What it feels like to let an LLM read my journals, sleep, finances and analyze me for 15 minutes a week (N=1, with guardrails)
I tried to write an experience report articulating the emotional and cognitive shifts I've experienced from this process. It's been introspective, fun and unnerving, and has made me a little bit more self-compassionate.
I use Obsidian to take notes, an Oura ring, and Plaid/beancount for plain text accounting to pull all my finances.
To give Claude accurate context I made an Obsidian plugin that looks at only what's changed across my 2000+ notes. Each week, I edit around 20-40 notes and Claude only gets the "track changes" or diffs/hunks (in coding jargon; I made visualizations to show how this works to non-technical folk).
Open to any feedback, especially whether the visualizations are clear and what guardrails you use! If anyone else has tried experiments like this I'm all ears :) in the absence of RCTs this N=1 anecdata is all we have for now 😬
Also, curious if you agree with me that this presents a consent problem on long horizons, because taking input from LLMs on smaller decisions is low risk, but it's hard to give informed consent when you don't know how the LLM could shift your identity/decision profile over years of use. I'm wary!
Comments Section
I love these stories about people's personal systems.
I feel like footnote 1 (it told you it wasn't a prodrome of depression when it was!) is really important, but... buried in a footnote. Still, very interesting stuff.
How did you create the habit of journaling in the first place? do you do it throughout the day or once at night etc?
Thank you for taking a look! I wrote it because I found myself also wanting to read many more such hyper-specific experience reports and personal systems with AI.
> How did you create the habit of journaling in the first place?
I started with the "3 things a day you're grateful for" exercises which felt cheesy at first but I did it every night for about 7 years, even if it was really small like "felt sunlight". Then I switched to VS code and editing markdown files on laptop/phone for another 5 years (which led to longer, in-depth entries), and then switched to Obsidian. Now the habit is just when emotionally salient events happen - I usually write more for positive events and try not to dwell on negative events too much (to avoid rumination), unless it seems important or with high-risk consequences. I also use Claude voice mode to draft entries, which has been helpful for longer form entries and condensing rambles.
These days I wouldn't call it "journaling" so much as lifelogging. I'll copy paste messages to/from friends and family, have various categories (things that feel nice to receive, feedback, project notes, etc). If I had to guess maybe 5-10% of my daily input to Obsidian is typical "journaling" where I'm writing first person and doing some type of experience report or introspection.
> do you do it throughout the day or once at night etc?
Throughout the day, the only regular once a day thing is subjective sleep log (a few words about how I feel waking up, to complement the Oura objective data).
> I feel like footnote 1 (it told you it wasn't a prodrome of depression when it was!) is really important, but... buried in a footnote. Still, very interesting stuff.
EDIT: you are absolutely right and I corrected this; see below.
Sorry for the wall of text; I'm just interested in this stuff and curious about people's takes :)
“Felt cheesy at first” then proceeds to continue for 12 years.
Amazing. When I’ve tried to journal I didn’t make it through 12 days.
Do you have any feelings of vulnerability by having all this information captured in files? Perhaps it is a product of how I was raised, but I would never put personal and private information onto paper/writing, because nothing ever stays private.
Yes, I definitely feel vulnerable in giving all this information to Anthropic.
I sometimes think about the Finnish hack where a 23 year old gained access to 33000 people's therapy transcripts with deadly outcomes (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/jan/17/vastaamo-hack-finland-therapy-notes).
Unfortunately I don't think it's a matter of if but when something like this happens with OpenAI/Anthropic given the potential monetary value of such a breach.
Because I've worked with millions of people's health care data in one form or another for the past 7 years, maybe I'm a bit desensitized to putting health, financial, emotional data into digital form. The cost-benefit has been worth it so far. And some precautions like having two-step authentication, encryption, backups, open source alternatives make me feel a little bit safer.
The slight benefit of the workflow outlined in the post is that the models do not gain access to the entirety of my journals, only the parts that I've edited most recently. So that gives me a little bit more peace of mind, that it would take extra effort to stitch together my full thoughts across 50+ sessions each year, to reconstruct parts of my thinking or emotional state. It might make for good gossip for a very small number of people haha.
Wait, I'm confused. I thought "the latter" meant the psychiatrist said it WAS prodrome/incipient depression.
I have done the grateful thing before and found it surprisingly effective myself.
I've played around with obsidian a little, but never got over the hump. Is it really that much better than VSCode for markdown? I didn't find the added friction worth it for me but maybe I gave up too soon.
> I've played around with obsidian a little, but never got over the hump. Is it really that much better than VSCode for markdown? I didn't find the added friction worth it for me but maybe I gave up too soon.
