Taxing Mechanical Engineers and Subsidizing Drama Majors

In The Student Loan Giveaway is Much Bigger Than You Think I argued that the Biden student loan plan would incentivize students to take on more debt and incentivize schools to raise tuition with most of the increased costs being passed on to taxpayers through generous income based repayment plans. Adam Looney at Brookings takes a deep dive into the IDR plan and concludes that it’s even worse than I thought. Here are some of Looney’s key points:

  • As recently as 2017, CBO projected that student loan borrowers would, on average, repay close to $1.11 per dollar they borrowed (including interest). Borrowing was often perceived to be the least favorable way to pay for college. But under the administration’s IDR proposal (and other regulatory changes), undergraduate borrowers who enroll in the plan might be expected to pay approximately $0.50 for each $1 borrowed—and some can reliably expect to pay zero. As a result, borrowing will be the best way to pay for college. If there’s a chance you’ll not need to repay all of the loan—and it’s likely that a majority of undergraduate students will be in that boat—it will be a financial no-brainer to take out the maximum student loan.
  • The data shows that roughly half of Americans with some college experience but not a BA would qualify for zero payments under the proposal, as would about 25% of BA graduates. However, the vast majority of students (including more than 80% of BA recipients) would qualify for reduced payments.
  •  [A] lot of student debt represents borrowing for living expenses, and thus a sizable share of the value of loans forgiven under the IDR proposal will be for such expenses…A graduate student at Columbia University can borrow $30,827 each year for living expenses, personal expenses, and other costs above and beyond how much they borrow for tuition. A significant number of those graduates can expect those borrowed amounts to be forgiven. That means that the federal government will pay twice as much to subsidize the rent of a Columbia graduate student than it will for a low-income individual under the Section 8 housing voucher program…

Looney agrees that the incentive to increase tuition will apply to some graduate and professional programs but he thinks there is less room to increase tuition at undergraduate programs because borrowing is capped (currently! AT) at fairly low rates. But he offers an even more plausible but disheartening scenario that takes us in exactly the wrong direction.

Because the IDR subsidy is based primarily on post-college earnings, programs that leave students without a degree or that don’t lead to a good job will get a larger subsidy. Students at good schools and high-return programs will be asked to repay their loans nearly in full. Want a free ride to college? You can have one, but only if you study cosmetology, liberal arts, or drama, preferably at a for-profit school. Want to be a nurse, an engineer, or major in computer science or math? You’ll have to pay full price (especially at the best programs in each field). This is a problem because most student outcomes—both bad and good—are highly predictable based on the quality, value, completion rate, and post-graduation earnings of the program attended. IDR can work if designed well, but this IDR imposed on the current U.S. system of higher education means programs and institutions with the worst outcomes and highest debts will accrue the largest subsidies.

Looney does a back of the envelope calculation and estimates that typical graduates in Mechanical Engineering will on average get a 0% subsidy but graduates in Music will get a 96% subsidy, in Drama a 99% subsidy and Masseuses a 100% subsidy on average. This of course is exactly the wrong approach. If we are going to subsidize, we should subsidize degrees with plausible positive spillovers not masseues.

The problem is not just the subsidy but the encouragement this gives to create low-value programs:

  • …institutions will have an incentive to create valueless programs and aggressively recruit students into those programs with promises they will be free under an IDR plan….The fact that a student can take a loan for living expenses (or even enroll in a program for purposes of taking out such a loan) makes the loan program easy to abuse. Some borrowers will use the loan system as an ATM, taking out student loans knowing they’ll qualify for forgiveness, and receiving the proceeds in cash, expecting not to repay the loan….I suspect that such abuses will be facilitated by predatory institutions.

Overall, the student loan program, as currently written, is looking to be one of the most costly, inefficient and unwise government programs of the 21st century. As I said in my first post, “fixing” the program is likely to drive ever more increasing intervention into higher education much as has happened with health care. My guess is that no one really thought this albatross through.

Comments

"likely to drive ever more increasing intervention into higher education much as has happened with health care. My guess is that no one really thought this albatross through." Your guess carries with it the assumption that the motivation is a good faith effort to fix problems for students. If you go in with the assumption that it is an attempt to keep the good times rolling for the instructors in these low-value-added programs, which instructors are reliable constituents of President Biden's party, it looks much more plausible that it has been 'thought through'

Multiple incentives here:
1) subsidize a core demographic (the not very bright person who has nevertheless found a niche in higher education employment)
2) subsidize the creation of the next generation of the Democratic party base: entitled

3) encourage people to take public-sector jobs;
4) off-the-books salary increase for those public sector employees.

The income based repayment (IPR) changes are the big giveaways here, not the $10K. And IPR is *much* more generous if you are a government worker.

In addition, government workers are paid with relatively low salaries but with generous benefits and extremely generous pensions. The income-based repayment plans will be based only on the low salaries.

Accidentally posted mid-writing.
Continued on 2)
..., Unthinking people who are incapable of scientific thought and champion using emotion rather than logic.

Once again, China is winning. The US is turning into next-gen Argentina. The decline is accelerating. Within twenty years, the world will be unipolar and that polar will be Mandarin.

I think you are spot on ...

... except for China, which is facing demographic collapse, which I am not going to explain.

The US will remain the sole planetary superpower because we are attracting, into a very good framework, people who like to work, f**k, and have kids.

Yup. And note the dissolution of blame, which is incredibly typical of Alex and other Dems. It isn't "Biden didn't think this through."

Instead it is "No one thought this through."

Hilarious!

This is just standard persuasion 101. Calling Biden and the other designers of this retarded policy out and saying he's evil or an idiot is not a great way to convince them to change their mind and would instead cause them to double down. This appears to be what a lot of pundits are doing when they take softball stances.

Is this a new field of persuasion? I distinctly remember every Trump policy being branded as “evil” and Trump’s name being mentioned every 2nd or 3rd sentence.

Strange. I guess the field of “persuasion” is evolving very rapidly.

Crediting policies personally to Trump but not Biden seems consistent with reality. Trump was undeniably the force behind a distinctive policy agenda. Biden just as clearly adopted a standard Democratic wishlist to get nominated, and there is good reason to doubt he has more than cursory involvement in any of the initiatives of his administration.

You don't actually think Biden came up with any part of this student loan plan, do you?

As for this blog supposedly calling all of Trump's policies evil, that's not really accurate.

"You don't actually think Biden came up with...this...do you?"

Classic Progressive politics - the elected leadership just blows sunshine while the unelected bureaucracy makes the actual rules, far out of public view.

"
FACT CHECK: FALSE! (PANTS ON FIRE!)
"I distinctly remember every Trump policy being branded as “evil”"

As for this blog supposedly calling all of Trump's policies evil, that's not really accurate.

In 2019 Marginal Revolution labeled Trump's immigration policy as 'wrong headed' not "Evil" as in the claim showing that the poster "Reason" is WRONG.

Further, analysis of all media reports on Trump showed that only 73% labeled his policies as "Evil".

Claim proven FALSE again!

Clearly, 'Reason' is dealing in misinformation and the FBI has been notified.
"

Found the poster who "works" at Snopes.

The comment was about "persuasion" techniques and pointed out the hypocrisy. The persuasion tactic used against a Biden policy vs the tactic used against a Trump policy. Whether it is a good policy doesn't matter.
It was the TACTIC used. If it's a good idea not to brand this Biden policy "evil" because that's the right way to persuade people .... Just maybe people should have followed that tactic when trying to persuade Trump????

If it weren't for double standards some people wouldn't have any standards at all.

Biden didn’t come up with it ; apparently it took a long time for his advisers to convince him.

My guess is he didn’t like the smell of it but did it for the sake of the Democratic Party.

Continue this thread →

> "it is an attempt to keep the good times rolling for the instructors in these low-value-added programs"

How many drama instructors are there, out there?

Would maybe make more sense to me to say that the policy was formulated by policymakers with worthless degrees, who are serving their own interests. (May also help their former instructors, as a side-effect.)

Make the schools that talked these students into worthless majors pay if the students cannot find jobs in that major.

"Nobody has thought this through"
Exactly. That is because it was pieced together in the dark by the inappropriate branch of government. The subject is not necessarily off limits, but any deliberation should have been undertaken elsewhere.
This was done to avoid that, and as such it is an abuse of power.

