Trump Administration Limits Predatory Lending in Education

The New Republic writes “President Trump is banning students majoring in degrees that don’t make enough money from taking out college loans.” Yes, but do note that no student is banned from any major and the lending rule is mild. Undergraduate programs must show:

that their graduates earn more than the typical high school diploma holder…[and] graduate programs will be required to demonstrate that their graduates earn more than the typical bachelor’s degree holder. (emphasis added).

Think about how low that bar is. The comparison group for an undergraduate program is working adults aged 25-34 with nothing more than a high school diploma. A college program that can’t beat that has almost certainly made its students worse off. For graduate programs the bar is the lowest of several bachelor’s benchmarks, including bachelor’s holders in the same field. A master’s in social work need only beat people with a bachelor’s in social work. A program must also fail in two out of three years before it loses loan eligibility. The Department estimates that about 5% of programs will fail in the first year.

I mocked the term “predatory lending” when it first became common in the financial crisis but in this case predatory lending fits the bill because the real borrower isn’t the individual student. Under income-driven repayment, the taxpayer is a forced co-signer, and it’s the taxpayer who gets predated.

Most expansions of the student loan program have been motivated by the picture of an enterprising student who works hard and wants to major in mechanical engineering or nursing but because of their poor circumstances they can’t afford college. “Credit constraints, asymmetric information, you can’t collateralize human capital,” said the economists. Nice theory, what’s the practice?

The economists wanted loans for good investments and insurance against bad luck but the economists can’t swing the vote and once the government is lending, colleges want more tuition money and students want more forgiveness. The result is a subsidy for programs whose graduates are never likely to repay. As Looney and Yannelis document:

Starting in the late 1990s, policymakers weakened regulations that had constrained institutions from enrolling aid-dependent students. This led to rising enrollment of relatively disadvantaged students, but primarily at poor-performing, low-value institutions whose students systematically failed to complete a degree, struggled to repay their loans, defaulted at high rates, and foundered in the job market. As these new borrowers experienced similarly poor outcomes, their loans piled up, loan performance deteriorated, and with it the finances of the federal program.

Indeed, the program worked in reverse of what was promised. The biggest subsidies went to programs whose graduates were least able to repay, rather than programs with the strongest case for public support. As I wrote earlier:

Looney does a back of the envelope calculation and estimates that typical graduates in Mechanical Engineering will on average get a 0% subsidy but graduates in Music will get a 96% subsidy, in Drama a 99% subsidy and Masseuses a 100% subsidy on average. This of course is exactly the wrong approach. If we are going to subsidize, we should subsidize degrees with plausible positive spillovers not masseuses.

The courts later blocked Biden’s Save plan but the problem is built into income-driven repayment. If music, drama and masseuses are promised a 95%+ subsidy who is paying? The taxpayers. Moreover, it’s even worse than this because the very existence of these loans incentivizes the creation of expensive, useless programs. It’s not just the drama colleges, however. Not surprisingly, the law schools have proven adept at using Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) to rip off the taxpayer. The school raises tuition, then covers the student’s small income-driven payments for ten years, and the taxpayer forgives the rest. In short, protecting students from the cost of failure rewards colleges for producing it.

Fortunately, the same bill limiting loans ended Grad PLUS loans and capped graduate borrowing. You can see the logic: if taxpayers are going to insure the loans, they need some say over which programs qualify and how much is borrowed. I don’t like giving government that power, but this is the Mises–Higgs intervention ratchet in action: subsidize the loans, absorb the losses, then regulate the programs to limit the losses.

My ideal program would get the government out of the student loan business altogether but until then this is a good first step at limiting one of the most expensive and wasteful programs of the federal government.

Comments

"one of the most expensive and wasteful programs of the federal government"

wasteful sure, but it's far from most expensive. accoding to GAO, loans made over 1997–2021 (which includes the covid pause) will cost about $197B in total. new lending costs around $16B a year, about 0.2% of the federal budget. most loans are still repaid, so the actual amount "spent" on the program is much lower than the amount disbursed

Respond

The waste is not just the net distribution of funds out of the exchequer - it is the marginal increase in idle years outside the workforce for large numbers of workers, it is the life decisions made to conform to the diktats of decades of debt service, it is the class of workers willed into existance as status chasing universities extract rents to cover the administrative empires.

