  I still would be delighted to have Liang Wenfang on the show, and I would do so without obsessing over the issue of distillation.  How about it Liang Wenfang?

Xi Jinping is welcome too.  Chairman Mao, is pork belly with red sauce over- or underrated?  The world awaits your response.

Comments

"That is a violation of terms of service, and in economic terms it is an event and a depredation of pretty serious magnitude. "

The pearl clutching from Anthropic over this is absurd in view of the unprecedented scale of the violations of copyright, TOS, and and general piracy employed to train their own models.

The problem is she is neither interesting or accomplished enough to justify it

Ted, it’s easy enough to look into the allegations. She’s a plagiarist, period. From my perspective as a lawyer, I would call the plagiarism blatant, not minor. In my book, that disqualifies her for being taken seriously, including being interviewed by Tyler. But of course that’s Tyler’s call to make, and I have to admit I’ll listen.

Zhuge also said in the episode that she had plans to appear on “a whole bunch of podcasts by Western intellectuals.” She added that American intellectuals also routinely face intense criticism online, citing American political scientist Francis Fukuyama as an example.

The same day, three August book talks Zhuge was scheduled to attend in Shanghai and the central Hubei and Hunan provinces to promote her recent translations of works by German-American philosopher Hannah Arendt were also canceled, with the organizer citing “changes to (Zhuge’s) personal schedule.”

- siwth tone (zine

Seems like she us looking for respit and legitimacy in the Intilectual circuit.

If this "well-known Chinese internet intellectual" (a complete mystery to me) remains interesting to speak with (as I would concede at least provisionally), it would remain interesting to speak with her candidly about plagiarism (and at whatever length permits her to be forthcoming)--whether charges made against her, aspects of the yet-unresolved career of the late Jason Arday, cases involving other scholars or academicians of repute, questions regarding the substance of journalist explications of (and media outlet apologias for) any of the foregoing, further queries concerning writers of fiction adapting to the new rigors of LLMs, et al.

It could well be the case that the most interesting thing she could address in a CWT would be the very subject of plagiarism: so please don't neglect to consider this possibility, Tyler.

We were introduced to this "well-known Chinese internet intellectual" via Tyler's [Aug 1st] Saturday assorted links:

5. Chinese interview with Christopher Nolan.

M was the only one to comment on the interview and—like me eventually—he did not question her academic-level knowledge:

I think you can also see that Nolan kind of isn't quite equipped to answer some of these more academic questions with the level of detail that an academic or a historical novelist can, in a way that you understand why it provoked Wilson's review.

M nudged me back toward the interview the next day.

Hopefully this is the Spaced Repetition that will make my Learning of Zeus' Law (Xenia) permanently stick. It's no Golden Rule but it's a step towards that direction. YMMV.

3. Your interview with SBF was fantastic. It revealed a side to SBF that one had to pay close attention ("critical" attention) in order to get it. All of your discussions are like that. You are the best.

Can you be specific ?

I think Tyler is focusing too narrowly on the questions "is this going to be a fun conversation and is it going to be good publicity for me?" rather than "what is the value of a social norm forbidding fraud and plagiarism, and how much am I going to damage that norm with my actions?"

A world where Tyler does this interview, all else being equal, is more interesting than one where he doesn't. A world where everyone follows this logic, all the time, is a nightmare where the most duplicitous rise to the top and can't be removed because their fame sustains itself. Though I suppose my opinion doesn't matter because I haven't done anything scandalous enough to be worth listening to. Maybe if I go pick enough pockets I'll get the chance to expound my views on Conversations with Tyler.

https://www.reddit.com/r/podcasts/comments/1vrgni3/viral_chinese_podcaster_accused_of_mass/

“ However, a collaborative open-source investigation by Chinese listeners has cross-checked 125 episodes of her podcast so far. 75 out of the 125 episodes (60%) show severe source dependence or attribution issues.”

Lol.

I was unfamiliar with the plagiarism claims; but now i am curious ehat she would say about it.
What ate the different rules and norms for plagiarism un that culture? What are her thoughts on the differences? What are her thought as on the Deepseek distillation.

