Skip to main content My son (4yo) thought eating people was ok : r/slatestarcodex

My son (4yo) thought eating people was ok

My son is 4. Tonight I was explaining cattle farming to him, and that some people choose not to eat meat for ethical reasons, basically vegetarianism.

He thought about it and suggested that we could just wait for a cow to die naturally before eating it, so nobody has to kill it. Fair enough, pretty reasonable.

Then he said, "Oh, I have an idea: when a person is old, we can wait until they die and then eat them."

He's 4, so it came out a bit garbled, and at first I thought he'd misspoken. He repeated it twice. I asked what he meant, and we both got confused. He was confused about why I was confused. Eventually I understood: he genuinely thought eating people was normal.

I said, "But you know we eat the meat of animals, right?" He said, "Yes, but I thought both. People and animals."

I told him we don't eat people. He asked "why?" many times, and I did my best to explain the taboo.

What surprised me is that I had always assumed the cannibalism taboo was something that arises spontaneously, some innate revulsion. Apparently is not, at least not for my son.

Honestly, I was shocked and I felt really unsettled. I felt at the same time the need to share this with someone, and also the need to NOT tell this to people he is close with: I am not sure about telling this to his mother (my wife). On the other hand, I am pretty sure we will laugh about it once he grows up (if he doesnt end up being a cannibal, that is).

I hope you people enjoy this anecdote.


Join the conversation
Best
Open comment sort options

Comments Section

If it makes you feel any better, "saying weird morbid things about death and dead people" is an extremely common developmental thing that often happens around age 4. If you interact with a lot of four year olds, you'll hear lots of stuff like this. Before that age, they don't really have the concept of being dead at all, and then part of how they learn about death and incorporate it into their understanding of things is by testing out ideas and learning how people react. I expect he would not actually want to eat a human corpse if he saw one (or an animal corpse that hadn't been prepared to look like food for that matter)

People no longer tell fairy tales to children, this is the result.

When I was 4, I knew very well that only wolves and monsters eat people.

People no longer tell fairy tales to children

Yeah, like Hansel and Gretel.

I think he is less confused than you. You had already agreed that waiting until death makes it okay morally. "People are different than animals" is a terrible argument for any moral question. First, because "people" is the claim of difference in itself, so you are begging the question. And second, because even that claim of difference is not necessarily relevant.

Suppose your son said, "Maybe we should not torture animals." Would you argue, "Oh, except for people, because people and animals are different"? The claim of difference is debatable itself; and even if that claim were true, it wouldn't follow that any particular moral rule is different between them, or which direction the difference would go if it were. Maybe we should eat only humans after they die. Maybe cows deserve more dignity because humans should only make choices for humans. Nothing about "people" tells us.

In any case, the true answer is probably prion disease, not a moral rule.

This is my take on it too. The hypothetical cow and the hypothetical human both died of something, I may or may not know what it was. I'm also a human, and things that can kill humans can kill me. So eating the human is more likely to kill me than eating the cow. So purely from a self-preservation standpoint, an aversion to cannibalism makes sense. However, if starvation is more likely to kill me than whatever killed them, it makes sense to bend that rule.

You've lost touch with your common sense mate, too much time trying to be intellectual on online forums

Why? What common sense did i miss?

r/humanitarianism is the best way to lower your carbon footprint.

Too many like this in this sub 😂

ZOMG! Can't we just let kids have hobbies without using it to drum up controversy on Reddit?

Hobbies? Controversies? Are you making a joke?

>Honestly, I was shocked and I felt really unsettled.
why though? isnt this a very common type of moral error in kids? if it even is a moral error and not just cultural.

Of course it is lol. They have no grasp of complex morals and consequence at that age…

I was unaware of that and I am still unsure it is a common error

kids at that age basically dont have a moral sense. many probably never think about cannibalism at that point, but generally understanding some cultural taboo they never heard of is like five steps ahead of the obedience/punishment and instrumental "morality" of very young kids.
Don't you frequently encounter the fact the kid has a childlike pre-morality?

This should be an amusing story to tell people when he grows up, not something to get your knickers in a twist about.

>taboo

How did you explain it? What exactly did you cover?

This whole thing was a small chat as he was in the bed getting ready to fall asleep so we didnt cover much. I told him that we dont eat people. He asked me why. I said I personally feel a sense of disgust, and most people do, and i asked him whether he feels that. He obviously said no. I just say that for me is a sense of disgust that i just feel and cant explain, and that it's not nice to treat people as food. That's as good as an explanation i could come up with on the spot

I see. It would greatly benefit both of you to explore this once he’s a bit more grown. Especially the social contract aspect of it because it’ll apply to other “moral absolutes” too. My mum’s in her 60s and we’ve talked about it fairly recently? Despite her conservatism she’s a curious bird, and we agreed it’s just generally counterproductive for various reasons you can read on Wikipedia.

Your son is going to love Stranger in a Strange Land in a few years.

Make sure to get the unabridged version. In Jill and Ben's early discussion of real vs. syntho steak: "If you stick a fork in it, it will turn imploring eyes on you" vs. "If you stick a fork in it, it will moo."

"If you stick a fork in it, it will turn imploring eyes on you"

And on that subject, make sure to add The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy to the reading list.

I mean it's an actual fair point. He might as well have asked "Why about dogs and cats? We surely eat them as well?" - and you could tell him how we've made this arbitrary system where we've decide which animals it's okay to harm, hurt, torture, rape, and then slaugther to eat their corpse - based on their perceived cuteness and whether we've domesticated them as pets.

