Discussion about this post

Amitav Krishna's avatar
WSLaFleur's avatar

*sigh*

I have had this experience of getting punched in the head repeatedly while trying to discuss the 'Trans Community' and 'Trans Activism' by people who expect the next words out of my mouth to be a justification for all sorts of action against trans individuals.

*sigh*

Sometimes it feels like the entry fee for having real, serious, nuanced beliefs about complex situations is that you're simply required to put in totally disproportionate amounts of Hermeneutic conversational effort to thread the needle and avoid having your position compressed into something more familiar and easier to process.

(EDIT: One of the most devastating and exhausting things about this sort of reaction is how little effect rapport seems to have on it. Even after somebody has observed supererogatory conversational behavior from you for years, they can still succumb to this sort of knee-jerk immune system response—to which the only constructive thing to do is apply more patience, more effort, and more careful consideration!)

JJ Treadway's avatar

I'd argue an even *better* thing your brother could have done, under the circumstances, would have been to talk to you to ensure that you were *fully informed* about the costs of picking the flute and appropriately taking those costs into account in your decision, but then not put further pressure on you beyond that.

But yeah your broader point (that [problem] + [coping strategy] may well be an improvement over just [problem] even if [coping strategy] looks kinda dumb/bad in isolation) is very much a good one.

Also I'm loving Pass so far!

19 more comments...

Ready for more?