Do you actually want to be 10x agentic or 95th percentile? [for most people, I suspect the answer is no]
There's a phenomenon in the corners of the internet I frequent. Every few months, someone writes a viral post about how to be more agentic, more ambitious, or more skilled, and everyone nods along in agreement.
Two that stood out to me are Nick Cammarata's tweet earlier this year:
"I hate how well asking myself 'if I had 10x the agency I have, what would I do' works"
and Dan Luu's essay from a few years ago arguing that becoming the 95th percentile in any skill is actually pretty easy—if you simply care enough and try. Heck, I even wrote my own: “things I tell myself to be more agentic”
It feels like everyone wholeheartedly endorses the idea of being 10x more agentic, of getting better at everything. How could you not want that? And yet... the vast majority of us, after reading these revelatory posts, sharing them, and perhaps even bookmarking them for future reference, just go back to our normal lives, operating at our usual levels of agency. Revealed preferences tell a different story for most of us, placing us somewhere in percentiles 1-94.
Is it really that these ideas—prompts like "what would I do with more agency," or getting feedback and making a deliberate practice plan—are so groundbreaking that they just never occurred to anyone before these posts hit this corner of the internet? Or is something else at play, keeping nearly everyone from pursuing constant improvement at the highest levels?
Take any task you're working on. If someone told you that doing it 2x better, or 10x faster, or with a tenth of the resources would stop something catastrophic from happening, or they would give you $1,000,000, you'd probably figure it out. Or if a friend was working on the same goal but was much more ambitious or diligent than you and checked in with you every day (or every three hours); or if you hired a tutor, or someone who merely follows up with you with the right prompts to hold you accountable—you’d find a way to do better than you currently are. We all intrinsically know what to do or what it takes. It's the prompting us to think like this and the motivation and mindset of applying this thought to every hour of every day that's often lacking.
I recently read the new book about SpaceX, Reentry, which left me with the simple takeaway that the way to reconcile Elon Musk's corporate achievements with literally all of his public actions showing him to be a deranged doofus is the observation that his companies are built off a single algorithm—hire very smart male engineers who believe the work they are doing is spiritually important, and then interrupt their normal workflows on a constant basis, demanding they: "do this 10x better/faster/with less? Or you are fired, or the project fails." With this group, with this mission, this algorithm works.
If my boss came to me and said the big project I'm working on that was scheduled to be completed next quarter was actually now due in one week, and it was on me to do everything possible to get it done, yeah, maybe I could stomach the request once. But if it happened every quarter (for my current job), while it may work for Musk and SpaceX, I'd just quit. I'm reminded of when I used to work at a large law firm and had to bill 6-minute increments of my time. It wasn't the long hours or the difficult work, or unhappy and constantly stressed colleagues that made me want to quit; it was having to make every 6 minutes a dedicated effort worth billing one client for—and my brain never feeling it had the freedom to relax. I will never go back to working in any job where I need to docket my time in such a way. Musk’s algorithm might build rockets, but I don’t want to live in that kind of pressure cooker. And the thought of always pushing to improve in such a way or be much more ambitious feels a lot like that. It's this relentless drain on my soul.
Okay, but what about something I really care about and would benefit from? I really enjoy blogging, which I mostly do because I enjoy thinking through these ideas, sharing them with people who find them interesting and can help improve my ideas (or benefit from them themselves). Which is to say, while I love writing this, I would be happier if instead of the small number of people who currently read it, it reached orders of magnitude more. So how would I get to 95% in blogging? Or what does the 10x agentic version of myself who is trying to get my blogs read by more people look like?
Well, for starters, I could install an ability to subscribe to my blog. Or create a Substack. Or get a Twitter account. Or begin sharing drafts with an editor or others for feedback. Or spend my spare time doing writing exercises. Or create writing commitment goals. Or post the blog on more link aggregation websites (or create sockpuppet accounts/ask friends to upvote my content). I could send my blogs to key people to read (or ask people kindly to reshare the blog)—or befriend higher-status people with this sole motivation in mind.
If I'm able to come up with these ideas, why don't I actually do them…? Some of them seem like good ideas but take something I do for fun and in a hobby-type way and make it feel icky. Some of them seem like they would be miserable to do. And others seem like only a psychopath would be capable of doing. But I’m going to be honest—as I wrote them out, some of them seem like ideas that I obviously should be doing and this prompt really works.