Hello, Never give up in life. They all say no cure to HSV 2 (genital herpes) which is a big lie. I have seen many people ignorantly say this and so i never believed there was really a cure to HERPES until I met Dr.Water, the doctor that have been helping many people for many years. I come across this doctor on facebook when I was searching for possible cures online. I found out about this man, and to my greatest surprise this man has the solution to my problem and even many other health problems people are going through out there, which some of us have been looking for, for many years. I explained my history of herpes problem to him through his email that I found on facebook. Dr.Water replied me and explain how the process works, so after i opted to give it a try. I placed an order for his herbal product. I got it delivered to me within 7 days and I took it according to the Doctor's instruction. I was so happy after few days of taking the medicine, there was very big change in my health and my blisters were all healing very fast. When I was done with the process, I went for a medical check up and I found out that i was now negative. That day i had tears of joy. And i took it upon myself to spread this good news anyway i can and share his contact details
Email> DRWATERHIVCURECENTRE©GMAIL.COM
You can as well help by rebroadcasting it to your social media handles, because some many people out there, especially in this part of the world, don't know about this cure and they are suffering a lot. These are some other treatnments that he is also specialized in treating:
Cancer,
Genital warts (Human papillomavirus, HPV)
Fibroid,
HIV,
Shingles,
Hepatitis,
Sclerosis,
Arthritis,
Asthma,
Frequent miscarriages,
Ulcer,
Infertility,
Chlamydia,
Premature ejaculation

Dave,
Do you know what the cap is for the loan forgiveness, or how the forgiveness is tied to total income.

Pants on fire for one time $10k loan forgiveness for those who qualify with incomes less than $125k.

Not even wrong.

So you can't deny or defend.
Got it.
Not even wrong.

Bill, he's letting you know that you didn't understand the article. It is not talking about the one time debt jubilee. It is talking about the Income-Driven Repayment plan that is part 3 of the announced executive policy and will affect new borrowers going forward, https://studentaid.gov/debt-relief-announcement/

I have spoken with leftists about this stuff many times. I have calmly explained that in every single kind of loan that exists, the lender takes on the risk, but in American student loans the lender is absolved of all risk and risk is instead placed on students, and disproportionately on students of color or students from a working class background. I have said that subsidizing loans like this takes money that could be used for social programs and in effect redistributes it to the financial sector. They have nodded and agreed with every logical step. But I've never converted a single one to the idea that student lending should incorporate some sort of ability-to-repay analysis based on the economic value of the specific degree being pursued.

In the end, they always say something like "are you saying that poor kids shouldn't be able to study the humanities?"

These people actually believe that studying things like drama is inherently valuable and makes you a better person. They assign great value to it that the market does not.

The idea that markets mis-value goods and services is a fundamental belief of the left. So they likely reject the premise that one type of degree is inherently more valuable than another. Especially if the value is derivative of market transactions like employment and income.

Also most of them are intellectually incapable of completing even the basic engineering coursework (omg math no I can't math!). Acknowledging that would be acknowledging their own intellectual limitations.

This part I actually don't think is true. I think they could learn basic engineer coursework, but they find it "boring". Obviously, drama, music, the classics, that shit is more fun than engineering.

On some level, I think a lot of these people just feel fundamentally entitled to having a nice life where they get to do fun things, and are unwilling to consider that is not where most of the important work that gives people a nice live where people can do fun things (some of the time) actually lies. In otherwise, they aspire, and feel entitled to be pseudo-nobility that gets to enjoy life at the expense of other people that does the hard work of making that life possible.

>I think they could learn basic engineer coursework

Maybe with treble the time spent by a typical decent engineering students. From my experiences peer editing papers and TAing writing intensive courses, the students in rigorous (read: math-y) majors are also on average better at writing than the students in writing focused majors.
Writing involves pattern recognition as it's basically sequencing characters into words and words into sentences. Someone who's bright enough to stick it out in electrical engineering is bright enough to write. This might not have been true when fewer marginal students were admitted to become lib arts/humanity majors, but it sure as hell is true now.

Yes, perhaps with more time. (Maybe not triple). But that's what you should do if you need to produce more people with engineering skills.
Actually ALL education should work like that, you need to align the skills people are learning to market demands, and if that means taking some people who are marginally slower at learning those skills, and giving them a bit more time, that is what you ought to do. It is more efficient then training a bunch of people in skills that nobody wants.

" I think they could learn basic engineer coursework, but they find it "boring"."

Once again, wrongness on an epic scale.

Especially if the value is derivative of market transactions like employment and income

IOW, getting a degree that leads to better economic prospects is seen by the progressives as "selling out." That filthy lucre taints everything it touches and therefore it's the moral imperative for the well-off to subsidize those who "eat out our substance."

Cite your sources on progressives "selling out" for getting a job. As a "progressive" with an economics degree who went to school with many with similar beliefs, I'm not sure where you're getting this idea from - outside of just making it up.

N=1

The market does "mis-value" things, people do, etc. But it is the best way to determine value. Humanities degrees are inherently valuable even if the market values them little. Simply knowing things, history, philosophy, literature, is valuable. But we have to be rational and allocate student loan dollars more carefully. It clearly makes little sense to emphasize high dollar humanities degrees over something like engineering or medicine. Especially at the federal level where arguably Manning site no other nation outcompetes us technologically would be the driver. Those federal dollars should be going to math and science, especially the applied kind.

*making sure no other nation...

There is some truth to the idea that markets mis-value goods and services, though. Markets value what consumers are willing and able to pay for, and there's often a divergence between what people value and what they actually pay for, sometimes driven by self-control issues. We've also poorly designed a number of incentive systems for jobs like teaching and nursing - it's hard to measure good teachers and nurses, and hard to compensate them for quality, even when good teachers and nurses can make a huge difference in outcomes.

Markets are constructs of human beings. And as such are subject to flaws in conception, structure and execution.

Still, they are the best available mechanism for coordinating the needs and desires of large groups of people.

Complaints of market misvaluation mostly boil down to a lament that they don’t cater to the preferences of the complainer. As Hazel alludes to above, its a form of narcissism that they fail to recognize my importance and preferences.

What about, like, junk food displays at checkout stands? I think most people would prefer that they not be there, and many only buy things from there in moments of weakness that they later regret. Markets don't differentiate between our long-term desires and short-term actions, even if those short-term actions are self-harming.

The problem is not that it's hard top measure good teachers and nurses. The problem is that the relevant unions don't allow measurements of teaches and nurses to affect their compensation.

-dk

The counter to "are you saying that poor kids shouldn't be able to study the humanities" is that if the lenders had more risk, the schools probably wouldn't charge as much for a drama degree. If a humanities BA could be had for $5k per year (which should really be possible), then it would be available even to a poor kid with limited employment opportunities with the degree. Schools have very little holding them back from charging ever higher tuition under the current arrangement.

The problem with countering such blather is that you can't.
You either LIE or you tell them "YES! Poor kids shouldn't study the humanities. It's a stupid idea for them. It's a consumer good. Poor kids shouldn't buy Lamborghini's either."

>If a humanities BA could be had for $5k per year (which should really be possible)

I visited my alma mater (a large land-grant university) for the first time in about 20 years. The amount of high-end amenities nowadays is both amazing and sad. I resolved to find a genuine "non-profit" for my donations.

The problem is that very few schools have different tuition rates for different undergrad programs. It would also make changing majors really complicated, and one of the benefits of the American system of education is that students can change majors as they discover their strengths and weaknesses.

Also, cheap humanities degrees would just lead to even more students studying the humanities. Even though the return on investment may be worse, people, especially 18 year olds, are terrible at making long-term investment decisions, especially when they involve debt and having to work hard. Cheap humanities degrees would just lead to even more people getting unnecessary degrees in drama and art history.

Re: "are you saying that poor kids shouldn't be able to study the humanities?"

Most poor kids should not borrow money to study humanities at most colleges. So, mostly, yes.

Yes, and "why does it take a formal paid-for degree to learn humanities?" is also a good answer.
You can learn humanities by reading, you don't need a professor to get you into a classroom and make you do homework assignments.

I mean, it's certainly possible to get an education by reading and watching lectures on YouTube, but most people don't have that kind of willpower and self-control. Part of the whole purpose of formal education is providing an incentive structure behind learning, forcing you to actually follow through with what you'd like to do. You can look at the completion rates for MOOCs for proof of that.

Also, getting feedback on your thoughts and arguments is an important part of learning humanities. Hard to do that without some sort of instructor.

"getting feedback on your thoughts and arguments is an important part of learning humanities"

That's what the internet is for. There are blogs and comment sections and so forth where you can go to write about whatever you want to write about and get responses from people who are interested in the same thing. And if you're talking about something like the humanities, you're probably looking at a smallish community that is full of people who have actually read the texts and many of them have received formal education, and they can point you at the right books to read and give you feedback and argue with you , for free!

You can chalk this up as most ironically un-ironic comment of the day.

