Sunday assorted links

1. New London play about Keynes.

2. Aphantasia, and looking at buildings.

3. AI and job growth in Africa.

4. On Nussbaum, opera, and liberalism.

5. Congress seeks to speed up energy permitting (NYT).

6. Teenager jobs have not disappeared altogether (NYT).

7. An Antikythera field trip and investigation.

Comments

#1. New London play about Keynes.

Great! I'm near Connecticut right now, so I can catch this before I fly home.

Respond

No, the 'Canes play at Florida State next, not at the Coast Guard Academy.

Respond

2. This person with aphantasia has assumed way too much about those without it. Almost nobody is making aesthetic judgments about architecture and art based upon thinking about the subjects in their mind's eye.

Respond

" ... this blazing new play tells the astonishing story of rebel economist and member of the Bloomsbury Group, John Maynard Keynes."

I can't even imagine any economist in any country who was more inserito in the establishment than Keynes.

Respond

"Establishment" in the social and political sense, yes. But Keynes was a rebel and disrupter when it came to economic theory and policy. A dissenter against the Treaty of Versailles. Etc.

Respond

British policy toward Germany changed the year after Versailles was signed. His early theorizing was clarifying, not rebelling, looking behind the money to the real stuff. Even the General Theory is quintessentially English. Schumpeter once wrote that it has the wrong title. Should have been called The Theory of Employment, Interest and Money: The Special Case of England. And England is the only place extreme Keynsianism actually took hold. Here, he would not have approved.

For anything we might reasonably discuss, though, the big problem, then and now, is hagiography in defense of doctrines held on altogether different grounds.

Respond

#7
Antikythera is an amazing object.

Ten years ago we flew to Athens with our kids to see it at the National Archaeological Museum.

But the fact that it was built does not by itself show that it was profitable enough to be produced at scaleโ€”unless, of course, we simply have not yet found the other copies. If more copies had been made and used, one would expect to hear more about them in ancient sources.

Of course, perhaps this particular machine was a prototype lost very early, and some know-how was lost with it. But perhaps it was simply too far ahead of its time, and there was too little market for it.

Not being an expert at all on Greek engineering, I asked ChatGPT about similarly dated engineering products and the scale of their usage.

The contrast is striking. Greek catapults were standardized, described in engineering manuals, produced in dozens and even hundreds, and repeatedly deployed. Even the hysplexโ€”the mechanical starting gate used in Greek stadiumsโ€”appears at several sites, and we even have a surviving contract for one.

So when a Greek engineering product was valuable enough to replicate, traces of replication do exist.

That makes Antikythera even more fascinatingโ€”but perhaps as a technological marvel that was never scaled up.

Why it was not scaled up would seem to me a very good puzzle to solve, and a natural companion to the question: what, exactly, was it able to do? The latter could provide clues for the former.

Respond

Also the ( economically impractical ) Hero's/Heron's Engine:
https://www.artefacts-berlin.de/portfolio-item/heron-of-alexandira-automated-temple-doors/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile

Respond

#1 It is disturbing to me how excited I am about the chance of seeing a play about an.... economist. I think I gotta go outside more...

(I can imagine a Gilbert & Sullivan patter song about Keynes in an operetta version ...

At Versailles in '19 I lectured the Treas-u-ry,
But Clem and Wilson paid no heed at all-to-me;
Reparations so big that Jerry couldn't owe'em,
So I wrote my smashing book in order just to show'em!
Economic Consequences sold out in every-stall,
Though Lloyd and the Frenchies didn't like-it-at-all...

etc. Okay, it needs work...

Respond

https://www.irwincollier.com/chicago-gilbert-and-sullivan-parody-songs-about-classical-and-keynesian-economics/

Respond

You have me thinking about "Keynes!" sung to the tune of "Fame!"....

Respond

"1. New London play about Keynes."
"4. On Nussbaum, opera, and liberalism."