What’s really interesting to me, though, is how different levels of ambition change the way your strategies for a given action might look. If I want this blog to be read by 2x the number of people versus 100x, the strategies to achieve those goals would be very different. When brainstorming what actions you ought to take, it’s likely worth considering the entire range of 2-10-100x before honing in on what you actually want to do. I’m curious whether the ideas that seem 10x but feel really icky in my head (ie creating sock puppets, mercilessly spamming my blog, building friendships with people who have larger audiences and explicitly requesting they reshare my posts) are actually more impactful than the more practical, realistic incremental improvements—like hiring an editor, sticking to a schedule and asking a few peers for feedback.
In my own experience, moving from Canada to NYC and spending much more time immersed in the world of high-agency, big-thinking internet nerds made ambition feel more default, in this raw, gut-level way. I genuinely feel much more ambitious than I did a few years ago (and no more psychopathic).
Maybe the takeaway from this is that these prompts really do work and are effective, but the framing of being 10x more agentic or 95th percentile isn’t really to get you to those levels, but to inspire ideas that will enable you to be 1.1x more agentic, or 5 percentile points better. More than that, they’re like a mirror: they show you what you’re actually apathetic about, and maybe that’s the point—not to fix it all, but to figure out where you’re okay letting it slide.
Comments Section
I think your missing a huge thing: you’re not a machine. You have emotions and desires and often they are conflicting. You have a part of you that wants to be lazy, a part of you that wants to play, a part of you that wants to achieve at this task, a part of you that wants to explore another task, a part of you that just wants to help your family, a part of you that just wants sex, a part of you that just wants power, etc etc.
Most people don’t make certain choices that increase productivity because there are internal emotional tensions with other desires they have. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy as they say.
Weirdly my pet theory is those that hyper succeed in today’s competitive world are those that are compulsively obsessed with just ONE thing. They often burn all family and friends while achieving but I don’t think they are role models and we shouldn’t emulate them. We should instead tax them and redistribute the gains from their compulsions so the rest of us can live normal balanced happy lives.
There's a fantastic article by David Foster Wallace on the world of professional tennis - and in particular people who are on the edge of being professional - that I'm reminded of: https://www.esquire.com/sports/a5151/the-string-theory-david-foster-wallace/
The final paragraph stuck with me:
Great point!
Always like DFW's writing. At this point I'm really hoping he isn't like Neil Gaiman with some fucked up shit so I can keep liking him.
He had the fucked up shit of the other variety. He took his own life by suicide in 2008, at age 46. Most of his writings are emphatic self-sermons of hope, a battle against uselessness and meaningless. He fought very hard for hope, and I will always be grateful for his work
Oh damn rip. The good writers always take their own lives.
Yeah, that's why Stephen King is still alive
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Foster_Wallace#Abuse_allegations
Sounds like Highly Agentic behavior (seriously).
It's surely a shadow to fight with in all this.
huh?
The anti-social tendencies of DFW as described by the accuser do sound agentic. David Geffen supposedly literally pointed a gun at people's heads and said they must do another take. Apparently Steve Jobs was a total asshole, as are all the other big tech guys anyone can name. Apparently it means you're screwed if you get an email from bezos or musk or zuck or whatever. The requests aren't going to be reasonable or give a gram of fuck about work life balance. Anyway, it's 'par for the course.' Accounts of working for Hillary Clinton are similar. Also, plenty of high-performing professors and researchers abuse their underlings with overwork, sexual misconduct, etc. I daresay this is also common.
Even Ghandi is probably in this list.
It's a common shadow of being highly agentic.
Amen brother. This really is the root of so many of our issues. Our incentive structure and systems reward unhealthy and even antisocial people and behaviors.
Yep.
Blegghhh… was ready to enthusiastically smash the upvote button until that last sentence. Now I can only muster a decidedly unenthusiastic upvote due to that terrible conclusion.
