This week’s newsletter brought to you by the Pit of Despair — otherwise known as being a fan of the Seattle Mariners Baseball Club.
Is This a Kissing Book?: Anna Louie Sussman tackles the “impossibility of family”
New Polling Update: Life is pain, Highness. Anyone who says differently is selling something.
Parting Shots
Is This a Kissing Book?
There are few journalists today working on questions of family better at capturing the zeitgeist of the liberal elite than Anna Louie Sussman. That is not meant to damn with faint praise (some of my best friends are in the liberal elite, or close to it)! Sussman’s work frequently both reflects and thoughtfully answers the questions that consume the audience of the New Yorker, the New York Times, the New York Review of Books, and other prestige publications she’s written for (check out her full bibliography at her website.) She is also, as of this month, the author of “Inconceivable: The Impossibility of Family in an Age of Uncertainty – A Journalist’s Global Investigation into the Forces Keeping People from the Families They Want,” available now on Amazon or wherever fine books are sold.
Sussman graciously allowed me to read an advance copy of the book before publication, and this is what the publishers put in her promotional material:
“Anna Louie Sussman has delivered a thoughtful, deeply reported investigation into contemporary family formation, giving voice to those who feel parenthood and partnership have become so seemingly out of reach. Inconceivable will start innumerable conversations among those who see declining marriage and fertility rates both in the U.S. and around the world, and wonder what, if anything, can be done to change our trajectory. You may not agree with her answers—but you can’t deny that Sussman is asking the right questions.”
I’m never entirely certain what the proper protocol is in reviewing a book that you’ve already blurbed, so I’ve turned down an invitation to do a proper review elsewhere and will instead engage in the discourse started by Sussman’s book, including an interview with Sussman conducted by Vox’s Rachel Cohen Booth, a review from the right by Jennifer Lahl MA, BSN, RN for the American Reformer Substack, a review from the left by Margaret Talbot for The New Yorker, and a review from the center-left by Darby Saxbe for her Substack, Natal Gazing.
All of the reviewers and I agree that Sussman is incredibly effective at finding individual stories that illustrate one of her book’s main points — that the decline in fertility, though it defies easy characterization, cannot be explained just in terms of the burdens on new parents, or on women specifically. We can never stop emphasizing that the baby bust is decidedly downstream of the relationship recession, and as men and women find it harder to connect, pair off, and settle down, our fertility rates will continue to reflect that failure to launch. I assigned her New York Times essay on why contemporary dating is so depressing for so many women to my students in the Hertog Foundation’s seminar on Politics and the Family this summer because I think it colorfully depicts so much of what’s going (or gone) wrong with how young adults today meet and date.
In her interview with Booth, Sussman seems to edge away from her subtitle a touch — is it actually impossible to start a family, or is it just really hard, especially given the tradeoffs involved? Some of the individuals she talks to for her book were involved in long-term relationships that ended up not working out; others made the choice to pursue careers with lots of international travel and long, grinding hours that made it difficult to date with intentionality. “I really want to highlight is how individual these negotiations are,” she tells Booth, “whether you come down on it being impossible or whether you want to lower your standards.”
And I don’t doubt that is how it feels for a lot of women (in particular) who want to achieve career success while facing the inexorable reality of biology’s limits. As we know from Marcia Inhorn’s work in Motherhood on Ice, a growing number of college-educated women are choosing to freeze their eggs not necessarily because they are deliberately choosing career over parenthood, but as an insurance policy because committed partnership doesn’t seem in the cards. It is certainly tough medicine to tell the audience who sees themselves in Sussman’s portraits that different choices might be necessary to avoid being trapped in the situation too many of her interview suspects find themselves in — with time running out and few viable romantic interests in the offing. And it may well feel like “lowering your standards” to say some career opportunities or presumed deal-breakers might need to be traded in if you’re hoping to start trying to have a family at age 33 than age 39.