If the government made a net $33 billion a year off the lending, I would still count it a horrible waste worthy of drastic reform.

Like seriously, consider the basics of the setup. We have young kids, often 17 and legal minors, making decisions in high school about if or where to attend college. Student loans obscure prices and many students sign up not knowing the real costs. And the net result?

40% of student loan borrowers last decade complete their degrees. 11% got an associates, 10% got a tech certificate ... and a whopping 39% got *none* of those. Median student loan debt is $20,281.

That's an FHA minimum downpayment on the median US house! And that is the cheap stuff. Suppose you burn 2 years on community college, you are not earning during that time and you lose 2 years of income, any interest on savings, and the rest. Now we are talking $100,00 forgone. Plus whatever consumer surplus would be had from somebody working in construction, retail, or whatever.

Then we get to the hard to quantify stuff where the lending programs encourage zero sum status competition among universities paid for by students unwittingly thanks to loans. I increasingly think spending a few years where you live off credit with no concern for the prices is a terrible habit formation cesspool. It encourages folks to adopt habits like eating out, buying expensive daily coffees, having poor time managment, expecting somebody to provide services for all the insults of life. And then we, of course, have the cultural arguments (e.g. does many college payment low friction delay marriage?). Harder to quantify but possibly greater in impact.

The law is teacher and right now it teaches some shoddy habits about how to handle credit, debt, daily expenses, and the rest. If legal adults want to spend money on four years of all-expenses-included living with some skill acquisition on the side, fine, it is a free country. But we shouldn't be endorsing such things carte blanche through federal expenditure.

And then we get to the life decisions. I know physicians who turned down great job opportunities because loan forgiveness was too tempting in the short run. One, eventually, left the underesourced area he served because of its sweet loan deal and returned East did some research and developed some medical devices that saved many lives. The whole thing was a waste in terms of money (both his and the government's), but also likely killed a lot of people by delaying life saving innovation with a pair of golden handcuffs fashioned from loan repayment.

And that is not uncommon. When job markets are tight, loan forbearance induces a lot of wasteful graduate degrees. Income based deferrals can drive all sorts of counterproductive behavior (e.g. not formally marrying your spouse lest you muck up the paperwork).

And, then, of course, we have the "administrator" class. Students who are not shopping on price shop on reputation. And while the lazy rivers get all the headlines, the real insidious things are the overstaffing of bureaucracy with marginal, at best, evidenced of improved student outcomes. If you can climb US News rankings by hiring an administrator (and I have been party to discussion to do exactly this), people will. Student lending in this country is a highly effective means of transfering funds from the student's working years to the salaries of folks who "promote diversity", "engage students", and "coordinate programs".

Again, if adults wish to spend their money on such waste, fine have at. But it seems bizarre to look back on the near doubling of college administration with little evidence of improved outcomes and say "yes we should do anything, at all, that facilitates this".

And all of this, mind, is without even considering the the political economy of creating DSA-style political constituencies.

The waste may be paid for in delayed consumption, foregone reproduction, or a host of other options. But the top line numbers are not even the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the wastefulness of government creating a world-unto-itself in education lending. The fact that the costs fall so disproportionately on the folks who fail to graduate by no means excuses the wasteful hardships it engenders in their lives.

Respond

This comment coupled with the one below is an example of the problem with so much of the discussion around higher education. It treats it like a singular thing rather than separating very different sectors.

You refer to 2yr colleges, reference commitment deadlines (as early as January?) that only apply to elite institutions (that impact ~3% of 18-22yros). At most publics you have until May 1 to commit and they generally hand out deferals liberally. No one cares if you take a gap year at a 2yr school and most regional publics don't care if you are right out of high school or not. Admissions people talk about melt - the students who pay a deposit in May and then never show up. It bounces around 5-10% at the R1 I work at. Tuition isn't due until August, so you have until then to change your mind without any significant skin in the game. That may not be true if you are talking about the Ivy+ schools. Though are we really worried about those alums (with 95%+ graduation rates) not being able to pay back their student loans? The for-profit/online sector is a very different story with their sub-30% grad rates and high default rates. But then those students aren't putting off life (nor are the typical 2yr students) while studying/partying full time. A huge fraction are working their way through school (and also tend to be a bit older).

