Post

Conversation

I read the paper, the Times article back when it came out, and I understand the reference perfectly well. That doesn’t make it above criticism. I think it’s gratuitous here. There are real problems with choosing to describe family relationships and women’s reproductive decisions in those terms, and pointing me back to Becker doesn't address it. Especially if, as you claim, you hope your research will lead to better and more conversations between families then yes you of course shoulder some responsibility for the rhetoric you choose to deploy as you push these ideas forward. I would offer that you do not respond to your (predominately but not exclusively) female critics with suggestions that they must just be ignorant about economics or whatever it is
Quote
Matthew E. Kahn
@mattkahn1966
Have you read our paper? The Nobel Laureate Gary Becker introduced "The Rotten Kid Theorem" 30 years ago. Our paper is written for academic economists and our paper extends his ideas. Would you like to interview us for your journal? (1/3)
Quote
Rachel Cohen Booth
@rcobooth
this is weird and not funny, you should not have called it this
Amitav Krishna
Post your reply

I'm surprised why they chose to use that terminology. Becker's context is quite different (but one could also argue that perhaps there is no need for those words, and the theory could be renamed. Without knowing the paper, rotten kid can be interpreted in so many ways)
Real problems because it’s not moral to think of it like this or because it is not true? Why don’t you argue why you think the theory is WRONG? This is not an emotional debate: it is a rational, argumentative one. Trying to shame authors based on smth you don’t like is stupid.
Jesus christ maybe crawl out of your own asshole for a breath of air > you shouldn’t have called it that This is a clear accusation and makes it obvious that you *were* ignorant of the academic context - they weren’t the ones to call it that! Their response was perfectly
“Real problems describing.., in those terms” Ie you hate reality and want to be coddled.

Trending now