Skip to main content Cheap data is great for Indians, but not for India’s reputation : r/neoliberal

Cheap data is great for Indians, but not for India’s reputation

"BITCH LASAGNA" is the name of a song by PewDiePie. It is also a two-word social history of the relationship between India and the internet. For five years Mr Pie, a Swede whose real name is irrelevant, was the owner-operator of YouTube’s most popular channel. In early 2019, after several months of back-and-forth, he was decisively overtaken by T-Series, a Bollywood studio. In the run-up to his defeat, the Swedish streamer posted what his fans described as a “diss track”, and what anyone else would consider to be bordering on bigotry. Its lyrics include references to open defecation, ridicule of Indian languages as "mumble rap", and a meme about “bobs or vegana” (don’t ask). The song’s title alludes to a Facebook Messenger screenshot of an Indian man requesting unclothed self-portraits from a woman and, on being ignored, hurling the presumably auto-corrected epithet at her. The internet really does bring out the worst in everyone.

Mr Pie’s battle with T-Series marked a turning point in India’s internet adoption. In 2016 Mukesh Ambani, an industrialist who inherited a petrochemical company, took literally the maxim that “data is the new oil” and launched Jio, a mobile network with rock-bottom prices and generous data allowances. Almost overnight, the share of India’s population covered by a modern mobile-broadband network jumped from 4% to 74%. A price war followed. Internet users doubled in just three years from a sixth of India’s people when Jio launched to a third when T-Series triumphed, rising to over two-thirds today. A billion Indians use the internet, or three for every American. Not satisfied with bringing Indians online, Jio also gives them something to do once they get there. Its streaming service, Hotstar, has more than 450m monthly users, well ahead of Netflix or Amazon’s Prime Video. But neither Jio nor anyone else has managed to build a social space Indians prefer to Western ones. Indians are now the largest nationality on YouTube, Instagram and Facebook and a significant minority on X, Reddit and Snapchat. And their influx onto these platforms has been catastrophic for India’s image in the world.

“Bitch Lasagna”, though tasteless, reflects a common stereotype online of Indian men as forever propositioning women on social media. The idea of India as an unsanitary place, too, is depressingly common. And Indians have of late acquired a reputation as fierce nationalists with thin skins and foul mouths. As one viral post on X put it, “Never invade Russia in winter. Never attack India by Twitter.” Some of the criticism is overblown. Crude men and noisy nationalists exist everywhere, but the sheer scale of the Indian contingent makes them more noticeable. Some of it is the result of India’s openness. Because Indians use the same platforms and often post in English, the country’s flaws are more visible than those of other countries.

And some of it may well be cynical. Social-media algorithms prioritise content that elicits strong reactions. YouTube travel videos that portray India as filthy and dysfunctional often attract millions of views. Instagram has lately been flooded with AI-generated videos showing street-food vendors cooking in appallingly unhygienic conditions. Ragebaiting Indians can be a sound commercial strategy, as the 300m-plus views of “Bitch Lasagna” demonstrated. All of which obscures just how fun and indeed funny India’s internet can be. Influencers and YouTubers make material for all tastes. Social-media memes are the currency of youth slang and infiltrate the mainstream, too. This year’s “cockroach” youth protests started life as an online joke. It is only a matter of time before India’s popular culture starts breaking through more widely. Some of it already has. A dance move in a Telugu song called “Naatu Naatu” went viral in 2022 and later won an Oscar. Early this year an extended joke by Azeem Banatwalla, a stand-up comedian, resonated globally. As more culture crosses over, India’s image online will change too.

Until then, India’s reputation provides fodder for content. Mr Banatwalla’s gag was a list of all the traffic violations you can commit in Mumbai for the price of a speeding fine in Norway. Somnath Padhy, another comic, has a routine riffing on how “there are one billion websites in the world [and] I think Indians have commented on all of them.” And Reddit has a community dedicated to “the chaos unleashed by cheap internet”. It is called “Jio was a mistake”.