Are there issues that need to be addressed? Absolutely. But blunt generalizations about higher ed don't help. It's like arguing we should overhaul the health sector based on arguments that bundle complaints about cosmetic surgery, chiropractor, GPs, and oncologists. The issues with Capella, Bob Jones, Harvard, Ferris State, Mercer, Texas A&M, and Tidewater Community College are not the same.

Respond

Ehh, when I talk about the impact of student loans on physicians I would hope that it would be intuitive that they are not the same as those on folks who attend 2 years and are done.

But they do come from similar mechanics - students from community college to the Ivies are getting diminished price signals from the loan system.

Prices are highly informative if they are negotiated in a market where people can compare options, evaluate past interactions between sellers and consumers, and don't have external factors outweighing the price information.

But modern student loans obscure all of that. I have seen student physicians go wild on spending during medical school - luxury apartments, nice cars, and the rest - and then get locked into loan forgiveness hell when circumstances change. I have likewise seen kids with limited academic and financial means lock themselves into an extra car payment for two decades thanks to trying (and failing) at community college. And worse, they encourage schools to do all the normal price inflation (maximize profits from the unwary who are take maximal loans)/ "need based" discounts/"scholarships".

The problem with both is that the government hawks loans to students without much regard for if the loan is wise and the cultural message - student loans good - gives rise to folks who regret their decisions very often.

And for what? Maybe you want to talk about some marginal reduction in interest rates for borrowers or some fun story about low credit access from the private sector. But overwhelmingly, the system has transferred rents from borrowers to educators (and honestly more administrators). When I teach residents and medical students it is astounding to me how much administrative bloat there is in medical education. But nobody bats an eye - the loans get repaid one way or another ... but in a very real sense it creates waste.

And I wouldn't care if the debts were fully private. You want to move consumption forward in life with a lower net total over the lifespan? Have at. But the cultural message of "this is so good that we have the federal government backstop the lending, we provide escape paths if it goes wrong, and we don't care about what 'education' you actually buy" is toxic.

The waste comes in many forms - the kids who try a semester or four before they decide "college isn't for them" and they default to construction or services - they and we would be much better off if they could see more clearly the costs and benefits before dumping months or years into incomplete education. The folks who are extended wildly more debt for living the high life than even predatory credit card companies would offer - would be much better off if they could not get socially sanctioned debt that no private lender would touch for all-inclusive-housing. And I am convinced that the Universities would be far more functional places if there wasn't an endless flow of debt financed money for make-work to juice the rankings.

Are there non-debt related issues? Of course. But socially sanctioned debt drives many, many educational pathologies - lost years of earning for blue collar workers, treble-priced consumption on the top end, inefficient university operation from rank chasing with unquestioned income streams, political dynamics from the embittered core of threatened administrators/long term student debtors.

I bundle these particular complaints because they are all driven or worsened by the free availability of socially sanctioned debt.

Are there other troubles? Of course. Every so often I find somebody whose debt aversions tank their careers in wildly inefficient means (e.g. they cheap out medical school housing and burn class rank/study efficiency on lost sleep/inefficient commutes and then suffer millions in lost lifetime earnings when they just barely miss the cuts for competitive specialties in the Match). But debt is at least the fuel for the fire for a huge number of common failure modes.

Could we add enough epicycles to make these problems manageable for each demographic with their own idiosyncratic needs? Maybe.

But it seems like a lot when we could just turn down the loan spigot and restore the price signals to some of their normal functions. Stop making student debt "good debt" and a lot of these things really would get better in my estimation.