Getting over the hump or activation energy for me took a body doubling/coworking session with a friend for several hours. It involved migrating hundreds of gigabytes out of my iCloud account so I could get below the free iCloud drive limit and not have to pay for Obsidian sync to try it out.
Now with the iPhone app and MacOS apps, I think of it as a very fast interface for text. It takes a few seconds max to open one of thousands of notes or get full-text search among them, or copy and paste something (from/to Claude, from/to a message, etc).
It's a weird, freeform middle ground between apps like https://raindrop.io/ for bookmarks, as in it lets you add additional context to links, a journal, a project management system, etc.
My take would be to try it out without replacing your initial system; I used my VS code + dropbox markdown folder for a few weeks in tandem with Obsidian as I got used to it. Then you'll have a sense of whether it's worth the switch.
Caveat of my approach: with this ability to "track changes" across hundreds of markdown files, it will be much harder to migrate if Obsidian ever disappears, and could be very annoying to replicate this feature in a fully open source solution.
Whoops!! That is a GREAT and very important catch and totally on me. Fixed. Thanks again.
Reworded the footnote: "Writing this a few months later, and with the help of my psychiatrist, I can confirm it was the former; a normal situational grief response."
I think both some of the biggest personal gains, but also the biggest personal risks come when using AI in the middle of some sort of self improvement feedback loop. And by self here I mean the user and not the AI.
So many people just use AI as an answer box when it's a really powerful tool for guiding and refining your own effort. That being said the sycophancy bias of current AI is so real and I worry that most people are susceptible to some form of low grade AI psychosis because of this and doubly more so when it's being injected directly into the core of your being vis a vis your emotions/diary etc.
I'm extremely wary of giving AI any form of input into anything too deep or emotional or therapy-ish. I'm very sensitive to people with bipolar and it really seems like AI is giving too many people around me that use it diet mania.
100% agree, and I hope the examples I shared of the confabulations/hallucinations the AI gives me were enough to raise eyebrows. I also tried to use enough hedging language to make my ambivalence clear, while remaining accurate to the subtle shifts I've noticed like a bit more self-compassion.
Re: people experiencing bipolar or other forms of severe mental health conditions, this deserves a separate callout as this is woefully understudied right now. The recent review I cited from last month mentions this specifically, that LLM chatbots are "unsuitable for high-risk cases of mental illness, such as suicide-risk or severe psychiatric conditions and vulnerable populations especially due to the risk of validating or reinforcing harmful beliefs such as suicidal ideations or delusions. This risk can occur from the underrepresentation of severe mental health cases in training data, training on stigmatizing data, or by [chatbots] reflecting users’ biases" (https://www.nature.com/articles/s41746-026-03054-x).
The low grade AI psychosis may be more prevalent than we'd collectively care to admit. Part of my hope in writing this was to spur this kind of discussion around guardrails and the vulnerable populations turning toward LLMs for support (see for example r/therapyGPT).
Forgot to mention, the other paper I cited has an excellent figure highlighting that concerning behavior escalates faster for simulated users with mania/psychosis (per your comments): https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-026-04577-2/figures/4
Good read! Thanks! That's some difficult vocabulary my friend: prodome, lacrimal, affordances, prosteses, salient, anacdata. Color me impressed.
I personally have a more and more negative relationship with technology with regards to personal development. I think being conscious about your life is very important; what you're doing day to day, where you want to go, how this is going. And I think this is achieved through journaling and looking inside. I however do it in a physical journal, which is impractical in many ways and hurts my hand. But for me it's sadly the only way because of how weak I am towards the endless distractions my phone and computer offer.
If you don't have this weakness, then I think your approach is excellent. It's like an evolution of the second brain; now with emotional counseling.
Grateful for the kind words! I do love language/words being an English as a second language kid.
I agree being conscious in your life is important, to a degree. I've over-journaled, and once when my mental health was not so great I had to take a break from it because reinforce rumination. And I experience the same endless distractions from phone & computer use! On the whole, I prefer the LLM interface to many others on my computer/phone/internet - it removes distractions and helps me focus on what I want to accomplish. The trade-off is it can reduce thinking sometimes, which is why writing (without AI) has become more important for me to figure stuff out and learn for myself. I'm not confident my solutions will last, as it's only been 6 months of this convoluted setup haha - which is partly why I wanted to share it to see what alternative systems people use.
Re: the pain of manually journaling, I share this and have had some chronic pain in my hands. I've found Claude voice mode does a great job of allowing me to ramble out loud then summarizing that audio into coherent paragraphs. It does a surprisingly good job of keeping the text in my voice and vocabulary. Then I'll copy and paste that as a journal entry or message/update to friends.