Economics on the theatrical stage, and politics on the operatic stage. Dogs and cats living together -- mass hysteria!

Respond

"7. An Antikythera field trip and investigation."

Nice research project, but an undergraduate (I assume she's an undergrad) has limited skills to do research that advances the field. Still, it could be useful that she has evaluated the state of research and lack of progress on the mechanism.

I think that research could, and to some extent has, proceeded along a couple of lines, a theoretical and virtual one and an empirical mechanical one.

The theoretical approach: we know (mostly) what the mechanism was designed to do. Given that, what should the arrangement of its gears and other mechanisms be? The post mentions one researcher who created a virtual version of the mechanism; the next research step would be to create many virtual versions and compare them to the real one. The ones that are inconsistent can be thrown out, leaving us with a set of virtual models that feasibly could be accurate representations of the lost or damaged parts of the mechanism. We still wouldn't know exactly what the mechanism had inside, but we'd have a range of feasible designs.

The empirical approach, which seems to be what she favors, is to minutely exam the actual mechanism to deduce its date and place of manufacture, the exact materials used, and potentially be able to make educated guesses about who the builders were and what their manufacturing techniques were.

I think both techniques would be helpful, but from the post it sounds like not much current research is being done? Which seems surprising, e.g. ร–tzi the Iceman has been forensically examined to death (figuratively, and beyond death literally). The treasure of King Tut has been examined and catalogued minutely. Maybe an analogy is with the Dead Sea Scrolls, that for decades (and maybe even now) were kept in a highly secure and conserved environment. So secure that only a few researchers were even permitted to look at them, resulting in a slow pace of research.

Respond

Yes, there's nothing wrong with a charismatic young undergrad and internet access - their enthusiasm is laudable.

But it is not clear that their expertise is in any way comparable to that of the many boring middle-aged engineers, scientists and historians who have made significant progress on the object, it's history and context in the ancient Greek world and even on plausibly -period-technology-correct reconstruction of the mechanism.

Respond

I like your points about examining ancient objects.:)

And, repeating myself (sorry!), I would note that ultimately technology fosters progress not through extreme novelty and ingenuity per se, but through its use at scaleโ€”which, seemingly, was not the case here.

Respond

5. Congress seeks to speed up energy permitting (NYT).โ€ 

Naming things is hard. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 sounds very similarโ€”in spiritโ€”to Mark Carney's Bill C-39โ€”Building Canada Strong Act. Are we witnessing the Ascent of Anglo Abundance?

โ€  (Ungated archive) Exasperated by Delays, Congress Aims to Speed Up Energy Permitsโ€”NYT

Respond

I fear the rise of sellable-sound-byte-named bills is what we have been experiencing for quite some time. Somehow it's hard to believe Dems are going to let any environmental regs slip away. Good chance they've carefully worked in some traps they can spring down the road to block anything they don't like. Hopefully Pubs will be extremely vigilant...

Respond

1. music video about AI Safety

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvgrYOPHaBU

Respond

It's unbelievable that "Chandhana" uses footnotes/endnotes to cite...her own rambling observations, instead of the thousands of pages of academic literature by actual archaeologists who have published on this object.

Next to the Nebra Sky Disc, this is probably the most widely argued about and investigated object from antiquity in contemporary history.

When it was discovered, antiquity--o-mania was at a fever pitch along with Egypt-o-mania and archaeologists in Germany and England were international celebrities. The Antikythera has been famous itself ever since.

It's not surprising to see the current iteration of MR encouraging this type of hubris and is a reminder that the founders do not seem to have as much depth on many subjects as they would have one believe, particularly regarding German and British culture.

Respond

6. Or what I did when I gave up my paper route.

Respond

"My personal theory is that the construction took place in Alexandria. It had the strongest inventing culture of the period."

Add the recent conjecture that the Old Testament was written there in the third century BC and that's quite a double-whammy.

Respond
Respond

Add Comment