It may be true right now that you can tap into communities, but that approach doesn't scale. Expecting random internet volunteers to be responsible for education might work for a few interested people, but that system can easily get clogged up. The incentives are also imperfect - if fellow commenters call your argument stupid, you can just leave, and you won't get better. Your professor calls your argument stupid, you better improve it or you won't pass.

It also doesn't satisfy the credentialing purpose of education. Getting a degree in English says that some university is endorsing your ability to write and think. (Whether they deserve that endorsing authority is a different discussion). You can't go up to a potential employer and say "trust me, I've cut my teeth in the Marginal Revolution comment section, and thus you should hire me."

@Colin C, what is the point of being credentialed in something that isn't in demand in the market?

The central point of this discussion is that we should not give loans to people to study fields where they are unlikely to find jobs. If humanities were an in-demand field, this wouldn't be an issue.

Continue this thread →

But you cannot get a credential from just reading on the internet. A piece of paper or an entry in a database that is certified by an institution that is respected. Without credentials, knowledge is useless these days. Even for the engineers, a BS is often not enough. Unless you are a wonderful inventor, you won't get the big bucks without at least an MS, or maybe a PhD. And if you want to stay in academia, the PhD is essential.

I thin the bigger problem of the cost is that the universities and the departments of grivance studies pay their profs too much, in order to keep them happy and not rioting on the quad. They cannot be paid significantly less than the petro profs, because that would make them feel really bad.

When I was in college (a state U with tuition (at the time) of $1250/semester), my high school friends borrowed money to attend community college. And bought guitars or drums or cars with the money (a really cool Gibson Explorer in one case - maybe more useful than some of the majors available these days). So, unless human nature has changed, some borrowers may be using the $ for stuff other than post-colonial analyses of Ukrainian literature.

It is drearier than either you or AT imagine. Majoring in drama? If only. No, they will all be majoring in "leadership". Education is free and now free of any ... education.

Now that we've seen how it'sall worked out: can we get the CCC back?

It's much simpler than that: A leftist with student loans will be stoked by getting a bunch of money, and will be very motivated to not think about this. Many an older democratic voter sees that the older setup was nonsense, and the new one isn't an improvement.

I suspect that there was a better ruleset that could be written, matching priorities of a far wider set of constituents. This one wouldn't pass the senate with 50, much less 60. But since anything regarding immigration, healthcare or education needs 60, we aren't going to see fair, consensus improvements, ever. Too many seats where giving a middle finger to the other side for electoral reasons is more important than good policy

"These people actually believe that studying things like drama is inherently valuable"

The science and engineering are the least liberal of all the academic disciplines. We can't fund that. Too many smart people.

The answer to that question is "no, I'm saying that we shouldn't LEND MONEY to poor students so they can study the humanities".

Also, studying the humanities is not something that requires spending a lot of money. You can go buy a used book on the classics and read it. You can go join a Shakespeare in the Park troupe. It does not require formal accreditation to learn and grow.

There are many how questions to ask in response: how many poor kids? How much of their time? How is the cost covered? How long does it go on until the value is assessed?

Most poor kids are disserved by spending their days studying the humanities. Certainly not all, and I know a few who benefited, but I am a double Ivy, so not encountering the median poor kid. But it is a luxury good to spend the bulk of one’s time studying material that has no foreseeable economic return, and thus a suboptimal pursuit for the vast majority of poor kids.

N for N’s sake is the definition of a luxury item.

Education has adopted the Soviet factory model of production, where the only thing that matters is the quantity of output and, to the extent necessary, quality shall be reduced to enable the quantity target to be hit.

Through the 50's and 60's, the soviets bragged annually about how their wheat yields had shattered records. Again. The US was posting impressive gains, but nothing like the soviets. It was, it seemed, a nod to centralized planning.

Then, in 1973, an opportunity, arose to sell the soviets some wheat. The US believed the growth in the USSR had been so spectacular that the soviets needed additional grain to feed livestock. And so, the US sold $1B in subsidized grain to the USSR on credit to try and open markets. But behind the scenes, the soviets had had dismal wheat outputs for decades, followed by a drought that nearly left the country in famine. They bought as much of the subsidized wheat as they could. The deal crashed wheat markets and caused some food prices to rise 30-80%. This was called the "great grain robbery"

In short, don't trust the soviets on any production numbers.

That didn't work because it was merely food. We can trust the products churned out by universities as it is easily determined whether they have a credential or not. The production numbers are sound!

Bad policy with huge long term collateral damage from the Biden administration. I’m shocked.

Now do defacto open borders.

“Two years of wide open borders seems to have had a negative impact on the nation. I’m starting to believe that no one thought this through.”

some masseuses do cause positive spillovers.

You are a very naughty boy.

This is such a good, but unsurprising, example of why markets vastly outperform government. One provides an incentive to do what works, and the other provides an incentive to maximize your need for assistance.

I’m starting to believe in the conspiracy theories that the current status quo requires more and more brainwashing via college in order to sustain itself. And that really is now the primary function of education, no matter the broader impact on the economy.

The Democratic party needs to funnel more people into expensive and useless liberal arts colleges, get them to take on debt, and then reward them by partially paying off that debt, so that they can be both obligated to support stupid policies and also brainwashed into believing nonsense (because a Nicaraguan immigrant working as a skilled mechanic is going to just look at you funny and wonder what the crazy gringo is saying if you start using terms like "Latinx".

No conspiracy necessary, it emergent order.

And reminiscent of the symbiotic relationship between the christian church and the imperial state in late antiquity. The state needed legitimacy provided by the new religion and so subsidized it. Which over the long term weakened the failing state structure, transferring wealth and power to the church.

That's probably why they support stuff like "Drama", they know it's really a degree in reading liberal propaganda, so of course they subsidize that.

That said, most of the brainwashing occurs in elementary and middle school history class. Computer science majors are not being brainwashed, kids are not being brainwashed in math class*, they're being brainwashed in history class by being taught that black slavery was a unique evil, MLK was a hero, pluralism is real, etc.

* at least back in my day, ie the 2000s. Apparently they are taught that 2+2=white supremacy now, but 20 years ago in the US south history class was an absolute dumpster fire. It was constantly about the evil of segregation, black slavery, and the Holocaust. This is all of the history that 99% of people will learn in their lives, and they are learning that white gentiles are evil when they don't let foreigners rule over them. That's the brainwashing.

When you give lazy, liberal women with a useless skill-set the keys to your civilization's cultural values, you get plans to subsidize the lifestyles of lazy, liberal women with useless skill sets.

At some point we need to stop viewing these issues as economic issues, and recognize the issues for what they are - the destructive feminization of society.

If we asked just about anyone from any culture at any point in human history what our biggest problem is today, it would be a no brainer. They’d be like “you should probably stop basing you’re entire society on the whims of teenage girls”

Lazy? I thought they were career obsessed so they dont want to make babies. Make up your mind.

Steve

What’s worse is that they then become “librarians”.

You know, if your so upset that there are so many women with useless skill sets, one might think you would be more supportive of efforts to convince women to become engineers and computer scientists.

"My guess is that no one really thought this albatross through"

No one other than those that believe college should be 100% taxpayer financed and government controlled, like K-12. Also, remember that the Green New Deal aims to provide "economic security for all who are unable or *unwilling* to work." This "albatross" actually seems to be a launching pad for both aims.

The real question is how such massive welfare can be enacted by executive fiat with no Congressional legislation.

Guaranteed student loans have generated awful incentives and rent-seeking from their inception. Why is the GMU Econ department just now noticing this?

Next, you'll tell me education is a private good!

Alex and Tyler have covered student loans on and off on this blog for more than a decade.

You can use the search box too, like I did. They have been notably quiet about guaranteed student loans and their horrible economics.

Why didn't Alex+Tyler+Brookings make this harsh criticism, when this policy was being proposed on the 2020 campaign trail and voters were being asked to render a choice? To quote Joe Biden's pledge from March 22, 2020: "we should forgive a minimum of $10,000/person of federal student loans, as proposed by Senator Warren and colleagues. Young people and other student debt holders bore the brunt of the last crisis. It shouldn't happen again." So, these policy changes were very predictable and are what Joe Biden pledged to do as a candidate.

Tyler's quote from the 2020 election season sums it up: “Yes I support [Warren for POTUS], but she has the worst proposed economic policies of any candidate in the adult lifetime of Tyler Cowen.”

It seems that Tyler+Alex have given the Democrats a rubber stamp approval, even on terrible policies, during elections.

One has to be a bit dumb to imagine this policy was anything but a desperate attempt to avoid a negative outcome come November.