Join the conversation
New (Default)
Open comment sort options

Comments Section

News and opinion articles require a short submission statement explaining its relevance to the subreddit. Articles without a submission statement will be removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

emoji:tagore: Rabindranath Tagore

Can the Economist stop posting slop

Bitch lasagna flash back

emoji:powell: Jerome Powell

I loled at Mr. Pie

emoji:pif: Pacific Islands Forum
  1. Access to the open internet is a good thing. I know we all have some cynical takes about social media but at the end of the day, China style walled garden internet is antithetical to liberalism

  2. I have not seen all of what's being described in the article. I've certainly felt the rise of Indian internet users on reddit, and there have been some downsides, but the anti India slop isn't something that comes across my feed. This is probably because I'm not doom scrolling the super algorithmfied platforms. Which makes me think this is more of a platform problem and less of a person problem. There are shitty racists everywhere you go in the world. They would be less of a problem if there wasn't an incentive to amplify their shitty racism.

Edited
emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

I've felt this for a long time, I wish India had developed it's own internet complex similar to China. I think it would just be healthier for Indians who don't just get ridiculed. There's a lot of clash online and in the grand scheme of things who cares but it's real, a very niche example of this is the various cricket subs. Because of India's sheer numbers it dominates the discussion and it very clearly pisses off the rest of the cricket fans from the other nations.

There's lots of cringe embarrassing behavior that they clearly don't recognize. The most prominent example that comes to my mind is anytime someone posts a video about India and it has a map of India, and inevitably because they're in the west, they use the map of India that shows Kashmir as disputed. This leads to a massive shitstorm.

There was a prominent youtuber who did a video highlighting India's space program, humble beginnings to enormous success, it was a very flattering towards India all things considered. He got dogpiled by Indian commenters because he used a map of India. Things will get better, but you sandwhich a large group of people who grew up in a different culture into a wildly different one you'll get a clash.

If China's internet wasn't sequestered you'd see a lot more of that as well given how jingoistic some Chinese social media spaces can be.

Edited
emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

The guy who made the video made a very snarky post in response which gave the impression that he expected Indians to be 'grateful' that he covered the country (not out loud but those were the vibes I got). I personally feel that a normal person would learn to distinguish nationalists from regular people and if they felt the need to not want to cover Indian content again, just make a normal response about being uncomfortable about it. I've seen this come up before and it can usually just be addressed by saying that they're using the internationally recognised map and leave it at that.

I don't agree with this because I think a 'firewall' is fundamentally anti-liberal. Indians will have to learn to co-exist with the rest of the internet and develop their own spaces. The latter of which has already happened on the lines of language.

Ultimately the internet will need to live with the changed demographics if we want an ultimately more open and liberal space in the long term.

emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

Why do you believe that Indians will inevitably conform to western online norms? They have the numbers to resist assimilation pressure.

It seems to me that the pre ~2010s/2020s western online culture was a circumstantial aberration that has already substantially eroded—partially population-driven, but also from the rise of algorithms.

emoji:carney: Mark Carney

What exactly are they supposed to even conform to? It's not like nationalists from the US, for example, are any less obnoxious. Fewer of them maybe, but only because of the huge population difference

emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

Because most Indians aren't nationalist thumping weirdos who have no decency towards women?

Like I spend my time in Indian circles. Most people aren't like this. I fail to see why Indians won't gradually conform as the rest of the population pressures them. The scale of every bad apple will be magnified but so will good ones.

emoji:commonwealth: Commonwealth

One dog pile I’ve seen a few times is an insistence from Hindu nationalists thay any discussion or explanation of Hindu texts refers to the stories as Indian history instead of Hindu mythology.

Widespread internet adoption in India brought a very significant wave of new users, a significant number of whom were ignorant, arrogant, and hostile. It was particularly apparent not only because of the sheer numbers, but also in how much of it was wrapped in an overt, aggressive nationalism.

