News

Alexander Graham Bell descendants upset after Parks Canada calls inventor a eugenicist

Review says Bell 'discouraged the use of sign language' and held 'eugenics beliefs'

Alexander Graham Bell
Alexander Graham Bell, his great-grandchildren say, did not try to prevent deaf people from marrying other deaf people, nor was he against sign language. (Getty Images)

The family of Alexander Graham Bell, the Scottish-born Canadian inventor of the telephone, is upset over a planned redesign of a commemorative plaque that could add that he was a proponent of eugenics and held controversial views about deaf people.

Bell was designated as a national historic person in 1977 by Parks Canada, which installed a commemorate plaque in Baddeck, N.S., near his summer home where he died in 1922.

The plaque says he “devoted his life, with unusual success, to the benefit of mankind,” and that he “produced important inventions and discoveries in medicine, aeronautics, marine engineering, genetics and electrical science, and greatly advanced the methods and practices of teaching the deaf.”

Comments

Top Comments

    1. Comment by Phyllis Beaton Vazquez.

      In 1884 Bell published "Memoir upon the Formation of a Deaf Variety of the Human Race", where he expressed fears that intermarriage among deaf persons, deaf schools and the use of sign language would lead to the formation of a deaf race. He pushed for laws to sterilize deaf women out of fear they would bear deaf children. He was also against Sign Language when others, such as Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet advocated for its use as the Natural language of deaf persons.

      Second, deaf people have used sign language for centuries, since the beginning of time. The first Ontario school for the Deaf in Belleville, established in 1870, Sir James Whitney and many other schools across the country and in the United States, used the Language of Signs/The Sign Language in classes, which is now known as American Sign Language (ASL). So sign language did not develop in 1950 as Grosvenor incorrectly states.

      These facts need to be acknowledged and published regardless of Bell's other accomplishments and regardless of the historical context in which they occurred. Kudos to Parks Canada for listening to the deaf community.

    2. Comment by Rene Wells.

      Quite the precedent being set by Parks Canada. One can only wonder what future generations will be saying about the prominent individuals today who receive such recognitions.

      Interesting too that they featured the word "mankind" on their updated plaque. I thought that was expunged. Not to the extent, mind you, that Justin Trudeau once did, dazzling his captivated audience in Edmonton when correcting someone with that bizarre "peoplekind" reference...

    3. Comment by Doug Whalen.

      Tommy Douglas, founder of the CCF (now NDP) and voted the "most important Canadian" was also a believer in eugenics.....as were many others in the early days of the idea and long before it morphed into something immoral....but you will never hear about that from the hard core wokists that want to besmirch Bell....

    Read Next