The statement seemingly implies that singularly-focused hyperachievers somehow undermine the ability of “the rest of us” to live normal balanced happy lives - an extraordinary assumption which begs equally extraordinary substantiation. Especially considering the assumption:
is at odds with contemporary understandings of economics
could just as easily be the opposite of true (i.e. the hyperachievers already enable the rest of us to live happy normal balanced lives even if everyone was taxed the same flat rates)
hyperachievers being able to accrue wealth is by no means necessarily at odds with everyone else’s ability to live normal happy balanced lives
hyperachievers could easily go do their hyper-achieving in a lower-tax jurisdiction where we would not reap any benefits of their work
etc x100
My argument is you have to get tax revenues from someone. Those who compulsively work at things have inelastic demand for work so it’s very efficient to tax them compared to others. Additionally having compulsive people as bosses who don’t have balance in their lives can’t empathize with those that do. That leads to bad management usually.
Not necessarily, but you'd have to define hyperachiever. In op's post it seems like a hyperachiever is simply defined as someone who accumulates a lot of money.
Some "hyperachievers" accumulate their wealth by producing something of value that other people want, which is (I assume) the kinds of people you are thinking of. And I agree that that doesn't necessarily interfere with other peoples' ability to live freely.
But the people who accumulate the most money (the hyper-hyperachievers) don't do it that way. They generally do it by starting off wealthy (either by being a regular hyper-achiever or just through inheritance), then leveraging that wealth, individually or collectively, to extract more and more wealth from workers or natural resources, and that definitely interferes with the lives of normal people.
The people at the top of the economy could be called “singularly focused hyperachievers” and they have great influence over people’s ability - or should we say, inability - to live happy lives. Not only are they holding enormous amounts of wealth and necessarily keeping it out of the hands of the everyday person, they make deliberate decisions to influence policy and society. Surely you agree that Elon Musk is affecting people’s ability to live happy lives?
I think this is the wrong way to think about it. If you're able to 10x (or even 2-3x) productivity compared to everyone else, you don't actually need to become a workaholic, dominate your industry, and become master of the world, or whatever.
Capacity for higher levels of productivity can simply allow you to work less. It can also be strived for when you're young, with the longest time horizon for compounding.
Compare someone without much agency, with someone with the capacity for being 10x more agentic. One makes an average income, works an average number of hours, and is subject to average problems. The other can choose to live the same non-agentic lifestyle if they wish, or they can choose to work hard for 40 hours a week and make a lot more money, or choose to work 80 hours a week and almost certainly make millions. I think Christopher Lagan embodies this best. Despite having the capacity to do some pretty impressive things, he actively chooses to live as a farmer. He isn't a farmer for non-agentic reasons, such as that's what his parents did, and he can't imagine himself pursuing any other life.
The capacity for agentic behavior doesn't make one into a machine, although it can, it gives someone the option for a variety of modes of living, with all of them being "better" in almost every meaningful way.
I'd go as far to say that the internal emotional tension that forces someone to laze around and watch TV all day is a fundamentally wrong internal state. If you actively choose to do so despite the capacity to do great things, I disagree, but respect it (although how one can differentiate between that and someone who's controlled by their sloth I don't know). The agentic part of our minds should control when and where we increase productivity, and where we correspondingly increase "play" or any one of the other desires we have.
Isn't he some sort of fraud? Even in the wiki article, it is implied that his IQ score is fake, and he took it multiple times using pseudonyms. I think he went on Michael Knowles (an alt-right grifter), and Michael was embarrassed enough not to put this interview anywhere.
I didn’t know that (I knew the claim of smartest person in the world wasn’t true, but believed his SAT scores).
I think the general point still stands, as at least in my personal life I know at least a couple of very intelligent, agentic people who choose to live a “simple” life. Not many people who are like that have Wikipedia articles though, so it’s hard to demonstrate.
I think a better example of a prodigy who decided to just "chill" would be William Sidis
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_James_Sidis
though, of course, some claims are ridiculous, like
but notice, that unlike Lagan, it was his relatives who claimed that. Though, even with Sidis — he still had intellectual interests (I don't know whether creating a conlang or writing articles — equivalent of having a blog today — could be considered "agentic"). His story is rather a cautionary tale against being a lonely genius polymath, and not a part of the scientific community. Imagine doing all that (building conlangs, writing about cosmology or mathematics), but now having a company of other brilliant people who can also check you.
“I’d go as far to say that the internal emotional tension that forces someone to laze around and watch TV all day is a fundamentally wrong internal state. If you actively choose to do so despite the capacity to do great things, I disagree, but respect it (although how one can differentiate between that and someone who’s controlled by their sloth I don’t know). The agentic part of our minds should control when and where we increase productivity, and where we correspondingly increase “play” or any one of the other desires we have.”