I suspect Mechanical Engineers are a less reliable Democrat vote compared to drama majors.

If student loans need to be forgiven because the students were suckered into acquiring debt by unfillable promises, the solution would seem to necessarily entail some means of limiting future borrowing.

Perhaps that would mean curtailing the percentage of operating costs that can come from student loans (IIRC an institution can only rely of Sallie Mae for something like 90% of their budget, which makes military students highly coveted). Perhaps schools with high income based repayment percentages should be forced to give claw backs.

The fact that we are only talking about, most charitably, the moral imperative of helping current debtors suggests that this is simply not about improving any of the actual issues.

Looking at it through my preferred lens, does this help the educated class have more freedom of action in their lives, seems to fit the facts quite nicely. The powerful have a bunch of friends who are not obviously all that different, but who failed to land a good government/foundation/legacy media/parasitic DEI job. The powerful worry that if something happens to limit their hold on power (e.g. the Republicans somehow tackle the Augean Stables and more explicitly politicize federal civil service hiring, retail investors manage to win judgments against having their index fund voting rights used to diminish value through ES investment) they will be left with only the expensive price tag for their ticket to prosperity and respectability. Income based repayment then creates a backstop should they do poorly, but also ensures that people who might get rich in a manner that diminishes their clout still have to pay. And more generally, the very generous means testing ensures that "the rich" will not be overly advantaged so they are also safe from moral injury.

For most of history post-1789 a better predictor is not how the policy benefits the nation, the world, or the people, but how it helps the educated classes. This appears to be just another example.

Let me suggest a simpler lens: for all of history, a better predictor is not how a policy benefits the nation, the world, or the people, but how it benefits the governing class.

Subsidizing drama majors for (more and more and more and more) political theatre?

Factor in antifa or other extracurricular activities to see which baristas are involved. Flexible hours, fellow-travelers, caffeine a winning combo.

but Justin Trudeau. . . oh, wait. . .

"Well, it isn't as wasteful as a 20-year-long war" - The best argument that can be made in defense of student loan forgiveness???

A physicist/music professor I know once said college is like buying a small house in cost so in effect a second mortgage. I thought unless it comes down to the price of a car it is not worth the cost.

"Any healthy country is taxing big business ..." You can't tax big business except in a bookkeeping sense. The incidence of the tax always falls on customers, employees or shareholders.

Being a legal fiction that eats no doughnuts, a business can't reduce its consumption of doughnuts in response to an increase in tax. But customers, employees and shareholders will find themselves reducing consumption.

Your mom is a legal fiction.

I work as a CPA, my very progressive wife is a higher education consultant.

I have avoided reading about the Student Loan Forgiveness. I will find it all kinds of stupid. I have a difficult time learning not to share facts with the very progressive.

the truth will set you free

When I graduated from college in 1980, I owed a total of $500 in student debt. And that was after taking about 126 credit hours of classes. Why? Because tuition was reasonable, and I had a government subsidy (the GI Bill).

When I went to graduate school 20 years later, I finished with $30,000 in student debt (after only 30 credit hours of classes). And I just finished paying it off a couple of years ago. Why?

Good question. How did education—one of the most vital components of a well-functioning democracy—become something you have to spend the rest of your life paying for? We all benefit from an educated populace. How did we let it go from—to cite Eric Hoffer—an ideal to a business to a scam?

Let's not complain about what Biden's doing. Let's go to the root of the problem and get the cost of higher education back to where it should be.

"We all benefit from an educated populace."
Not necessarily. There is a societal benefit from having many educated professionals, but those professionals are paid in a way that is commensurate with their value to society. The benefit to society of your average history major is dubious. Please, don't take history for me; do it for yourself or don't do it at all.

This is much more true for university than for K-12 education. Basic literacy and numeracy are important in the labor force. Actual skills training beyond K-12 would also benefit society, and deserves some subsidy, but ask almost any professor (I am a professor) and they will tell you that "universities are not a job training center". Fine, so let's not subsidize generic university degrees that impart few if any skills as though they are essential to the economy or society. Let's treat them as though they are a 4 year summer camp for young people who do not yet wish to engage with being adults, i.e. productive members of society. And don't worry about the engineers, scientists and doctors; they're gaining skills, and their boosted earning potential will pay for their education investment; the taxpayer won't have to.

The vast majority of the benefit from earning a degree goes to the degree holder, not to the public at large. If your graduate degree did not deliver a sufficient earnings boost to make that investment pay off, that is society sending you a signal that society doesn't find your graduate degree very useful. Maybe you shouldn't have taken it.

As for the post-war GI bill -- It was a reward for GI's, who deserved it. I'm fine with that. I'll also happily foot the education bill for a young person who signs up for 4-6 years of service to the country. That's not most college students. And the 'value to society' is the military service, not the degree.

>"The benefit to society of your average history major is dubious."

I majored in philosophy as an undergraduate, and I have done extremely well in life. Extremely well. Why?

Philosophy taught me how to ingest large quantities of information and quickly figure out what was important. It taught me how to compare and contrast abstract ideas. It taught me how to make inductive and deductive leaps from what I had gleaned. It taught me how to ask hard questions about the topics at hand. It taught me how to concisely communicate my findings.

These were the skills that—after a few years in the workforce learning the basics of the job—propelled me quickly beyond my peers.

My last real job was managing a DARPA project. Almost all of the people working for me were either CS or EE types who could run rings around me when it came to understanding the fundamental technical issues or coding the solutions. I interviewed and hired all of them, and they were brilliant. But not one of the CS or EE types could think beyond the technical task at hand. There was not one whit of management potential.

And here's the thing . . .

I told the recruiters that I wanted 1/4 to 1/3 of the hires to have had a liberal arts undergraduate degree (preferably in English, history, or philosophy) and to have picked up networking and coding later. And that's what we did. I suspected—and I was right—that the liberal arts types would become the team leaders and communicators. They did.

That project ended in 2006. When it was over, all the CS and EE types were let go. All the liberal arts types are still at the lab, doing great work.

>The vast majority of the benefit from earning a degree goes to the degree holder, not to the public at large.

Well-educated individual are definitely a public benefit. The make for an informed electorate and they make for an involved citizenry, both cornerstones of a healthy democracy.

By the way, although not a professor, I was an adjunct at a university for a while and I totally agree that universities are not job training centers. The purpose of an undergraduate education is—in my view—to teach people to think and communicate at certain levels. Whether one learns those skills studying history or electrical engineering is moot.

Uh-huh. As a liberal arts degree, I've had exactly the same experience with CS and EE in a defence environment. So I'm group technical lead despite not having any science beyond 6th form (college freshman, in US terms).

Oh yeah, and philosophy is absolutely crushing in a cross-disciplinary environment.

Uhh... Cool story!?

The data on incomes by college major completely refute the general form of your anecdote. Also, "not one of the CS or EE types could think beyond the technical task at hand".

I'm an EE and a manager, and you sir, are a bigot.

Also. You just seem to be saying words to win arguments. Playing fast and loose. Contrast the two statements below.

" I finished with $30,000 in student debt (after only 30 credit hours of classes). And I just finished paying it off a couple of years ago."

" I have done extremely well in life. Extremely well."

It took you ~20 years to pay off a 30k debt. Doesn't sound like "extreme" success to me.

I'm just an EE though so probably the words are just over my head because they aren't narrowly technical enough. Oh well. I've got a 8-figure net worth and I'm still a few years away from 40, but shucks, if only I had that philosophy degree. Then I could attain extreme wellness. Probably it's my deficit in thinking ability, being only an EE and all that.

My dad was a high school teacher and my mom was the lunch lady, in case you were wondering. I am very thankful for my EE degree, which taught me "how to ingest large quantities of information and quickly figure out what was important. It taught me how to compare and contrast abstract ideas. It taught me how to make inductive and deductive leaps from what I had gleaned. It taught me how to ask hard questions about the topics at hand. It taught me how to concisely communicate my findings."

I'm also a professor, and it seems like more and more students treat university as a job training center. Many of the most popular and growing majors are mostly pre-professional in nature (business, nursing, etc.), and students and especially parents care about getting a good return on their educational investment, especially with high tuition rates. Of course, my university has a particular focus on career preparation, but I don't think we're too far out of the ordinary. Only the elite, very selective colleges have the luxury of ignoring career preparation, as most of the students there will end up with fine careers anyway.

Also, society benefits from having a better education and trained population through more taxes paid. Highly paid professionals allow for more public goods that can be enjoyed by all of society; they don't capture all of those gains for themselves.