Respond

"The waste is not just the net distribution of funds out of the exchequer - it is the marginal increase in idle years outside the workforce for large numbers of workers, it is the life decisions made to conform to the diktats of decades of debt service, it is the class of workers willed into existance as status chasing universities extract rents to cover the administrative empires."

these are plausible yet difficult-to-quantify costs of student loans. yet note that alex didn't write his post about any of these

however, i personally think you are a bit too pessimistic. the college wage premium has declined in the last few years, but is still around 80% (https://www.ft.com/content/54cf40cd-149f-40db-b603-21aecd5f66ec), and causal estimates of the earnings effects among marginal students are high (https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/141/1/429/8376650)

Respond

2 in 5 borrowers don't enjoy the premium. A system which kinda works for 3 in 5 but results in upward rent transfers from 2 in 5 isn't exactly a wonderful program for me.

And with even small numbers of the educated doing counterproductive work (e.g. like many education bureaucrats I know), this quickly tips into a policy that is net harmful even if we take the losses incurred by the bottom as equal weight to the gains accrued to the top.

And, of course, the bigger point is not that this is a question of colleges vs no colleges ... but about socialized loans vs private loans. The bulk of the winners will still be able to get degrees. But even some small steps towards sanity on the other side will limit a lot of the pathologies from folks having misaligned incentives.

Ideally, we'd have the colleges fronting the costs and allowing payment over the following decade. If a college sucks, it goes broke, and gets replaced by someone better.

But right now the loans create perverse incentives and obscure price signals. Nothing good comes from that.

Respond

These are all complaints about college generally, not government loan programs for college. As an undergrad-is-credentials-and-signaling believer, I would agree that the system is inefficient and could in principle do the same thing in less time. But if the point is basically credentials and signaling that sort who gets to be a doctor/ibanker and who doesn't, it is crucial that people find the credential to be legitimate, and a past complaint has been that college is unaffordable and for the wealthy people only. All the social engineering in terms of loans, financial aid, diversity etc are intended to defeat these narratives and they do a pretty good job, it's much more rare to hear "your degree from the elite school (or any school) doesn't mean more than Big State U (or HS), it's just that you paid a ton of money because you're a cake eating rich kid" these days. And maybe it did something on the margin to decrease real wealth/class educational/cultural disparities as well in addition to the psychology.

Respond

Meanwhile we're spending $1 Billion a day to escort Oil out of the Persian Gulf...

Respond

The U.S. is spending over $5 billion a day in debt service. One of the great benefits of tax cuts without matching spending cuts.

Respond

If you go back to the year 2000, when the budget was balanced, and grow both spending and tax collections at inflation plus growth in the population guess what you find? 2026 tax collections are higher than 2000. 2026 spending is just absurdly higher. It's more than 100% a spending problem.

Respond

The guy at link does a nice analysis of student loans and repayments including inflation effects. Excluding the covid years taxpayers subsidize about $.70 out of every $100 loaned.

https://thecollegeinvestor.com/39673/does-the-government-profit-off-of-student-loans/

As to the program I guess it's better than nothing but I think I would rather have it based on the repayment of loans. If all of a school's students are making lots of money but many are defaulting it will cost the taxpayer. If students are going into lower paying jobs but they are repaying their loans I am not sure why I should care that much. (IIRC we had such a program but it was rescinded as it was hurting the for-profit and HBCUs too much.)

Steve

Respond

Bog-standard consumer protection. These schools are selling a product (to minors, no less) that's objectively harmful.

Respond

Couldn't existing lemon laws be applied to this? The manufacturer of the defective product should be required to issue the refunds

Respond

Mostly, it's to fully legal adults and their parents.

Respond

Nah, decision about college happen during the first year of senior year of high school - admission commitments are well underway by January when the median kid turns 18. Even if with a traditional deadlines in March, you are talking about 25% making their commitments as minors.

And it would be one thing if you could easily renege and face no penalty by changing course in April or whatever day the kid turns 18 ... but we know that's a farce. People who take gap years without a lot of scaffolding face all manner of scrutiny and it is generally assumed that if you bailed on college for a year there is higher odds you will do it again later.

We've made college a high stakes affair with the actual decision points for students rolling back well into their minorities.

And maybe that's fine. Maybe we should let the market discipline universities and find an equilibrium where young adults can renegotiate without permanent statistical reduction of expected lifetime remuneration.

But then get the Feds out. Because right now the FAFSA is filed by a supermajority of minors. The early decision and early stuff is all decided before kids become legal adults.