I will add a data point and say I'm pretty sure I had to be taught that cannibalism is wrong. That being said, just because there was a time when I wasn't aware of that as an abstract principle, doesn't mean that I wouldn't have been revulsed if I actually witnessed cannibalism.

Interesting thanks

Plenty of cultures around the world at various points in time had no "westernized" taboo around cannibalism. Plenty of wild animals also practice cannibalism for very simple and logical reasons. And yes, "people" being "animals" likely played a role in his "confusion" but it's certainly nothing for a 4 year old to be ashamed of asking about. Tell your wife btw.

Yeah I will. I obviously didnt shame him at all, actually he was about to go to sleep otherwise i would have talked more with him about all this

I think it is somewhat innate, but might develop later in life. Young children are pretty egotistical, maybe once you start to see others as individuals then cannibalism becomes more repulsive.

Is there any evidence it's innate?

I strongly doubt its innate, given plenty of cultures around the world simply never developed the taboo. Cannibalism was banned in Papua New Guinea in the 1960s.

Not innate to me, either. Obviously the idea of hastening someone's demise to eat them is abhorrent, but once someone's dead they're dead, might as well eat them, on a fundamental level I don't get what the big deal is about.

When I'm dead I want people to just throw me in the trash.

Edited

I do agree about the trash part and I am also pretty immune to the whole sacred body idea - but for me, eating people is indeed a taboo - i simply find it disgusting to a visceral level, and I never have questioned it. But it is possible that this disgust was learnt.

One of the things my wife told me during medical school is that dissecting cadavers made her crave meat. This grossed her out, but only in a meta way, like it was gross that she wasn’t grossed out by the suggestion of humans-as-meat. I suspect both the people who say they are revolted by cannibalism and people who say they aren’t might be surprised when confronted with it (or, more realistically, a close proxy for it) more viscerally.

Wow thanks for sharing that. Was she craving meat while carving it? Was she craving animal meat, human meat, or just more generally any meat?

Edited

Meat in general, which expressed itself as wanting animal meat. I don’t think she could have craved human meat specifically, having never had it. I think it was mostly that the human muscles looked and felt like raw meat, and the “but this is a human!” counter-signal wasn’t strong enough to override that. Like a human thigh muscle triggers an emotional response for “hunk of meat” and not just “part of a human”

Edit: and yes, I think the cutting was part of it, since it’s not so different from carving meat

This made me think i have never craved meat in my life. I eat it, but i dont care for it.

dissecting cadavers made her crave meat

That's unusual. I had zero interest in roast beef for probably the first month of gross anatomy, and I'm very carnivorous by nature.

Right so that’s sort of my point: I don’t think people really know how they’ll react to stuff like this until it’s in front of them. I’d like to think I would compartmentalize and neither find a cadaver appetizing nor revolting, but having never dissected something bigger than a fetal pig, I have no idea.

The interesting thing about a 4yo is that they have no conditioning about what their reaction to cannibalism is supposed to be, in addition to their not knowing what it would be in reality.

Worldwide, drinking the blood of an enemy or eating the heart of an enemy was very widespread, but not universal.

If I ever need an amputation that's not a result of disease/infection, I have every intention of asking for a piece to take home and cook. Just kinda curious, and I feel like that's the one way to do it that negates all the possible ethical issues. (Also, I am aware that this is an exceptionally unlikely scenario .)

Well, it was indeed enjoyable. Thanks you for sharing. On personal note, as aspie child i was quite confused why people are shocked when humans die movies but not so much when other kind of animal is killed/is hunted. I guess that somewhere deep inside i still am, hence as I can make such choice I'm vegan :p

Yeah dude you’re freaking about nothing imo. Do you remember your specific thoughts on cannibalism when you were 4, 5, 6, 7? Your reasoning? Your influences? What is your reasoning against eating humans currently?

I think it’s just a socially learned thing, nothing innate about it. Think you’re just confusing your own socially learned beliefs with what is actually innate lol .

Killing other humans is generally ethically wrong, violating their right to life. But it’s wrong to eat a dead human? Why?

Historically things like diseases are a reason cannibalism is taboo - you can get prion-based diseases by eating human brains, there’s some tribe that was studied where this was found.

But yeah I am not sure why you think it’s okay to eat meat and not humans. You can say there’s something innate, but that statement means nothing to me if you don’t have any rationale.

He's making a modest proposal.

What surprised me is that I had always assumed the cannibalism taboo was something that arises spontaneously, some innate revulsion.

As far as we can tell cannibalism used to be pretty common in paleolithic times -

archaeological evidence of butchering marks on bone, and skull cups at several sites from the Lower Paleolithic to the Upper Paleolithic show evidence that cannibalism was not a culture taboo during this time. Evidence of cannibalism can be found at Homo heidelbergensis, Homo antecessor, Neanderthal, and Homo sapiens archaeological sites.

- https://paleoanthropologyy.blogspot.com/2022/10/cannibalism-from-lower-paleolithic-to.html

There is archaeological evidence that cannibalism has been practised for at least hundreds of thousands of years by early Homo sapiens and archaic hominins.[7] Some anthropologists, such as Tim D. White, suggest that cannibalism was common in human societies before the beginning of the Upper Paleolithic period. This theory is based on the large amount of "butchered human" bones found in Neanderthal and other Lower/Middle Paleolithic sites.[8]

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannibalism_in_Europe#Prehistory

You should probably work on intelligently parenting. If you cant handle the basic moral errors now, just wait until your teenager does something serious.

What made you conclude i can't handle it?

Also, you should practice intelligent commenting. Your comment was quite impolite and mildly upsetting.

Shame, maybe your ai peep wouldve said something nicer

Repost

Repost suggestions