Discussion about this post

Amitav Krishna's avatar
Joseph's avatar

My problem with these studies, whether liberal or conservative, is that people rarely rigorously define their terms. So if I try to point out how an ideology governs does not in fact increase fertility, we end up in no true scotsman territory.

If for example, a right wing government meant integralist catholics who enforced natural family planning where abortion and birth control are categorically banned, I could definitely see how that would mechanically increase the birth rate. But is that what people mean by right wing governments increasing fertility? I am skeptical but then what do people mean?

Not trying to pick on conservatives specifically. Liberals are equally feckless on fertility for their own ideological reasons.

Semi-Augustinian's avatar

Tasmania has been ruled by the Liberals (despite the name, they're conservatives and are becoming more conservative in the last few years) since 2014, and Tasmanian fertility rate has been collapsing since 2014. In 2014, Tasmania had the second highest TFR in Australia, now it's the second lowest.

So yes, in Australia conservative governance is bad for fertility. At least, conservative governance in Australia does not improve fertility rate in any nontrivial way.

1 more comment...