I think your concept of the brain is misunderstanding how it works from my experience. The brain isn’t composed of an overlord that has ultimate agency along with minor emotions. The mind is instead ruled by conflicting emotions and there is a minor part that can negotiate among emotions and create consensus. If you simply try to sublimate emotional states, you are making war within your own mind and those emotions will reemerge in unhealthy ways and make you miserable despite your achievements. People think all they need to do is “have more willpower” when in reality what they need to do is “negotiate a compromise in their mind among conflicting desires”.
I think this is a non-agentic mindset that is self-fulfilling. We tell ourselves we can’t control our emotions, because we often fail to do so, and it’s really hard. Much easier to say “Well, I know I need to exercise, study, or work a little harder, but I need to negotiate with the part of my brain that doesn’t want to do that.”
The advice “be more agentic” isn’t really helpful to a lot of people though, so when someone chimes in “the way to solve obesity is to just consume less calories and burn more” people get fairly annoyed. It’s 100% without the vast majority of obese people’s current ability to walk or run 10 miles a day (or to work up to that over a period of time), which would solve obesity for all those people. Of course most people aren’t able to exert willpower in that way, but that’s not because they fundamentally can’t, it’s a lot more likely it’s because of a mindset like you describe.
You might have decided that you consistently fail to control the parts of your brain your agency disagrees with, so rather than feeling bad (or developing severe stress) about that consistent failure, you create a mental model that accepts negotiation with your lower desires, rather than self-control. I’m sure everyone has different levels of difficulty with this problem (I certainly know it’s incredibly difficult), but I think this falls into the category of comforting lie, rather than truth.
Again, I think you misconceive how human emotions work. You can’t destroy your wants and desires. They are fundamentally a part of you. You can limit them and make sure they express themselves in appropriate ways but the way you conceive of things seems more like conversion therapy for your desires rather than something that would be healthy.
The goal isn’t do “destroy your wants and desires” which portrays self-control as something terrible. The goal is to control and minimize your desires that often, you don’t even actually “want” in the first place.
A great example is doomscrolling social media. A lot of people do it, but they don’t actually want to do it. I hope you’ll agree that there are practical things one can do to first control, then minimize this desire to almost nothing. Similar things can be done with many other aspects of yourself that are undesirable for their own sake, but we do because the modern world is good at hacking our brains evolved for a much different context.
Wanting to browse memes might be “fundamentally a part of you” in that memes are activating a deeper part of your brain you don’t directly control, but that doesn’t mean through deliberate effort you can’t break that habit, and eventually relegate it to something you don’t even think about.
You can subtly associate it with negative things like destroying oneself or conversion therapy, but this is a basic tenant of self control that only has positive effects on one’s life if used correctly. You shouldn’t “destroy your wants and desires” for fun and productive hobbies or spending time with friends and family, and you can’t just turn off those desires like a switch through willpower, but continuous effort to change habits definitely does work, and feeds back into changing your desires for the better.
Your last paragraph is the key one. You will always constantly have desires and impulses, but you can learn to not react to them immediately, and then not in the medium term, and then not really at all. But the real trick isn't that there's some kind of monumental Will Power you call upon and it fixes your problem. Like all things, it is a matter of consistent practice and habit. Just like your point about CICO for dieting, it's true but it only works through months/years of consistent intentional practice.
Some people will have a harder time with this than others though. And maybe that's just passing the willpower buck along; nobody expects you to immediately change your behaviour, but you're expected to consistently and conscientiously make minor adjustments to build new habits. If you're good at practising skills, this might be easier and more natural for you, but if you're not disposed to it or don't have any experience with it, it can seem impossible.
I agree with your take in terms of it being the right thing to do to make it more likely to succeed along these lines, but I think this is by far a minority viewpoint.
Surely the more common view is that to be perceived as "serious" about losing weight, for example, you need to performatively eschew desserts and eat salads and go to the gym 5x a week and try to start running a 10k right away without any ramp up.
Unsurprisingly, this gets results for a few weeks or months, then is given up as "too hard," or because they injured themselves. Thus having valiantly given it their all and failed or been taken out of the game through no fault of their own, they can go back to their previous habits guilt free. And this isn't rare, this is at least the median experience, and probably the vast majority experience.
