Post

Conversation

At first I thought this had to be a joke because it’s so preposterous. I even replied to the post saying “Tell me you’re joking.” But then I saw the same account commenting on it under a mutual’s (completely unrelated) post! 1/
Image
The philosophy of love and the philosophy of sex goes all the way back to ancient Greece. Philosophers have developed theories about the nature of love and of sexual desire, about ethical commitments pertaining to loving relationships, and about sexual ethics, since day one. 2/
Plato dedicates two dialogues (Symposium and Phaedrus) to the nature of eros (often translated as “erotic love” or “erotic desire,” but used by Plato to refer to desire much more broadly construed). The topic of eros comes up again in the Republic. 3/
He also dedicates a dialogue (Lysis) to philia (often translated as “friendly love” or “brotherly love”). Aristotle also dedicates two books of the Nicomachean Ethics to philia. In those books, he also explicitly discusses the bond between husband and wife as a kind of philia. 4/
There’s a whole tradition of Christian thought, starting with the Bible and ancient philosophers like Augustine through Medieval philosophers like Aquinas to modern theologians like Nygren and beyond about agape (often translated as “neighbourly love” or “charitable love” 5/
In that tradition, the question is sometimes raised of the relation between these different concepts of love: eros, philia, and agape. This comes up explicitly in Augustine, Aquinas, and Nygren. It also famously makes up the substance of C.S. Lewis’ book The Four Loves. 6/
There’s also a whole philosophical tradition of thought about the ethics of sexual relations. It’s in Augustine (e.g., his On the Good of Marriage), in Aquinas (in the Treatise of the Virtues in the Summa Theologica), in Kant (in the Metaphysics of Morals), etc. 7/
There is by this point an enormous body of work on the philosophy of love and sex, most of which builds on work in this tradition in some way. For instance, there’s a wealth of scholarship in analytic philosophy about the nature of love, the nature of sex, sexual ethics, etc. 8/
Key analytic philosophers working on these questions in the last fifty years or so include Alan Soble, Raja Halwani, Neera Badhwar, Martha Nussbaum, Harry Frankfurt, Robert Nozick, Roger Scruton, Robert C. Solomon, Eleonore Stump, and J.S. Velleman, among many others. 9/
In the reply I screenshotted above, the person in question says the problem is the course is “marketed” as being about sex and implying that such a course can’t possibly expose students to “serious scholarship.” This is a bizarre framing and an unjustified assumption. 10/
Courses in universities have some focus. Sometimes they focus on a figure (e.g., Plato, Kant, etc.). Sometimes they focus on a topic (philosophy of language, philosophy of art, etc.). In the latter case, it might be a historical survey or focus on contemporary work. 11/
This is simply a historical survey course that focus on a particular topic, namely, love and sex in the philosophical tradition from Plato through Aristotle, Aquinas, Kant, and Mill to Foucault (though there are a few others peppered in, notably Freud and Marcuse). 12/
As in any other area, some of the contemporary work is poor, but much of it is highly rigorous scholarship. Certainly no less rigorous than in any other area of contemporary analytic ethics and metaphysics. So just a silly thing to say overall. 13/13
I used a screenshot above because I wanted to fit my original post and the quote tweet in the picture. I was recently made aware that "shadow-quoting" people is considered rude, so I'm happy to tag here so as not to give the impression of talking behind his back.
In case anyone is curious about the course outline, we do: two weeks of Plato, one week of Aristotle, two weeks of Aquinas, a week of Kant, a week of Mill, and a week of Foucault, along with some classes introducing the topics and drawing connections between the readings.
Quote
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
Replying to @DonkorST
Happily!
Thanks! It's a very fun course to teach. And yes, of course. In the past, I've used Augustine instead of Aquinas for the topic of agape and/or the topic of sexual and marital ethics in Christianity, but I've found Aquinas more helpful. In the past, I've often gotten students to
What is even funnier is that it is an account named "Sun and Steel", a book by Mishima, a philosopher and author who wrote extensively on eroticism, love, and sex. A lot of people don't actually read books, they just like the idea of books.
Me: Teaches about Plato's view that eros is a longing to be united with what is good forever, Aristotle's view that philia is the love for oneself extended out to another self, Aquinas' view that agape is first and foremost a bond of friendship with God that causes us to love all
Image