And it isn't helpful for the bureaucracy to diminish the salience of price signals and prop up a decision structure that pushes a lot of commitment into minority and then say "meh everyone was an adult".

Respond

Okay. 17-yr olds and their parents, none of whom are legally obligated to spend a dime on college. Maybe the legal age of majority is too low.

Respond

But what you seem to be complaining about here applies to only a tiny minority of undergraduates - those applying to competitive 4-year colleges and these are the ones playing early-admission games. And for the most part, this is the exactly population whose parents are most deeply involved in (taking charge of) college planning...

For the most part, undergraduate schools are relatively non-competitive in admissions, admit students in a relatively wide age range and have relatively flexible deadline / commitment points. Their students take on relatively low debt. The median is ca $20K - that's definitely real money. But it's also in the same range as a note on a decent used card.

There may well be too many students attending college and getting a relatively useless education, relative to better vocational training.

The availability of grants and loans has almost certainly contributed to increase in price, without a corresponding increase in quality or value.

Absolutely there are problems. But "tricking unsuspecting children into massive financial committment" is not one of them.....

Respond

Fully agree. I'm on my third kid going through all this right now.
And I want prices to come down all around, or just stop charging parents based on what they make. Give everyone the same reasonable price you commies!

Respond
Continue this thread →

AG:
Yeah but humans are a social species. And when you use the law and government resources to put a fat finger on the scales towards some behavior you really should be certain that it is not harmful. If the FDA approved a medicine that left 39% of patients *significantly* worse off, the package insert would come with multiple black box warnings and the threat of jail time if anyone even thought about prescribing it to the general population.

You want to play the free to not spend a dime card? Fine. Get the government out of the business then.

Marie:
Social norms diffuse out from both the top and the bottom. If the top 3% of kids all make their decisions about college in December, odds are pretty good that the kids in the 94-97th centiles also make similar decisions. And the game proceeds downward.

Legally or whatever, fine people can wait until September to commit to community colleges. But if you want FAFSA condtional money you need to commit to the paperwork a year prior in most cases. If you want to coordinate with friends, romantic interests, or other students. Again the decision process is earlier.

De facto, colleges have kids make decisions in the Fall of Senior year. Those decisions have real impacts and folks bucking the system for late decisions pay a variety of prices. Some are social (the other kids think your are weird). Some are psychic (you stress for longer). Some are monetary and some are academic.

Reality is we have most kids make most of their college decisions when most of them are still minors. That may not be the law, but it is the society that law helped shape.

Respond

I haven't looked into it, but that number does not come anywhere close to passing the smell test. I would guess that's not including any number of factors, including the time value of money.

Respond

Defaults don't change much because student loan debt is non-dischargeable. It is the government subsidies (income-based repayment) that costs us.

Respond

Are these number correct? I assume the GOA numbers are correct, but if in the past 30 years the government lent $197B, how is the outstanding student loan debt now around $1.2T. Ballooning balances I guess. Which is a sign of a problem somewhere.

Respond

Roughly 25% ($234 billion) of the federal portfolio remains in default.

Respond

i've definitely gotten some plausible positive spillover from masseuses

Respond

ugh checked the original post and of course someone made that joke

Respond

This sounds so much like Marc Reisner's Cadillac Desert. Reisner is a good lefty environmentalist and he details how the federal government built lots of dams, with an initial promise that they would pay for themselves, because the people who benefited from them would pay off the borrowing. But the beneficiaries soon cried that they couldn't pay (because the benefits had been overstated) and the feds kept forgiving more and more.

Respond

The lesson being " benefits had been overstated". We should apply that to dam removal projects as well.

Respond

Know a kid graduating with an MSW from Columbia and decided to see what admissions rate was. Well, a whopping 75% and no standardized test requirements. Think that says it all. Good news for Columbia is that this kid's parents are very wealthy so full pay of tuition, etc a drop in the bucket for them. They happy with the kid getting an Ivy League degree!