The vast majority of people don't know the state of the literature, or enough physiology, or what actually works, to do anything BUT this. They're operating on vibes, and what they see other people on tv and in real life do. Since "weight loss" fails for 80-98% of people depending on how low you set the bar, this is a sure recipe for failure.
People are really bad at slow incremental change, and Atomic Habits-style incorporation of ongoing changes in a way that sticks.
Practically nobody knows that it works better than the vibes / performative way, and even of the people that DO know that, probably less than half ever actually do it successfully.
That "less than half up there" is probably where willpower comes in, but there's definitely a "meta" dynamic there where most people don't even know that there are better moves than others, or that there are rules of the game, or even what game they're playing.
If time can do it, damn it, so can I!
But, like a good prisoner's dilemma, if you don't emulate them (ie, defect with them), there'll be consequences.
I'd say that these emotional tensions are not necessarily endorsed, to be explicit about why I think your argument goes against the title of the post of "do you actually want to be". I don't endorse a lot of my laziness, even from a "get the most out of entertainment", a lot of it is just reticence to start rather than an actual "oh I haven't read any fiction today, that's making me dull/bored".
It seems to me like you're describing what 99.9th percentile blogging would be like and saying that's 95th percentile. If you're a regular blogger, 95th percentile readership (avg views x posts) really isn't that hard, because most people with blogs don't blog regularly at all. This is the kind of intuition you get from seeing a lot of distributions (of user contributions to forums, of customer purchases, etc). That's why I think Dan Luu is still right that
On the other hand, Nick's 10x agency seems completely different than Dan's 95th percentile in competence to me, and Nick's "one weird trick" doesn't work at all for me. I'm naturally hardworking but only moderately agentic, and I'm privileged enough to know friends and work peers who I consider truly 10x agency vs me. There is no combination of tricks I can think of, and not for lack of desperate trying, that has reliably closed the yawning agency gap between me and them.
95th percentile is 1 in 20. that's not that many people. that's the level of competency I would expect for say, a middle-school teacher of X subject
I think the real hidden advantage of taking agency and doing 10x the work in the same amount of time are the lessons learned from those few days of crunch time. Realizing that most of what a project constitutes is just wasted time, and if you really force yourself to boil off the slag, thing can get done extremely quickly. At the end you're left with an understanding on how to get more done with less, in less time, which makes the normal work time even less stressful. Unless of course you allow this mindset to poison you, so you procrastinate until a quarter-long project is due in a week, then the psychological burden of the unfinished project hangs over you like the Sword of Damocles.
If only we could turn procrastinated, last-minute energy on at will.
If you could actually finish a project that takes you a quarter in a week, you could plausibly get by while only doing 4 weeks of work per year. Maybe the existing corporate structure can't contain something like that without just making you work more for little more pay, but freelancing as a consultant, (or starting your own firm), while bringing the same energy, even if you only initially make 1/2 (or 1/4, or 1/8) as much, would allow you to profit significantly from the 10x energy.
You absolutely can, but it's the worrying if the end result is any good that takes a toll. And some of that "worrying time" you actually might be spending for thoughts that make the end result much higher standard.
You can write a book in a week, but not all books could have been written in a week.
I think a high-agency person would have enough agency to see that worrying about something pointlessly is a low-agency activity and instead just make progress towards the thing they’re worrying about.
Ignoring his own emotions doing so. It does not ask the same amount of energy for everyone to "stop worrying", even if the reason is pointless.
Being able to make progress towards the thing we’re worrying about seems to be a strong evolutionary advantage as first glance. Maybe it's not so simple.
A lot of times when I take a break and idly think about things, I come up with a much better idea than what would have happened if I tried to brute force the current approach.
I think what I'm saying is being misinterpreted as "You should always work with 10x the energy and just plow forward like a bulldozer"
I'm not saying that this is a thing you should do all the time, but something that should be practiced, and developed into a skill that can be used situationally, just like taking time to reflect and consider without getting anything done. They are all tools, and this one might be a hammer, but you're going to have a lot of trouble building a house if you're missing a hammer.
A lot of times what needs to get done is a known quantity, it's well understood, and through more weight at the problem actually does solve things. In those cases, where you know what needs to get done, bringing strong energy to the problem can move (literally?) mountains.
All of your examples seem to be 'what if being more agentic means my employer could exploit me more thoroughly, or if I could use it to do things I don't want to do that would make my life worse'?