People don’t tend to talk about Christian or Muslim mythology, so they kind of do have a point.

emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

Yeah, the part that bothers me I would just say is that's it not unique to India or Indians, it's just the sheer volume that makes it stand out.

All humans have the same underlying cognitive biases and they're on full display in the internet. A joke amongst Indians is "uncle's whatsapp messages" which are pretty similar to the "crazy uncle at Thanksgiving" or your MAGA uncle posting on Facebook. Not just the nature or tone of the message, even the underlying message is often the same just reskinned in a different context.

It's funny when you see similar things, a common one I've seen is when you see an interview on youtube of a prominent person who happens to be a specific ethnicity.

I've seen people comment "Proud to be x" ranging from India, Pakistan, Albania, Indonesia, Serbia etc.

I don't know, in a way it's fascinating to see how similar we are, the posts we make are so similar just in a different context.

emoji:commonwealth: Commonwealth

You’re not wrong.

The other funny thing is that in a lot of ways I think it has kind of improved since 2016, too. At least in my browsing experience.

Anti-Indian racism has gotten super rampant recently, but it has felt pretty disconnected from Indians online as compared to immigration from India. At least in Canada.

Edited
emoji:transmasc: Transmasc Pride

Instagram has lately been flooded with AI-generated videos showing street-food vendors cooking in appallingly unhygienic conditions.

AI Generated? I remember seeing plenty before AI even existed.

Also I think one thing this article fails to mention is call center scams, Kitboga, etc. It's like how Nigeria used to have that Nigerian Prince scam reputation until people stopped falling for them and it went out of date, like when's the last time you genuinely saw someone bring up Nigerian Scammers. Honestly now that AI voices can do the scamming hopefully it won't be long until people stop associating Indian Accents with "DO NOT REDEEM" and the like, since people will be more aware of AI. As for the nationalism, it's really not that unique it's just a repeat of Wolf Warrior Types China has but unlike China, India has no need for a cyber firewall keeping their people away from the rest of the net.

As for the nationalism, it's really not that unique it's just a repeat of Wolf Warrior Types China has but unlike China

Eh China's wolf warriors were and are arguably worse tbh. The folks who got famous were literally Chinese diplomats working in their foreign consulates.

Edited
emoji:popper: Karl Popper

Yes. A ton of them are either AI generated, decade old videos, or from neighboring states that also use Devanagari script because people who aren't from South Asia can't tell the difference between Nepali, Bengali, or Hindi.

It isn't much different from Vietnam outside of the D1 or Thao Dien bubble.

It's just a repeat of Eternal September. Eventually, Indians who are new to the internet will either assimilate to existing norms of conduct or develop their own, and be no different than everyone else.

Every community that gained mass access to the internet has gone through the same thing with everyone going wild with their perceived anonymity at first, before being forced to tone it down by communal pressure.

Communal pressure only works if the community has the #'s to apply the pressure. I just unsubbed from a subreddit where people helped each other with machine learning problems; I had been a contributing member for years. The community for years tried to fight against what I can only refer to as a localization issue, where the questions were becoming more and more specific to how Indian people - "freshers" was a term they loved - could get jobs, visas, build a quick portfolio to show people overseas, access to American datasets, how to maximize AI to produce results, etc. rather than actually questions about ML fundamentals

It was just impossible to the community to try to put pressure on this issue, because the # of posts and upvoted from Indian people simply prevented the original community composition from existing. I even tried pointing out there was an MLIndia subreddit, but that didn't stop anything.

And before you say xenophobia or anything, the subreddit had the setting where you can see the nationalities of where people were viewing your posts from. India was consistantly #1 by the time I left.

emoji:douglass: Frederick Douglass

Was this r/learnmachinelearning? Because I've seen a very similar dynamic play out there.

No fucking way. Yes it was lmao.

emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

What subreddit was this?
And wouldn't restricting posts solve this? Alongside blocking key words?

