Discussion about this post

Amitav Krishna's avatar
Lauren Gilbert's avatar

If I was Kahn's child, I am not sure how I would feel about him starting a Substack post that he is a father and not a grandfather. (I agree it is an interesting paper; also that information is not contained in the paper and I would feel weird about it being disclosed to the internet if I was his child.)

On a personal note: I am a childfree only child. My father has (a very serious) cancer, so we have been having a lot of "what regrets do you have" conversations. I asked if he felt like I made his life worse by choosing not to have children. His response was "it would have been nice, people say grandchildren are really special, but you shouldn't have children on my account". I think this is probably the view held by the majority of parents who will not be grandparents.

Jacquelyn Thayer's avatar

A major point that's frustrating me in this discourse (and perhaps it even is touched upon in the original paper) is that many millennials, the generation primarily targeted by this argument as the "Rotten Adult Kids," were themselves the children of parents who were already in their 30s when they were born, given the increase of women in the 1970s and '80s delaying motherhood because they now had more options and opportunities to do so. It seems disingenuous to solely blame today's 30- and 40somethings for compounding the grandchild-grandparent age gap.

19 more comments...

Ready for more?