That's... not what being agentic is. I kind of feel like you have 'agentic' confused with 'grindset', or something.
Being agentic is just not having akrasia, not doing things you know you don't want to do, doing things you know you want to do. You don't have to also decide to do things that are against your utility function, you can just figure out what optimizes your utility function and actually do it.
If you rationally decide, on deep reflection, that being lazy and coasting through life is what will make you happiest, then you can be agentic by coasting as well as possible, lounging around watching movies that are moving and enjoyable instead of lounging around doomscrolling social media, calling your friends or romantic interests to hang out with you around the house instead of being too socially anxious and just vegetating alone, etc.
Hm, I’ve moved back to the suburbs and away from the big-city grind and have noticed that my ambition has dropped dramatically.
Not psychological ambition (I have big goals in my head!) but not being surrounded by folks who are grinding every day (but rather, are much more laid back here) I feel has impacted my ability to put into action my high-level ambition.
Curious how moving to NYC changed things for you, as I’m wondering if the opposite-ish move has affected me.
If you liked Reentry I would also suggest How Big Things Get Done: The Surprising Factors That Determine the Fate of Every Project, from Home Renovations to Space Exploration and Everything In Between. SpaceX succeeds I think because of the clarity and pure focus of its goal.
Second this - How Big Things Get Done is a great book. Also, the authors name is "Bent Flyvbjerg," which, C'MON! You gotta read it just for that name!
I reviewed it here for anyone interested in a taste before reading the whole book, but it's def worth it to read the whole book.
I think much of it comes down to personality and genetics. For the hyper productive it’s essentially a way of life. For the specific thing it doesn’t really require a lot of effort. It’s also very domain specific.
I think the genetics portion is under rated in general discourse, and not just raw intelligence but the physical health to execute your hyper productivity.
Through college I (subjectively) felt hyper productive - as soon as I hit 23, my health crashed. I’m “stuck” (but objectively very blessed) in a job that allows me to live life in the slow lane (work from home, get done all the work I need in a 40 hour week done in 20, flexible hours and comfortable pay). But that itch of hyper productivity is still there. Some days I’m grateful for it for all the reasons other people commented on here. Other times it’s maddening.
Not sure why I’m commenting on this other than to ask if anyone else is in a similar situation, and if you have tools to help navigate the transition.
Exactly the same. One thing that helps hyper productivity and that I do is exactly what op States. To do lists
Some agentic thinking is about recognising you can just do things rather than spin your wheels, and in that sense it can be actually easier to be an agentic person. When I was working I was always amazed about how scared a lot people were of taking responsibility for fear of being blamed if something went wrong, even when any kind of decision would be better than the status quo.
I like this text, where can I read more of your stuff?
(Inb4 the irony of finding new methods to be a more efficient blogger)
Thank you for the kind comment.
Here is where I am posting all of my recent writing: https://danfrank.ca/blog/
Some articles I particularly enjoyed writing:
Daniel-isms: 50 Ideas for Life I Repeatedly Share
Most singers become singers because they want to be singers, not because they want to sing
How a Basketball Statistic Changed How I See the World
I like the thought gives me fresh wider perspective, similar to considering what you ideally want to be written on your grave stone, or what if the current moment is the only thing there ever is.
There is a meta level that missing here. I want to be 10x of myself. Just 10x effort adjusted. Not zombie 10x pure better performance.
It’s like stock trading. Anyone with three brain cells to rub together wants to maximize something like sharp or sortino ratio not mere returns.
Npc idiots think 10x means slave harder. Real 10x means do 10times less work for the same reward or take on 10x as much work and get 100x the reward.
But 10x reward for 10x effort is absolutely brain dead. Why would anyone seriously consider that?
What I want is to be 10x more agentic with equal amount of work, stress, and so on.
It is true that right now that right now I could be far more agentic towards a particular goal by stressing about it and spending more time and focus on it. You spend a lot of time in the post talking about this. But this would be at the expense of other goals and my general well-being, which is why I don't do it.
As a long-time software developer ...
A while back, I had some thoughts about the coming AIs that were starting to increase developer productivity. Making it more efficient, essentially. Do more with less. And then there's Jevon's Paradox - so, the more efficiently we can produce software, the more we'll want to produce. And frankly, the more productive a given minute spent developing software, the more costly a minute not spent doing so becomes.