Respond

In his latest Free Press column, TC contemplates a future where “the machines have taken care of both the basic functions of life and certain higher aims such as scientific research.” Are humans still doing mechanical engineering in that world? If yes, then TC's vision of the future isn't very realistic. If no, then AT's presumption of which college degrees have, or don't have, plausible positive spillovers isn't very realistic.

Respond

Yes, but also don't forget the possibility that both of their views are unrealistic.

Respond

Has anyone done a cost-benefit analysis on this regulation? Most of the loans and degrees awarded are at the undergraduate level, but most of the problematic degrees are at the graduate level. I can easily imagine that we will spend more meeting the compliance regulations for this policy than we will save in aggregate. These kinds of policies inevitably lead to additional administrative staff to do the bean counting which will then make college more expensive.

Respond

"These kinds of policies inevitably lead to additional administrative staff to do the bean counting "

Is the sensible approach is to do the bean counting once and cut the programs that fail? Given the current enrollment outlook...

Respond

If degree programs were static, then sure. But, they aren’t. The textile degree turns into material science. CompSci saw an enrollment drop and now we have a data science degree and an AI degree. Then degrees get merged and split apart. The secondary ed degree turned into about half a dozen different degrees (science ed, english/reading, social studies, etc…) then merged back with different tracks as license rules change.

Respond

There's a small grain of truth to that most of what you're referring to is rebranding in hopes of selling the SOS. If there's no demand for "textiles" then most of the courses will also have no demand. To the degree that "textiles" is really "materials science" - and not just rebranding "textiles" - then move the few relevant courses into materials science and shitcan the rest. Problem solved.

In the end you have to conform your course offerings to workplace demand.

Respond

Change the system so that the federal government only guarantees half the loan. States, the private sector, or the university are then on the hook for the rest. And make the fed's half of the debt senior in a bankruptcy, but allow student debt to be retired in bankruptcy 10 years after the loan is issued.

Respond

Undergraduate lending is already capped well below the annual tuition cost of private colleges.

The biggest issue is grad school, where the “full need”- ie, tuition + rent + living expenses can be borrowed.

Basically go to law school or grad school/PhD in liberal arts(or whatever) and the taxpayer pays all of your living expenses for years.

And then when you graduate you can either opt for income-based repayment or go for the “public interest” option- get a job in government or at an NGO and after 10 years of paying the minimum your loan is forgiven.

Effectively the taxpayer is funding the NGO pipeline, excess masters and PhD degrees, all of those MFA and Masters in education programs and those bottom tier law schools and PhD programs (the ones who don’t provide feee tuition and stipends for top students out of their research grants and endowment).

Respond

The big problem in undergraduate are the folks suckered into non-selective colleges who do not complete a degree. That's 39% of borrowers.

We have people wasting years of their productive working life, incurring debt, and having less than nothing to show for it.

Student loans drastically diminish the saliency of price signals and misalign incentives - community colleges and like non-selective options have basically all the incentive in the world to enroll students, basically none to not enroll them, and the kids making the decisions their senior year have a giant neon sign saying they should ignore the costs - we will lend without a worry because, of course, you will come out ahead.

The real tragedy in higher education is not the money that the gets written on the checks - it is the wasted time, the delayed functional adulthood, and the tarring people with "failure" because we don't want to confront the inherent inequalties between people in a forthright manner.

Respond

>fter 10 years of paying the minimum your loan is forgiven.

[McMahon Reaction #1] that "minimum payment" is way below amortization; it's capped at 10% of your "discretionary income" (i.e., after housing, food, and transportation), regardless of how much you borrowed.

[McMahon Reaction #2] it's only ~8 years for the COVID class. The government waived those two years of minimum payments.

[McMahon Reaction #3] PSLF forgiveness is tax free... unlike every other kind of debt forgiveness

[McMahon Reaction #4] government workers make about 125% more than equivalent private sector + have better benefits.

Respond

Comparison of government workers compensation to "equivalent private sector" surely needs to be broken out by sector? Absolutely untrue in my experience, transitioning from HHS to the private sector, and for the majority of my former colleagues. Likely more true for less senior and less skilled government employees? Potentially technically accurate for me as a lawyer, but only to the extent that we pretend that the alternative to my government role was the median lawyer income, and not the income offered for the actual jobs available to me given my skills and experience. The moral dilemma for me and many colleagues is how to give up the golden handcuffs of the private sector to return to public service in federal government. A state government salary would be a 300-400% pay cut, which is sadly off the table until my kids are grown. Sorry but I get so sick of right-wing complaints about the low quality of government bureaucrats while simultaneously complaining about how overpaid they are.

