The polity that is Singapore

Police in Singapore have charged a man who is accused of posting an AI-generated image of a saltwater crocodile in a popular reservoir.

Ye Lin was charged with communicating a false message and obstructing the course of justice for allegedly deleting the picture and the application he used.

The fake image caused public concern, authorities allege. The national water agency suspended its work at the city-state’s largest reservoir for two days last month after receiving information that a crocodile had been spotted.

Here is the full story, via Kyle.

Comments

Cowen admires Singapore, so I don't believe Cowen is trolling. AI-generated images will become an increasing problem, causing panic, identifying scapegoats, creating a sense of chaos, all to the benefit of the authoritarian who will protect us. And the worst of all, causing the public to distrust AI, which may become the scapegoat.

Respond

The images are fake -- and the enshittification of the internet is real. And getting worse, with AI providing tools to the enshittifiers.

Respond

If social welfare democracies want to survive they need to follow Singapore's example. It's not altruism but the certainty of punishment that binds people together.

Respond

Especially if his punishment were to be being fed to crocs.

Respond

AI generated images include Coalition for Content Provenance and Authenticity (C2PA) metadata and text watermarks are just around the proverbial corner.

Respond

Google's SynthID watermarking is an industry standard also adopted by OpenAI who also provides an online verify tool. You can also ask the Gemini app to verify. iOS Photos does not display C2PA metadata, unfortunately.

Respond

It'll probably cause more problems that it helps, as you can still take a signed photo of an AI image. That is, it gives the illusion of proof, not actual proof.

Respond

I get the false message crime - yelling fire in a crowded nightclub, etc. I don't see the obstruction by him of removing a fake picture. How dare he? It certainly wouldn't happen in the USA. It would be the DA's office that invents fanciful interpretations of the law and brings the full coersive weight of the government down on him, his friends, and family - while they seize the accused assets preventing him from mounting a full defense.

Respond

...and leak edited and false evidence to the media.

Respond

It certainly has happened in the US.

I thought the US recently brought a case against a traveler wiping his phone. If I remember correctly, the US often asks those entering the country to open their phones to see if there are any offending files (questionable enough). This guy had a "duress code" that deleted everything and rendered the files unrecoverable. The feds considered this destroying evidence.

Respond

Intentionally deleting evidence of a crime is a crime. He should only have been charged if they had a specific reason to see the contents of his phone and he intentionally deleted the contents. But if that's the case, it's a pretty standard crime. It's no different than flushing drugs down the toilet if the police are coming in. That's a crime also. Even if they aren't "your" drugs.

Respond

I understand that there was no evidence of an underlying crime. It is being litigated now and an underlying issue is whether the initial request constituted a warrantless search.

Could every "housekeeping" deletion of files be construed as a cover up of a crime without the authorities specifying a crime under investigation?

Respond

>I get the false message crime

I don't. There is no imminent lawless action here to prevent.

Respond

It's the same kind of crime as phoning in a false bomb threat or fire. Wasting public resources and causing a panic is indeed a crime in most places.

Respond

per the article, he sent it to "a colleague," not the police.

Respond

Actually, in the US both private and govt entities would sue the social media company for allowing the doctored photo to be posted. Victimhood must be properly monetized...

Respond

The Straits Times:

[Aug 20] Search ongoing after crocodile sighted at Pandan Reservoir; water activities suspended

[Aug 21] Police investigating after picture of crocodile sighting at Pandan Reservoir found to be fake

[Sept 29] Man charged over fake image of crocodile at Pandan Reservoir:

Ye Lin was handed one charge for transmitting a false message, and another for obstructing the course of justice.

Charge sheets stated that the 30-year-old Myanmar national allegedly sent the AI-generated image of a crocodile at Pandan Reservoir to another person on Aug 20.

He is said to have then deleted the digitally edited image and the Gemini AI application history log from his phone on Aug 21.

Ye, who spoke through an interpreter, said he intends to plead guilty and will not be engaging a lawyer.

Respond

Yet, (YouTube Short) Singapore otters are real.

Respond

Wow, a fake AI-generated video was my first guess, but apparently the video and the otters are real.

Respond

The natural consequence of tasking the govt with regulating "misinformation"...

Respond

Whatever happened to American get-up-and-go? Nobody bothered to fake a photo of a croc in the Memorial Reflecting Pool in Washington.

Respond

Somebody just did this in LA with a fake image of a Gabon viper supposedly on the loose.

Respond

Also the polity that is Singapore.

On the bright side, fewer people are at risk from the crocodiles.

Respond

Police in Singapore have charged a man who is accused of posting an AI-generated image of a saltwater crocodile in a popular reservoir.

Just to be clear, if he had Photoshopped -- is that what boomers used to call it? -- a saltwater crocodile into a picture of a popular reservoir, that would be perfectly fine and would have precipitated no one's moral outrage.

Respond

Singapore is a successful city-state but also a dirigiste economy and society. They even regulate immigration by race.

Respond
Respond

Add Comment