The Tragedy of Nikole Hannah-Jones

Nikole Hannah-Jones famously sent her child to a predominantly black/lower-income public school in New York City. Now her child says she shouldn’t have been used as political fodder.

The essay makes for hard reading and I acknowledge NHJ’s courage in writing about her mistakes and the cost to her child. The piece is raw and true when talking about her personal choices, but the larger story in which NHJ embeds her personal history is mostly false. The problem isn’t funding. The failures she documents are failures of management and accountability, not lack of resources. NYC spends upwards of $40k per pupil on average, the highest of any large district in the country. Moreover, schools in NYC with lower-income students get more than the average. PS 307, where NHJ initially sent her child, is currently funded at just over 52k per student, far above the national average.

Nationally, there haven’t been big gaps in funding within states by race or income for decades. NHJ has reckoned with her failing her own child but she has not yet reckoned with the failure of her entire educational philosophy.

The role of ideology in blinding NHJ is dramatic. NHJ’s daughter earns high grades in her math classes but she fails standardized tests. Most parents, especially conservatives, know what that means. The classes are a lie. But NHJ is blinded by ideology and assumes it’s the standardized tests that are biased. It’s only when her daughter demands to go to a better school that she and her daughter confront the truth:

Najya knew very little algebra and had huge gaps in many of the building blocks of math that she should have learned in elementary school, like mastery of long division and fractions.

The confrontation is almost disastrous:

My child’s confidence wilted like an unwatered plant. She started to develop an almost debilitating anxiety around taking tests. She became sullen at school and began to act out. For the first time ever, I got messages from teachers about Najya’s behavior.

Fortunately, Najya battles back and recovers but much more could be said here about the costs of social promotion, DEI and mismatch on the so-called beneficiaries.

Ironically, NHJ invokes the heroic history of Black Americans integrating schools to justify keeping her own child in a segregated one. Painful.

NHJ thought that she and her husband–politically connected, astute people who were not afraid to speak up–could do well for their daughter and the other kids in the school. But in the end she has written a great piece on why voice fails–even a powerful voice–in the absence of the threat of exit. Hannah-Jones could have saved herself some grief and her child a poor education by reading my post The tragedy of Jonathan Kozol.

It’s been said that Ayn Rand’s heroes don’t exist, but her villains do. Case in point. Hannah-Jones says that she and her husband “felt an obligation to make educational decisions based on the collective good.” But she wasn’t just sacrificing herself for her ideology; she was sacrificing her child, who had no choice in the matter. “I don’t think she’s deserving of more than other kids,” she said in 2017. Nearly a decade later, Najya reminded her that in the abstract your child may not deserve more than other children, but she is nevertheless entitled to expect more from you. “Sometimes I wish instead of always thinking about other kids, you would have thought about me.” You don’t have to be a Randian to think that your child should not be sacrificed to the collective good, but it doesn’t hurt.

Comments

It was a difficult read. I couldn't help but feel it was a kind of sociopolitical Munchausen by proxy, where she knowingly put her daughter in a bad situation and then got to play activist and reformer. The fact that it took so long to realize that her daughter wasn't learning anything was really damning.

Respond

Before the 1619 project, Hannah-Jones made her name writing about education. One of her main points was how hypocritical white liberal parents were when it came to their own children. Hannah-Jones tried to demonstrate some personal leadership with her own child but found out the limits of such personal leadership.

I knew Hannah-Jones failed to understand the scope of the problem when I saw her speak in DC and she talked about powerful (white) parents being able to influence public school systems to do better. Of course, she was saying this in a city with the highest concentration of politically powerful people who had not been able to influence local government to improve for decades.

Respond

I'm glad for the honest example of someone living by their publicly stated principles and then honestly telling the world how poorly it went. This is limited by her astonishing ability to not see the world directly around her as it is.

I am flabbergasted that the elder Hannah-Jones did not bother to investigate, or even notice, that her child was behind educationally, until her daughter confronted her angrily.

Meanwhile she still makes excuses for the failing school. On watching elementary school children assaulting each other during lunch "kids of all incomes are rambunctious at lunchtime"... hmm that wasn't my experiene of my well-to-do suburban public school - I remember loud conversations but not not a lot of of hitting and pushing.

Respond

Many on the US left tell themselves a comforting myth that the problem in America is low taxes and low government spending. Just elect leaders willing to spend money and suddenly we will have all the nice public goods that Japan or Sweden has.

Urban public schools and California high-speed rail are two things that demonstrate that willingness to spend is not enough. Rather, the ability of the American state to turn money into public goods is fundamentally broken. Institutional reform is needed to make spending effective.

It’s not really a problem for the Democrat establishment who aren’t super interested in providing public goods. But the new generation of young Democrats, who are explicitly socialist, do seem to have a genuine interest in providing public goods. They will find that unless they pursue institutional reform they will be unable to ever make good on campaign promises.

Respond

What struck me was how the teachers were blamed. But surely the problem was failure by the school to impose strict discipline. Even average teachers can teach well if the class is well behaved. And misbehaviour leads inevitably to teachers leaving or going off with stress.

Respond

Everyone seems to fail to recognize or refuse to admit that there is a huge trade off between strict discipline and completion. Expelling and suspending students does not work when the families do not care. Holding children back only works one time because 20 y/o high school seniors are generally not tolerated by everyone else.

Respond

Attention seeking, sure. But at least she didn't choke her kid to death.

Respond

"Most parents, especially conservatives, know what that means." oh right, because terms like "liberal" and "conservative" are clear as day. EVERYONE knows their precise meaning, that's why you never define terms, beacuse it wouldn't be propaganda if you really intended to sincerely communicate meaning.

"growth!"

Respond

The Beatles refused to play for a segregated audience in Jacksonville, FL. Why were they so "woke" (another term idiots repeat) and ideological!!!??? They ended up playing before an integrated crowd, sorry Alex.

Respond

feels like you didn't read Professor Tabarrok's nuanced, substantive, and excellent post. You also are confused about what NHJ did... She chose to keep her kid in the segregated school. Your Beatles point (which carries no real weight) would go against NHJ's decision.

Respond
Respond

Add Comment