The cost of higher education will increase **bcz** of the Biden plan. The more stupid people you put in a university, the more it costs per student. The cost increases substantially as the bar lowers since the lowest students need the most academic help. That's just the academic help, which was always there to some degree. But today we have an entirely new kind of help: the emergence of the University as parent, responsible for providing both a physically and emotionally safe campus. That's an entirely new administrative infrastructure. Last but not least, the more we fund useless degrees like drama, the less return we get in economic growth to plow back into the university.

>Let's not complain about what Biden's doing. Let's go to the root of the problem

What Biden is doing is a great example of what the root of the problem is: money shovelled into higher education while taking away all semblance of risk from the students and post secondary institutions.

It's fortunate that you were born early enough to not have to suffer the predictable consequences of Democrat policies. I can tell by your post that you're dim enough to have been one of the blue haired gender studies majors if you were born in the 90s.

>"I can tell by your post that you're dim enough to have been one of the blue haired gender studies majors if you were born in the 90s."

If gender studies were taught properly, students would learn the core critical thinking skills to take them successfully though life that I learned—and articulated, above—studying philosophy.

I can tell you're dim enough not to understand what an education at the undergraduate level is all about, and that the particular major is secondary to the critical thinking skills that underlie it all.

I like how you disregarded the point of the post - that Biden's "solution" is exactly "the root of the problem" - because you know you can't rebut it. So much for critical thinking.

Get over yourself; you were a dime a dozen platitude spouting middle manager. Everyone knows this type, and it's a worn cliche to complain about them at this point. lol "leaders" "communicators" "critical thinking". I half expected you to talk about the benefits of diversity by the end of your response.

I’m the dean at small state school. This research has given me lots of good ideas. I will be designing a plan to increase enrollments in my college based on this.

Dean Wormer would like a word with you. His parade major idea crashed.

Alex writes: "Overall, the student loan program, as currently written, is looking to be one of the most costly, inefficient and unwise government programs of the 21st century."

The Iraq and Afghan invasions beg to differ.

Ironic that Joe Biden authorized the Iraq War, too.

The man is on a roll!

"One of"

Wiggle words. And when it comes to expensive gov't mismanagement, this ain't close to the top.

Are we still talking only about the $10k and $20k that is involved in the new Biden student loan program? I am not an economist but why would we need to offer loan forgiveness to professions that are already going to make a lot of money? If I am going to make $100k-$200k a year I am going to be discouraged about going into that career because I will have to pay back $10k in loans and a music major wont? Telling me I would not have to pay back $10k in loans would make me more likely to want that major? That's BS.

On the other side of the issue maybe it encourages a possible music major. Maybe. My bet is that they already know they arent going to make a lot of money.

Steve

Income based repayment allows you to get a large amount of loan debt forgiven. Biden is basically creating an extremely strong incentive to game the system.

Suppose some predatory university were to go up to minimum wage employees and say, hey come get a "degree" or two from us. You will borrow $130,00 from the feds. You sign the form for income based loan repayment. We take a cut, you have "living expenses", and as long as you can keep your on-the-books income reasonably loan, it all gets forgiven later. And I think you might even be able to put funds towards actually buying a house this way.

Maybe you think the for-profit educational sector would not be this brazen, but I seem to recall Ashford University signing up veterans for classes in the TBI ward. This is yet another of those cases where the policy makes little sense in economic or social terms but backstops the educated by removing the fear of failure from their educational endeavors.

Also, it says most recent report. Would that include 2020 or 2021? Some of those incomes look much lower than what you find listed as average earnings for those majors anywhere on the internet and not sure those two years are very representative.

Steve

Most of this post is about the proposed income-driven repayment (IDR) system that was the less-publicized half of the policy. The $10,000 loan forgiveness got more attention, but the long-term effects of the IDR plan are much greater.

And some of the reasons to not means-test the $10,000 forgiveness program are perceived fairness to those who actually put their education to good use, and minimizing regulatory costs.

Why are biology degrees in the "most subsidized" bucket?

Why do biology degree holders make less that music degree holders?

There is massive overproduction of biology majors, and hence underemployment. (A bit old: https://dailynorthwestern.com/2018/11/20/campus/psychology-and-biology-majors-among-highest-level-of-underemployment-study-shows/)
The "STEM" category has a lot of variation in employability.

By the way: here at the University of Oregon, there are more marine biology majors than physics majors. As fond as I am of dolphins, this makes no sense.

I suspect the value of a BS in Biology is limited as compared to a MS or PhD. My sister has a BS in BioChem and didn't figure out until after graduation that there was little demand for a BS and most entry level jobs required a MS. Furthermore most of the jobs were clustered in cities with a big pharma presence, so you better be willing to relocate and won't have the luxury of picking Tampa or Boise as your home.

Another strange one is "communication disorders sciences". Being a speech language pathologist is a well-paying job, and at universities where I've taught, the number of students admitted into those programs was restricted.

But note that they are looking at earnings two years after graduation, and SLP need about 2 years of graduate study. I suspect the same factor might drive down 2-year earnings of biology majors: a bunch of them are in medical school.

About 10% of biology majors go to medical school.
There are about 127,000 biology degrees awarded per year, and about 13,000 of each year's med school entrants were biology majors.

I caught that too, as daughter is a biologist. Googling around, the starting salary for biology BA's is about double the salary shown in the post.

My guess is that no one really thought this albatross through.

My guess is that -- given that the main beneficiaries align well with (D) voting tendencies -- some folks absolutely DID think this through carefully (though we may never precisely just who those folks were). Votes don't buy themselves by accident.

Hmm, if you take the list of occupations and sort them by level of sex ratio you seem to get a very similar sorting? So it seems roughly that the majority of the males will pay for the majority of the females? The more things change, the less things change..

". . . we should subsidize degrees with plausible positive spillovers not masseues."

Is no one asking why there is a college degree for *massaging people*?

"“fixing” the program is likely to drive ever more increasing intervention into higher education much as has happened with health care. My guess is that no one really thought this albatross through."

No, they thought it through.

1. Its a large chunk of vote buying just before the mid-terms.

2. Using the damage caused by a government action to justify more government action is a favorite tactic of the government. Its practically standard operating procedure.

3. Its a problem for 'future-Biden' - if he's around in two years for the next presidential election.

Does this account for liberal arts majors subsidizing STEM majors in college? It's much cheaper to provide a liberal arts education. There are no laboratories, lower infrastructure requirements, and less expensive teaching staff. This was a big thing when the University of Washington had to expand its computer science department to meet demand for that major. I'm guessing this is a problem at other schools as well.

The GI Bill was a massive government giveaway that fostered the growth of university programs with little long term value. Who needs philosophy anyways?

Masseuses probably create more positive spillovers than any other profession. Why the hate?

Well, the world does have a shortage of drama queens.

What I can't understand is why cannot anyone in our government have the sense to align:
A) Student loan reform, and
B) Recruitment and training of more engineers, computer scientists, medical professionals, and other STEM professionals.

You would think that one obvious way of killing those two birds with one stone would be to offer more favorable loan terms to people pursuing STEM degrees.

Yes, I realize that not all non-STEM degrees are useless and so on, but at least as a rough hack at alleviating the nations shortages of engineers and computer scientists, not to mention training more doctors and nurses would be to offer people economic incentives to study engineering and computer science and medical fields. And the most obvious, number one incentive you could offer would be to subsidize the tuition cost of those degrees, and the most innocuous way to do that would be to make the loan terms more favorable.

So why is nobody actually proposing we do such a thing?

Because they're everywhere always worried more about politics and the results of the next election than they are about sound, sensible policy.

One issue is major switching - if I start out in Comp Sci but realize I can't hack it and switch my major to, say, marketing, do I get a new financial aid package? 80% of students switch their major at some point, so this is pretty critical.

Also, enrollments in humanities have been declining, while increasing in many STEM fields: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltnietzel/2022/07/24/the-five-most-significant-ten-year-trends-in-college-majors/ Seems like the market is slowly working, and I'm not sure if it's necessary to speed it up.