Ugh, now there's a slap to the face, yeah? You start off thinking, wow these tools will make me more productive, I'll be able to get more done, I'll have more free time..? Except, no, the opposite. You'll have less and less. The pressure to be spending your time working and not falling behind will increase. Because those that spend all that time working will get so far ahead of you, there'll be little point in you trying to compete with them.
It was such a disheartening thought. It's not what almost any of us wanted out of increased productivity. We wanted leisure and fun! We wanted more time for ourselves, but we'll get less.
Ultimately, the problem with supreme ambition and "agency" is it is somewhat orthogonal to value. Happiness. Self-contentment. What's worth living for. It can easily become a trap. A bad dream maybe you wake up from in your 60s or 70s and realize it was all kind of a waste?
I skimmed this in a hurry because your part about Musk aligns too perfectly with a thought I was having earlier.
My genome, which I suspect is fairly typical for high performing European-descended technical personnel, has markers that correlate to ADHD, high testosterone, and high intelligence. The last is a gimme, but the first two suggest that I am mentally and physically resilient to stress, but also prone to distraction in the absence of stress. Those are in fact the case. So, to generalize from N=1, the Musk companies (and similar environments) are manipulating the stress response of people who perform at their best under stress and only under stress.
That points to an easy answer to your question: many people don’t like stress. Presumably that’s where the testosterone and the social framing kick in: our young engineer needs to prove their worth.
What I was actually thinking about earlier was why western Europe has been so anemic in recent history (post decolonization or post Cold War). I guess they are just exercising, fucking, and enjoying the scenery like any high test ADHD person who doesn’t have anything left to prove.
About the “10x faster” type demands from Musk-like people: from my experiences in (what I see as) similar circumstances, it does stress you out, but for some, the stress can be addicting in a way. It ends up being all-consuming and shuts out whatever else is going on in life. Afterwards you feel proud, exhausted, but also a bit empty, now that the purpose has been fulfilled and there’s a vacuum of purpose left behind.
About “95th percentile” — I’m skeptical of Dan Luu’s post since it depends on comparing oneself with people who aren’t attempting to improve in any real or systematic way, like winning a foot race race against people walking on the sidewalk. The remainder is deliberate practice, which is already a well-established idea.
Disclaimer: I kinda skimmed cause it's late and I'm about to watch a movie. Might have other thoughts upon a closer reading and more engagement with other comments. Below are initial thoughts.
This seems to confuse a couple things. I do think you're correct that there are some things we think we want, that we actually don't. For example, I like the idea of being a rock climber, but I think it's fair to say that by my revealed preferences, I don't actually like it all that much. On the other extreme, I might want to be able to bench three plates -- but no matter how hard I will it, I'm not getting that weight off the rack. I was going to use quitting smoking as an example, but I chose this one because it's unambiguously nothing to do with anything that might be called willpower.
Most things are somewhere shy of this -- à la Kahnemann, I think it was, we might think of the individual as a collection of competing utility functions. One might want to quit smoking, the other really really wants to keep smoking. To me, agency means the tendency to optimize on the former rather than the latter. And we might decompose that into trait agency and state agency. The former being, being the sort of person to whom making that choice comes easily, and the latter being, making that choice actively, willing yourself to be more agentic. Neither, I think, imply I should go rock climbing more often. (That said, I do think a more agentic myself would have started to go rock climbing more often, decided he didn't like it that much, and then stop.)
Folks always conflate excellence with agency. Motivation for excellence is one thing, but agency is different. Excellence is motivated by being seen and heard. Agency's motives spring from choice--not from being on a stage. When you are "agententic," the thing is IN you, like a beating heart, regardless of who sees you. That's more powerful to me than simply wanting to be the best for fame or fortune.
The reason most people aren't agents in that way is because their minds are fragmented. They are literally double minded people, brains working at cross purposes on an implicit level. The reasons are all unique, like the one who believes the bully who told them they'd fail--not so much in the rational brain but in the bodily brain. Or there's implicit fear of success, like the boy whose mother's success enabled her to leave him behind with his deadbeat dad. Implicit pain or fear fragments the implicit mind. These things sabotage agency.
Pure agency is a function of integrity. BEING over doing. The agent doesn't check boxes, doesn't perform. He's Integrated. Present. Fearless, not just in the conscious headspace, but all the way through to the primitive brain. Elon Musk can't use fear to produce presence. He might get to excellence. Maybe. Presence is antithetical to fear. The byproducts of true presence ARE excellent, but you can't fake it. I've no desire to be frantically excellent. But a true agent--? Definitely.