I'd love to write more about what you mentioned about the evolution of the second brain and the possible ramifications, as I have felt some subtle shifts (some good, some bad). Perhaps another post down the line :)
Not to be glib, but your point about informed consent seems like it would show that you can't have informed consent to any long-running practice. Imagine this was a blog about starting to do daily physical exercise: who knows what the long term implications for your personality might be if you exercise every day for 10 years? Maybe you'll become an obsessive CrossFit person. Maybe you'll have a different outlook on the value of natural beauty in your community. Maybe you'll develop joint problems that cause significant daily pain that makes you into an angry recluse that destroys every relationship you had. Maybe you'll become driven and conscientious.
You could imagine all sorts of possible personality changes that come from any significant decision over the long run, and there are plenty more that you won't think of. Not sure whether you consider this a modus ponens or a modus tollens to your original idea but it seems to me the reasoning extends far beyond getting an LLM to analyze your life.
Modus ponens -- agree with you that you can't really have informed consent for many long-running practices, and those are good examples.
The difference with AI is in how informed we can be. For things that have been around for decades we have a much better idea of tail risk, so we can better give consent/undergo a practice. E.g. if I take psychedelics there is a risk of permanent effects, good or bad. If I do an intensive meditation retreat there is emerging data on the (small) risk of psychosis. The base rates are easier to understand.
For newer things like intensive experimentation with AI, there are few case studies and it is hard to talk about (took me a while to get the courage to post about this; I imagine harder to come forward for someone who has suffered), and studies are more difficult (e.g. models change, social confounds like users sharing knowledge amongst each other).
So I wanted to point out the "unknown unknown" risks that are potentially larger as AI is newer technology, more pervasive, harder to study, and maybe has larger tail risk.
Thanks for helping try to make this more precise, appreciate the discussion!
I found this a chore to read through; im the same way that Claude opus text is hard to get through, not in the way that James Joyce prose is...
For example: "Lacrimal event" doesn't, to me, say anything that you couldn't say more simply, and just sounds pretentious or like you're trying to sound more authoritative.
Feedback noted! Perhaps spending many hours each day with Claude for many months has rubbed off on my writing brain ><
Re: lacrimal as a word choice, I thought it was funnier than saying "brought a tear to my eye" or other cliché but maybe that was just me. Def not trying to sound more authoritative about crying.
Honestly I think I just wrote kind of like claude to begin with—more accurately claude writes kind of like me, because if you're a decent writer with anything available online, then that's where claude got the idea lol, but at first I thought it was adopting my writing style so I would give it more engagement gold coins or whatever.
I used Claude for an 18 month job search, with the only positive result being that I found out that you can't get run a job search like a coding project lol, because all I ended up with was a system that was excellent at confirming my biases & making me feel better about my failures & giving me just enough platitudinal homework to make me feel busy, when in reality the economy was prob already in freefall & it was maybe the worst time to try & find a job in a decade or two. I didn't know anyone would want to read about it tho lol
The idea of doing multiple notes per day and tracking so many personal details sounds both tedious and incredibly self-obsessed. And this is coming from a person that's been keeping a daily affect rating (1-10) and free text notes for about 6 years.
I would guess that this is just your natural inclination. Do you find yourself in self-analysis mode for large portions of your thinking time? If you've been collecting this data for so many years prior to this you must get some value out of it.
It can definitely feel tedious when not automated, which is why I haven't done this until LLMs improved. This year I was able to vibe code the necessary tooling to require minimum input. For example the Oura ring data and finances are pulled automatically via APIs and I don't need to look at it manually unless I want to.
> Do you find yourself in self-analysis mode for large portions of your thinking time?
No. If I had to estimate then <10% of my weekly word count is manual self analysis mode, the rest is taking notes / organizing projects / working. If I notice I'm entering rumination territory that is a red flag and I pull back on journaling (which I've had to do once many years ago).
Maybe it's an artefact from graduate school and academia where I had to learn to balance multiple competing interests and projects; thinking or working this way has felt natural for over a decade. Out of the thousands of notes and detritus I've amassed, there's a big power law and >99% of them are low value never to be returned to, ephemeral tools for thought. That feels like the value I derive from apps like Obsidian + note-taking.
Curious about others' journaling/note taking habits - I imagine the diversity of practices varies significantly.
Could use a more concise summary at top. Reads as "what am I reading"
Will fix that, thank you! Do you mean a more concise summary in the body of the reddit post, or the post itself?
Post itself. Just was my thought as I read it. Like in the military the top line is a 'BLUF' - bottom line up front
Good call, fixed with a summary at the top of the post: "Each week I give an AI my journal, notes, sleep, and financial data and receive a 15-minute podcast. It’s right often enough to move me, and wrong enough to keep me vigilant."
Hope that helps orient a new reader!