I hail from 3 generations of engineers. My father was a pioneer in plastics design back in the '50s, has a product in the 1998 NY World Fair Time Capsule, worked on the space suit, and designed, on a drafting board, many of the products used till this day. My brother was an environmental engineer working for 45 yrs, beginning in the 60s, having written most of the regs for the state, many of which were adopted by the feds - take that home AOC!
My husband has a BS in chem (70s) and when he went to big pharma in NJ for a job they told him not to bother to get a PhD because he won't get a job due to the fact that Indian H1B bosses only hired other Indians. He then when on to get a MS in Math and Computer Science. He wrote the code for a major delivery service - the first bar codes used for scanning packages. Back then he suggested setting up local service stores. They laughed at the idea and promoted an unqualified Asian woman and laid him off., He attended Brooklyn Tech back when it was a great High School to avoid NY public schools and avoid getting beat up by the new Caribbean immigrants who threw glass bottles at his mother. BT labs and foundry have since been gutted and replaced with mock court rooms per the predominately Asian students. He went on to spend 25 years in IT before the H1B Indians were insourced and couldn't find work in 2000. He was then hired in the aerospace defense industry employed for 20 yrs, and only recently made 6 figures, He has 3 patents, was given $500 each, $200 of which went to taxes.
My son just started college majoring in ME and was accepted at 5 colleges in the NE. He was an honors student, First Robotics, Future Business Leadership Club, self taught piano because we couldn't afford lessons ,and Eagle Scout. I searched for scholarships - forget it. He "identifies" as male and is white. Unless you are female (which I am all for), Hispanic, black, or LGBTQ+ there is no money for you. Wake up folks - read the Competes Act which is STEM focused. It allows companies to outsource if they feel necessary and increases the H1B Visa's. Both parties talk out of both sides of their mouths. When I analyzed the ROI at the top engineering schools I found we were looking at $160K of debt with a salary of $68K/yr! That's with 40K/yr school scholarships all unrelated to STEM. Because the local public elementary school ranks 3/10, we choose to send him to the least expensive parochial school at a cost $150K for just K-8. We have lived paycheck to paycheck for 20 yrs. My son, unlike many of his eng. friends chose the state univ. because he refused to take on that kind of debt.
I attended community college in the early 70s, AS in nursing, back in the era when most women became nurses and/or teachers. I then went on to get a BS in nursing, then a MHA at Johns Hopkins, Health Policy and Management and worked my way all through college. When I spoke with my Health Policy & Regulation professor, a prominent DC lawyer who was limo'd from Baltimore to DC, and told him I was interested in working in hospital adm. business end, (not nursing adm) he told me to forget it, due to the fact I was a nurse and would never be hired. I've worked with world famous doctors, did the FDA clinical trials with the doc who invented fentanyl in the '70s for use with the artificial heart transplant, in critical care for 20 years, and at the first and premier Trauma/EMS Institute in Adm. After finishing nursing school I wanted to be a MD. Tuition was $300/semester and my parents refused to mortgage their then $20k home, build by hand by my WW2 Air force pilot father. I was unaware of loans. My MD friends say the cost was relavant for the times, but not really when the ROI of $200K debt for an MD today is the same for an engineer and the ROI as a MD speaks for itself. And Alistair, everyone is not cut out to be managers, plus you probably have an accent which is very popular in this country today. Immigration is not a binary issue, meaning for or against. Immigration is a right not a privilege. To avoid a tribal block, 2% per country has been the rule, Guest worker programs supplement for the merit based policy. Besides the US now imports 80% of it's produce from countries south of the border, so don't tell me there are no jobs down there, not to speak of Microsoft, GM, Maytag, etc. I resent paying $700/night to house illegals who are here for economic reasons and benefits which US citizens are denied.
The college kids of my friends' who are training as physical therapists are getting PhD degrees and going into administration. The problem is we have too many bosses and not enough worker bees. s
Employment - Ford is laying off 8,00O US workers as taxpayers are giving them billions. Why aren't they laying off in their Mexico plants as Mexico allows the cartels to push drugs into our country killing 300/day? Why does my 94 yr mother, who still lives at home and worked until she was 84 have to give up her house to get a nursing home bed (my inheritance) while an illegal thru chain migration qualifies to get her mother a nursing home bed for FREE!? What about the undocumented TPS kids who qualify for free tuition in my state, when the immigrants from Europe who came here in the 1900s, fleeing famine and wars asked for nothing, expected nothing, and were offered nothing from the government and build this country. And why the heck can someone who makes $125K/yr not afford to pay off their student loan? Too busy buying 50k cars, traveling and eating out? College, like health care, is big business. Like big corporations and elite politicians, it's all about greed and a socialist agenda. As Thatcher said "socialism is great until you have to pay for it". Immigration is a right not a privilege. What about my dreams? What about MY son's dreams? The US is the most generous and diverse country in the world. Read the bills, and vote! Restore America!

I hail from 3 generations of engineers. My father was a pioneer in plastics design back in the '50s, has a product in the 1998 NY World Fair Time Capsule, worked on the space suit, and designed, on a drafting board, many of the products used till this day. My brother was an environmental engineer working for 45 yrs, beginning in the 60s, having written most of the regs for the state, many of which were adopted by the feds - take that home AOC!
My husband has a BS in chem (70s) and when he went to big pharma in NJ for a job they told him not to bother to get a PhD because he won't get a job due to the fact that Indian H1B bosses only hired other Indians. He then when on to get a MS in Math and Computer Science. He wrote the code for a major delivery service - the first bar codes used for scanning packages. Back then he suggested setting up local service stores. They laughed at the idea and promoted an unqualified Asian woman and laid him off., He attended Brooklyn Tech back when it was a great High School to avoid NY public schools and avoid getting beat up by the new Caribbean immigrants who threw glass bottles at his mother. BT labs and foundry have since been gutted and replaced with mock court rooms per the predominately Asian students. He went on to spend 25 years in IT before the H1B Indians were insourced and couldn't find work in 2000. He was then hired in the aerospace defense industry employed for 20 yrs, and only recently made 6 figures, He has 3 patents, was given $500 each, $200 of which went to taxes.
My son just started college majoring in ME and was accepted at 5 colleges in the NE. He was an honors student, First Robotics, Future Business Leadership Club, self taught piano because we couldn't afford lessons ,and Eagle Scout. I searched for scholarships - forget it. He "identifies" as male and is white. Unless you are female (which I am all for), Hispanic, black, or LGBTQ+ there is no money for you. Wake up folks - read the Competes Act which is STEM focused. It allows companies to outsource if they feel necessary and increases the H1B Visa's. Both parties talk out of both sides of their mouths. When I analyzed the ROI at the top engineering schools I found we were looking at $160K of debt with a salary of $68K/yr! That's with 40K/yr school scholarships all unrelated to STEM. Because the local public elementary school ranks 3/10, we choose to send him to the least expensive parochial school at a cost $150K for just K-8. We have lived paycheck to paycheck for 20 yrs. My son, unlike many of his eng. friends chose the state univ. because he refused to take on that kind of debt.
I attended community college in the early 70s, AS in nursing, back in the era when most women became nurses and/or teachers. I then went on to get a BS in nursing, then a MHA at Johns Hopkins, Health Policy and Management and worked my way all through college. When I spoke with my Health Policy & Regulation professor, a prominent DC lawyer who was limo'd from Baltimore to DC, and told him I was interested in working in hospital adm. business end, (not nursing adm) he told me to forget it, due to the fact I was a nurse and would never be hired. I've worked with world famous doctors, did the FDA clinical trials with the doc who invented fentanyl in the '70s for use with the artificial heart transplant, in critical care for 20 years, and at the first and premier Trauma/EMS Institute in Adm. After finishing nursing school I wanted to be a MD. Tuition was $300/semester and my parents refused to mortgage their then $20k home, build by hand by my WW2 Air force pilot father. I was unaware of loans. My MD friends say the cost was relavant for the times, but not really when the ROI of $200K debt for an MD today is the same for an engineer and the ROI as a MD speaks for itself. And Alistair, everyone is not cut out to be managers, plus you probably have an accent which is very popular in this country today. Immigration is not a binary issue, meaning for or against. Immigration is a right not a privilege. To avoid a tribal block, 2% per country has been the rule, Guest worker programs supplement for the merit based policy. Besides the US now imports 80% of it's produce from countries south of the border, so don't tell me there are no jobs down there, not to speak of Microsoft, GM, Maytag, etc. I resent paying $700/night to house illegals who are here for economic reasons and benefits which US citizens are denied.
The college kids of my friends' who are training as physical therapists are getting PhD degrees and going into administration. The problem is we have too many bosses and not enough worker bees. s
Employment - Ford is laying off 8,00O US workers as taxpayers are giving them billions. Why aren't they laying off in their Mexico plants as Mexico allows the cartels to push drugs into our country killing 300/day? Why does my 94 yr mother, who still lives at home and worked until she was 84 have to give up her house to get a nursing home bed (my inheritance) while an illegal thru chain migration qualifies to get her mother a nursing home bed for FREE!? What about the undocumented TPS kids who qualify for free tuition in my state, when the immigrants from Europe who came here in the 1900s, fleeing famine and wars asked for nothing, expected nothing, and were offered nothing from the government and build this country. And why the heck can someone who makes $125K/yr not afford to pay off their student loan? Too busy buying 50k cars, traveling and eating out? College, like health care, is big business. Like big corporations and elite politicians, it's all about greed and a socialist agenda. As Thatcher said "socialism is great until you have to pay for it". What about my dreams? What about MY son's dreams? The US is the most generous and diverse country in the world. Read the bills, and vote! Restore America!

