Review article
Keywords
The Coolidge effect
; Female sexual behavior
; Male sexual behavior
; Sexual novelty
Introduction
Sexual behavior is a feasible way to study the mechanisms through which hormones and neurotransmitters converge in neural systems. Due to its evolutionary importance for survival, sexual behavior is highly-conserved in mammals (Paredes, 2014). For this reason, there are similarities between the neurobiology of sexual behavior among species. One consistent phenomenon, related to sexual behavior, is the resumption of mating induced by a novel sexual partner (Bermant et al., 1968, Dewsbury, 1981, Lucio et al., 2014). Although largely reported in males (Wilson et al., 1963, Bermant et al., 1968, Brown, 1974, Rodriguez-Manzo, 1999, Lucio et al., 2014, Lucio et al., 2017), the study of the Coolidge effect in females is a relatively new area and a growing field of research (Lisk and Baron, 1982, Ventura-Aquino et al., 2016).
The term Coolidge effect was coined by a research group, led by the behavioral endocrinologist Frank A. Beach, derived from an anecdotal event, which veracity has not been confirmed (Wilson et al., 1963, Ågmo, 2007). The 30th president of the United States, Mr. Calvin Coolidge and his wife made a separate tour during a visit to a large farm. When Mrs. Coolidge was in the chicken's area, she noted that a rooster mated repeatedly; she asked the guide “how many times the rooster mated in a day?”, and the guide answered “dozens of times”. Mrs. Coolidge asked the guide to notice that to Mr. President. When Mr. Coolidge arrived to the henhouse, the guide did. The president remained silent, thought for a moment and asked if the rooster mated with the same hen every time, the guide replied negatively. Mr. President requested the guide “tell that to Mrs. Coolidge” (Ågmo, 2007).
Although extensive studies have evaluated the Coolidge effect in males (Dewsbury, 1981, Lucio et al., 2014), the concept has been only recently extended to females and therefore, it is necessary a wider definition that involves both sexes. Thus, the Coolidge effect could be defined as the renewal of motivational and appetitive components of sexual behavior due to sexual novelty, after mating repeatedly with a single partner. In the following sections, we will describe various aspects of the Coolidge effect in both sexes in experimental animals and an approximation in humans.
For the present review we conducted on line searching on scientific indexed journals data bases such as Scopus, PubMed and Science, filling in the search field: “Coolidge effect”, “sexual habituation”, “sexual satiety” and “males” or “females” and their combination. We restricted the search to scientific areas but we considered results with no limitation of dating or document type. However, using this initial searching filter some results did not fit with our criteria, in these cases, we considered articles related with sexual behavior focused on mammals.
Section snippets
The Coolidge effect in non-human males
The Coolidge effect has been extensively studied in males of many species (Tlachi-López et al., 2012, Lucio et al., 2014), including primates (Michael and Zumpe, 1978) and almost always related to sexual satiation, defined as the sexual inhibition induced by repeated copulation (Phillips-Farfán and Fernández-Guasti, 2009). A male rat may copulate repeatedly with a single female until becoming sexually exhausted. This satiation involves three stages: development, complete inhibition of mating
The Coolidge effect in non-human females
Contrary to the extensive research on males, there are few reports of sexual satiety and the effect of a novel sexual partner in females, although it is well recognized that males influence females’ neuroendocrine and reproductive functions in diverse species (Bruce, 1960, Colmenares and Gomendio, 1988). It would not be surprising that some of these effects involve changes on sexual motivation and therefore, is plausible the expression of the Coolidge effect in females. Notwithstanding, it has
Some considerations about the Coolidge effect in humans
Sexual behavior in humans is modeled by factors that cannot be strictly controlled under a laboratory environment. Some of them include individual and sociocultural connotations that undoubtedly are also influenced by the endocrine status (Atallah et al., 2016, Brotto et al., 2016, Thomas and Thurston, 2016). For example, people with some personality traits, develop different attitudes that relate with sexual aspects such as the number of sexual partners, sexual activity frequency, sexual
The habituation of sexual response in human males
The majority of reports in this topic have been conducted in men, have employed diverse sexually explicit content as stimuli, and have measured penile tumescence employing devices such as mercury-in-rubber strain gauge or electromechanical strain gauge (O'Donohue and Geer, 1985, Dawson et al., 2013); and psychological sexual arousal, mainly evaluated by self-report scales, ranking the subjective sexual arousal (O'Donohue and Geer, 1985, Kelley and Musialowski, 1986, Koukounas and Over, 1993,
The sexual response habituation in the human female
Genital arousal in women is measured by vaginal plethysmography and subjective arousal by a self-reported scale. Regarding the habituation of the women's sexual response, there is a smaller number of reports that show inconsistent results, as compared with those involving men. For example, Ingrid Meuwissen and Over (1990) evaluated sexual arousal in women who watched the same erotic film or engaged in a sexual fantasy for 18 times (Meuwissen and Over, 1990). After initial presentations, the
Conclusions
In both, males and females, there is a decline of sexual arousal after repeated exposition to the same sexual stimulus. This effect seems to be general to the whole range of species studied, including humans, although the results in women have to be further explored. Sexual novelty increases motivational aspects of sexual behavior in males, evidenced by the Coolidge effect. In females, including women, the expression of that effect is related to other factors that affect sexual behavior, such
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank M.Sc. Rebeca Reyes-Serrano and Mrs. Blanca Gómez Quintanar for technical assistance. We are also thankful to CONACyT for granting fellowship number 243413 to EV-A.
References (77)
Sexual motivation—an inquiry into events determining the occurrence of sexual behavior
Behav. Brain Res.
(1999)Chapter 2-An Incentive Motivational Framework and the Description of Sexual Behaviors
(2007)- et al.
Preclinical models of sexual desire: conceptual and behavioral analyses
Pharmacol. Biochem. Behav.
(2004) - et al.
Ethical and sociocultural aspects of sexual function and dysfunction in both sexes
J. Sex. Med.
(2016) - et al.
What is the role of dopamine in reward: hedonic impact, reward learning, or incentive salience?
Brain Res. Rev.
(1998) - et al.
Feminine sexual behavior: cellular integration of hormonal and afferent information in the rodent forebrain
- et al.
Psychological and interpersonal dimensions of sexual function and dysfunction
J. Sex. Med.
(2016) Sexual arousal, the Coolidge effect and dominance in the rat (rattus norvegicus)
Anim. Behav.
(1974)- et al.
A sex difference in features that elicit genital response
Biol. Psychol.
(2005) - et al.
Habituation of sexual responses in men and women: a test of the preparation hypothesis of Women's genital responses
J. Sex. Med.
(2013)