But an undeniable side effect of a culture in which marriage is pushed to later and later ages (for those who marry at all) is an unavoidable narrowing of time, and the fight to reclaim it through technological means with a very mixed track record (Sussman herself recognizes the eugenicist, even creepy, ends to which some assisted reproduction tools, which she benefited from, are being put to use by Silicon Valley types.) Better messaging — and messengers — about the limits of fertility windows, the availability of careers that can harmonize with family life, and more deliberate attention paid to how institutions can help provide young people with the opportunities and scaffolding to more easily (and safely) mix and meet up could all help more young people have a more realistic view of what is needed to achieve relationship and career success.1
Sussman is quick to blame capitalism for some of the ills she reports on, and she’s not fully wrong to do so — dating apps operate on an explicit market logic, social media fuels a meat-market emphasis on appearance and branding, intimacy is degraded and cheapened by widespread access to graphic pornography. We’ve allowed the logic of the marketplace to too thoroughly invade decisions around family and reproduction in ways that voices from across the political aisle should be able to identify. As Lahl notes, attempting to use assisted reproduction technologies to solve these problems — while it may work for some — is ultimately a leaky patch to slap on much deeper social problems: “It is somewhat strange that a book this attentive to structural failure never turns the same attention on the structure of the fertility industry it keeps offering as the safety net underneath everyone else’s story.”
But while modern capitalism has its flaws, it has also led to high and rising living standards, and that’s where a right-of-center reader will find himself or herself growing frustrated with Sussman’s point of view. Indeed, part of the reason that people are delaying marriage for professional success is because so much of our identity has become bound up in career — itself a product of a post-scarcity economy that allows more people to find meaning, rather than just a daily wage, through work. As Talbot notes, Sussman is exceptionally motivated by an economic story of fertility decline, looking longingly at the social welfare state of the Nordics while recognizing that that hasn’t been enough to forestall falling birth rates there.
Inconceivable captures something of the feeling of precarity — that even if something isn’t going wrong now, it might go wrong soon, so better to avoid risks — that characterizes so much of Millennial economic discourse (Zoomers, for their part, seem more inclined to a frustrating nihilism.) But, of course, today’s 20- and 30-somethings aren’t the first people to take a risk by considering parenthood. It’s more accurate to say that we have more to lose than generations prior, whether that’s in actual earnings or career prospects. And that sense of affluence, rather than precarity, driving birth rates lower matches up with the best available data, which shows that out-of-pocket costs do not actually describe much of falling fertility in the U.S., and that changing attitudes about parenthood and the sacrifices required therein are at least as much to blame. I find Saxbe’s suggestion that perhaps “better fertility education and culture change to raise the value of parenthood would do more to move the needle on the fulfillment of fertility intentions than affordable childcare policy” quite worth experimenting with.
You will not regret picking Inconceivable to enter into the world of Sussman and her peers, if only to get a glimpse into what separates progressive pro-natalism from its more conservative variants. Even in her interview with Vox, Sussman is never quite able to make the normative claim:
“Having kids for people who want to have kids is good. But I don’t know, I do hesitate to privilege that relationship above all others because of what doing so means. If you say having kids is good, well, who has kids? That immediately has gendered implications and instantly puts an onus on women.”
Conservatives aren’t out trying to make people who don’t want kids into parents. But we are, I think, out to make people who think they don’t want kids to realize that — for many, many people — they will find their lives richer and more meaningful than if they do not. The left, it seems to me, needs to bite that bullet for parenthood to become something more than just one life path among many. The right, for its part, needs to more fundamentally grapple with the structural tradeoffs and sacrifices parenthood always involves (as well as the “onus” it puts on women that will deserve special care). Not all of them can be massaged away; sometimes, the sacrifices are necessary and worthwhile even if they come at a cost that can never be truly compensated. But a more pro-family society would be one that treats them with the seriousness they deserve — as Sussman does. The prospects for a better conversation around family policy, in other words, may turn out to only be mostly dead.
New Polling Update
A new poll from American Policy Ventures and BPC Action gives an update on the political status of pro-family efforts, and the news is, well, the same as usual.
A greater emphasis on families always polls well on paper, and this one is no different: a firm two-thirds of Americans say the federal government is doing “too little” to help Americans who are raising families. Again, two-thirds of likely voters (is it the same two-thirds? We’ll never know) said they support the newly-created Trump accounts for newborns.