There are two subjects this article makes me think of: 1. The inefficiency of the student loan repayment. Though this is clearly a win for the debtor class in the states, it doesn’t reward quality. For example, the $10k would completely repay a degree from trump university but might not come close for a student nurse at a competitive community college. That sort of paradox is absurd. The delivery method is also inefficient and encourages price inflation for universities. 2. This looks like one up-man-ship after the stimulus cheques. It is possible the american presidential contests are in or going in to a demagogic race to handout the most to the most people. There are several reasons this is not ideal, and it will be something to keep an eye on.

I'll take "I didn't realize that I bought my house using an agent with a fine arts degree" for 600, Asked

with the decline of non-stem education in universities, maybe encouraging some people to do those things isn't so bad. i mean, who doesn't like a good massage? who doesn't like listening to music?

As a Journeyman carpenter who is transitioning to draftsman... I'm mildly disgusted at the mistakes architects and engineers make.

Revising plans recently, its been simple things - archi ha laundry room in back of house, through master closet... Too bad he called his closet doors with 24" openings and W/D is min 30"... Call the crane!?

I was a 20 year window cleaner before carpenter and believe you me, the shit I've seen college educated mother fuckers design and produce, is ridiculous.

Common sense ain't so common, so these college degrees seem to be more and more worthless - my grammar isn't great, and I write run on sentences - but I'll I write better than a lot of college educated folks, and I'm just a nail smasher who can draw...

College ain't shit, experience is what matters

Those socialists at Perdue, and their Income Share Agreement, foster the same, only at the front end:

"From the student’s standpoint, ISAs assure a manageable payback amount, never more than the agreed portion of their incomes. Although every provider is different, terms tend to range from 5 percent to 10 percent of income for 10 to 15 years, or somewhat higher (10 percent to 15 percent for shorter contracts such as five to seven years). Best of all, they shift the risk of career shortcomings from student to investor: If the graduate earns less than expected, it is the investors who are disappointed; if the student decides to go off to find himself in Nepal instead of working, the loss is entirely on the funding providers, who will presumably price that risk accordingly when offering their terms. This is true “debt-free” college.
As an ISA market develops, students will benefit further from the market signaling that tells them which fields are most likely to be rewarded economically. A chemical engineer, for instance, is likely to negotiate a much lower repayment rate or shorter repayment term than her art history roommate.

Because of these student-friendly advantages, ISAs have gained support from an unusually broad spectrum of experts. Beth Akers of the Brookings Institution wrote, “[ISAs] should have a place in the landscape of services available in the heterogeneous market for higher education.” An analyst at the New America Foundation said, “It’s only a matter of time before people start skipping private student loans altogether and jump straight to ISAs.” Scholars at the American Enterprise Institute concluded, “ISAs are better suited for student financing than traditional student loans.” This growing consensus adds credence to the concept’s viability and fosters hope that the few legal uncertainties and ambiguities that cloud the ISA picture might be clarified by Congress through bipartisan legislation introduced three weeks ago. A number of companies and funds have already organized to serve this new market, eagerly awaiting college partners prepared to add ISAs to their menu of student-aid choices."

This is a piece written by Mitch Daniels in WAPO.

The student debt crisis and the ISA model results from a failure earlier to offer low tuition at public universities. Anyone have any memories of how low public college tuition was in the past?

Interesting approach for sure. I hope it works and catches on. Mitch Daniels is also pretty famous for keeping tuition low. I have no idea how you link investors to socialists though.

Perdue is a poultry company. I believe Purdue is what you were looking for there. Though I concede that I can’t quite discern whether you’re being facetious in referring to an Indiana public university—under the guidance of the state’s former Republican governor—as socialist. Are you unaware that under Mitch Daniels’ guidance Purdue has not raised tuition by a single cent in 11 years?

Perdue, then Tyson, Pilgrim and the rest of the brood.
As on the farm, there is a pecking order in life.

1. ISA's differ in that you have to convince someone you're worth the risk. The government plan doesn't have that. There is no checking on risk.

2. Yes. I remember the before-fore times when colleges was (relatively) inexpensive. It changed just as I reached college age. That was before the credentionalism era. With guaranteed student loans. Thus the price of education went up to suck up the guaranteed loans. Why do you think schools have all the gucci bullshit for students they have now - student loans pay for it.

One could also argue for separating out the costs of the teaching function from the research function at Universities, and charging only for the costs of teaching,

So, a faculty member who teaches only two courses, and has the remainder of his time and salary spent on research, today has the research charge attached to the university and to the students.

And, if you are a researcher, and write a book, the revenue goes to you, and not the school.

So, let's break out the teaching component and separate it from the research time (and the overhead of grant making, grant oversight, etc.) to get a better picture of the actual costs of education...not the aggregate cost of college which includes research costs and administration.

Increase the course loads for faculty. And, I've never seen a Department Chair who could not be replaced by a good Administrative Assistant, who do most of the work anyway while the Department Chair creates and attends meetings.

> Although every provider is different, terms tend to range from 5 percent to 10 percent of income for 10 to 15 years

Biden's plan is 5% of "discretionary" income for 10 years. In other words, borrow $500K, including lavish room and board for 10 years of study, leave college, make $55K/year, you have no disposable income, so you pay nothing. You walk on, basically, a house. And you had a hell of a good time to show for it.

These loans are not paying for tuition. They are covering living expenses. They are paying for lunch every day. A college kid drinking two $8 coffees per day is drinking $5K in coffees per year. Those are call covered by the taxpayer under Biden's plan. There's no limit. There's no throttle. Every dime you spent while in college was good and virtuous and helped society, and must be paid for by a plumber who was in a 12" crawlspace yesterday shared by spiders as he ran a run of PEX.

About half of spring breakers used student loans to pay for spring break. That is covered by the taxpayer too.

Inflation-adjusted tuition has tripled in the last 40 years. That's nearly 3% YoY growth above inflation. For a lesser product too.

NYPost nails it:

https://nypost.com/2022/09/03/think-bidens-student-loan-write-offs-are-unfair-just-take-a-look-at-the-fine-print/

Here is the text of the plan. You misrepresent it. You have nothing to offer but imagination.

Here are the terms: How do I know if I am eligible for debt cancellation?

"To be eligible, your annual income must have fallen below $125,000 (for individuals) or $250,000 (for married couples or heads of households)
If you received a Pell Grant in college and meet the income threshold, you will be eligible for up to $20,000 in debt cancellation.
If you did not receive a Pell Grant in college and meet the income threshold, you will be eligible for up to $10,000 in debt cancellation." https://studentaid.gov/debt-relief-announcement/

Your comment is also illogical. Students pay tuition and room and board. Debt is fungible: you pay tuition and you also pay to stay at school, which comprises the total debt for college. The loans are still due, with a one time $10k loan forgiveness for persons making less than $125K. This isn't even on the same planet as the Trump tax cut per person for the top 1%.

Debt cancellation and the IBR changes are separate aspects of the plan. Don't confuse the two.

Good point. As for an Income Driven plan, They changed the current limit of 15% of discretionary income to 10% and reduced the payment period.

"The amount you pay each month on an income-driven repayment plan is based on your discretionary income, not your loan balance. Discretionary income is what’s left over after essential life needs, such as food or housing.
Right now, the Education Department calculates discretionary income as your household income minus 150% of the federal poverty guideline for your family size and location. If your household income is $75,000 for a family of four in Virginia, your nondiscretionary income is $41,625 and your discretionary income is $33,375. The income-based repayment amount is a percentage of $33,375.
The new plan places the threshold for discretionary income at 225% of the federal poverty guideline. That same $75,000 household would see payments based on $12,572.50 of discretionary income.Borrowers are eligible for forgiveness of their remaining balance after 20 or 25 years with current IDR plans. However, the new plan cuts that time to 10 years for borrowers with original loan balances of $12,000 or less.
A recent NerdWallet analysis found that only borrowers with starting annual salaries of $20,000 and $30,000 with 3% yearly raises stand to see forgiveness after 20 years with the current IDR plan. With the new plan, the Education Department projects that nearly all community college borrowers will be debt-free within 10 years.
Jeff Strohl, research director at the Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce, says while not everyone will be happy with the new IDR plan — specifically those who may be cut out of the biggest benefits — “it’s going to offer a lot of help to people in lowering their debt and making college more affordable.” https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/student-loans/the-new-idr-plan

Phinton,

You overstate your argument, failing to mention size of debt relative to poverty guidelines, income limits, etc. Stick to facts and not exaggeration.