Restricting posts and blocking keywords are temporary solution sure, but it goes against the OPs argument about communal pressure being what would "tone down" or change their behavior.

emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

Assimilation pressure is weaker in this case just from sheer numbers, though.

I remember being on the internet in the early 90s and it was mostly only the elites or nerds.

I liked that. I miss it.

It doesn’t mean I’m against more people getting access.

Set aside this article being stupid and already out of date. Online narratives have no bearing on India's future, their success isn't up for an online vote. All that matters is that they keep building up their economy and society, as they've been doing.

And one day those memes will be gone and India will be an object of psychological projection of people's grievances towards their own countries and a rhetorical prop in domestic political disputes, in the way China is today.

By that time Westerners will wish they had spent this time fixing their own problems instead of bickering over China or Israel or India.

emoji:george: Henry George

their success isn't up for an online vote

True, the main consequence of online bigotry will not be affecting India's success, it will be stoking real world bigotry against ethnic Indians living outside India.

The cause of anti-Indian bigotry is not Indian facebook commenters, it's the internal pathologies of those other countries. The Indian diaspora is successful and therefore resented.

emoji:george: Henry George

Yeah ultimately the responsibility for racism is with the racist. I'm just saying the racism will predominantly fall on the Indian diaspora not on Indians living in India.

Yeah, it's obvious that anti-Indian bigotry is growing, and it's not unreasonable at all to figure out why so it can be combated. Accusing anyone trying to figure out why of also being bigoted is counterproductive.

Edited
emoji:worldbank: World Bank

Le heckin wholesum small creator vs big evil corporation

(Bridge incident? What's that?)

FYI, reddit had subs like jailbait, watchn&&&&sdie, c&&ntown at that time and redditors used to vehemently defend these subs as free speech

Free speech is when a white person says something, duh.

That era of peak Horny Indian Commenter memes reminds me a lot of a similar period in time when middle class Chinese tourism exploded and there was a brief period of culture clash where the reputation of Chinese tourists got so bad that the Chinese government had to step in and launch a campaign to shame anyone caught behaving badly. If you went off of what you read online you’d assume that tourist hotspots the world over were being swarmed by young children shitting everywhere.

The 2010s were interesting in that sense, it was like a new manifestation of globalization.

Edited
emoji:eroosevelt: Eleanor Roosevelt

This is a pretty low quality article lol. “Sadly, Indians have a reputation for asking for bobs and vagene. Although, they do be asking for bobs and vagene. Some have racistly pointed this out, but they are also correct. BTW this is all based on my personal internet usage”

emoji:smith: Adam Smith

I would expect no less from the Economist

It isn’t even true that most Americans hate India lol, the country literally polls favorable with similar favorability unfavorably numbers as Ukraine according to Gallup polling from this year.

It’s literally just “I saw this shit on the internet must be representative”

emoji:eroosevelt: Eleanor Roosevelt

Journalists continue to overuse Twitter and have it frame their worldview, even as it has become a Nazi shit hole

I think articles like this are for normie economist subscriber dads for whom this is all completely new and strange information

I managed to stay far far away from anything involving PewDiePie, and only know about this incident from an episode of Darknet Diaries, where the host insisted the whole thing was about individuals vs businesses. See, pdp is one dude, but t series is a business. And as long as the biggest YouTuber is a dude, then YouTube will have to care about individual users 👍

Knowing the whole thing was coated in racism (and not mentioned by Diaries) is not surprising, but also deeply disappointing.

emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

Who cares? Indians having internet access at such scale is an objectively good thing and an achievement (Well we can talk a out the ills of social media but everyone suffers that). These gains have also helped with economic growth and delivery of social security schemes.

Yeah it sucks that this has also encouraged blatant racism but it's ultimately a painful phase that every country faces as it becomes visible. China didn't shed the reputation as being the source for cheap and poor quality products until recently. The internet being less west centric as a whole is also a good thing if you want the demographics of the internet (especially english speaking) to be less Euro and America centric.