Agree the CEOs were all boring.

Take this line of thought to logical conclusion and we learn nothing about what evil people are like, how bad people process their justifications, how nasty people became the way they are.

It's not like Tyler is doing PR for the devil, he's digging into the way their minds work. And it is phenomenal! We are all better for his gift.

TYLER: Suppose I have four days in Taiwan. Taipei, Tainan, or Hualien?

XI: Taiwan is a province of China.

TYLER: That's not a very useful itinerary.

Correctness commenters are like "from the bottom of my selfless heart, Tyler, please don't make what I think is a mistake".

I definitely hope that you have Liang Wenfang on, but only if you and he directly address the distillation issue

I once attempted to write a piece about authors who wrote about how they (tried to) killed their wife. I never finished it because A. it got too dark and B. I found Althusser's book about it unreadable.

I guess anyone can get interviewed . Good , bad, ugly. Whatever. Post truth world . You decide.

It's fascinating how many fewer East Asian than South Asian public intellectuals are well-known in America.

Interestingly, I tried the prompt "influential thinkers in the USA active in 2020s" six times in Gemini and it gave me Fukuyama three times, as its most favoured result in the political theorist category (the only other individual provided as frequently was Judith Butler) with Chetty and Gopinath once each only.

No other Asian-Americans, apart from it throwing Ahmari in there once together with Deneen... but frankly let's be honest - he's a lamppost for a drunk, putting it kindly.

It's not a good era for public intellectuals in general.

We gotten to the point where courage matters more than brilliance, and courage is what's lack in public intellectuals.

Fully supportive of more convicted criminals. A vastly underrated subject population in podcasting.

The issue of cheating and plagiarism is worth exploring as its own topic. A laymen might think that test scores (SAT, GRE, whatever) would suffer due to this cheating. But they don’t! At the same time, cheating clearly helps your GPA, which matters in the race for admissions for grad school, elite employment. I know lots of kids in the 18-25 range and they all talk about the ethnic angle in cheating, especially among Asians, but shy from talking about it publicly because it’s racist. I’d really be interested to hear an honest discussion about it, especially as it differs at elite institutions like MIT or CalTech versus the ME department at a mid tier flagship. Are the stereotypes true? And either way what do they mean?

"I do not regret any of them as guests, except insofar as they were boring."
Beautiful. This sentiment is exactly why CWT is great. Ignore the woke who are trying to cancel this woman. Im happy this interview will proceed.

?

if the accusations are correct her career should be over. this is entirely separate from whether cowen ought to interview her. that is his whole point

Presumably she or her representative offered an interview to him, once she decided to hit the circuit. My guess she was not in his target pool, and could not pass on the opportunity.

They will likely want to go from interview to release quicker than normal.

If someone tells me “A person in China did [fill in the blank]” my initial reaction is still “Are they interesting to talk to?”

A person in China did patently useless research that resulted in 10,000% more deaths than the worst industrial accident in history.

I think they would be very interesting to talk to.

If the gain of function crowd was consistent, they would be against the frontier labs experimentation with AI alignment...gesturing at the revelations from the past few weeks... yet silence... pointing to this being fake outrage.

and Tyler would, without a reservation from him nor his audience, interview any scientist doing those experiments.

Senator Paul feels he is unlikely to suffer physical attack from an 85 year old. Young, aggressive AIs guys ????

I think regardless of the allegations, she was a more interesting and pointed interviewer than anyone else with Nolan. She also maintained a polite demeanor while asking some tough questions.

If you hold your ear just right, Conversations with Tyler is, in a way, a distilled version of Mindhunter. Unfortunately the series only lasted two seasons so this'll have to do.

I for one find it very likely that people make “plagiarism” into a political tool. Is it really well defined anyway today???

I haven't looked deeply into the allegations, but those that I've heard seem fairly minor. Also, men are often threatened by young, attractive women who are accomplished and competing in a male-dominated area.

I know that'll receive pushback. But it seems to me that men often have this feeling of "oh she's smart, good at X, *and* she's pretty? That's unfair". And of course the distribution of talent and attractiveness is unfair, but it is what it is.

Comments for this post are closed