Post

Conversation

Poland in 2026. A house divided. In 2023, PIS government lost power after 8 years. Eight years of changes which if called controversial would be an understatement, encompassing all areas of life. One of them is the chief of Constitutional Order - the Constitutional Tribunal. 🧵
Quote
Paweł Wójcik 🦋
@SaladinAlDronni
Replying to @SaladinAlDronni
Hmm, should I do a thread? Normally I don't comment on the Polish stuff other than usual shitposting, but some signalled an interest in reading my take. And I happen to know quite a bit, to the surprise of noone because I live here. Unless someone still is surprised by this fact.
Amitav Krishna
Post your reply

In our system, there are two chambers of parliament. Senate (upper house) and the Sejm (the lower), with the Sejm being the main source of power. When voted in in general elections, winning majority decides who rules. Senate is a correction/confirmation machine. Useless.
Both have a cadency of 4 years. Presidential office in Poland is also decided by general election. But for five years. So, if one government is able to have a presidential ally, all is fine and dandy. If it doesn't - it becomes a nightmare. Something we called "cohabitation".
This Post includes a word you muted.
You may remember a US version of a plan in advance - Project 2025. It was something similar. PIS came into power with the strategy of crippling the power of judges in all kinds of courts and replace major positions there in order to occupy it for years. They have suceeded.
And at that point nothing was that brazen (it became later, because appointes were simply too shameless and more corrupt than the people they were supposed to replace) but a major stumbling block remained. The Constitutional Tribunal we are witnessing another chaos around today.
Before PO (Tusk's party) lost power, they tried (under the command of new leader) to make a unusual move. Judges in CTL have long, 9-years cadencies in post, there are 15 of them, with one becoming a chief. They happened to have a vacancy, 5 seats in the tribunal.
The Sejm has power to decide on judges in that tribunal. Knowing that they would lose (Tusk had been gone for over a year in the EU, his replacements were pathetic) they attempted to decide on new judges. But there was a problem. That sparked the fire.
3 seats could be legally decided on by the Sejm during its finishing term which was supposed to end in November 2015. 2 - by the new one, voted in after general elections in December 2015. PO decided to risk it and voted them all in. Unconstitutionally, since they could 3.
A major drama ensued, in which the tribunal at the time (which had a great reputation, it matters), ruled that PO should only vote in three new judges and leave two others to the next parliament. PO abided by it. PIS in the next government... didn't.
When the new government took over, they saw an opportunity. An opportunity to kill the tribunal and make it a puppet. So they adopted a resulution proclaiming the judges chosen by PO were ilegally appointed - and chose five new ones. At the time...
New President, the ally of Kaczyński, quickly swore in new judges (President must receive their oath! It's important!!!) during the night, in order to quickly make a fait accompli situation and make their appointee, Przyłębska, chief judge of the tribunal. They suceeded.
What happened next is a long story, but the CTL rules on new law and its complaince with the consitution. To take it over with political appointees (PIS voted in their own Sejm MPs to the tribunal) means you have a safe voting enabling machine. Which is what happened.
I can ramble on for a long time, believe me, their corrupt take over of that tribunal mattered for every section of political changes they wanted (but the EU was something they couldn't overcome ;), last bastion). What matters is how shameless this tribunal has become.
Once PIS lost power in 2023, new coalition under the commander-in-chief Tusk faced a problem no one in our post-communist history faced. Something Magyar faced in Hungary , but has constitutional majority, making Orban tricks childish attempts and destroyed them. Tusk couldn't.
Not only the coalition falls short of having a majority, it's also diverse in ideology, largely linked by hate for PIS. In addition, all courts and bodies related to law, justice demand majoritirs. They also, above all, demand a president. Tusk had no president.
Remember early from the thread that the Sejm has 4 years but president has 5? It's by design to ensure the winner continues its vision, but obviously has to work with the government. Nobody expected they wouldn't work with the government but actively would try to sabotage it.
This Post includes a word you muted.
Veto over majority the Sejm passes into law. In order to annihilate vote, you need...constitutional majority. You already grasp what I am about to say right? Yeah, you are completely right. Tusk government met veto at every occasion. President also has weird power...
That isn't really a power, but some kind of a gentleman, verbal agreement, same as UK Monarch when a new PM comes to the Palace to meet the King and the King gives his nod for him to start the rule. We also have something like this. But nobody expected presidents... to refuse.