Discussion about this post

Amitav Krishna's avatar
Taylor's avatar

I came for data-driven parenting goals, I came away with absolution for that one time I essentially ended a friendship because of their extremely indulgent child’s-feelings-led parenting style. Thanks Lyman!

DeepLeftAnalysis🔸's avatar

Sounds like you're saying "the ROI of skill-building is lower than the ROI of character/habit/moral/culture building." Our culture emphasizes too much skill-based striverism, and not enough character-based judgments. We need to bring back institutional frameworks that select for leaders with positive character traits, and put less emphasis on maximizing resumes. Effectively, this looks like institutions dominated at the top by a contest of virtue. The question then becomes, which virtues do we select for?

The loss of Mainline Christianity as a dominant morality created a "hyper-morality" -- that is, we are not less moral, but we are more morally *conflicted* than ever before. MAGA seems to value conspiracy-mindedness and anti-elitism as a virtue, while wokeness is centered on "harm avoidance." It's not that we are "amoral," but that we have too many competing moral systems. Basically, we need to narrow the field of virtue, define it rigorously, and start excluding people from leadership who display poor virtue.

16 more comments...