In my opinion, it is ultimately noise. Noise that can manifest into dangerous levels of hate but that would exist even without the internet. India building a firewall would just insulate it and encourage even more censorship than it already has.

Seems like an MGS 2 meme

There is a lot of noise, but bad actors can come in and contextualise this noise for a harmful purpose

Not saying that building a firewall is a solution and getting internet has been objectively good for us , but these side - effects are demoralising in my personal life to say the least

Not a very insightful article, it just has talking points ive been seeing since the last 5-6 years and no data or analysis but maybe bc im brown im more prone to have heard the talking points

Surprised its an economist article

Jio’s 4G mobile internet plan was a second Eternal September, for better or worse. IMO, an underappreciated component of the sudden, seemingly out-of-nowhere surge of overt bigotry against South Asians in the last few years is that a lot of young Westerners felt that online spaces they thought were theirs had been “invaded” by Indians, so they were primed to respond positively to politicians, pundits, and influencers channeling those sentiments into “real-world” hatred.

This makes a lotta sense. Its like the older sibling enjoying all the benefits but now theres a new baby in the house and has to be shared

emoji:eu: European Union

Let those who have never made a "diss" track against an entire country consisting entirely of racist stereotypes cast the first stone.

emoji:transfem: Transfem Pride

Economicst is a British paper after all. Reddit was disgustingly racists towards Indians before Jio was a glimmer in Motta Bhai's oligopolistic eyes.I have seen people whining about Indians having subreddit about watches like yea.

PewDiePie is a racists loser

Internet racism against Indians and "pajeet" jokes precede reddit tbh.

I recall back in the aughts there were comments from Americans on Piratebay complaining about Bollywood slur movies being hosted on their American platform. (Piratebay is Swedish.....)

I havent watched him in years, but imo it seems like ever since the Christchurch mass shooting he has steered clear of politics ever since.

emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

“Loser” meaning a person you dislike, right? Because regardless what you think of him, PewDiePie has been enormously successful at life.

emoji:transfem: Transfem Pride

And Donald Trump is the president of America. Being successful doesn't fix the fundamental flaws in their characters.

Edited
emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

Trump is successful, but he’s also wildly insecure and has had numerous highly visible failures (like the midterms). I wouldn’t object to someone calling Trump a loser.

PewDiePie was the most successful streamer in the world then retired from public view to raise a family. I don’t see much of a loser case for him. He might be a racist but idk enough to comment on that.

Racists by definition are losers!

What does the Economist being a British publication have to do with anything?

emoji:commonwealth: Commonwealth

The funny thing is T-Series is literally just a platform for hosting music? Like VEVO or something. The role reversal would be in a universe where India were the US of the world and some Indian Smosh equivalent made a diss track against VEVO and filled it with American stereotypes. Which is quite a funny thought now I think about it.

Rifle or hamburger, whichever will it be?

Sit the fuck down Vevo I'm here to spill the real tea (uh)

You tryna dethrone me from spot on number one

But you American, you lose, so best think you haven't won

When I'm through with you, we're gonna be completely fuckin' done

'Cause we only just begun, I review you

Zero, bye bitch, gone

So come on Vevo, looking hungry for some drama

Here, let me serve you shit hamburger

I'm just gonna say that half the American public thinks China is some provincial backwater stuck in the middle ages... while the other half believes China is several light years ahead of the United States.

Like seriously... caring this much about how other countries feel about your country feels like a tad bit much.

Funnily enough half of china wants the US to think of it as a backwater and the other half wants the US to think of it as being light years ahead

So there is some agreement there

I like how you used a unit of distance to measure time

emoji:george: Henry George

The more light years the more future because light years is IN SPACE.

emoji:eu: European Union

Except this is not about the country but the people.

For them being Indian IS the punchline.

emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

It's the punchline because India is poor. That's literally it. if India was as rich, clean and technologically advanced as China, you'd get dozens of westerns swooning and comparing themselves to it.

