My mom is the third of four girls. She grew up with much more scarcity than I’ve ever known, and felt the strain from competing with her sisters for care and attention and resources. She was born into a very sexist culture — she and my aunts were destined for young marriages, and education was never considered much of a priority for them. They weren’t allowed to cut their hair, which they kept oiled and tied in ever-thicker and longer braids.
Since she was a little girl, my mom dreamed of having a daughter. Just one, so she could have all of the care and attention and resources without having to share and fight. She dreamed that her daughter would grow up to be highly educated and successful, and go on to marry a highly educated and successful man who would treat her with a level of respect far beyond what my mom grew up expecting from men in her life.
My mom did end up having a daughter, just one. She showered her little girl with so much love, and raising that little girl brought her so much joy.
My mom and I don’t have a ton in common today. It feels like we have two or three generations between us instead of one, and she doesn’t really know me. But I’ve managed to fulfill her dreams,1 and that is one of the things I find most meaningful about my own life.
One thing I do have in common with my mom is that I’ve always loved babies and always dreamed of being a mother. I mostly imagined having girls, except I wanted a lot of them. I imagined making elaborate Easter Egg hunts for them and their school friends. I imagined reading to them from my YA fantasy novels (since I would be a YA fantasy author).
At fifteen, I found EA. It was clear that having kids wouldn’t be the impact maximizing thing. But at the time, I wasn’t so maximizing. I read my Julia Wise, and planned on having a normal family while giving away a large portion of my income. I imagined Easter Egg hunts on a smaller lawn.
Once I found the Bay Area scene and started a full time job, my ambitions rose. I decided I shouldn’t have kids because it would take too much time away from work. At 21, I looked into getting a hysterectomy so the choice would be taken away from me, but no doctor was willing to do this for me.2
As I set out in my career, my efforts felt very removed from impact, and I struggled to motivate myself to work the very long hours I thought I should. I started to feel like the practical tradeoff against work wasn’t quite as stark as I assumed. All that time when I wasn’t working, my life often felt a little empty, and I started to crave the uncorrelated alpha kids could bring. I grew more squishy and ecumenical in my values, and opened up to kids again.
By the time my husband and I were deciding whether to get married, I needed him to be okay having at least one kid. It was a big ask. He was also worried about the impact cost, and wanted it much less. We talked about whether we could just agree to have children after the Singularity. For him, it was like moving to a wealthier country. For me, it was like death. I wanted to know I could have a kid in this life. Eventually, he agreed.
We didn’t actually pull the trigger for a few more years yet.3 We opted for surrogacy, because while it felt worthwhile to take time away from work to care for our child, it didn’t feel worthwhile to take time and energy for pregnancy and birth (something I always found horrifying in the first place). The journey was long and annoying,4 but we eventually hired a wonderful lady who became pregnant with a little boy last spring.
I’d always imagined following in my mom’s footsteps and having my own daughter. But I quickly fell in love with the idea of our son. I looked at old albums of my husband as a little boy and got excited about the idea of watching him grow up. Maybe my son and my husband would talk about niche obsessions together. Maybe they would play video games together. Maybe I’d finally learn how to play video games alongside my son (probably he would quickly beat me). I thought of all the good young men I knew, and how gratifying it would be to create another.
That summer, shortly after my husband got hit by a car and shattered his knee, our surrogate had a miscarriage at twelve weeks. Between the injury and the increasing intensity of our work (especially his), it was an overwhelming time for us. We gave it some months before we tried again.
Our next attempt didn’t take, and we had to wait more months to try again. Then about two months ago, toward the end of the most intense work project I’d ever taken on, I learned that our surrogate was pregnant with identical twins: two little girls.
After last time, I tried not to get my hopes up. I had very little mental space to think about it anyway. My friends told me twin pregnancies were risky and I should do a bunch of research to see if I wanted to run extra tests or even terminate. I decided I would just have to leave this one to God.
It seemed that God was smiling on them; they were developing at the same size,5 and all the bloodwork seemed good. I started to imagine the cute little matching outfits, the tasteful racially ambiguous names that would sound good together. How happy my mom would be to hold her granddaughters, and the dreams she would have for them.
We lost them a few days ago, at fourteen weeks. I found out on a lunch break in the middle of a long workday. I was surprisingly fine, and worked the rest of the day without anyone being the wiser. Late at night, after all the activity died down, I cried myself to sleep.
I’m sad to lose my girls. But it was not even the most stressful part of my week. Other than writing this post and talking to a few friends, it hasn’t occupied much of my attention. I’m sad and frustrated about that, too. I wish I had the mental space to feel more proper grief, and I feel like a bad mother that grief hasn’t grabbed me harder.
The truth is that even over the course of this pregnancy, the prospect of being a parent in the near term has gotten worse and worse. I’ve been working more and more, and the AI situation has been feeling more and more intense. If it had happened for us, we would have made it work, and it would have been wonderful in many ways. But we’re not sure when, or if, we’ll try again.
I have failed in two main respects so far: not getting a Master’s degree, and not having my own children.
At the time, I was angry about the rank paternalism they showed toward a grown adult. I now feel more mixed about it, and my past self feels painfully young to me. Ironically, when I eventually did try for a kid eight years later, I hired a surrogate.
A lot of the reason for our delay is that I told myself I would try to keep pushing at work until I reached some hypothesized “groove” or “stride” or “steady state”, and then go for kids. But every year, work continued to be a struggle in ways old and new, and every year I wished we had just had a kid last year. I don’t know what I actually wish happened. It might have been wonderful to have experienced being a parent for the last few years. It would have been hard to do the work I did in the last few months if I had little kids at home.
This is a whole separate blog post, but the surrogate agency business involves terrible customer service and blatant rent seeking and is ripe for disruption by some sort of app, if anyone is looking for startup ideas.
This is a positive sign about twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome, the main risk of twin pregnancies that share a placenta.
I’m so sorry for your loss
I am sad and angry at the universe for not being what it could be. It's an unreasonable and impotent rage, driven by a need to make it *not this way* without an action to channel that need into.
The vessel of last resort is hope, and lacking anything better I offer all the hope I have to give.
I do not know you well, but you are one of the people I am most grateful to be sharing a world with facing the danger and uncertainty of the present moment. I am very often scared, but less so.
When this is over, if the future is anything like the future that could be, I hope that one day, holding your child, when we are better able to viscerally appreciate problems of scope that for now elude our hearts, you feel and know how many children you've helped, how much joy and goodness you've helped bring into the world.