Respond

Definitely needs to be broken out. Military docs, for instance, get paid less than their civilian counterparts and absent the loan forgiveness programs, we would need a lot more incentives to get enough surgeons and what not to staff the military hospitals.

On the other hand, Doge provided us with a nice real world experiment. A bunch of senior bureaucrats within the government were tossed out of places like USAID. The ones I know personally were near uniformly unable to arrange comparable salaries and work conditions in the private sector - even if they were hired by an NGO. The ones in the news stories were even more drastic in salary reductions.

And Doge has the advantage that these transitions were unplanned so we aren't seeing things like folks cashing in via regulatory capture, too much selection of effort or whatnot, or even different goals among career switchers.

As somebody who straddles both worlds and is deeply involved in administration in both, I think the government side (and my you my direct experience is disaster response folks and the Guard/Reserves) is that there are too many, too unqualified, and too ideological of administrators. Like my hospital system is a byzantine mess of conflicting authorities and misaligned missions with little internal consistency ... but somehow my dealings with BUMED have involved even more paperwork and wasted time.

I often wonder if the too many chiefs, not enough braves, mentality in the government creates inefficiency spirals where folks looking for a sinecure come in and eventually drive out the folks actually doing the mission. Like if I am going to have to put up with petty empire builders, I may as well get paid well for it.

Respond

You need to think rank-and-file. The modal government job is probably elementary school teacher, where the public school ones make considerably more than the private school ones.

The public schools normally argue that pay gap is OK b/c their early elementary teachers tend have PHD's. Now, why that degree is useful for teaching fractions to 8 yro's remains unknowable.

Respond

Whatever happened to the concept that education is a good thing? That a good education makes for a better person and a better citizen? Alex seems to be advocating that college become a glorified trade school.

I don't disagree that a lot of useless programs exist -- basketweaving and the like. I would crack down on these private and on-line schools that are financed by persuading students to take out school loans.

With AI rushing upon us, I wonder if statistics, mathematics, and a number of other scientific and technical college majors will become just as dead-end career-wise as a degree in basketweaving. Will the hardliners want to excuse the debt for a student who can't find employment in his chosen field of statistics -- but favor punishing a student who majored in basketweaving and can't find a job.

Respond

"Whatever happened to the concept that education is a good thing? That a good education makes for a better person and a better citizen? "
The sort of education operative when that was commonly believed was dutifully killed by the leftward shift of the faculty. Finding a pre-medical or pre-law student who can read Latin and have facility with the canon that people believed underpinned those sentiments is almost impossible. I routinely meet bright young medical students who have majored in everything - philosophy, literature, biology, mathematics, or environmental science - and I cannot recall the last one who had read any Locke, Cicero, Voltaire, Calvin, Augustine, or Aquinas. It is increasingly hard to find ones who have read Paine, Jay, Madison, Henry, Edwards, Witherspoon, Clay, Lincoln, or Roosevelt (either) - and even the revival of Hamilton from the musical is petering out.

A big part of why education was thought to make better citizens is that they read the source materials of the guys who designed the civics that govern the country. But now? I get folks who read Robin DeAngelo, Nikole Hannah-Jones, or maybe Thomas Picketty if they are extremely well read.

A lot of people view "education" as little more than indoctrination. Having had to coach residents through the fundamentals of government (e.g. what is legally required for court ordered medical treatment and why), mathematics (e.g. what sorts of functions have inflection points), religion (e.g. why are Historically Black Protestants opposed to abortion), and a host of other topics I just don't see modern education leading to the sorts of knowledge and skills that make people "better" on most metrics.

Making so, so much of modern education about introspection and the critiques of the moment has drastically shifted what people come out knowing and believing. And the majority of Americans no longer buy that spending years learning labeling schema, polemicizing against outgroups, or massaging the mental health allowance system actually improves all that much in life.