"The new plan places the threshold for discretionary income at 225% of the federal poverty guideline. That same $75,000 household would see payments based on $12,572.50 of discretionary income.Borrowers are eligible for forgiveness of their remaining balance after 20 or 25 years with current IDR plans. However, the new plan cuts that time to 10 years for borrowers with original loan balances of $12,000 or less.
A recent NerdWallet analysis found that only borrowers with starting annual salaries of $20,000 and $30,000 with 3% yearly raises stand to see forgiveness after 20 years with the current IDR plan. With the new plan, the Education Department projects that nearly all community college borrowers will be debt-free within 10 years.
Jeff Strohl, research director at the Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce, says while not everyone will be happy with the new IDR plan — specifically those who may be cut out of the biggest benefits — “it’s going to offer a lot of help to people in lowering their debt and making college more affordable.” https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/student-loans/the-new-idr-plan

Continue this thread →

> They changed the current limit of 15% of discretionary income to 10% and reduced the payment period.

No, it's 5%. See link below. Additionally, what was "discretionary" was re-defined so that borrowers have even LESS discretionary income. Discretionary income now included "essential" cost of living expenses.

https://www.star-telegram.com/news/nation-world/national/article264850464.html

Continue this thread →

> Here is the text of the plan. You misrepresent it. You have nothing to offer but imagination.

The income based repayment is the bigger giveaway here, Bill. You appear not to know that.

That we will erase room and board debt for college is foolish. The incentive here is to live lavishly during college knowing you will never have to repay most of that thanks to IBR.

In other words, whether I borrow $100K for room and board for 4 years or $1M for room and board for 4 years, I still pay the exact same back. So, which would you choose? Would you choose the low-end Kia or high-end Porsche if your cost were the same?

Starting to see the problem?

"If we are going to subsidize, we should subsidize degrees with plausible positive spillovers not masseues."

Don't artists have plausible positive spillovers? We subsidize public art all the time, including the museums in our nations capital.

Anything worthwhile created in the last 80 years?

If this can be done by the current administration, can it be undone by the next?

Can it be undone before then by lawsuit? POTUS is not supposed to be able to spend a trillion dollars with a stroke of the pen.

Steve Jobs was an art major. It isn't engineers that make jobs, it is creative people

I’ll agree, and actively vote, for this “loan forgiveness is a bad idea” as soon as it is applied to people and corporations who actually can pay their loans back is enforced. See: PPO.

Did you endorse those policy? Because those policies WERE ALSO BAD.
And I've never met a liberal who opposed them. They all wanted massive federal expenditures to "do something" to help everyone.

What if I think those policies WERE ALSO GOOD?

The govt policy of Loaning Government Money is never a bad idea. The policy of forgiving the loan, or portions, to people/groups fully capable of paying the loan back in full is criminal malfeasance of tax money usage. Bankruptcy laws exist, except for student loans of course. Funny that…

"As a result, borrowing will be the best way to pay for college."

This analysis if fundamentally misguided. It is a one off amnesty that did not create incentives that determined if the loans were entered into in the first place.

Mr. Jefferson believed in "generational sovereignty": every generation all debts and obligations would be wiped clean so the new generation could start over. He defined a "generation" as 19 years. His friend Mr. Madison talked Mr. Jefferson out of sharing this numbskull idea lest people think Jefferson had gone round the bend.

I recently read that Princeton has decided to cover the tuition and room and board for students from lower income families. It's a graduated program, but families earning up to $100,000 will pay nothing. More than 25% of undergraduate students will pay nothing. The program begins in the Fall 2023. Princeton is the highest rated national university according to US News.

Most states had similar programs when I attended college many years ago. No, states didn't pay the tuition, but public colleges charged very low tuition. I attended my state's flagship university for part of my education, and I never paid more than $1,000 a year tuition. Why states decided to drop this subsidy and base tuition on what the market will bear is debatable. One reason is that many graduates would leave the state: why subsidize a student who plans to leave the state. Another is the belief that colleges are cesspools of undesirables, teaching impressionable young men and women radical ideas about, well, everything. States don't wish to subsidize that! An aside, Peter Davison has died. Davison spent 35 years editing (correcting) Orwell's books, essays, letters, diaries, and manuscripts. Reading about Davison's achievement, I decided to read some material about Orwell as a refresher. I won't repeat the sordid facts about Orwell, but I found it interesting that Orwell was reckless in labeling people he didn't like "communists", who he referred to as "cryptos" (as in crypto-communist). Crypto-communist, crypto-currency. Now whenever I read about the latest crypto nonsense I will think about Orwell.

Jefferson was always heavily in debt.

Churchill was often in debt due to gambling, a trait that ran in the family. Hard to be comfortable with a politician having one hand on the dice and another on the Exchecquer's nuts.

>every generation all debts and obligations would be wiped clean so the new generation could start over.

? At least in the US, death cancels all debts; they aren't passed on to the new generation.

You should be a decent human being and quit your job.

I find much of the commentary here difficult to understand. People aren't rational economic actors, we live in a highly individualistic culture with compulsory education that encourages the pursuit of individual interests, aptitudes and dreams. Culture in education is stronger than market incentives. So, many more than the rational number of 18 year olds will study drama and not nursing or engineering, despite the exceedingly obvious needs of society. The cost doesn't much matter if the debt-financing is available, and this is where libertarianism shows weakness as an overarching analysis, as if people can be incentivised by the market and that by involving itself the government is inflaming the problem. Why not recognise that the market doesn't always function as an incentive and instead argue for regulation on tuition and student loans (amount, interest rates, other terms)? And have compassion for the drama major who now finds himself in permanent debt-servitude.

These people *are* rational. Its the easy credit that allows them to choose bullshit majors that provide no return nor do they even enrich their lives - spend 6 years getting you (*)-studies graduate degree and then maybe, with some hard work and moving up the ladder, go manage a Dillards.

People get 'art' degrees because their plan is to 'teach art'. How many art teachers do they think there are? Doesn't matter - they can take on the debt right now to find out if they have a shot at being an adjunct professor getting paid a grand a credit hour.

Roll the dice: if you win, you get to become an art teacher. If you lose, you've taken on a lifetime of debt, in exchange for wasting 6 years at school that can't be renarratavised and 30 years of grind at Dillards. So go the vanquished.

Great! Now do this for forgiven PPP loans

That has already been done. That was also a bad policy .... I'm assuming you supported it at the time.

Author should disclose what tuition was when they were in school.

How is this worse than say, Iraq War or Afghanistan? The fact that THIS is what makes you go “most wasteful of the century” is REALLY telling. I mean sure its inefficient but MUSIC WILL STILL BE A MONEY LOSER.

10k or 20k aint going to make useless degrees worth it.

It's pushing kids to get college degrees that won't help them which is kind of evil. Ya they'll probably turn into Democrat voters but they'll waste 4 years of their life learning something economically worthless which is going to harm them for the rest of their life by either pushing them into a low paying job or forcing them to take another 2-3 years going to school to get a useful degree.

Also, why do you think college prices have gone up so much? A big part of that has been government subsidizing education through the student loan program. This makes that worse and is going to raise the cost of college even more.

> A big part of that has been government subsidizing education through the student loan program.

Yes indeed. The gov just passed more subsidies for electric cars, and like clockwork, the car makers started to raise the price of EVs by the amount of the new subsidy.

Subsidies rarely have the desired effect.

Except subsidies do have the desired effect.
The desired effect is graft.

《it will be a financial no-brainer to take out the maximum student loan》

《with most of the increased costs being passed on to taxpayers》

Why isn't it a financial no-brainer for Treasury to simply sell new bonds faster than old bonds need to be redeemed, thus obviating taxes altogether?

Wow, Alex, that title is A++ in hipocrisy. Did you consider writing policy proposals for the Koch Brothers & co.?
Any healthy country is taxing big business and subsidising everyone who wants to participate in higher education. Even as an engineer myself I have to confess that those of us working in our field usually produce far higher negative externalities than your average drama major. Mechanical engineers destroy the environment through their corporate overlords, lawyers and IT people abolish democracy via tech and economists...well, we know they are the worst misguiding the whole economy. So do I mind a one-time subsidy for some lost souls whom effect are mostly neutral on the world or in some rare cases might be even positive? No, I do not.

Yet you still work as an engineer.

Do existing monetary incentives make student debt forgiveness impact just a rounding error?

Comments for this post are closed