It's ultimately the symptom of people treating poverty as a sign of inferiority and backwardness and therefore the right to feel superior to them.

emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

It's 99% the cleanliness. India has a huge issue with this, even in Indian subs you'll see discussion of a lack of "civic sense". I think that's a bit oversimplified and things will get way better but it takes time for these things to change.

emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

Yeah. Things will get worse before they get better. I do think women's safety would also improve its reputation. North India in particular has a nasty reputation of being hostile to female tourists.

It's half the reason. Vietnam is as poor as India and doesn't have half the reputation India has.

The other half is that India shares the same internet as westerners (no firewall) and has a lot of English speakers

Vietnam is like twice as rich as India and has much better urban governance

Theyre also just not that prominent online

emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

Vietnam is about twice of India's per capita today and benefits from being a lot cleaner. Cleanliness is partially poverty but also bad management on India's end but nonetheless it looks bad.

I think it would be an interesting study to figure out if racism against Indians was downstream of India having significantly more state level government workers than local but idk if it's that simple

Edited
emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

I do think it has a big effect. This racism is ultimately very surface level. It's based on pure aesthetic appeal and vibes. India is not a very aesthetic or pleasing place to visit let alone live in. That's the reality.

If your exposure to a large city in India re open drains, stains on walls, garbage and litter being ubiqutious, it will not form a positive image in anyone's mind.

Damn ive never looked at it this way, thanks

I guess if we had also continued our ties with ussr and modern day russia , leftists would be defending us haha

emoji:bi: Bisexual Pride

Probably. A lot of leftists excuse racism against Indians on the basis that Indians themselves are racist, islamophobic nationalists and love countries like Israel. If India was an actively anti-west nation, there would be some odd subset defending it like those who unironically blame the Ukraine war on the US or think Iran is a completely innocent party vis-a-vis Israel lol.

"Probably. A lot of leftists excuse racism against Indians on the basis that Indians themselves are racist, islamophobic nationalists and love countries like Israel."

Jeez, this made me remember when someone posted identical posts being hateful towards Indians and Black people on AITA and showed just how hypocritical redditors can be lol

Comment Image
emoji:friedman: Milton Friedman

Holy shit this is gold. Was there a separate sub/discussion where they posted the results and let people comment?

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmITheAngel/comments/11uhcrm/two_posts_with_the_exact_same_wording_one_about/

^^ Here, this is where I found the screenshot. Some people are agreeing whereas others are saying there were issues in the methodology

This is just justifying PDPs racism against Indians

Edited
Loyal Liberals

It might be me being old, but I have no idea how that guy ever blew up the way he did. MrBeast isn't my cup of tea either, but I can understand how and why. How the PDP channel got so massive is beyond me.

Edited
emoji:yimby: YIMBY

Gaming streaming/let's plays are a very big part of online entertainment, and he was one of the first.

emoji:douglass: Frederick Douglass

Submission statement: This article looks at India's steadily deteriorating reputation in online spaces, and describes it as a consequence of the launch of Jio in 2016, which provided Internet access to a huge swath of people across India and led to a sudden flood of Indians into popular online spaces and social media platforms. It is relevant to the subreddit because it looks at the wider consequences of the chauvinistic/nationalistic attitudes of the general Indian population, and their downstream effects on rising anti-Indian sentiment in Western countries. The article also touches on "how fun and indeed funny" India's internet spaces (Facebook, YouTube, WhatsApp, etc.) have become, and the rising influence of Indian popular culture abroad.

Some of the older redditors here may remember subreddits such as r/indianpeoplefacebook, a once-popular community where people would post screenshots of Indians communicating in broken English on online platforms to humorous effect, and how the moderators of the subreddit closed the community due to concerns that such posts were encouraging anti-Indian sentiment.

!ping IND&WHATSAPP-FORWARDS

Always remember -Pho-

Repost

Repost suggestions