The more academia becomes a one-party preserve of Leftwing orthodoxy, the less folks trust that it betters people.

Respond

"Whatever happened to the concept that education is a good thing? "

Progressivism. It turned "education" into a system of political patronage, indoctrination, and diploma mills.

Respond

Why not just price controls? They decrease supply. Don't we want to decrease the supply of $400,000 art history degrees? Have the government cap the amount it will loan to anyone and have colleges figure out how to make it happen for less. Maybe index the cap to inflation.

Respond

>student’s small income-driven payments for ten years, and the taxpayer forgives the rest.

Yea, the current student loan system is incredibly generous, amazingly so. Unfortunately, we no longer live in the kind of high-trust society such a generous program requires, and thus, it gets looted by grifters like @Georgetown Law.

Fraud, it's not just in MN.

Respond

Does this new rule take into account each particular college or does it look at everyone with that degree? For example, for say bachelors in music, is a Julliard degree grouped in with degrees from third rate state schools, or does the rule take into account the higher pay that Julliard music bachelors grads command?

Respond

Easy student loans cause schools to raise prices. To get more profit they need more students. So they improve, dorms, sports facilities, but not necessarily education.

I agree that a student loan has to show that it is a reasonable investment not just a way to finance an extension of chilhood.

Respond

Alex Tabarrok: just another boring Republican talking head. Yawn.

Respond

From a public choice point of view, warnings like the following should always accompany AT’s parables:

From a public choice perspective, the funding structure of Mercatus demonstrates how concentrated private interests engage in ideological rent-seeking to capture public university infrastructure for private benefit. Wealthy philanthropists and corporate donors systematically invest in proprietary graduate pipelines to extract "academic rents," effectively purchasing the institutional prestige, tax exemptions, and intellectual legitimacy of a state school. By exploiting the rational ignorance of the broader public, these donors bypass traditional academic oversight to install curated faculty and students who manufacture specialized intellectual capital. This targeted philanthropy operates as an elite, subsidized form of lobbying. Instead of producing neutral public goods, it intentionally shifts the intellectual supply curve to generate policy outcomes and regulatory rollbacks that directly protect the donors' private economic interests.

Respond

"Not surprisingly, the law schools have proven adept at using Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) to rip off the taxpayer. The school raises tuition [citation needed], then covers the student’s small income-driven payments for ten years..." Are we really supposed to accept a rando tweet as support for the assertion that PSLF is a meaningful contributor to increases in law school tuition? Seems like Alex might learn a thing or two from this guy: https://www.libertarianism.org/podcasts/building-tomorrow/prices-are-too-damn-high-with-alexander-tabarrok

I'm also struggling to understand why lawyers who forego lucrative private sector salaries in order to work in public service are "ripping off" taxpayers. Isn't funding for public services what taxes are for? A critique of the trade-offs involved, suggestions for better targeting, etc. could be helpful, but to characterize the whole thing as a rip-off is pure mood-affiliated flame-throwing.

Respond

Reminder that Trump paid $25M in fines for conning Trump U students.

Respond

Sounds like a step in the right direction, although ending all loans and subsidies for private colleges and universities and focusing on subsidized public education still seems like the right direction.

By the way, aren’t we supposed to be getting an all online university of the United States from the Trump administration? Where are we on that?

Respond

Not sure why you think that Public education is prederable to private. I believe that public and private schools have similar costs to educate students. The only reason they charge less than private schools is because state taxpayers are making up the difference in costs between it and the privte school. So taxpayers all the same, just a more local set.

Respond

This is the sort of nanny-state bullshit policy that you would almost certainly criticize if it were proposed by another source

Respond

College students who were in the most productive programs, such as computer engineering, are now hell-bent on destroying humanity and the global economy. Now is that the better choice for subsidizing a college education? Did I mention that Meta and the other AI companies have claimed tens of billions in "research" tax credits for the cost of the data centers. So should we subsidize the creative minds studying accounting, or just supply them with sharp pencils?

Respond

Oh Ray, never change.

Respond

Seems to me the public gets a pretty good deal on music teachers, all things considered.

Respond
Respond

Add Comment