Chris Lakin's avatar

my favorite mindset for flirting is that it’s predetermined: either you’re already compatible with the other person, or you’re already incompatible. flirting isn’t “convincing” the other person to like you, it’s *revealing*

How many kids should I have if I want my lineage to exist in the future?

You probably need to have at least 4!

This is an interesting, and difficult, question. TFR (total fertility rate) all over the world has been declining, the share of women with 0 kids has been growing in every developed country, and demographers routinely, howlingly overestimate what TFR will be in the next generation (generally by about 15% in recent decades). All the headwinds are vastly against us.

What I have done here is model various TFR scenarios in America to determine your chances of lineage preservation at a given number of kids.

America is already down to 1.6 children per woman following a big TFR decline beginning during the 2008 Great Recession. Worse, given worldwide trends, we should probably expect further decreases, which I've modeled in a few scenarios.

What you're seeing in the chart

  • The blue line in the chart assumes that we stabilize around 1.5 - 1.6 TFR, with ~28% childlessness.

  • The orange line is we decline 8% per generation for 3 generations, then level off at .9 of the third generation, with childlessness reaching 31% - 37%.

  • The gray line declines 15% for 3 generations, then levels off at S Korea’s "lowest in the world" TFR today, with childlessness reaching 34% - 47%.

  • The yellow line is assuming S. Korea TFR for the US, which is stable and doesn't decline further than about 0.8 children per woman, with childlessness holding at 47%.

What do we see?

That if you truly want your lineage to persist, you probably want at least 4 kids! More kids would be even better, but you know, until we get uterine replicators (or unless you’re rich enough to do surrogates, nannies, and cooks), good luck selling the wives in the equation on that one!

About 9% of households have 4 children these days, so you need to be in the top 10% of child-havers to even have a chance. Go forth and multiply!

14 Likes
∙
7 Replies
∙
3 Restacks
Oct 25
at
2:44 p.m.
Rothari's avatar

tearing up as I hand this sacred chart to my favorite of 16 grandkids, remembering the graph that started it all

Drunk Wisconsin's avatar

I'm settling for having three and poking holes in their condoms.

Henrik's avatar

How many do you have?

Brave Traveller's avatar

There are all kinds of issues with projecting your bloodline infinitely into the future. Results in more and more selfish behavior. One generation is no problem. More than that isn’t necessarily bad, but something to keep in mind.

Kryptogal (Kate, if you like)'s avatar

There's no “your bloodline” at this point anyway. By six generation, any of your descendants would be 1.5% your genes and 98.5% a bunch of other people’s. Next gen after that it's less than 1% related to you, I find this all so very bizarre to care about something like that, way after you're dead too.

Anonymous Dude's avatar

Oh good, I’ll never get that far now so I don’t have to try at all.

Quix's avatar

Just have girls and make sure everyone in your pathway always has girls. It’s way simpler. Girls are always in demand and will continue to be forever.

StatJew's avatar

So it assumes independence between children and grandchildren and each person having TFR distribution of the line you gave?

Related notes

William's avatar

Some hard pills to swallow:

Libs: Most “trans women” are autistic men with autogynephilia. They do not belong in girl’s sports or women’s restrooms and shackling your entire platform to the whims of these deranged narcissists is a losing strategy.

Conservatives: Women going to college is not suppressing the birth rate and marriage. The family collapse is happening with non-college educated people. Stop alienating the State School Upper Middle Class.

Catholics: The NFP thing legit weirds out a t…

Brian Moore's avatar

Yes, this is how it works, absolutely. You’ve definitely figured it out. Next up, we’ll figure out where mom goes during that peekaboo game, and who profits from lying about it.

Sol Hando's avatar

What’s happening in France with their budget and debt makes me feel a bit better about the US.

Whatever is going to happen with national debt is likely to play out there first. Without control over EU monetary policy France is missing the “delay the problem for a few more years” button that the US has.

I’m following along very closely.

William Meijer's avatar

10 reasons why leftists inevitably capture democratic institutions:

1. Humans want status.

2. Politics is primarily about self-interested attempts to redistribute status.

3. Status is roughly zero-sum and power-law distributed. A minority of people has most of the status. A majority is low-status.

Performative Bafflement's avatar

"Just tax rich people" doesn't work - Part II

I previously showed that we already tax our rich people 20% more than all the flagship EU countries people want to emulate, and are ~40% more progressive in our taxation overall.¹

In this note, I'm going to take it further. I look at how much more in taxes we could get from increasing either i…