To no one’s surprise, the electorate names inflation and the economy as its top concern, with six in ten respondents saying they feel the country is headed down the “wrong track.” One-third of respondents with children at home named inflation as their “top” political priority this November, so if Republicans are hoping to distract families from the cost of gas they may be disappointed in the results.
There’s other evidence that active family policy still has a generational fight to win on the right. The only sub-demographic by age and sex in which fewer than 60% of respondents agreed with the sentiment that the government was doing “too little” for families was among men age 55 and over. Break it out by party ID and sex, and less than half of Republican men agreed with that sentiment as well, while 54% of Republican women did so. (Democrats, of course, nearly broke the scales in agreeing with that statement.) We don’t have age by sex by party ID breakdowns, but a commonsense extrapolation (along with plenty of anecdotes) suggests that older Republican men are uniquely hesitant to see their party embrace anything that feels too aggressive in the family policy arena. Over a long enough time horizon, I suspect that will fade — how soon, who’s to say.
Another, different generational gap is on display in a new report out this morning from The Harris Poll. For a while, the best available evidence is that the decline in religion had stalled out among Gen Z. This poll is the latest to show some evidence of a potential rebound. In this survey, a full one-third of Gen Zers describe themselves as “religious.” Another half of respondents described themselves as either “spiritual but not religious” or “both spiritual and religious.” Secularism, it seems, may not yet have the final word.
It’s not always conventional religion - young adults are still (reportedly) less likely to pray than older generations, and more likely to turn to manifestation, astrology, or tarot. But the report suggests a hunger for in-person community, in particular, that belonging to a religious congregation can provide. It’s still too early to declare religion officially “back” (we still have a lot of what demographers might refer to as cohort replacement to churn through) — but the future picture seems less assuredly one of decline than we might have guessed even a decade ago.
As a reminder — only paid subscribers are able to comment on Family Matters posts. Subscribe today to give yourself not just the phenomenal cosmic power of being able to comment, but the warm glow of supporting high-quality family policy writing.
Parting Shots
My EPPC colleague Jamie Bryan Hall gives much-needed context to recent ProPublica reporting, with his look at CDC data showing “both the pro-life states that would ban abortion post-Dobbs and the pro-choice states that would not have done so experienced far higher rates of ectopic-pregnancy-related deaths since the removal of the in-person safeguards for abortion pills.” (National Review)
It should shock no one that DraftKings uses analytics to “target losing gamblers with promotions that encourage more betting” — the very group of bettors who are most likely to develop gambling addiction. In-depth reporting from Alex Klavens, Walt Bogdanich and Jenny Vrentas for the New York Times.
My EPPC colleague Andrew Walker writes a column on Christian nationalism, pointing out that one cannot simply “declare” a Christian nation into being, à la the Office’s Michael Scott (WORLD)
In North Dakota, voters will determine whether to approve a constitutional measure that would provide free breakfast and lunch to K-12 students.
Washington, D.C., is facing a budget crunch, and cut back paid leave benefits — but smartly focused the reductions in family and medical leave, leaving the benefits for new parents untouched. There’s a lesson there!
Joe Waters and Elliot Haspel contribute to a symposium about schooling by pointing out that the lines between education policy and family policy are often fuzzy (Democracy)
“You’ll do anything for your baby,” reports Chabeli Carrazana in a sharp piece for The 19th. “The algorithm knows how to exploit that.” (Influencers, I continue to aver, are bad news.)
Joel Kotkin calls for a “new humanism” in the face of the oncoming politics of depopulation (National Review)
Washington state discovered an estimated $37 million in questionable child care subsidy costs, so the state is reverting back to attendance-, rather than enrollment-, based billing (KOMO)
The Mother & Infant Cash Coalition says pro-family values and fiscal efficiency are drawing GOP support for upfront cash assistance to new parents, reports FOX News
In their analysis of plans that could expand eligibility for the CCDBG to stay-at-home parents, as previously discussed in Family Matters, Adam Michel and Krit Chanwong estimate such a change “would increase the eligible population by roughly 40 percent in the average state.”
Comments and criticism both welcome, albeit not quite equally; send me a postcard, drop me a line, and then sign up for more content and analysis from EPPC scholars.
Different solutions would need to be emphasized for non-college Americans, but they are less the subject of Sussman’s reporting.