The way is in attention to tensions. Committing to pain. And stillness. Patience. Checking your motives. Over and over again. You don't need a monastery or quiet space. You just need a piece of work--whatever is immediately in front of you.
These people just want more status, not more consciousness.
Comment deleted by user
God I hate how real this is lol
Hey, qq - I see you posting both here and in the PI subreddit, I had a question about your take on the whole Duterte thing - I've been looking for sharp people who have an opinion. I tried to message but you have a whitelist, if you'd be up for that discussion, lmk.
Comment deleted by user
How do you set up a whitelist?
Thanks!
To my mind, there's multiple layers on the Duterte thing, but I could be totally misunderstanding some of them:
The actual fact of legalizing "killing whoever you want, then throwing a baggie of drugs on them," with some likely political maneuvers in the killings, and ~10-40k dead
The fact that this did apparently decrease drug usage and crime (unsurprisingly), although in ways I've never been able to find a good quantification for
The fact that a bona fide, elected leader of a sovereign nation passed laws via whatever legitimate processes existed, and now a decade later is being prosecuted by an outside, Western, developed country for those laws
The fact that this is literally maximally positive for Sara Duterte's election chances, and is suspiciously optimally timed to get her and her family name in the news continually, for free, in a very sympathetic way, in the time right before the election
With my own fairly limited understanding, my best precis of what's going on is "this is either a politically-motivated persecution by Noynoy that severely backfired, or a 4d chess move by Sara to ensure she gets elected."
Either way, the thought of the ICC beating up on a less militarily capable, poorer country for something an elected leader did that was definitionally legal (because they passed laws allowing it) seems extremely fucked up and like a terrible precedent - just try doing that to China, or Iran, or Russia.
I really don't know enough about internal politics in PI to understand how these bits and pieces come together into what's actually happening out in the real world, and this is why I was pretty interested in hearing your thoughts.
I know basically nothing about the Philippines and can't really contribute on that front, but one point I'll note:
My perspective as a liberal interventionist on this is that you can make legal whatever you want. To Godwin's law the conversation, the Holocaust was legal, under German law. We entered the war to stop German conquest of Europe, but even if it stayed entirely within their borders, I think intervention would have been justified.
As for precedent, I'd like to do it to them too, if I could (and the US as well, for what crimes we may have committed). It's like law enforcement in general; just because you can't get the biggest gangs under control doesn't mean you stop trying entirely.
That said, none of this is an argument for ICC jurisdiction over the Philippines in particular, which from a brief overview I would guess they lack. I think we should establish bodies/law with such universal jurisdiction, but the ICC lacks it, and I'm not sure I'd argue they should have it in this particular case.
Comment deleted by user
Wow, thanks for that context on 1), I assumed there had been explicit initiatives passed in terms of law. Singapore does the "death to drug offenses" thing, and Thailand did a similar Duterte style homicidal crackdown, which I assumed was frameworked legally, but maybe wasn't?
Looking forward to your thoughts on the other stuff.
Comment deleted by user
Thanks, super interesting, and I really appreciate your thoughts.
So you think Noynoy is a lock, basically, and all the free coverage of protests and media and social media doesn't really matter, because she's pissed off the current national and international powers that be, and will be disqualified by force majeure?
Comment removed by moderator
This comment is basically just eliding the distinction between trait and state characteristics, and assuming/asserting that only trait agency exists/matters. But what difference does it make to me whether Obama naturally had that spark in him, or whether he had to will himself out of bed every day to do what he needed to achieve his long term goals? Under your definition, only the former Obama was actually agentic/an agent, and I think it would be silly to say the latter isn't (cf. the Chinese room).
I guess then, if you want, you can reserve the word "agency" for what I call trait agency. But then, I and many others want to learn to emulate the behavior of agents in such a way as to be able to be indistinguishable from them. Call that whatever you want, but I know it's possible, with the right environment. I know that no external pressure is insufficient, and that a drill instructor at a military boot camp would almost certainly be sufficient. The question, then, is what, short of that latter source of pressure, is sufficient to achieve my goals? That's what we're talking about.
C'mon man, don't leave us hanging! What's it like working for Musk?
Comment removed by moderator
Thanks for replying!